AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The Hamdam Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd., a society registered under the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 1972, made an application on 18 August 2020 for registration of its Group Housing project developed on a lease hold plot obtained by the Applicant Society from DDA admeasuring 7000.16 sq. mtrs of land situated at Plot No.7, Sector 18A, Dwarka, New Delhi 110075.
The application and attached documents were scrutinized and a number of deficiencies were found in the application, and accordingly a deficiency letter was issued to the Applicant Society on 7 September 2020. In submitting its reply on 16 September 2020, the Applicant Society submitted a number of documents including a list of its 105 members. The said reply was scrutinized and it was found that some of the deficiencies had not been addressed adequately, and that in particular the Applicant Society did not furnish a statement of reasons for delay in making application for registration of their ongoing project under provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 except to say that as per their understanding the work related to the society was completed in 2016 and that they applied for registration only when the Registrar of Cooperative Societies asked for documentation relating to such registration with RERA.
In order to provide a further opportunity for rectification of remaining defects as well as for a hearing on the issues relating to delay in making an application for registration, a show cause notice was issued to the Applicant Society requiring it to provide additional documentation, if any, in respect of the remaining deficiencies and to appear before this Authority on 13 October 2020.
The Applicant Society represented by its President Shri Sachin Kumar, submitted during the hearing held on 13 October 2020 that they had filed certain additional documents on 4 October 2020 via email. During the course of the hearing, the President of the Applicant Society submitted that all construction work in relation to the project had been completed by April 2016 when the Applicant Society applied for a Completion Certificate (CC), which CC was issued by MCD in October 2018. He further submitted upon enquiry that a joint inspection by various authorities for considering grant of CC was held sometime during 2018; though he was not able to recollect the exact date.
The President of the Applicant Society further submitted that after issuance of CC in October 2018, the Society had pursued for approval of Registrar of Cooperative Societies to the conduct of draw of lots by DDA and that a writ petition was filed by the Applicant Society before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in May/June 2020 and that the Hon’ble High Court was pleased to issue two orders – one in July 2020 and the other dated 1 October 2020. The President of the Applicant Society requested for, and was granted, one week’s time to furnish copies of the writ petition and the orders passed by Hon’ble High Court of Delhi for perusal and reference of the Authority. But on the next date of hearing held on 28 October 2020, he requested for some more time to obtain and file the certified true copies of the requisite documents. He also stated that the fact of the Applicant Society having made an application for registration of the project under the provisions of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act had been mentioned to the Hon’ble High Court.
During the final hearing held on 19 November 2020, Shri Sachin Kumar, President of the Applicant Society submitted that all the documents as directed by the Authority had been submitted and the office confirmed the receipt of the documentation. The President of the Applicant Society further submitted that the initial approval of the sanction plan was received from DDA on 21 June 2004 and that the same was renewed from time to time until completion of the project. Subsequently, the President of the Applicant Society filed an affidavit dated 21 November 2020 stating that the Applicant Society had sought the extension of the approval of the sanction plan on several occasions and that the last such extension approval was sought by the Applicant Society on 26 December 2017 and received from DDA on 27 March 2018, which approval was valid until 31 December 2018.
Taking into account the totality of the circumstances, we are of the considered view that while the Applicant Society has rectified the defects in application, it has not been able to provide any cogent reasons to explain the delay of three years in making the application for registration of the above stated project and non-conformity to the provisions contained in Section 3 and 4 of the Act during the period of delay. In accordance with Section 59 of the Act, if the Promoter does not comply with the provisions, he shall be liable to a penalty which may extend to ten percent of the total estimated cost of the real estate project as determined by the Authority. Also, there is no provision in the Act or the Rules framed there under where the Authority is empowered to condone the delay in making the application for registration of a real estate project.
In view of the above and looking into the facts submitted by the Applicant Society, we are of the considered view that it is appropriate to impose a penalty of an amount equal to three times the registration fees payable for the project, which total penalty is less than one tenth of one percent of the total estimated project cost.
We accordingly order that for the delay in making the application for registration of its real estate project, which was ongoing as on the date of entry into force of the Act (1 May 2017), a penalty of an amount equal to three times the registration fees payable for the project be imposed on the Applicant Society. Let the penalty be deposited by the Applicant Society in accordance with the provisions of the Act, and the project be registered subject to usual conditions upon payment of such penalty.
