AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
J.N. Wazir, C.J.—This is an appeal by Tribat Singh husband who prayed for a decree for divorce against his Wife Mst. Bimla on the allegations that his wife was unchaste and unfaithful to him and had been leading an adulterous life. Mst. Bimla Devi, the wife, denied the allegations made by the husband and has averred that all the allegations made in the petition were false. It is further stated by her that she has always been ready to go to her husband but it is her husband who refused to keep her in his house. The trial Court of District Judge raised the following issue:
Has the Respondent contracted illicit connection with Kartar Singh and is she committing adultery with him and with some other persons also, if so, since when and is the applicant entitled to get the decree for divorce?
This issue was found against the husband Petitioner and his application was dismissed. He has come up in appeal.
On behalf of the Appellant it is contended that the District Judge has not properly appreciated the evidence and has erred in dismissing his petition for divorce. We have been taken through the evidence adduced by the Petitioner Appellant to show that his wife was not of good character and was leading an adulterous life.
Bhag Singh is the Numberdar of the village in which the Petitioner resides. From his evidence it is clear that a man by the name of Kartar Singh used to visit the non-applicant in her house and she used to be absent from her house for four to six days at a stretch. He has deposed that the non-applicant is not a woman of good character.
Varyam Singh is another respectable witness or the locality who stated that he had seen the non-applicant moving about in Jammu more than once with one Kartar Singh and the brother of the Petitioner had informed him that the non-applicant had contracted illicit connection with Kartar Singh.
Jiwan Singh, Petitioner's witness, who is a relation of the Petitioner had seen the non-applicant travelling in a bus in the company of a stranger.
Shankar Singh another witness of the Petitioner definitely stated that the non-applicant is a woman of loose character and that she had gone to visit Jhiri fair with Kartar Singh. Natha Singh another witness had also seen the non-applicant moving about with Kartar Singh at Jhiri fair. He had known Kartar Singh before and he recognised him when he was going about with the non-applicant at Jhiri fair.
Nanku is a neighbour of the Petitioner. He has stated that the non-applicant was a woman of bad character. He had seen Kartar Singh visiting her house very often.
The Petitioner has examined himself and in his statement he has mentioned that he is employed in the Army and when he came home on leave he went to Domana and there he found that his wife was not at home and had gone to Jhiri fair. He went to Jhiri and on the way he met his father-in-law and brother-in-law and he enquired from them whether his wife had gone to the fair but they did not reply. He went to Jhiri fair and there he saw his wife in the company of two military men. They were sitting together and eating sweets. He watched their movements for about two hours and came home.
The learned Counsel for the non-applicant has argued that the evidence adduced by the Petitioner does not establish that the non-applicant was leading an adulterous life. No direct evidence has been adduced to prove adultery.
It is true that there is no evidence adduced by the Petitioner to prove that the non-applicant had been cohabiting with Kartar Singh or with some other persons. It is generally difficult to adduce direct evidence to prove adultery but circumstancial evidence may be sufficient to prove that a woman is leading an adulterous life. In the present case respectable persons of the locality and neighbours of the Petitioner have come forward to depose that the non-applicant was not a chaste woman, that she had been remaining absent from the house for four to six days at a time and was seen moving about with a stranger by the name Kartar Singh.
The Petitioner has himself seen the non-applicant in the company of two military men in Jhiri fair. There is evidence to show that she was seen with one Kartar Singh at Jammu at different occasions by the witnesses and also travelling in a bus with the same man. Mst. Bimla Devi non-applicant has appeared as a witness and she has simply denied her intimacy with Kartar Singh and has further stated that she did not know anyone by the name of Kartar Singh. On the other hand, as pointed out above, there is ample evidence to show that she was visited by Kartar Singh at her house and she had been seen moving about with the same man at different times and at different places.
No good ground has been made out to show as to why the witnesses of the locality are deposing against the non-applicant. Neither do we find any good reason to disbelieve the testimony of the respectable witnesses produced by the Appellant who have no grudge or enmity with the non-applicant. The fact that the non-applicant, a married woman, has been absenting herself from her house for four to six days at a stretch and has been seen more than once with Kartar Singh, a total stranger to her husband's family, and no explanation is given by Kartar for having been seen in the company of Kartar Singh at different places, leads to an irresistible conclusion that she had contracted illicit connection with that man and had been living in adultery with him.
In the result we allow this appeal and grant the husband Appellant a decree for divorce against his wife u/s 13 Clause (i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, but in the circumstances of the case we make no order as to costs.
K.V. Gopalakrishnan Nair, J.
I agree.
