AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard learned Senior Advocate Mr. Dharmadhikari, along with Mr. Chandurkar, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Mirache, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1 to 3. With the consent of the learned counsels for the respective parties, the matter is taken up for final disposal.
In the present appeal, the challenge is to the judgment and order dated 26.07.2019 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Nagpur, in Claim Petition No.566 of 2013, whereby, the learned Tribunal, has awarded the compensation of Rs.60,47,170/- in favour of respondents-claimants.
The appellant who approached before this Court has substantially raised the legal issues, as to whether the vehicle owned by the Western Coalfields Limited comes under the definition of “Motor Vehicle” or not and secondly, in absence of the details of the registration of the vehicle, the learned Tribunal was justified to entertain the application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “the Act”).
In view of the issues raised by the appellant, it would be relevant to record certain facts of the matter, which are undisputed are as under :-
The respondents-claimants filed the claim petition before the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-3, Nagpur, stating that on 31.03.2013 at about 17.15 hrs., the deceased Devkumar Banwarilal Petha, aged about 44 years, was going towards Coal Staff Office from Canteen of WCL, Umred. At that time, a Tanker bearing No.9390 owned by appellant-Company, came in a high speed with rash and negligent manner and gave a dash to the deceased. The deceased sustained fatal injuries and succumbed to the same on spot.
It is further submitted that the said incident was registered as an offense under Sections 279, 304-A of Indian Penal Code, 1860, against the driver of the offending vehicle at Police Station Mouda. In view of the registration of the offense, by obtaining the documents from the Investigation Officer, the claim petition was filed before the learned Tribunal, claiming thereby, compensation of Rs.1,21,00,000/-, but, due to paucity of funds, they have restricted their claim to Rs.1,00,000/-only.
In the said claim petition, the present appellant in response to the notices received to them, appeared and opposed the claim petition. It is the submission of the appellant that the claim petition was not maintainable, as the accident had occurred inside the mining premises and same cannot be termed as a road accident. It is further stated that as the accident was not occurred on road, the provisions of the Act, are not applicable.
In addition to above, it was stated that as claimants are not entitled for compensation under Motor Vehicles Act, in lieu thereof they have granted the compassionate appointment to appellant No.1 along with other monetary benefits. It is stated that, appellant has paid the amount of Rs.6,90,080/- towards compensation under Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. So also, paid an amount of Rs.84,600/- as ex gratia and Rs.1,12,800/- under the Life Cover Scheme. Hence, according to the appellant, it was not a case that the appellant did not accept the responsibility of death caused to deceased in the mines premises. Considering these benefits, the claim for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, was not tenable.
Appellant states that learned Claim Tribunal failed to consider all the legal issues involved in the matter. The Learned Tribunal failed to verify the fact whether vehicle involved in the accident was registered as Motor Vehicle or a Construction Vehicle. It is also not considered that accident occurred in coal mines, then whether it can be termed as road accident or not. Therefore, seeks interference of this Court in the matter.
Learned counsel for the respondents-claimants stated that the accident which was occurred in the coal mines premises, the vehicle involved was a Water Tanker bearing No.9390. As such, considering the involvement of vehicle owned by the appellant was a Water Tanker/Dumper, the same comes under the definition of a “Motor Vehicle”. Therefore, the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, rightly entertained the claim petition and awarded just and fair compensation in the matter.
In the light of rival submissions of both the parties, I have perused the provisions of the Act, as well as the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989, which are relevant to decide the controversy involved in the matter.
It would be first relevant to note that the definition of the a “Motor Vehicle” provided under Section 2(28) of the Act, which reads as under :-
2.Definitions.—In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires, —
(28)“motor vehicle” or “vehicle” means any mechanically propelled vehicle adapted for use upon roads whether the power of propulsion is transmitted thereto from an external or internal source and includes a chassis to which a body has not been attached and a trailer; but does not include a vehicle running upon fixed rails or a vehicle of a special type adapted for use only in a factory or in any other enclosed premises or a vehicle having less than four wheels fitted with engine capacity of not exceeding1 [twenty-five cubic centimetres];
The definition a “Motor Vehicle” falls in two parts. The first part of this definition, which reads as under ““vehicle” means any mechanically propelled vehicle adapted for use upon roads whether the power of propulsion is transmitted thereto from an external or internal source and includes a chassis to which a body has not been attached and a trailer”. The second part which is an exclusive to consider the motor vehicle is that “but does not include a vehicle running upon fixed rails or a vehicle of a special type adapted for use only in a factory or in any other enclosed premises or a vehicle having less than four wheels fitted with engine capacity of not exceeding [twenty five cubic centimeters]”
After going through the definition of this “Motor Vehicle” which is in two parts, it would be necessary to verify as to how this vehicle is to be registered under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act. The relevant provision for registration of the vehicle is under Chapter IV particularly, under Section 39, 40 and 41. As per these provisions, no owner of a “Motor Vehicle” can be permitted to drive any vehicle in any public place unless, the vehicle is registered in accordance with the provisions of this law. These provisions further states how the every owner of the “Motor Vehicle” shall register his vehicle and the procedure which is contemplated particularly, under Section 41 of the Act, is required to be followed for registration of the vehicle.
In addition to above, it would be further relevant to refer Chapter III of the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989. The Rules framed thereunder, specifically states that every owner shall submit the application for registration and the Registering Authority, shall specify whether the vehicle is a two wheeler, four wheeler, light motor vehicle, medium commercial vehicle, heavy commercial vehicle, etc. then after verification of the vehicle, the registration number is provided. Furthermore, under the provisions of the Maharashtra Motor Vehicles Rules, again the procedure, is incorporated and specifically states that the registration mark shall consist of the State Code for example Maharashtra-“MH” followed by code number of the Registering Authority and then by the registration number. After the registration of the vehicle, then same can be permitted in any public place or any other place in accordance with the provisions of law.
It is the submission of the appellant, if the record of the present case is perused, it is clear that the vehicle which was involved in the accident, its particulars were not properly given by the respondents-claimants. In his claim application, while providing the registration number and type of vehicle, he has only stated Water Tanker No.9390. This description of the vehicle is itself doubtful. The registration number of the vehicle ought to have been in the manner prescribed under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 or Maharashtra Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989. But, the appellant failed to provide the details of the vehicle.
The appellant stated that admittedly, the appellant is involved in the mining business and for carrying out the said business, they were having heavy earth moving machinery, special service vehicles or construction vehicles to carry out the work within the mines. The vehicles which they use are never permitted to ply on any public place except the mining area. Therefore, the said vehicle do not come under the definition of the “Motor Vehicle”.
The appellant in support of their submissions has relied upon two judgments one is of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.3352-3353/2017 in case of Ultratech Cement Ltd., Vs. The State of Gujarat and Others, decided on 08.01.2026, the second judgment is relied upon of the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition No.4916/2008 Western Coalfields Limited Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others, decided on 06.04.2026.
In the light of the above judgments and more particularly judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Ultratech Cements’ case (supra), which is relied upon, the Hon’ble Supreme Court, while interpreting the definition “Motor Vehicle” under section 2(28) of the Act, has categorically held that the definition is in two parts. The first part is inclusive and the second part is exclusive to consider the vehicle as “Motor Vehicle”. The relevant findings recorded by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, in para No.37, reads as under :-
37.A simple and plain reading of the aforesaid provision would reveal that it is in two parts. The first part is inclusive and the second part is exclusive. The first part, in short, provides that a motor vehicle or a vehicle means any mechanically propelled vehicle which is adapted for use upon roads and includes the chassis to which a body has not been attached and a trailer. So, the above part of the definition of motor vehicle is inclusive in nature. The second part provides for the exclusion of certain vehicles from the definition of the motor vehicle. It provides that motor vehicle does not include a vehicle running upon fixed rails or a vehicle of a special type adapted for use only in a factory or in any other enclosed premises. It means that the legislature has consciously provided for the exclusion of the vehicles of the special kind which have been adapted for use only in a factory or any other enclosed premises from the definition of motor vehicle. In other words, though the term motor vehicle is wide enough but it expressly excludes some of the motor vehicles which are of special type and have been adapted for use only in factory or in any other enclosed premises from its ambit.”
In the same judgment, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India held that the interpretation of the definition under Section 2(28) of the Act, was not considered in various case laws which were pointed out by the other side before Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. In this regard, further finding is recorded in para No.51, which reads as under :-
“51.The decisions to the contrary cited at the Bar starting from Travancore Tea Estates Co. Ltd vs. State of Kerala & Ors., Union of India and Ors. vs. Chowgule and Co. Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., M/s Central Coal Fields Ltd. vs. State of Orissa & Ors., Chief General Manager, Jagannath Area & Ors. (supra), Bose Abraham vs. State of Kerala & Anr., State of Gujarat & Ors. (supra) are all decisions of the different Division Benches of this Court. No doubt, they hold that vehicles used or kept for use on the public roads of the State are exigible to tax, and if they are not so used they can claim exemption but all these decisions fail to take into account the specific exclusion as contained in the second part of Section 2 (28) of the Act which defines "motor vehicles". As stated earlier, the vehicles or the construction equipment vehicles used by the appellants are "motor vehicles" within the first part of the definition as contained in Section 2 (28) but they stand excluded by virtue of the second part of the said definition. This aspect of the matter has not been specifically considered by any of the above decisions. Moreover, all these decisions simply brushes aside Bolani Ores Ltd. (supra) without actually ruling it out on the ground that it relates to "motor vehicles" as defined under the old Act without realising that there was no material change between the definition of "motor vehicles" in the old or present Act.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, distinguished the two judgments which were holding the field till deciding the issue by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. One judgment was of Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Another reported in 2016 (11) SCC 613 and Natwar Parikh and Co. Ltd., Vs. State of Karnataka reported in 2005 (7) SCC 364. It is observed that in the case of Natwar Parkih’s case (supra), it has been simply held that “goods carriage” requires a permit under the Motor Vehicles Act and therefore, they are “Motor Vehicles”. The same was followed in Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Another (supra) wherein, it was held that excavators fall within the definition of “Motor Vehicles” as contained in Section 2(28) of the Act. In both these petitions, the definition under Section 2(28) of the Act, which was interpreted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ultratech’s case (supra) was not dealt with. Accordingly, it is held that the interpretation which is done by the Court, is required consideration, while interpreting the definition of “Motor Vehicle”.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has held the correct legal position which was considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court was in the case of Bolani Ores Ltd., Vs. State of Orissa reported in (1974) 2 SCC 777 wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has dealt with the definition of a “Motor Vehicle” which was existing in the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and held that the phrase used in Section 2(28) of the said Act, “adapted for use upon roads”, though involved vehicle such as dumpers, rockers and tractors are suitable for use on roads. But, as they were used only within a closed premises, specifically for the Industrial purposes, they cannot be held liable for taxation on that basis. Hence, applying the said principle, that tractors/trailers used to transporting goods, constitute a different category i.e. “goods carriage” which requires permit under Section 66 of the Act, and in absence of such permits, they are liable for tax under Section 3(2) of Karnataka Motor Vehicles Taxation Act, 1957.
The appellant stated that for carrying out the work of mining, they are possessing heavy earth moving machinery, special service vehicles for constructions/equipment and therefore, same cannot be held as “Motor Vehicle” as per law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ultratech’s case (supra). Appellant also relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court, in Writ Petition No.4916 of 2008 [Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others], wherein it is held that orders of assessment of tax passed by the Joint Commissioner of Sales Tax, being unjust, unreasonable and illegal and appellant are exempted from payment of tax of the said vehicles, under the Maharashtra Tax Act. It would be relevant to refer the relevant extract of order of the Hon’ble Division Bench in Writ Petition No.4916 of 2008 [Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Others], particularly, para Nos.1 and 2, which reads as under :-
“ Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the issue involved in the present petitions is covered by the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ultratech Cement Ltd. v. State of Gujarat and Others; [2026 SCC OnLine SC 48]. The issue considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court was whether heavy earth-moving machinery, special service vehicles, or construction equipment vehicles are “motor vehicles” within the meaning of Section 2(28) of the Motor Vehicles Act and, consequently, whether they are liable to pay tax under the Maharashtra Tax Act. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in paragraph 55, held as follows:
“55.In view of the aforesaid discussion specially considering the pleadings and the material on record, we are of the conclusive opinion that the vehicles used by the appellants are vehicles of special types, precisely construction equipment vehicles which are suitable and are meant for use for operation and use within the industrial area/factory premises/ defined enclosed premises and are not meant for use on roads or public roads. They are off-road equipments and as such stand excluded not only from the purview of the “motor vehicle” as defined under Section 2 (28) of the Act but also from tax as Entry 57 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution only authorizes taxation of vehicles suitable for use on roads only. They are not even chargeable to road tax in view of Schedule I to Section 3 (1) of the Gujarat Tax Act which do not prescribes any tax for such kind of vehicles i.e., construction equipment vehicles. However, if any such kind of vehicles are found using roads, they would not be free from the rigors of Section 2 (28) of the Act and Section 3 of the Gujarat Tax Act and may also be subject to proceedings for seizure and penalty in accordance with the law.”
2.Learned Assistant Government Pleader, on instructions, fairly states that the issue involved in the present petitions is covered by the aforesaid judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.”
Per contra, the respondents-claimants have relied upon the following judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court as well as this Court, namely (i) Western Coalfields Limited Vs. Krishnaji Ganpatrao Khapre and Others in First Appeal No.334/2017 decided on 24.04.2017; (ii) Sub-Area Manager, Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. Smt. Anjutai and Others in First Appeal No.1823 of 2019 decided on 14.03.2023 and (iii) General Manager Vs. Sau. Anita and Others in First Appeal No.264 of 2017 along with other connected appeals, decided on 12.08.2025, (iv) Western Coalfields Ltd. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr., reported in 2016 (11) SCC 615.
In the light of the submissions of both the parties and the provisions of the law as well as the case laws which they have pointed out in the present matter, it would be pertinent to note that Section 165 of the Act, is also required to be considered in the present matter. By this provision, the learned Tribunal constituted by the State Government, is entitled to adjudicate the claims for compensation in respect of the accident involving the death or bodily injury to persons arising out of use of “Motor Vehicle”. As such, this provision specifically states that the death or bodily injury caused to the persons arising out of the Motor Vehicle can file the application before the learned Tribunal. Therefore, it is more important for learned Tribunal to verify after the receipt of claim petition, particularly, in case in hand whether the death or bodily claim is arising out of use of motor vehicle or not.
In the light of the definition of the “Motor Vehicle”, which is clarified by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, it is now clear that the said definition is in two parts. The submission of the appellant is that the vehicle which was involved in the accident falls in second part of the definition. Therefore, the claim petition was not itself tenable before the learned Tribunal under Section 165 and 166 of the Act.
The respondents have stated that the vehicle involved being a Water Tanker Dumper, the same falls under the definition of Motor Vehicle and therefore, the claim petition filed by the claimants was tenable.
In the light of these rival submissions, the important fact would have been the registration of the vehicle. The submission of the appellant is that the vehicles which were used by them inside the coal mines are the special vehicles or construction equipment vehicles, the same are not required to be registered under the Motor Vehicles Act. To substantiate this submission, the appellant has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench in the case of Western Coalfields Ltd., Vs. State of Maharashtra (supra).
In this background, the controversy which is involved in the present matter can be considered only if the evidence of the parties was permitted to be recorded on the issues which they have first time raised before this Court. But, unfortunately, the appellant who has raised all these issues before this Court, has not established before the learned Tribunal that the vehicle which was involved in the accident, do not falls under the definition of the “Motor Vehicle”. The relevant documents such as certificate, the make of the vehicle, the details as to whether the said vehicle was termed as a construction equipment vehicle or not, are required to be produced before the learned Tribunal.
It is also pertinent to note that the appellant in support of his submissions has relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ultratech Cements’ case (supra). Upon perusal of the said judgment, it shows that the Hon’ble Supreme Court while reaching to the conclusion that the vehicles involved in the accidents come under the definition of “Motor Vehicle” or not, considered the various documents which were enclosed by the parties before the respective Lower Courts and on that basis the Hon’ble Supreme Court reached to the conclusion that the vehicles involved therein, did not fall in the first part of the definition of the “Motor Vehicle”. However, in the present case, after going through the record, the evidence available is short to reach to the conclusion that whether the vehicle involved in the motor accident falls in the second part of the definition of “Motor Vehicle” or not. It is further pertinent to note that the respondents-claimants, who were expected to furnish all the registration details of the vehicle before the learned Tribunal, have not clarified that the offending vehicle which has been described as a Water Tanker Dumper, was registered under the Motor Vehicles Act. They have not furnished the proper registration number of the vehicle. The number which they have disclosed in his application does not show the State-wise registration series or code number and then the registration number of the vehicle, as contemplated under the Central Motor Vehicles Rules and Maharashtra Motor Vehicles Rules. Therefore, this part needs to be clarified by producing the documents on record by both the rival parties.
In the light of the above factual position, the only option remains in the present matter is to remand back the present proceedings to the learned Tribunal, for deciding it afresh, by considering all the legal issues which are raised in the present appeal by the appellant. The appellant has already stated that the substantial compensation has already been paid towards the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 and one of the legal heir of the deceased has been provided the appointment on compassionate grounds. Accordingly, no prejudice would be caused to the appellant, if this matter is remanded back to the learned Tribunal to decide it afresh on its own merits.
In the present matter, all the issues which are raised can be considered by the learned Tribunal in the light of the documents and evidence, which would be brought to their notice by both the parties, so that all the controversy involved in the matter can be put to rest. Hence, considering the entire factual as well as legal position, I am satisfied that this is a fit case to remand back to the learned Tribunal to decide it afresh on its own merits. According, I proceed to pass the following Order :-
O R D E R
The First Appeal No.495 of 2021 is partly allowed.
Judgment and order dated 26.07.2019 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur, in Claim Petition No.566 of 2013, is hereby quashed and set-aside.
The proceeding bearing Claim Petition No.566 of 2013 is restored to the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur, for deciding it afresh on its own merits.
Both the parties are at liberty to file their additional submissions before the learned Tribunal and further to record evidence, if they, so desire.
The parties shall appear before the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur, on 26.11.2026.
It is made clear that the amount lying with the Registry of this Court, shall be transferred to the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur. The amount already withdrawn by respondents-claimants, shall be subject to appropriate orders passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur, while deciding the claim petition afresh.
In view of above, the first appeal stands disposed of. No order as to costs. Pending civil application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of, accordingly.
