AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard learned counsels for the respective parties. With the consent of both parties, the matter is taken up for final disposal, at admission stage itself.
In the present appeal, the appellant-Western Coalfields Ltd. has challenged the ex-parte judgment dated 10.11.2022 passed against them by the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Nagpur, in Motor Accident Claim Petition No.988 of 2014.
It is the submission of the appellant that on two grounds, the indulgence of this Court is necessary in the present matter. First, the vehicle which was alleged to be involved in the accident does not come under the definition of a “Motor Vehicle”. Secondly, the appellant could not get an opportunity to establish their case before the learned Tribunal, though, in another identical case arising out of a same accident, the learned Tribunal has dismissed the claim petition. Hence, on these counts, the appellant seeks indulgence of this Court in the matter.
The facts of the present case, in short, are as under:
On 17.07.2014 at about 01:00 p.m., the deceased who was proceeding by Tata Sumo bearing registration No.MH-40-N-7030 as a bonafide passenger in the premises of the Coal Mine. At the relevant time, the WCL Dumper bearing registration No.BH-50-M-3168 came from opposite direction and gave a forceful dash to Tata Sumo. In the said accident, the deceased sustained serious injuries and succumbed to same. After the said accident, an offence came to be registered in the present matter at Police Station, Umred, District Nagpur, for the offences punishable under Sections 279, 337, 304(A) of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) [now Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita], vide Crime No.80 of 2014 against the driver of the WCL Dumper bearing registration No.BH-50-M-3168.
On the basis of the documents prepared by the Investigation Officer in Crime No.80 of 2014, the respondents-claimants filed the claim petition before the learned Tribunal, alleging that it was the case of road accident as two motor vehicles were involved in the accident and the death has been caused in the accident. Respondents-claimants therefore, in the capacity of legal representatives of deceased are entitled for compensation as per the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
It is pertinent to note that in the said proceedings, the present appellant was impleaded as a necessary party by the respondents-claimants. It is also the submission of respondents-claimants that notice of the claim petition was duly served on the appellant, but, no one responded to the notice of the claim petition. Therefore, the learned Tribunal remained no option than to proceed ex-parte against the present appellant. Respondents-claimants states that in support of their claim, they have adduced evidence before the learned Tribunal and upon considering the same, the learned Tribunal has rightly awarded the compensation of Rs.62,11,455/- in favour of respondents-claimants.
The appellant who has approached before this Court stated that the respondents-claimants may be right in stating that the notice was served on the appellant-Company. However, it is the mistake of the concerned clerk or the Officer to not respond to the same. It is their submission that this mistake was inadvertent on their part because arising out of the same accident, the Claim Petition No.1040 of 2015 was filed before the learned Tribunal, arising out of same accident. In the said proceedings, they have contested the claim petition on merits and same was dismissed, by considering the submission of the appellant therein. Hence, there was no reason for them to not contest the claim petition filed by the respondents-claimants.
In respect of the tenability of the claim petition, the appellant has relied upon the definition of the “Motor Vehicle” which was considered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Civil Appeal No.3352-3353/2017 in case of Ultratech Cement Ltd., Vs. The State of Gujarat and Others, decided on 08.01.2026, whereby, it is held that the definition of “Motor Vehicle” under Section 2(28) of the Motor Vehicles Act, is in two parts. The first part is inclusive and the second part is exclusive.
It would be relevant to refer para No.37 of the Ultratech Cements’ case (supra), which reads as under :-
“37.A simple and plain reading of the aforesaid provision would reveal that it is in two parts. The first part is inclusive and the second part is exclusive. The first part, in short, provides that a motor vehicle or a vehicle means any mechanically propelled vehicle which is adapted for use upon roads and includes the chassis to which a body has not been attached and a trailer. So, the above part of the definition of motor vehicle is inclusive in nature. The second part provides for the exclusion of certain vehicles from the definition of the motor vehicle. It provides that motor vehicle does not include a vehicle running upon fixed rails or a vehicle of a special type adapted for use only in a factory or in any other enclosed premises. It means that the legislature has consciously provided for the exclusion of the vehicles of the special kind which have been adapted for use only in a factory or any other enclosed premises from the definition of motor vehicle. In other words, though the term motor vehicle is wide enough but it expressly excludes some of the motor vehicles which are of special type and have been adapted for use only in factory or in any other enclosed premises from its ambit.”
According to the appellant, the vehicle owned by the appellant-Company, was for the construction purposes. The same was not registered as required under the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act. Accordingly, the said vehicle falls in the second part of the “Motor Vehicle”, whereby, such vehicle are excluded from the definition of the “Motor Vehicle”.
The appellant further create a doubt on the registration number, which was recorded by the Police Authority, while registering the criminal case against the driver of the vehicle vide the Crime No.80 of 2014. The appellant has specifically relied upon Rule 50(8) of the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989. According to this Rule, the procedure is prescribed as to how the registration of the vehicle “BH” Series, is to be recorded. The relevant part of the Rule 50(8), reads as under:
“50(8) The registration mark for BH-series vehicle generated randomly through the portal shall be in black on white background and shall be exhibited in the following manner, namely:-XX XX #### XX Last two digits of Bharat Series 4 numerals 0001 to the year of code (2) letters 9999 followed by registration as “BH” letter(s) A, B, B…….and then AA, AB …...AZ, BA, BB ……...to ZZ excluding “I” & “O”.]
According to the appellant, if the registration number of the vehicle which was recorded in the Police Investigation is seen, it is clear that the same is not in accordance with Rule 50(8). Hence, the basic documents, on the basis of which, the learned Tribunal proceeded to decide the case as both the vehicles come under the definition of “Motor Vehicle” and accordingly, decided the issue of compensation, is required re-consideration in the matter. According to the appellant, prima-facie the registration of the vehicle is doubtful and therefore, the appellant needs an opportunity to establish their case by adducing proper evidence before the learned Tribunal.
Learned counsel for respondents-claimants strongly opposed the submissions of the appellant. According to the respondents-claimants, once the notice of the claim petition were received to them, it was their duty to attend the proceedings before the learned Tribunal. The appellant has not shown to have taken any steps in the matter who had committed an error of not pointing out the notice to the higher authorities in the matter, after the receipt of the notice. Therefore, in absence of any such action on the part of the appellant, the respondents-claimants will be the ultimate sufferer in the present matter. Therefore, stated that the order being just and proper, no interference is required at the instance of this Court in the present appeal.
It would be relevant to note that this Court has consider the identical issue, which is involved in the present appeal, which was filed by the appellant-Company in another motor accident case in the First Appeal No.495 of 2021. This Court elaborately considered the fact that whether the vehicles used for construction purpose in a coal mines, come under the definition of “Motor Vehicle” or not. In the said appeal, matter was remanded back to the learned Tribunal to decide the issue afresh, which can be proved only by leading evidence before the learned Tribunal.
In the present appeal, as discussed above, the appellant has established sufficient cause to not appear before the learned Tribunal. So also, raised substantial grounds for which recording of evidence before the learned Tribunal, would be necessary.
In the light of above, in my considered opinion, it would be just and proper to remand back the matter to the learned Tribunal to decide it afresh and consider all the issues, which are raised by the appellant in the present matter, by granting equal hearing opportunity. Accordingly, the following order is passed :-
O R D E R
The First Appeal No.645 of 2021 is partly allowed subject to cost of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees Twenty-Five Thousand Only) to be paid to respondents-claimants, on or before 20.11.2026.
Judgment and award dated 10.11.2022 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Nagpur, in Motor Accident Claim Petition No.988 of 2014, is hereby quashed and set-aside.
The proceeding bearing Motor Accident Claim Petition No.988 of 2014 is restored on the file of the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Nagpur, for deciding it afresh on its own merits.
The appellant would be at liberty to file his written statement and the parties can lead evidence in support of their submissions to establish their respective case before the learned Motor Accident Claim Tribunal, Nagpur.
The parties shall appear before the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Nagpur, on 20.11.2026.
All the issues raised in the appeal are kept open.
It is made clear that the amount lying with the Registry of this Court, shall be transferred to the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur. The amount already withdrawn by respondents-claimants, shall be subject to appropriate orders passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claim Tribunal-3, Nagpur, while deciding the claim petition afresh.
In view of above, the first appeal stands disposed of. No order as to costs.
