Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2021) 04 NGT CK 0059

Tarun vs Dharmender Singh & Anr

National Green Tribunal · Decided on 12 April 2021

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Original Application No. 219 Of 2021

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

14 paragraphs · 978 words
1.

Grievance in the application is against illegal mining by Dharmender Singh and Bhupender Singh sons of Randheer Singh at Mehar Majra, Tehsil Chhachhrauli, District Yamuna Nagar, in violation of environmental norms. According to the applicant, mining is being done on the bank of Som River without any permission. Complaints were filed with the Mining Department and the Chief Minister, Haryana but no action has been taken.

2.

Vide order dated 07.09.2021, the Tribunal directed a three Member Joint Committee of SEIAA, Haryana, Haryana State PCB and the District Magistrate, Yamuna Nagar to verify facts and take remedial action and file an action taken report.

3.

An action taken report has been filed by the joint Committee on 07.02.2022 which mentions seizure of the vehicle involved in illegal mining and its release on payment of fine. Fine, royalty and price of mineral have been recovered and thus no further action is required.

4.

We have given due consideration to the issue and find that in view of illegality found, action taken is not adequate. To show such inadequacy, we may first refer to report as follows:

“2. On dated 15.01.19, the above-mentioned complainant gave a complaint that Sh. Dharmendra Singh & Sh. Bhupendra Singh S/o Sh. Randhir Singh illegally mined his field in Vill. Mehar Majra. In view of that mining team Yamunanagar (MI Sh. Omdutt Sharma, MG Sh. Ramesh Kumar and HC Pardeep Kumar) went on the spot around 07:30 pm and the team founda dumper (HR 68B 7279) and a poclain (Eng. No. N601D03394) on the spot. The dumper was impounded/seized by the team in the P. S. Buria (copy of seizing is attached) and the statement was given by the complainant on the spot that the team listened to his complaint properly and he was satisfied with the action of the team and he also mentioned in his statement that a poclain machine wasn't seized as it's not possible to bring a poclain machine in the P.S. Buria at that time (copy of the statement is attached).

Also, the dumper owner Sh. Sanjeev Kumar S/o Sh. Satpal of Vill. Sarakpur, Distt. Panchkula paid the fine of seized dumper of Rs. 20,000 after that vehicle was released by the department having GRN No. 0043463630. After that MI Sh. Omdutt Sharma sent a letter to P.S. Buria to take an action against Sh. Dharmendra Singh & Sh. Bhupendra Singh S/o Sh. Randhir Singh who had illegally mined the field of Sh. Tarun Singh S/o Sh. Raj Kumar of Vill. Mehar Majra.

3.

Next, the complainant filed this complaint on CM Window Portal (CMOFF/N/2019/010907 dated 28.01.2019) which was office filed (Daftar dakhil) by then AME Sanjay Simberwal accordingly. Again, the complainant filed his second complaint on the CM Window Portal (CMOFF/N/2021/069337 dated 13.08.2021) that P.S. Buria didn't take any action on the letter of the mining department given by MI Sh. Omdutt Sharma, in reply to this, AME Sh. Neeraj Kumar sent a letter to SHO P.S. Buria to seek information on the action taken by his office (office memo no. 3384 dated 1709.21, copy attached).

Again, MO Sh. Gurjeet Singh sent a letter to SHO P.S. Buria to seek information on the action taken by his office on the complaint (office memo no. 6011 dated 11.10.21, copy attached). In reply to this P.S. Buria also sent a letter to this office to seek information about a dumper and a poclain on dated 11.10.21 and 11.11.21 respectively.

4.

0n dated 25.11.2021, the mining team (MI Rohit and MG Sukhpal) went to Vill. Mehar Majra to show their presence in the Nishandehi taken by Sh. Dharmendra Singh & Sh. Bhupendra Singh S/o Sh. Randhir Singh and done by the Kanungo Sh. Sushi] Kumar and Patwari Sh. Tarun Dhiman (as appointed by Tehsildar Chhachhrauli).

5.

0n dated 06.12.2021, the mining team (MI Rohit, MI Aman, MG Sukhpal and MG Shiv Kumar) jointly inspected the area of the complainant with SEIAA Member, SDO (C) Bilaspur Sh. Jaspal Gill, RO HSPCB Sh. Nirmal Kumar and Tehsildar Chhachhrauli Sh. Tarun Kumar in the presence of both the parties. Also, the mining team has taken the dimensions (LxBxH ft.) of the field of Sh. Tarun Kumar (Rakba 10/72, record as provided by Kanungo/Patwari on the spot) i.e., 84x15x11 ft As per the report of the mining team, the payment of fine, price of royalty and price of mineral which was illegally mined by Poclain Eng. No. N601D03394 challaned had been issued to Sh. Ashu Tomar (acquired land of Sh. Dharmendra Singh & Sh. Bhupendra Singh S/o Sh. Randhir Singh on Chakota, statement attached) and he submitted the fine accordingly equal to the sum of Rs. 79200 having GRN No. 0084945603. Now, a letter was also sent to SHO P.S. Buria that fine was submitted by the concerned persons and the complaint should be disposed of.”

5.

From the above, it is clear that illegal mining was being done in the land of the complainant also. Release of vehicles is not in terms of order of this Tribunal dated 26.02.2021 inter-alia in O.A. No. 360/2015, National Green Tribunal Bar Association v. Virender Singh (State of Gujarat). The complainant has not been compensated for illegal mining on his land.

6.

Accordingly, we direct a joint Committee of District Magistrate and SSP, Yamuna Nagar to revisit the action taken in the interest of justice after hearing the parties in accordance with law and file an action taken report within two months by e-mail at [email protected] preferably in the form of searchable PDF/ OCR Support PDF and not in the form of Image PDF with the Registrar General of this Tribunal, who may place the matter before the Bench, if found necessary.

Subject to above, the application is disposed of.

A copy of this order be forwarded to District Magistrate and SSP, Yamuna Nagar by e-mail for compliance.