High CourtsDivision Bench(1951) 02 GUJ CK 0002

State vs Jayantilal Laxmishanker

Gujarat High Court · Decided on 28 February 1951

HON’BLE JUDGES
Shah, C.JChhatpar, J
CASE NUMBER
Criminal Appeal No. 106 of 1950

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

7 paragraphs · 1,010 words

Chhatpar, J.—This is an appaal by Govt. u/s 417, Cr.P.C. from an order of acquittal passed by the Addl. Ses. J. Bhavnagar, getting aside the conviction of the reap. u/s 19(f), Arms Act.

2.

The Police had raided a premises in the occupation of the resp. under a special warrant under the Gambling Act & on making search found a gun, gunpowder & some bullets in the possession of the resp., who was consequently prosecuted under the above provisions of the Arms Act for being in possession of arms & ammunition without a license. The accused pleaded that he was not the owner of the arms & ammunition but that they were pledged with him as security for a loan of Rs. 25 made by him to one Husen Ishak. He also pleaded that he did not know how to use a gun & his possession of the arms & ammunition in question was merely that of a pledge. These fasts appear to be correct. The accused produced an account entry from his book wherein the transaction of the loan of Rs. 25 against the pledge is recorded; but the question is whether in three circumstances the accused came within the prohibition of the Arms Act. In a well consd. & reasoned judgment, the learned Mag. held that the accused had committed the offence u/s 19(f) of the Arms Act. He convicted & sentenced the accused to undergo simple imprisonment for 15 days & to pay a fine of Rs. 50. From this conviction, the accused appealed to the Sessions Ct. & the learned Addl. Ses. J. who heard the appeal, set aside the conviction & held that the possession of the accused was not such as would make him liable for prosecution under the Arms Act. The learned Judge held upon some rulings of H.Cts. where temporary possession of arms was held not to come within the clutches of the Arms Act. He was of the opinion that since the possession of the arms was not for use but for an innocent & legal purpose of a pledge, his possession could not be consd. unlawful under the Act.

3.

I cannot agree with the reasoning of the learned Judge. Section 19(f) makes penal the possession of having under control of any arms, ammunition or military stores in contravention of Sections 14 & 15 of the Act. Possession is to be distd. from mere temporary or accidental custody or charge. Possession. is the essence of a pledge. The pledgee can retain his possession of the goods pledged against the pledgor & for the time being his possession is exclusive. By reason of such possession he has special property in the goods pledged. His possession is not merely temporary or accidental, on behalf of any other person but it is in his own right. In the case of Prabhat Chandra v. Emperor 85 Cal. 219, it was held that the temporary possession of a gun by a person who had snatched it up to fire at a mid dog which had entered his premises, was not contemplated u/s 14 of the Act & Section 19(f) of the Act did not apply. In the case of Queen Empress v. Tata Ram 16 ALL. 276, it was held that the possession of a servant carrying his master's gun to a blackmith for repairs, or that of a blacksmith who had a gun left with him for repairs was not such as became an offence u/s 19, Arms Act. To the same effect is the ruling in the case of Emperor v. Harpal Rai 21 ALL. 451. In the case of Emperor v. Koya Hansji 87 Bom. 181 , it was held that the possession of a servant who was asked to fetch a gun for his master from an adjoining village did not come within the purview of Section 19(e) of the Act. In the case of Babu Ram Vs. Emperor , where the brother of a man who had a license for a gun, but who himself held no license during the time when rioting was going on in the neighbourhood, took his brother's gun & fired several shots in the air merely to scare away the rioters & prevent them from attacking the house, it was held that he was not in so acting guilty of any offence under the Arms Act. In the case of Emperor v. Muhammad Hasan AIR 1925 ALL. 116, the same H.C., however, held that a son of a person, who held a license for a shotgun took out his father's gun for the purpose of shooting birds, was liable to conviction u/s 19(f), Arms Act.

4.

The above cases in which the accused were acquitted are cases of temporary or accidental custody where possession as understood in the legal sense continued to remain with the holder of the license. These cases are distinguishable from the present case as the accused had obtained possession in his right as a pledgee & was entitled to retain it even against the pledgor. In my opinion such possession comes within the purview of Section 19(f) of the Act & the accused was rightly convicted by the Mag. I consequently set aside the order of the acquittal by the lower appellate Ct. & maintain the conviction of the accused u/s 19(f) of the Act.

5.

As regards the sentence, the learned Advocate for accused has made an earnest plea that the accused has acted in a bona fide manner & did not know that he was committing any offence by accepting the pledge of the gun & other articles. He has already undergone an ordeal of trial in three Cts. The learned Advocate requested that while maintaining the conviction this Ct. may restrict the sentence to fine only. The learned Advocate General has, in view of these circum-stances, not pressed for the sentence of imprisonment. I consequently order that the sentence imposed on the accused be restricted to fine only as ordered by the Mag.

Shah, C.J.

6.

I agree.