AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
A complaint was filed in FORM ‘M’ on 23.01.2024 by Shri Suraj Sanwal (hereinafter referred as “Complainant”) under section 31 r/w section 18 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (hereinafter referred to as ‘RE (RD) Act, 2016’) stating that in the year 2020, ‘Delhi Development Authority’ (hereinafter referred to as ‘Respondents’ or ‘DDA’) allotted him a Low Income Group (LIG) flat No. 643, Sixth Floor, Block-F in Sector G-7 through DDA's Housing Scheme 2019. The flat was physically handed over to the Complainant on 21.11.2020 by Northern Division-9 of the Respondent.
In the present case, the complainant is seeking refund of Rs. 22,66,767/-invested by him in the flat in Pocket-5, Sector G7, Narela, Delhi, which he alleged is now inhabitable three years after taking possession.
The Complainant has alleged multiple infrastructural and maintenance-related issues in his complaint. These allegations include systemic problems such as lack of proper security, rampant theft in neighbouring flats, poor maintenance of common areas, structural concerns including water leakage and seepage, and overall unsafe living conditions in the housing complex.
A preliminary hearing in the case was held on 04.03.2024 and notice to the Respondents was issued on 13.03.2024 through post and on 15.03.2024 via email.
The matter was thereafter heard on 02.05.2024, 31.07.2024, 26.09.2024, 12.11.2024, 28.01.2025 and 25.02.2025. The Respondents filed their reply on 14.10.2024.
For the sake of convenience, the submissions and arguments made on behalf of the Respondents are as follows:
a. The Complainant has suppressed material facts and attempted to present only those facts convenient to his narrative, rendering the complaint liable for dismissal.
b. The Housing Scheme 2019 was duly registered with RERA vide letter no. F1(80)/PR/RERA/2019/2475 dated 31.08.2022, and the Complainant was allotted Flat No. 643, Sixth Floor, Pocket-5, Block-F, Sector G-7 on a cash down basis.
c. Possession of the flat was physically handed over to the Complainant on 21.11.2020 by Northern Division-9. The housing pocket in Sector G-7 was completed in 2017, with a total of 4,297 LIG flats constructed and 4,183 flats allotted up to 31.08.2024.
d. In response to the Complainant's allegations of inhabitable conditions, DDA undertook comprehensive measures addressing various concerns:
Road Connectivity: Two gates established with proper road access;
Water Supply: R.O. plant installed for potable water; iii. Sewage: Existing and additional Sewage Treatment Plants installed;
Sanitation: Daily cleaning and garbage collection facilities implemented;
Safety and Security: Police chowki established, security agency assigned, boundary wall strengthening initiated
e. A joint inspection by MCD found no deficiencies in the handed-over services, as evidenced by their NIL deficiency report.
f. Regarding specific infrastructure concerns, the Respondents cleared that lifts in Block-F are functional and under Annual Comprehensive Maintenance, efforts to address fire hydrant thefts through FIR lodgement and green areas maintained by Horticulture wing
g. Consequently, DDA prays that the Hon'ble Authority may dismiss the present complaint and pass any order deemed fit and proper.
We have heard the arguments of Ld. Counsels of both the parties and perused the records of the case.
Analysis and Consideration:
Upon examination of the submitted documents and arguments, the Authority observes that the Respondent indicated the housing pocket was completed in 2017 and allotments were made in accordance with prescribed procedures. It is further noted that physical possession of the flat was transferred to the Complainant on November 21, 2020, which fundamentally distinguishes this case from instances of non-delivery of possession.
Section 11(1) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016 explicitly mandates that the promoter shall provide the real estate project in the manner and within the time period specified in the agreement for sale.
Moreover, Section 11(4) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016 stipulates that every promoter shall be responsible for providing and maintaining essential services and the project layout, in accordance with the sanctioned building plan, until the Residential Welfare Association (RWA) or the residents assume management of the project. This provision establishes a clear statutory obligation on the promoter to ensure the maintenance and essential services of the project.
The Authority reiterates that physical possession of the flat was handed over to the Complainant on November 21, 2020, which fundamentally differentiates this case from scenarios involving non-delivery of possession.
Considering the remedial actions undertaken by the Respondent and the fact of possession being delivered, the complaint cannot be sustained in its present form seeking an unconditional refund. The Complainant's primary relief sought a complete refund of ₹22,66,767, is fundamentally challenged by well-established legal principles that, once possession is taken and continued, the remedy of complete refund becomes substantially restricted.
The Complainant has been in possession of the flat since November 21, 2020, which exceeds three years, and has continued to reside therein. This voluntary continuation of possession significantly undermines the claim for a complete refund.
Section 18(3) of the Act provides specific mechanisms to address deficiencies in real estate projects. These mechanisms include requiring the promoter to rectify deficiencies, compensating the allottee for specific issues, and providing a refund with interest if the promoter fails to remedy identified defects.
In light of the provisions of Section 31 of the Act, the Authority provides alternative mechanisms for redressal. The Complainant is advised to pursue specific remedies such as: filing a detailed complaint articulating exact deficiencies, seeking proportionate compensation through appropriate channels, actively participating in Resident Welfare Association formation, and pursuing specific repair and maintenance requests through established mechanisms.
However, acknowledging the Complainant's continued concerns, the Authority advises the Complainant to file a complaint in Form 'N' before the Learned Adjudicating Officer under Section 18(3) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, specifically delineating the exact nature of defects or deficiencies in the flat or complex.
The present complaint is accordingly dismissed. The Complainant retains the liberty to pursue appropriate remedies under Section 18(3) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016.
No order is made with respect to costs.
The file shall be consigned to the record room.
