High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 P&H CK 6108

Renu Goyal vs State Of Haryana & Ors.

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 27 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Harpreet Singh Brar, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
C.W.P. No.30899 of 2019 (O&M) and C.W.P. No.31939 of 2019 (O&M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

32 paragraphs · 1,896 words

HARPREET SINGH BRAR, J. (ORAL)

1.

With the consent of parties, this common order shall dispose of the aforementioned two civil writ petitions as they arise from a similar factual matrix. For the sake of brevity, the facts are taken from CWP-30899-2019.

2.

The Civil Writ Petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ in the nature of Certiorari for quashing the selection and appointment of private respondent Nos.3 to 6, who have been selected and appointed to the post of Assistant Registrar vide Result dated 13.07.2019 (Annexure P-10). The petitioner seeks a direction to the official respondents to appoint her to the post of Assistant Registrar as per her merit. It is further prayed that an investigation into the alleged irregularities, record fabrication, and forgery in the selection process be entrusted to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI).

CONTENTIONS

3.

Learned Counsel for the petitioner, inter alia, contends that respondent No.2-University issued an Advertisement No. SVSU/18/ENT/007 (Annexure P-2) inviting applications for direct recruitment to various non-academic posts. Being fully qualified for the post of Assistant Registrar, the petitioner duly submitted her online application within the stipulated deadline prescribed in the aforesaid advertisement. In terms of the selection criteria set out therein (Annexure P-2), the total evaluation comprises 100 marks, divided equally between a 50-mark written test and 50 marks allocated toward academic merit, experience, and interview. Under this scheme, clearing the written examination is a mandatory prerequisite for being shortlisted for document verification and the subsequent interview. It is submitted that the petitioner appeared in the written examination, conducted on 19.01.2018 as discernible from the admit card (Annexure P-3A) and secured 57 marks, whereas private respondents secured less than 50 marks in the written examination, as discernible from the result (Annexure P-4) of the written examination. The petitioner not only secured higher marks in the written examination but was also awarded 23.65 marks under the combined criteria of academic merit and experience. Consequently, having met the requisite threshold, she was duly called for the scrutiny of documents. However, the petitioner was declared ineligible on the ground that she had not attached the proper Experience Certificate with the Application Form and was thus ignored, whereas the private respondents were allowed to participate in the interview in spite of not having the proper Experience Certificates. It is pointed out that a perusal of Annexure P-5 reveals that, barring respondent No. 3, all private respondents, including the petitioner, were shown to have inappropriate experience. Yet, as evident from Annexure P-8, only respondent Nos. 3, 5, and 6 were called for the interview, whereas the petitioner and respondent No. 4 were left out.

3.1.

It is argued that the result dated 13.07.2019 (Annexure P-10) clearly indicates that respondent No. 4 (Vinay Saini) was amongst the selected candidates, in spite of the fact that he was never called for the interview. Moreover, post-selection, a notice was issued for document verification wherein respondent Nos.3 to 6 were afforded an opportunity to submit proof of their educational administrative experience as well as salary verification. As such, it is contended that the respondent-University adopted different yardsticks and indulged in cherry-picking in the very same selection process, while completely ignoring the petitioner's Experience Certificate dated 17.09.2016 (appended at page 51 of the paper-book).

3.2.

It is further submitted that once the private respondents were permitted to participate in the interview despite lacking proper experience certificates, the petitioner also submitted a valid Experience Certificate on 25.02.2019 (Annexure P-9), clearly demonstrating that she discharged administrative responsibilities alongside her teaching duties. As such, the petitioner is entitled to parity and the grant of identical relief.

4.

Per contra, learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 2 contends that the petitioner's reliance on Annexure P-13 is wholly misconceived. It is submitted that the selection process was not carried out in-house by the respondent-University itself, but was entrusted to three independent bodies/agencies to ensure fairness and transparency: the written examination was conducted by Deenbandhu Chhotu Ram University of Science and Technology (DCRUST), Murthal; the scrutiny of documents for evaluating educational qualifications and awarding experience marks was assigned to Indira Gandhi University, Meerpur, Rewari; and the interview was conducted by the statutory Establishment Committee in accordance with the relevant Statutes of the University. As such, there is no violation of the mandate of the procedure prescribed for the selection of the post in question. After the recommendation and appointment of the private respondents, the University further verified their credentials by conducting an additional scrutiny; hence, there is no substantiated allegation of mala fides.

4.1.

Learned senior counsel for respondent Nos. 4 to 6 controverts the stand taken by the petitioner and has raised two preliminary objections. Firstly, it is contended that the petitioner's reliance upon the Scrutiny Committee's recommendations (Annexure P-5) is wholly misplaced, inasmuch as learned counsel for the petitioner has omitted to consider the explanatory Note appended at the foot thereof, whereby, all candidates were afforded another opportunity to supply any document in support of their educational qualifications, experience, or eligibility, in the event the same had not been annexed with their application forms for any reason, on or before 15:00 hours on 14.02.2019. Thereafter, through a subsequent notification dated 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/2), the time limit for submitting such documents was explicitly extended till 15:00 hours on 20.02.2019.

4.2.

It is further submitted that the petitioner's assertion regarding respondent No. 4 not being called for the interview is factually incorrect. Following the extension of the deadline and the subsequent submission of documents, a revised Interview Notice was issued (Annexure R-4/3), wherein the roll number of respondent No. 4 is duly reflected. Drawing reference to the Experience Certificate submitted by the petitioner alongside her application form (at page 51), learned Senior Counsel for the respondents submits that it fails to demonstrate any administrative experience, which is an essential prerequisite for the non-teaching post of Assistant Registrar, whereas the certificate of respondent No. 4, issued on 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/5), clearly indicates that he performed duties as a Head of the Department and was involved in both administrative and teaching work. Additionally, he had also been serving as Chief Warden of the college in question. Moreover, it is contended that the certificate submitted by the petitioner was admittedly submitted on 25.02.2019, well after the cut-off date specified in the notice dated 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/2). It is urged that there is neither any allegation of mala fides nor any substantiated plea of favoritism raised by the petitioner.

OBSERVATIONS AND ANALYSIS

5.

Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after perusal of the record with their able assistance, it transpires that the petitioner along with private respondents, participated in the selection process pursuant to the advertisement (supra) for recruitment to the post of Assistant Registrar. The essential qualification and experience for the said post as discernible from Annexure P-2 reads as under:-

4. Assistant Registrar

1.Name of the PostAssistant Registrar
2.Number of Posts04 (UR), 01 (SC)
3.ClassificationB
4.Pay Band15600-39100+5400
5.Mode of RecruitmentDirect
6.Age limit for direct recruits50 years
7.Educational and other qualification required for direct recruitsMaster’s Degree/LLB with at least 55% or its equivalent grade of B in the UGC seven-point scale. OR B.E./B.Tech. with first division or its equivalent grade. 5 years of experience as Assistant Professor in a college or a University with experience in education administration OR 5 years’ experience as superintendent in a University/examining body conducting public examination OR comparable experience in research establishments and/or institutions of higher education.
8.Period of probation if any2 years
6.

The petitioner's Experience Certificate dated 17.09.2016 attached with the application form (Annexure P-3, at page 51 of the paper-book) merely indicates that she served as an Assistant Professor in the Department of Electronics and Communication Engineering at Manav Rachna University, Faridabad. There is no mention therein of the petitioner having acquired any experience in educational administration. On 12.02.2019, the Scrutiny Committee recorded its observations concerning the experience possessed by candidates for various posts, flagging inappropriate experience among various candidates and appending an explanatory Note at the foot of Annexure P-5, whereby a uniform opportunity was afforded to all aspirants to rectify deficiencies in the documents already annexed or to furnish any document that could not be submitted alongside their application forms, with the deadline fixed as 14.02.2019. The said Note reads as under:

"Note:

In case, any candidate could not attach any document in support of qualification/experience/eligibility etc. due to any reason even after giving one opportunity, the LAST OPPORTUNITY is given to submit relevant document(s). All such document(s) to be sent on mail id: [email protected] upto 15.00 Hrs on 14th Feb, 2019. Candidates must ensure that they should submit all documents in support of their eligibility as per the notified eligibility criteria in the advertisement. Experience certificate must be issued by competent Authority mentioning pay scale and experience in the relevant area.

In the subject of mail only Roll Number and Name of Post to be given, in the body of mail details of documents must be mentioned. The University will not be responsible for any delay or late submission of document(s) and will not consider any representations after 15.00 Hrs on 14th Feb, 2019.

Interview schedule for all eligible candidates will be published on the University website separately."

7.

Thereafter, vide notification dated 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/2), the competent authority extended the timeline for submission of deficient documents up to 20.02.2019. A perusal of the certificate dated 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/5) page 129 demonstrates that respondent No. 4 was actively involved in both administrative and academic assignments, having discharged duties as Head of the Department as well as Chief Warden. Furthermore, the petitioner's assertion that respondent No. 4 was selected despite never having been called for the interview is factually incorrect, inasmuch as a perusal of the interview notice dated 25.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/3) explicitly reflects the roll number of respondent No. 4. It is trite law that the terms and conditions of an advertisement are sacrosanct and bind not only the participating candidates but the Selection Committee as well. The advertisement (supra) prescribes five years of experience as an Assistant Professor coupled with experience in educational administration. Given that the post in question is non-academic in character, the stipulated experience bears a direct nexus to the functional requirements of the post of Assistant Registrar.

CONCLUSION

8.

Admittedly, the petitioner originally annexed the 17.09.2016 (page 51) experience certificate with her application form (Annexure P-3), and when the Scrutiny Committee flagged it on 12.02.2019 (Annexure P-5), she re-submitted that very same certificate on 13.02.2019 (Annexure P-6), which was demonstrably deficient as it failed to reflect any experience in educational administration. Although the cut-off date for curing such documentary deficiencies was extended up to 20.02.2019 vide notification dated 14.02.2019 (Annexure R-4/2), the petitioner submitted a fresh Experience Certificate dated 25.02.2019 (Annexure P-9, page 76 of the paper-book) only on 25.02.2019, well after the extended deadline had expired. In such circumstances, this Court finds no infirmity or illegality in the action of the respondent-authorities in declining to consider the candidature of the petitioner for lack of requisite qualifying experience.

9.

In view of the aforesaid discussion, both the present writ petitions are dismissed.

10.

Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.

11.

Photocopy of this order be placed on the file of the connected case.