AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J.
The present writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondent-Commission to consider the candidature of the petitioner for the post of Primary Teacher (PRT), Mewat Cadre, advertised vide Advertisement No.05/2024, in the EWS category. Further prayer is for issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the final result dated 24.07.2026 (Annexure P-8) to the extent of the last selected candidate of the EWS category, and for a direction to the respondent-Commission to adopt a mechanism of provisional rejection, as adopted by the Haryana Public Service Commission (Annexure P-14), so as to afford all candidates an opportunity of correction at the appropriate stage.
CONTENTIONS
Learned counsel for the petitioner, inter alia, contends that the petitioner participated in the selection process pursuant to Advertisement No.05/2024 dated 09.08.2024 (Annexure P-1) issued by the respondent-Commission, under which online applications were to be submitted between 12.08.2024 and 21.08.2024. Clause 4.4 of the advertisement required the candidates claiming the benefit of the EWS category to furnish an EWS certificate valid for the year 2024-25. It is submitted that the petitioner applied for a fresh EWS certificate on the SARAL portal on 15.08.2024 but, owing to a technical glitch on the portal, he could not obtain the certificate before the closing date. The acknowledgment slip regarding the same was generated on 21.08.2024 (Annexure P-4) after verification by the Sarpanch and the Patwari. Accordingly, to prevent his application form from lapsing, he submitted the same on 21.08.2024 (Annexure P-5) in the EWS category, and uploaded along with it the income certificate dated 15.08.2024 (Annexure P-3) and the acknowledgment slip of the SARAL portal (Annexure P-4). The EWS certificate was thereafter issued to him on 22.08.2024 (Annexure P-6).
It is further submitted that the petitioner remained successful throughout the selection process and secured 71.25 marks (Annexure P-9), as against the cut-off of 70.3 marks for the EWS category. However, he has been excluded from the final result declared on 24.07.2026 (Annexure P-8) for not uploading the EWS certificate. Learned counsel points out that the candidates were never called for physical verification, and the scrutiny was confined to the documents uploaded along with the application forms (Annexure P-7), without any intimation to the petitioner of the defect. In response to his representation dated 03.08.2026 (Annexure P-10), the petitioner was informed that his candidature had not been considered for want of a valid EWS certificate.
Learned counsel emphasizes that the eligibility of the petitioner is not in question, since the certificate in question was applied for before the cut-off date, and that his substantive eligibility cannot be defeated by portal technicalities or by a hyper-technical approach. Reliance is placed upon the order dated 01.07.2025 passed in CWP-17581-2025, titled as ‘Sheetal and others v. State of Haryana and another’ (Annexure P-12), wherein the learned Advocate General, Haryana, on instructions from the respondent-Commission, made a statement that the candidates who had applied for their reservation certificates on the SARAL portal before the closing date would be considered in the respective reserved category upon production of the certificate. Pursuant thereto, the respondent-Commission, vide public notice dated 16.10.2025 (Annexure P-13), opened a correction portal for the candidates of the Common Eligibility Test (Group-C), 2025. Reliance is also placed upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE, (2005) 9 SCC 779.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent-Commission raises a preliminary objection that the certificate for claiming eligibility under the EWS category was not uploaded with the application form, and that the petitioner was not even in possession of the same as on the cut-off date stipulated in the advertisement for the submission of online application forms. It is submitted that it is trite law that the eligibility of a candidate has to be reckoned from the cut-off date. Reliance is placed upon the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in LPA-1397-2025, titled as ‘Haryana Public Service Commission v. Pardeep Kumar and others’, decided on 03.11.2025.
OBSERVATION & ANALYSIS
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record with their able assistance. The respondent-Commission issued Advertisement No.05/2024 dated 09.08.2024 (Annexure P-1) for recruitment to 1456 posts of PRT (Mewat Cadre), and online applications were invited from 12.08.2024 to 21.08.2024. The relevant clauses of the advertisement read as under:-
“4.4EWS certificate on prescribed proforma should be valid for the year in which the candidates have applied for the posts as per govt. instructions issued vide no. 22/12/2019-1GS-III, dated 25.02.2019. EWS certificate issued for jobs in Central Govt. will not be considered irrespective of income mentioned in certificate. The copy of EWS proforma is placed at Annexure-IV. If a candidate fails to submit certificate as per above requirement, then he/she shall be considered under General Category.
XX XX XX XX
9.5.The hard copy of application form along with all uploaded documents must be brought at the time when called upon to do so by Haryana Staff Selection Commission. Documents which have not been uploaded, shall not be entertained. However HSSC may ask an additional paper in support of already submitted document for more clarity if so desired.
XX XX XX XX
9.9.The Commission does not carry out physical scrutiny of the documents at the time submission of online application and the same is done only at the time of Scrutiny of documents.
XX XX XX XX
10.1.Applications must be submitted in online mode only. The hard copy of application form along with all uploaded documents must be brought at the time when called upon to do so by Haryana Staff Selection Commission. Documents which have not been uploaded shall not be entertained. However HSSC may ask additional documents in support of already uploaded documents if so desired.
XX XX XX XX
12.23.If any documents are required to be renewed/re-issue candidate must submit the old and new documents both at the time of scrutiny of documents.
XX XX XX XX
13.Scrutiny of Documents:- The Commission will not undertake detailed scrutiny of applications for the eligibility and other aspects at the time of written examination and, therefore, candidature will be considered only provisionally. The candidates are advised to go through the requirements of educational qualification, age & reservation etc. and satisfy themselves that they are eligible for the post. Only valid uploaded documents shall be considered for qualifications & experience. The uploaded document should be valid upto cut-off date in all respect, if it is beyond the cut-off date it shall not be considered. If at the time of scrutiny or at any stage any particulars are found false/incorrect due to non-submission/wrong submission of documents then candidature shall be deemed to be cancelled and such candidates shall not be considered against even unreserved category.”
(Emphasis added)
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid clauses shows that the EWS certificate was required to be valid for the year 2024-25 and to be held as on the cut-off date, i.e. 21.08.2024. Turning to the record, the acknowledgment generated by the SARAL portal (Annexure P-4) shows that the application of the petitioner bearing SARAL ID HREWS/2024/205214, for the issuance of an Income and Asset Certificate for the EWS category, was received before the cut-off date. The EWS certificate (Annexure P-6), valid for the year 2024-25 and certifying the income of his family for the financial year 2023-24, was issued on 22.08.2024.
It is settled law that the status of a candidate in the EWS category is not a constant status, since it depends upon the income and assets of his family for a particular financial year. A two-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Divya v. Union of India, (2024) 1 SCC 448, speaking through Justice K.V. Viswanathan, has held as under:-
“44.The meaning of the word “eligible” as defined in P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon is set out hereunder:-
“Applied to the selection of persons, the word has two meanings i.e. “legally qualified,” or “fit to be chosen.”
Applied to our context, a person can be found eligible as an economically weaker section candidate and he can be considered as a fit person to be chosen under that category only if the requirement of the OM of 31.01.2019 and Rule 27(3) read with Rule 28 are fulfilled. In Gaurav Singh’s case (supra), it has been categorically held that assets for the particular Financial Year, prior to the year of submission, goes to the root of eligibility of the candidate in the EWS category. It has been further held therein that the candidates whose I&ACs are not in order did not have any legal right to be considered. It has also been held that no candidate can claim any legal right for reconsideration of the candidature by submitting a fresh certificate and/or a rectified certificate.
45.That is the fundamental distinction between the Charles J. Skaria (supra) line of cases and the cases at hand. As pointed out earlier, the eligibility for being categorized as EWS candidate crystallizes only when the I&AC is issued and, in this case, as required under the rules, it was to be issued and possessed by the candidate before 22.02.2022.
46.It is also very well settled that if there are relevant rules which prescribe the date on which the eligibility should be possessed, those rules will prevail. In the absence of rules or any other date prescribed in the prospectus/advertisement for determining the eligibility, there is a judicial chorus holding that it would be the last date for submission of the application. (See Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan [1993 Supp (3) SCC 168]; Bhupinderpal Singh v. State of Punjab [(2000) 5 SCC 262]; Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India [(2007) 4 SCC 54].”
(Emphasis added)
However, the rule that the certificate must be issued by the cut-off date is not without exception. A three-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sakshi Arha v. Rajasthan High Court, 2025 INSC 463, speaking through Justice Augustine George Masih, held as under:-
“38.Significant reliance is placed by the Appellants on the 3-Judge Bench decision of this Court in Ram Kumar Gijroya (supra). A perusal of the decision rendered by the High Court of Delhi on the factual matrix therein is evidently distinct. The same, thus, cannot come to the rescue of the Appellants. In the instant case, it is not a contention of Appellants that they are missing a valid proof of attainment of their particular qualification or right. No candidate before us has a claim that they, to begin with, already availed and established their eligibility, or had applied for a NCL category certificate and issuance of the same is delayed at the behest of the competent authority. The ratio, therefore, in the relied judgment would not apply.”
(Emphasis added)
Thus, a candidate who, on or before the cut-off date, made a complete application to the competent authority for a certificate through the channel prescribed by the State, and to whom the certificate was issued later on that very application, cannot be said to lack the eligibility on the cut-off date. Having done all that was required of him before that date, such a candidate cannot be made to bear the time taken by the State machinery in issuing the certificate. The record of the portal, showing the application number and its date, is sufficient proof of such an application, whereas a bare plea of a technical glitch would not suffice. Notably, Clause 12.23 of the advertisement, which requires a candidate to produce both the old and the renewed document at the time of scrutiny, rests upon the same principle. Moreover, the respondent-Commission has itself accepted this position. In Sheetal (supra), the following statement was made by the learned Advocate General, Haryana, as recorded in the order dated 01.07.2025 (Annexure P-12):-
“Learned Advocate General, Haryana, on instructions from Mr. Parvesh Khokhar, District Attorney, Haryana Staff Selection Commission submits that in so far as the cases of candidates who had submitted their online application(s) for issuance of the respective reservation certificates on the Saral portal before the closing date and had also applied in the general category awaiting the issuance of the reservation certificates are concerned, those applicants shall be considered under the respective reserved category on the applicants producing the respective certificate of eligibility, in relation to the respective classes for which the benefit of reservation has been claimed, as and when they are required to do so by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission for which Public Notice/information shall be sent to all candidates. He thus contends that the grievance of such candidates shall be duly redressed.” (Emphasis added)
The respondent-Commission was directed in Sheetal (supra) to abide by the aforesaid undertaking, and it opened a correction portal vide public notice dated 16.10.2025 (Annexure P-13) in compliance thereof. Though the said undertaking was given in the context of the Common Eligibility Test (Group-C), 2025, it rests upon the same principle, namely, that a candidate who applied for the certificate on the SARAL portal before the closing date is to be considered in the reserved category upon production of that certificate. The respondent-Commission, being an instrumentality of the State, cannot apply a different yardstick to the petitioner in a recruitment conducted by it.
Furthermore, this Court is of the considered view that once the eligibility is held on the cut-off date, the time and the mode of its proof are matters of procedure. A three-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dolly Chhanda (supra), speaking through Justice G.P. Mathur, held as under:-
“7.The general rule is that while applying for any course of study or a post, a person must possess the eligibility qualification on the last date fixed for such purpose either in the admission brochure or in application form, as the case may be, unless there is an express provision to the contrary. There can be no relaxation in this regard i.e. in the matter of holding the requisite eligibility qualification by the date fixed. This has to be established by producing the necessary certificates, degrees or mark-sheets. Similarly, in order to avail of the benefit of reservation or weightage etc. necessary certificates have to be produced. These are documents in the nature of proof of holding of particular qualification or percentage of marks secured or entitlement for benefit of reservation. Depending upon the facts of a case, there can be some relaxation in the matter of submission of proof and it will not be proper to apply any rigid principle as it pertains in the domain of procedure. Every infraction of the rule relating to submission of proof need not necessarily result in rejection of candidature.”
(Emphasis added)
Following the aforesaid principle, the Division Bench of this Court in CWP-23835-2024, titled as ‘Divya Kalia v. State of Haryana and others’, decided on 20.03.2025, held as under:-
“9.(...) The general rule, thus, is that a candidate must deposit all requisite certificate(s) etc. at the time of submitting his application form and he ought not to be permitted to rectify such certificate(s). However, possession of a qualification is starkly distinct from the proof thereof. Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Charles K. Skaria (supra) has held that what is essential is the possession of a qualification before the concerned date and mode of proof thereof, is ancillary. Following this dicta; the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the cases of Dolly Chhanda (supra), Ram Kumar Gijroya (supra) and Karan Singh Yadav (supra); has carved out exception(s) when it relates to submission of a certificate/testimonial with a technical defect/irregularity, which was beyond the reasonable control of such candidate(s). (...) The common denominator, which runs through these decisions is that, even when correct requisite certificate(s) were allowed to be submitted belatedly, such candidate did actually possess such qualification on the cut-off-date. In other words, the Apex Court has enunciated that such certificate(s)/testimonial(s) were proof of an attribute which the candidate already possessed of and such attribute was not attained after the cut-off-date.
Judicial notice can well be taken by this Court that, such reservation certificate(s) are, more often than not, issued at the end of the concerned authority(s) and a candidate does not have any say nay authoritative say in issuance thereof. In actual life, it is often exasperatingly cumbersome for a candidate to obtain requisite certificate nay one issued in the exact prescribed form from the concerned authority. A technical irregularity/defect in such certificate(s) issued by the concerned competent authority is, thus, beyond the control of an aspirant. Actual excellence or even basic eligibility, thus, cannot be permitted to be obliterated by the choice of an orthodox interpretation of law and procedure. Equity ought to overpower technicality where the justice so demands. (...)” (Emphasis added)
Adverting to the facts of the present case, the application of the petitioner for the EWS certificate was received on the SARAL portal before the cut-off date, and the certificate (Annexure P-6) was issued to him well before the due date of 02.09.2024 shown in the acknowledgment. The petitioner, thus, did all that was required of him before the cut-off date, and the certificate so issued relates to the very period prescribed by the advertisement. Therefore, his eligibility in the EWS category cannot be said to have come into existence after the cut-off date. Further, the petitioner claimed the EWS category in his application form (Annexure P-5), and nothing on record suggests any misrepresentation on his part. Moreover, the respondent-Commission, despite holding the power under Clauses 9.5 and 10.1 of the advertisement to call for additional documents in support of those already uploaded, scrutinized only the uploaded documents without any intimation to the petitioner. The petitioner came to know of his exclusion only upon the declaration of the final result on 24.07.2026, and he moved promptly by submitting his representation dated 03.08.2026 (Annexure P-10) and thereafter by approaching this Court.
CONCLUSION
In view of the foregoing discussion, the present petition is hereby allowed in the following terms:-
a. The final result dated 24.07.2026 (Annexure P-8) is hereby quashed and set aside to the extent the candidature of the petitioner has not been considered in the EWS category.
b. The respondents/competent authorities shall verify from the record of the SARAL portal that the application of the petitioner bearing SARAL ID HREWS/2024/205214 was made on or before the cut-off date and the EWS certificate dated 22.08.2024 (Annexure P-6) was issued on that very application. Upon such verification, the candidature of the petitioner shall be considered in the EWS category. If the petitioner is found meritorious and otherwise eligible, he shall be appointed to the post of Primary Teacher (PRT), Mewat Cadre, against an available vacancy and, in the event of no vacancy being available, against a supernumerary post.
c. In the event of his appointment, the petitioner shall be entitled to all consequential notional benefits, including seniority, from the date on which the candidates with lesser marks, selected in the EWS category, were appointed. However, actual monetary benefits shall be given to him only from the date of his actual joining.
d. Needless to say, the candidates already selected and appointed shall not be disturbed. Unseating them at this stage would be contrary to public interest, as they have gained considerable experience in the meantime. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited v. Sandeep Choudhary, 2022(2) SCT 657 and of the Constitution Bench in Sivanandan C.T. v. High Court of Kerala, 2024(3) SCC 799.
e. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
