AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J. (Oral)
PRAYER
Prayer in this writ petition filed under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India, is for issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus, directing the respondent/Commission to consider the candidature of the petitioner under the Economically Weaker Section (EWS) category for selection and appointment to the post of Storekeeper (Category No.18) against advertisement No.12/2019 dated 20.07.2019 (Annexure P-1). Further prayer has been made to direct the respondent/Commission to revise the result declared on 31.01.2023 and 06.02.2023 (wrongly mentioned as 06.01.2023) (Annexures P-16 and P-17, respectively) by the respondent/Commission for considering him under General Category instead of EWS category for the post in question and to place him at the appropriate place in the selection list under the EWS category.
CONTENTIONS
Learned counsel for the petitioner has, inter alia, contended that the petitioner participated in the selection process against advertisement No.12 of 2019 (Annexure P-1) for the post of Store Keeper (Category No.18) under the EWS category. Eleven posts in the advertisement were reserved for the candidates belonging to the EWS category. The petitioner, being fully eligible, uploaded all requisite documents along with the online application form, including a valid EWS Certificate bearing No. EWS/2019/234 dated 02.04.2019 issued by the competent authority prior to the cut-off date prescribed under the advertisement (supra). Learned counsel for the petitioner has further argued that the petitioner submitted his application form on 10.09.2019 (Annexure P-8) and specifically disclosed the particulars of the aforesaid EWS certificate (Annexure P-7) in the relevant column of the application form. The petitioner, thereafter, appeared in the written examination pursuant to notice dated 31.01.2020 (Annexure P-10) and was declared successful in the result notified on 08.02.2022 (Annexure P-12).
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further contended that owing to COVID-19 pandemic, instead of physical scrutiny of documents contemplated under advertisement No.12 of 2019 (Annexure P-1), the respondent/Commission introduced an online scrutiny process and directed successful candidates to upload documents online vide result/notice dated 08.02.2022 (Annexure P-12) and scrutiny instructions (Annexure P-13). According to learned counsel for the petitioner, the notice issued along with the result (Annexure P-12) did not clarify whether the candidates were required to upload the same documents originally submitted with the application form (Annexure P-8). Consequently, acting under a bona fide impression and by way of abundant caution, the petitioner uploaded his subsequent EWS Certificate bearing No.EWS/2021/719 dated 10.03.2021. It is contended that the petitioner's eligibility as an EWS candidate on the cut-off date is undisputed, however, the respondent/Commission, during the online scrutiny, rejected the petitioner’s EWS claim merely on the ground that the petitioner had uploaded the subsequent EWS certificate dated 10.03.2021 (Annexure P-14) instead of re-uploading the EWS Certificate dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7) which was originally submitted with the application form (Annexure P-8).
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further argued that the petitioner subsequently submitted both the original EWS Certificate dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7) and the subsequent EWS certificate dated 10.03.2021 (Annexure P-14) to the respondent/Commission vide representation/Diary No.4927 dated 03.06.2022 (Annexure P-15), well before the declaration of the final result (Annexure P-16). It is, therefore, argued that denial of EWS benefit to the petitioner is wholly arbitrary, hyper-technical and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
Per contra, learned State counsel has argued that the recruitment process is strictly governed by the terms and conditions contained in advertisement No.12 of 2019 (Annexure P-1). It is contended that Clause 3.2 of the advertisement (Annexure P-1) specifically provides that only those documents which are uploaded by the candidate shall be considered at the time of scrutiny and any variation in the uploaded documents renders the candidature liable to cancellation.
Learned State counsel has further submitted that although the petitioner had mentioned particulars of EWS Certificate No.EWS/2019/234 dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7) in his application form (Annexure P-8), however at the time of online scrutiny, he uploaded an EWS Certificate No.EWS/2021/719 dated 10.03.2021 (Annexure P-14) which had admittedly been issued after the cut-off date of 26.09.2019. Since the claim under the reserved category was required to be substantiated through the documents uploaded at the time of scrutiny, the petitioner was rightly denied consideration under the EWS category.
OBSERVATIONS & ANALYSIS
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the case with their able assistance.
The facts necessary for adjudication of the controversy are not in dispute. The petitioner applied for the post of Store Keeper (Category No.18) advertised by Haryana Staff Selection Commission vide advertisement No.12 of 2019 dated 20.07.2019 (Annexure P-1). The petitioner submitted his application under the EWS category vide application form (Annexure P-8) and disclosed details of EWS Certificate No.EWS/2019/234 dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7). The said certificate had admittedly been issued prior to the closing date prescribed under the advertisement (Annexure P-1). The petitioner successfully cleared the written examination and his roll number figured in the result declared on 08.02.2022 (Annexure P-12).
A perusal of the result/notice dated 08.02.2022 (Annexure P-12) reveals that, owing to the prevailing Covid-19 pandemic, the candidates were directed not to appear physically before the respondent/Commission and the scrutiny of documents was to be undertaken through online mode. The candidates were accordingly given time to fill up the scrutiny form and upload documents online from 12.02.2022 to 22.02.2022. Significantly, however, the said notice did not clearly specify whether the candidates were required to re-upload the very same documents which had already been uploaded with the original application form or whether the documents then available with them were required to be uploaded afresh.
The aforesaid aspect assumes significance in the context of the conditions contained in the advertisement. Clause 2.4 thereof provides a Regulatory Framework and Note Nos. 5, 6 and 8 thereunder read as under:
5.The benefit of reservation will be given only to those SC/BCA/BCB/EWS and ESM candidates who are domicile of Haryana State.
6.The SC/BCA/BCB/EWS/ESP and PwD (Persons with Disabilities) candidates are required to upload certificate duly issued by the competent authority.
8.Qualifications and other terms and conditions of eligibility will be determined with regard to the last date fixed for receipt of online applications, also termed as closing date.
Further, Clause 3.1 of the advertisement provides as under:
"3.1 Documents to be uploaded with Application Form (Mandatory)
1.Scanned copy of essential academic qualifications and matriculation certificate showing date of birth and other relevant details.
2.Scanned copy of SC/BCA/BCB/EWS/ESP/ESM/ DESM/DFF/PwD certificate along with Haryana domicile certificate issued by competent authority.
3.Scanned copy of certificate claiming weightage marks under socio-economic criteria and experience along with Haryana domicile certificate issued by competent authority.
4.Scanned photograph duly signed by the candidate.
5.Scanned signatures of the candidate.
6.Scanned copies of all documents showing higher qualification, experience etc., on which basis candidate claims marks."
Similarly, Clause 3.2 relating to scrutiny of documents reads as under:
3.2Scrutiny of Documents – Only those documents which are uploaded by the candidates shall be considered. If there is any variation in the documents uploaded and produced at the time of scrutiny, candidature shall be liable to be cancelled. If any application is found without uploading requisite supporting documents and other relevant information, the candidate himself/herself shall be responsible for that and his/her candidature would be liable to be cancelled due to lack of proper or correct information."
Moreover, Clause 1.2 of the advertisement (supra) provides for “Procedure/ Instructions/Guidelines for Online Filling of Application Form” and Point (d) and (e) thereof, read as under:
"(d)After successful submission of application, candidates can again take final printout of application form and e-Challan.
(e)The hard copy of application form along with all uploaded documents must be brought at the time when called upon to do so by Haryana Staff Selection Commission. Documents which have not been uploaded shall not be entertained."
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it clear that a candidate seeking the benefit of reservation was required to upload the requisite category certificate along with the application form. At the same time, Note 8 of Clause 2.4 specifically provides that the qualifications and other terms and conditions of eligibility are to be determined with reference to the closing date for receipt of online applications. The closing date prescribed under the advertisement was 21.08.2019, however, the same was subsequently extended by the respondent/Commission, up to 26.09.2019.
The record clearly establishes that the petitioner possessed EWS Certificate No.EWS/2019/234 dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7) well before the closing date. The particulars of the said certificate were specifically disclosed in the original application form (Annexure P-8), and the certificate itself was uploaded along with the application form. The respondents have neither disputed the genuineness of the said certificate nor contended that it was invalid on the closing date. Thus, the petitioner's claim to EWS status was not founded upon any subsequent event or document. His eligibility under the EWS category had already accrued and stood duly disclosed to the respondents on the relevant date.
It is also not disputed that the advertisement (supra) originally contemplated physical scrutiny of documents. Clause 1.2(e) specifically required the candidate to produce the hard copy of the application form along with all the documents uploaded therewith, as and when called upon to do so. Had the procedure originally contemplated in the advertisement been followed, the petitioner would have produced the very same certificate which had been uploaded along with the application form. However, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, physical scrutiny was replaced by online scrutiny. The notice appended to the result dated 08.02.2022 (Annexure P-12) only directed the successful candidates not to appear physically before the respondent/Commission as the documents were to be scrutinized online and no documents were to be accepted offline or manually. The candidates were required to fill up the scrutiny form and upload the documents online between 12.02.2022 and 22.02.2022. However, the said notice did not expressly clarify whether the candidates were required to re-upload the same category certificate that had originally been submitted along with the application form or whether a current category certificate could be uploaded at the stage of online scrutiny.
In these peculiar circumstances, the explanation offered by the petitioner that he uploaded the latest EWS certificate issued on 10.03.2021 (Annexure P-14) under a bona fide impression cannot be said to be implausible. More importantly, the uploading of a latest EWS certificate neither changed the petitioner's category status nor created any new eligibility. The subsequent EWS certificate did not create any new eligibility rather at best, it constituted another document evidencing the same category status which the petitioner had already claimed and substantiated through his original certificate. As such, the foundational requirement of possessing a valid EWS certificate on the cut-off date stood satisfied.
The stipulation contained in Clause 3.2 of the advertisement (supra) requiring consistency in the documents produced at the stage of scrutiny cannot be applied mechanically so as to convert a procedural requirement into a substantive disqualification. The object of such a stipulation is to prevent a candidate from subsequently changing or improving his eligibility by relying upon a different document. It cannot reasonably be construed to extinguish an eligibility which had already accrued on the prescribed date and stood established from the material submitted with the original application.
In the facts of the present case, the respondents were required to examine the original EWS certificate already submitted by the petitioner and, if any doubt persisted regarding its genuineness or validity, seek clarification from him. Instead, the petitioner was denied consideration merely because another valid EWS certificate had been uploaded at the stage of online scrutiny. Such an approach elevates form over substance and disregards the distinction between the existence of eligibility and the subsequent verification of such eligibility.
The aforesaid view is fortified by the judgments rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Charles K. Skaria and others v. Dr. C. Mathew and others, (1980) 2 SCC 752 : AIR 1980 SC 1230; Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE and others, (2005) 9 SCC 779 : AIR 2004 SC 5043; Ram Kumar Gijroya v. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board and another, (2016) 4 SCC 754 : AIR 2016 SC 1098; Karn Singh Yadav v. Government of NCT of Delhi and others, SLP (C) No.14948 of 2016; (2024) 2 SCC 588; and Vashist Narayan Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2024 INSC 2 : (2024) 11 SCC 785, as well as the judgments of this Court in Divya Kalia v. State of Haryana and others, CWP-23835-2024, decided on 20.03.2025, reported as (2025) 1 HCC (P&H) 1, and the judgment rendered by the Delhi High Court in Staff Selection Commission v. Smt. Bala, W.P.(C) No.17740 of 2024, decided on 28.04.2025.
The petitioner submitted both the original EWS Certificate dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7) and the subsequent EWS Certificate dated 10.03.2021 (Annexure P-14) before the respondent/Commission vide representation/Diary No.4927 dated 03.06.2022 (Annexure P-15), much before declaration of the final result on 31.01.2023 (Annexure P-16). Thus, the original EWS certificate was very much available on the record of the respondent/Commission before the final result was declared and could have been duly verified.
In the absence of any fraud, misrepresentation, change of category, subsequent acquisition of eligibility or prejudice to any competing candidate, denial of the petitioner's candidature merely on account of his having uploaded another valid EWS certificate at the stage of online scrutiny cannot be sustained. The subsequent certificate neither nullified the original certificate nor displaced the petitioner's EWS eligibility as existing on the closing date.
It is also not disputed before this Court that the petitioner secured 62 marks and the last selected/wait-listed candidate in the EWS category as reflected in the final result dated 31.01.2023 (Annexure P-16) had secured fewer marks. Further, one post under the EWS category was directed to be kept vacant vide interim order dated 24.02.2023, passed by this Court. Thus, consideration of the petitioner under the EWS category would not cause any prejudice to the other candidates in the selection process.
CONCLUSION
In view of the admitted facts and circumstances of the case, the present petition is allowed. The respondents are directed to reconsider the petitioner's candidature under the EWS category on the basis of EWS Certificate No.EWS/2019/234 dated 02.04.2019 (Annexure P-7), which was in existence prior to the closing date and had been submitted/uploaded with the original application form (Annexure P-8). The respondents shall, accordingly, revise the final result dated 31.01.2023 (Annexure P-16) and corrigendum/partial result dated 06.02.2023 (Annexure P-17), to the limited extent necessary to give effect to the petitioner's entitlement under the EWS category.
Upon such reconsideration, if the petitioner falls within the zone of selection on the basis of his merit and he fulfills all other eligibility, document verification and service requirements applicable to the post in question, the respondents shall recommend his name for appointment against the EWS vacancy and issue the consequential appointment order in accordance with law.
In the event of appointment, the petitioner shall be entitled to all the consequential benefits including notional seniority and other service benefits from the date on which his batch-mates have been selected pursuant to the advertisement (supra). However, the petitioner shall not be entitled to actual salary for the period during which he did not discharge duties and monetary benefits shall be payable to him from the date of his actual joining in pursuance of the appointment so issued.
The aforesaid exercise shall be completed by the respondents within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
