High CourtsSingle Bench(2022) 10 KL CK 0081

P.K.Radeesh vs Pushpa

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 12 October 2022

HON’BLE JUDGES
Sathish Ninan, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Regular Second Appeal No. 814 Of 2010

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

14 paragraphs · 608 words

Sathish Ninan, J.

1.

The defendant in a suit for money is the appellant. The suit, though dismissed by the trial court, was decreed in appeal.

2.

According to the plaintiff, on 06.03.2006, the defendant borrowed an amount of ` 1,00,000/- from the plaintiff agreeing to repay it with interest. Ext.A1 is the agreement executed in the said regard. Since the amount was not being repaid in spite of repeated demands, the suit is filed.

3.

The defendant denied the execution and also her signature on Ext.A1. He denied the alleged transaction with the plaintiff.

4.

One of the witnesses to Ext.A1 agreement was examined as PW2 and the scribe/document writer was examined as PW3. The trial court held their evidence to be not acceptable, and accordingly dismissed the suit. The first appellate court on re-appreciation of the evidence found the plaintiff's case to be probable.

5.

Heard learned counsel Sri.S.Sachithananda Pai on behalf of the appellant-defendant and Sri.A.C.Devasia on behalf of the respondent-plaintiff on the following substantial question of law:-

“Was the first appellate court justified in reversing the trial court decree by relying on the evidence of PWs.2 and 3 ?”

6.

The signature of the defendant on Ext.A1 agreement is denied. There are two attestors to Ext.A1 agreement - one is the husband of the plaintiff, and the other is one Mercy - PW2. According to the defendant, one of his friends, Anish borrowed an amount of ` 25,000/- from PW2 in early 2006. As required by her, a blank cheque of the defendant was given as security. The cheque was misused and criminal proceedings initiated against the defendant. The present suit is filed at the instance of PW2, based on a fabricated document by forging the signature, is the contention.

7.

Though according to the defendant there was a transaction between PW2 and him which resulted in litigation, admittedly, as on the date of Ext.A1 agreement there were no disputes between them over the said transaction. The disputes between them have arisen only subsequent to the present alleged transaction. Therefore, litigation between PW2 and the defendant, by itself, could not be a ground to discard the evidence of PW2.

8.

Be that as it may, keeping aside the evidence of PW2, there is the evidence of PW3 the scribe/document writer. The defendant as DW1 has admitted that the scribe is a person known to him and that he had even got a document written through him. He has further admitted that there is no enmity between him and PW3. There is no reason why PW3 should depose against the defendant.

9.

The plaintiff and defendant are neighbors. Though the defendant challenges the financial capacity of the plaintiff, as PW1, she has deposed that she has income from agricultural operations in three acres of property belonging to her. The defendant was examined as DW1. From the cross-examination of DW1 it is evident that he had the habit of borrowing amounts from various persons. Though the defendant disputed his signature on Ext.A1, but for attempting to put the burden on the plaintiff, he did not take any steps to have the signature sent for expert opinion. The plaintiff had discharged the initial burden of proving the transaction by examining PWs.2 and 3.

10.

The first appellate court has analysed the evidence in detail and found the evidence of PWs.2 and 3 to be acceptable. I have noticed supra, various circumstances which justify the conclusions of the appellate court. Substantial question of law is answered accordingly.

11.

The judgment of the first appellate court warrants no interference.

The Regular Second Appeal lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.