High CourtsSingle Bench(2023) 11 KL CK 0033

Joe P.John vs Smt.Elizebath

High Court Of Kerala · Decided on 8 November 2023

HON’BLE JUDGES
Sathish Ninan, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Regular First Appeal No.739 of 2011

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

16 paragraphs · 886 words

Sathish Ninan, J.

1.

The decree for money is under challenge by the defendant in the suit.

2.

The suit has been instituted on Ext.A1 promissory note dated 30.08.2004. According to the plaintiff, on 30.08.2004 the defendant borrowed an amount of ` 2,30,000/- and executed Ext.A1 promissory note in her favour agreeing to repay it with interest. Consequent on the failure on the part of the defendant to repay the amount, the suit has been filed.

3.

The defendant denied the execution of Ext.A1 and also the signature and hand writing therein. According to the defendant, he did not have any transaction with the plaintiff. It was contended that Ext.A1 is a fabricated document.

4.

Before the trial court, the plaintiff got herself examined as PW1. One of the witnesses to Ext.A1 promissory note was examined as PW2. No evidence was adduced by the defendant. The trial court on appreciating the evidence upheld Ext.A1 and accordingly granted a decree in favour of the plaintiff.

5.

Heard learned counsel on either side.

6.

The following points arises for determination :-

(i) Is the finding of the trial court with regard to execution of Ext.A1 promissory note sustainable on the evidence on record ?

(ii) Does the decree and judgment of the trial court warrant any interference?

7.

The defendant has denied Ext.A1 and the alleged transaction thereunder. Though according to the plaintiff, her husband and the defendant were friends, the same is denied by the defendant. However, the defendant would admit that there were some sort of business transactions between them. To prove the execution of Ext.A1 promissory note, one of the witnesses in Ext.A1 was examined as PW2. He has vouched to the due execution of Ext.A1 by the defendant. He has also deposed that he has witnessed the passing of the consideration. While the defendant would not deny that there is striking resemblance of the signature in Ext.A1 with his signature, it is the contention that his signature is very simple that anyone can imitate/forge the same.

8.

Ext.A2 is the notice dated 27.11.2006 issued by the plaintiff prior to the institution of the suit, calling upon the defendant to pay the amount under Ext.A1. The notice was not replied by the defendant. The receipt of Ext.A1 is not disputed by the defendant. However it is his case that, on receipt of notice he met the plaintiff in person and he was informed that it was issued only to pressurise the defendant to arrive at a settlement of the dispute between them in respect of their business transaction, and hence the notice was not replied. The explanation offered by the defendant is far from satisfactory. If, the defendant had not borrowed any amount from the plaintiff nor had executed Ext.A1 promissory note, definitely the defendant would have replied to the same and taken appropriate steps. There is no evidence that there were disputes in connection with their business or that after issuance of Ext.A2 notice the dispute was settled. Therefore, the said explanation offered is only to be rejected.

9.

The learned counsel for the appellant would argue that, while PW1 would depose that the defendant had approached her two weeks prior to the grant of loan, PW2 would depose that the request for grant of loan was made only at the time of the transaction. Such contradiction would disprove the case of the plaintiff, it is contended. However, on a reading of the entire oral evidence, I do not think that the evidence is to be understood in the manner as contended by the defendant.

PW1 has categorically deposed that the defendant had made the request for grant of loan about two weeks prior to the transaction. One of the witnesses in Ext.A1 promissory note is one Noble, the son-in-law of the plaintiff. Noble had come to the house of the plaintiff at the time of execution of Ext.A1 promissory note, to be a witness in Ext.A1. It has been so deposed to by PW1. In the cross examination, PW2 has stated that, while he was present at the plaintiff's residence, the defendant came and requested for money which the plaintiff gave on execution of the promissory note which was brought by the defendant. If as contended by the defendant, the request for grant of loan was made for the first time in the presence of PW2, then the defendant would not have brought the promissory note with him. It could only be understood that it was in tune with the earlier understanding that the defendant came to the plaintiff's residence on the date of execution of Ext.A1 for receiving the amount and for executing the promissory note. I do not find any inconsistency between the evidence of PWs.1 and 2 in the said regard.

10.

The trial court has considered the evidence in its entirety and has granted a decree in favour of the plaintiff. The conclusions arrived at by the trial court is sustainable on the evidence. The trial court has allowed the plaintiff to realise interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of suit till date of decree and 6% thereafter, which is only reasonable.

The decree and judgment of the trial court warrants no interference. The points are answered accordingly.

The appeal fails and is dismissed.