Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2019) 08 RERA CK 0822

M/s. Mera Baba Reality Associates Pvt. Ltd.

Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · Decided on 29 August 2019

RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
No.1(30)/PR/2019

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

9 paragraphs · 1,340 words

An application was filed by the applicant M/s. Mera Baba Reality Associates Pvt. Ltd. for grant of registration for its project of construction of additional two floors over and above an existing structure of ground plus twelve floors of D Mall located at Plot No.A-1, Netaji Subhas Place, Ring Road, Pitam Pura, Delhi – 110034. The application was initially filed on 11 April 2019 and subsequently the applicant furnished some more documentation, suo-moto, on 10 May 2019. Upon scrutiny of the application, a deficiency memo was issued to the applicant with the direction to provide clarifications, submit additional documents (as listed therein), and to appear for a personal hearing on 24 May 2019. On that day, the applicant submitted some documents but requested for more time to file i) Structural safety certificate for addition of 13th and 14th floor; ii) Details of additional common areas and escalators etc. to be constructed/created for use of prospective buyers of additional floors; iii) a copy of original sanctioned drawings and revised drawing submitted for various clearances including fire clearance; iv) Copy of drawings submitted to DDA for addition and alteration and accord of permission for adding two floors; v) All relevant documents and submissions in connection with fulfillment of their application under Section 14 of the Act; vi) Cost of the project; vii) Source of funds; viii) An affidavit that they are not getting it financed from any bank or financial institution; and ix) Proforma of allotment letter, agreement for sale and the conveyance deed proposed to be signed with the prospective buyers. the hearing on 26 June 2019 and it was noted that the certificate did not provide details of any non-destructive or destructive tests carried out before issuance of the certificate, and that there was an apparent contradiction between the statement of the applicant and the certificate issued by the Structural Engineer, which needed to be clarified. Subsequently, the applicant furnished another certificate dated 3 May 2019 again purportedly issued by the same Shri M P Goyal, on consideration of which certificate on 19.8.2019, the Authority observed that "... On the certificate the stamp mentions as the name as Shri M P Goyal whereas he has signed the certificate as M.P.Goel. Let the Director of the project Mera Baba Reality Associates file on affidavit clarifying and certifying that the structural certificate has been signed and issued by the same person whose signatures are in the certificate". On 26 August 2019, the Applicant submitted an Affidavit-cum-Declaration signed by the Director of the Applicant along with a reprint of the certificate of 23.8.2019 (original dated 5 April 2019) on the letter head of M/s. Nutech Infrastructure Private Limited. Comparison of the fresh documents with the previously submitted documents indicates that the previous documents prima-facie appear to be fabricated and contain forged signatures of the issuer Shri Mahavir Goyal, Director of the said M/s. Nutech Infrastructure Private Limited. On being asked to explain, the applicant submitted that the previous documents had been submitted to the Authority as received from the office of the Structural Engineer. Let the Secretary RERA explore the filing of an appropriate case against the promoter for filing fabricated documents before the Authority.

3.

The Applicant had sought further time to file documents in respect of item v) above (and after repeated requests for further time) finally, on 25 July 2019, submitted copies of sample Builder-Buyer Agreement and Sale deeds/ conveyance deeds signed with two allottees relating to its earlier project of ground plus twelve floors (that had been completed in the year 2010) in order to demonstrate how the Applicant had retained to itself the rights of unfettered usage of the terrace in future, in any manner as decided by the Applicant. During the perusal of the documents pertaining to the previously completed project, it was current regulatory regime because of their variance from the texts of recommended similar documents under the Act. This also underscores the need for due scrutiny of such documents envisaged to be signed with prospective buyers of the present project. A moot point is whether upon completion of the present project of ‘construction of additional two floors over and above an existing structure of ground plus twelve floors’, the entire complex will function and operate as one singular facility or as two distinct structures/ entities, and in the former case, whether any measures are necessary to safeguard the interests of allottees/ buyers of the existing project.

4.

In its initial application, the Applicant had not submitted several documents that are required for safeguarding the interest of prospective unit-buyers such as the proforma of the allotment letter, agreement for sale and the conveyance deed proposed to be signed with the allottee, on the plea stated in its ‘Affidavit cum Undertaking’ dated 10 May 2019 that the applicant is constructing apartments with its own funds and arrangements, and that the proforma of the allotment letter, agreement for sale and conveyance deed proposed to be signed with the allottees shall be submitted to RERA Delhi as and when the apartments will be sold.

5.

Since these documents were considered a necessary part of the application, non-submission of the above noted legal documents was brought to the attention of the Applicant during the first hearing held on 24 May 2019, and the Applicant had sought time to file these (item no. ix) of the list above). However, the Applicant remained steadfast in its intention not to submit these documents and in its submissions made on 12 June 2019, the Applicant went on to state “...Still if the Authority directs us to file the said Proforma letters, then it may be allowed that we withdraw our application for project registration and our fees for project registration may also be refunded”.

6.

The Real Estate Regulation and Development Act, 2016 is a beneficial Act established with the objective of regulation and promotion manner, and that the interest of the consumers in the real estate sector are protected. The objectives are stated in the Preamble to the Act. Clearly, the enhancement of efficiency and transparency in the dealings between the builder/promoter on one side and the consumer on the other is the raison d'etre, the very reason, for enactment of the regulatory registration.

7.

The ability to "advertise, market, book, sell or offer for sale or invite persons to purchase in any manner any plot, apartment or building, as the case may be,,," and the prior registration of the real estate project are two sides of the same coin. Since these must go together, it does not seem feasible to separate the two. Further, there is no provision in the Act to accommodate the plea made by the applicant for permission to furnish the above-mentioned documents at a point when the applicant "finalizes" its intention to sell the units. Nor is there a provision to allow for refund of project registration fee paid by the applicant upon withdrawal of application.

8.

Taking into account that the submission of above-listed legal documents is intricately connected with the rights of the consumers and their submission is a sine-qua-non for ensuring efficiency and transparency of transactions between the builder/ promoter and unit-buyers; the Authority is of the view that the application for registration of the real estate project in its present form cannot be acceptable. There is no mechanism available whereby after registration of a project, the registrant/ promoter can be held back from its ability to "advertise, market, book, sell or offer for sale or invite persons to purchase in any manner any plot, apartment or building, as the case may be,,," in respect of various units in the registered real estate project until the registrant "finalizes" its "intention to sell" the units and then submits such requisite documents before the Authority that the Applicant chose not to submit prior to the registration of the project.

9.

The application for registration of real estate project is accordingly rejected in its present format.

10.

An intimation of rejection may be conveyed as per Form D.