Tribunals and CommissionsDivision Bench(2025) 11 CAT CK 0010

Hardeep vs Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (DSSSB) & Ors

Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench: New Delhi · Decided on 20 November 2025

RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
Original Application No. 4506 Of 2024

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

33 paragraphs · 1,902 words

Manish Garg, Member (J)

1.

In the present Original Application, the applicant has prayed for the following reliefs:

“8.1 To quash the order dated 07.10.2021 and order dated 18.01.2021 passed by the respondents whereby the candidature of the applicant for the post of warder, under Post Code 86/17, was cancelled.

8.2 To Declare the applicant eligible for the post of warder and pass necessary direction to the respondents to appoint the applicant on the post of warder w.e.f 18.09.2020 with all consequential benefits.

OR

Pass any other order(s), which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem just & equitable in the facts & circumstances of the case.”

2.

The brief facts of the case as narrated by the learned counsel for the applicant are as under:

2.1. The applicant applied for the post of Warder (Post Code 86/177) in the Delhi Prison Department under DSSSB Recruitment-2017 (Advertisement No. F.I (377) DSSSBIP&PP/2017/1151 dated 24.10.2017). He successfully cleared all stages of recruitment, including the Physical Endurance Test and the written examination. Following this, he was shortlisted for appointment and received an Offer of Appointment on 18.09.2020 from the Office of the Director General of Prisons, Tihar, and submitted his documents for verification. On 18.01.2021, a deficiency memo was issued by the respondents to the applicant regarding missing documents. However, on 07.10.2021, the applicant’s candidature was cancelled on the ground of his alleged involvement in FIR No. 188 dated 17.11.2018, and his dossier was returned to DSSSB. The applicant promptly complied with all deficiency memo and submitted the required documents. Despite this, the respondents did not reinstate his candidature.

2.2. The applicant subsequently challenged the cancellation, and on 15.02.2023, he was acquitted of all charges in the said FIR by the Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Hansi, Hisar in Criminal Case No. 24-I of 2019, as the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. The relevant portion of judgment dated 15.02.2023 in Criminal case No. 24-I of 2019, reads as under:

“119. Hence, from the perusal of entire evidence on the file, this court is of the considered view that prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubts. Therefore, this court acquits the accused namely Monu @ Hardeep son of Jagat Singh and Rohit son of Ranveer, from the charges levelled against them. Their previous bail bonds and surety bonds stand discharged. However, their fresh personal bonds in the sum of ₹.20,000/-each furnished, in compliance of Section 437-A of Cr.P.C., which are accepted and attested. Their personal bonds shall discharge automatically, in case no appeal/revision is preferred within the prescribed period by the prosecution. Case property, if any, be handed over to the rightful claimant as per rules after expiry of period of appeal if any or according to the direction of the appellate court.”

2.3. Following the acquittal, the applicant submitted representations dated 12.06.2023 and got issued a legal notice dated 30.06.2023 requesting reconsideration of his appointment. Despite multiple communications, the respondents failed to take any action, leading to unjust delay and inaction.

2.4. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the cancellation of applicant’s candidature was illegal and arbitrary, as he had been honourably acquitted of all criminal charges, which clearly established his suitability for the post of Warder, a post involving clerical and custodial duties with no responsibilities of maintaining law-and-order. Learned counsel further submitted that mere involvement in a criminal case, post-acquittal, cannot be a ground for denial of public employment, and reliance placed by the respondents on the FIR or compromise in the acquittal is legally unsustainable.

2.5. Learned counsel further contended that the applicant had fully disclosed the details of the FIR at the time of application, and there was no concealment or misrepresentation, as required under law. The respondents’ failure to reinstate his candidature post-acquittal violated Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India, the principles of natural justice, and the applicant’s legitimate expectation of appointment after successfully clearing all stages of recruitment.

2.6. Learned counsel for the applicant placed reliance on the judgment of Avtar Singh v. Union of India, AIR 2016 SC 3598, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that once acquitted in a criminal case, there is no ground to deny public employment, unless the acquittal is not honourable or involves moral turpitude. Learned counsel contended that no other adverse material exists against the applicant and, therefore, the respondents’ inaction was arbitrary and unjustified.

3.

Opposing the grant of relief, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 submitted that the DSSSB acted only as the recruiting agency and had forwarded the applicant’s dossier to the User Department (Office of the Director General of Prisons, Tihar) after provisional selection. The final appointment was subject to verification of character, antecedents, and other eligibility criteria by the User Department as per recruitment rules and MHA instructions. It was contended that the candidature was cancelled by the Appointing Authority (Respondent No. 2) based on the character and antecedent report and DSSSB had no independent role in the decision. Learned counsel further stated that the recruitment process for the post had already been completed and the waitlist panel had expired on 11.03.20021.

3.1. Learned counsel for Respondent No. 2 submitted that the applicant’s candidature was cancelled on the ground of his alleged involvement in FIR No. 188 dated 17.11.2018, as reported in the character and antecedent verification from the Police Authority. During document verification, certain deficiencies were also noted in the applicant’s documents, which were rectified by him. The matter was examined in light of the Apex Court judgments in Delhi Administration v. Sushil Kumar, 1999 (11) SCC 605, and Avtar Singh v. Union of India, AIR 2016 SC 3598. Considering the pending criminal case at that time, the candidature was cancelled, and the dossier was returned to DSSSB. Learned counsel further submitted that each case must be considered on its own facts and circumstances, and the judgment cited by the applicant is distinguishable and not applicable.

4.

Heard learned counsel for the respective parties and perused the pleadings available on record.

5.

ANALYSIS :

5.1. The primary issue for consideration is whether the applicant, who has been fully acquitted in FIR No. 188 dated 17.111.2018 can be denied appointment to the post of Warder (Post Code 86/17).

5.2. It is undisputed that the applicant had disclosed the FIR at the time of applying and successfully cleared all stages of recruitment, including thee Physical Endurance Test and the written examination. He was provisionally selected and received the Offer of Appointment on 18.09.2020, submitting all requisite documents for verification.

5.3. The cancellation of the candidature was based solely on the character and antecedent verification report citing the aforesaid FIR. However, the applicant was acquitted on 15.02.2023 by the Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Hansi, as the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. No material has been placed on record to show any subsisting criminality or moral turpitude.

5.4. The post of Warder is primarily clerical and custodial in nature, with no responsibilities of maintaining law and order. Therefore, apprehensions regarding indiscipline or violent tendencies are irrelevant in the context of the duties attached to the post.

5.5. The legal position is well settled. In Avtar Singh v. Union of India, AIR 2016 SC 3598, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that acquittal, particularly in trivial or false cases, should ordinarily enure to the benefit of the candidate.

5.6. Similarly, in Vikas Nagar v. Union of India [W.P.(C) No. 13913/2024, Delhi High Court], the Hon’ble Court held that a candidate cannot be made to suffer loss of employment opportunity solely on account of pendency or past criminal proceedings when the same have resulted in acquittal. Relevant portion of the said judgment is as under:

“2. While we are cognizant of the position in law that normally the courts would be circumspect in interfering with the opinion of the employer/screening committee in matters of judging the suitability of a candidate for appointment, we are unable to agree with the findings and the opinion of the Screening Committee in the present case.

3.

In the present case, as has been noted in our Order dated 03.10.2024, the criminal case has arisen out of a matrimonial dispute between the petitioner and his wife. The proceedings in the said criminal case have been stayed by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad vide its Order dated 23.02.2024 referred hereinabove. The petitioner cannot be made to suffer a punishment when the criminal case is yet to be adjudicated. We do not need to emphasise that in the matters of public employment, the opportunity does not come repeatedly and may never come for the petitioner again. The petitioner has been successful in obtaining the employment with the CISF based on his own merit and qualification. In case, the petitioner is not allowed to join, subject to the pendency of the criminal case, the petitioner may lose this opportunity for all times to come and this loss would never be compensated. On the other hand, in case he is eventually found guilty, the balance can be struck by making his appointment subject to the outcome of the criminal case and, in that event, directing that he would be terminated from service without any notice or following the rigours off an inquiry.

4.

We, therefore, dispose of this petition by setting aside the impugned letter dated 03.09.2024, issued by respondent no.2. The petitioner shall be allowed to join the post of Constable DCPO inn the CISF subject to the outcome of the criminal case, that is, Case No.6431/2023 arising out of the FIR No.322/2023 dated 30.08.2023, registered at Police Station Nakhasa, District Sambhal (Uttar Pradesh) under Sections 376/377/354/364/511/323/5004/506/452 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and pending before the Competent Court at Sambhal. In case the petitioner is eventually convicted in that case, the respondents shall be free to terminate the services of the petitioner, without the petitioner having any equity in his favour due to this Order or his service rendered in the interim. We further clarify that the petitioner shall not be entitled for any service benefits for the service that is rendered by him, in case of his conviction, except for the pay that he has earned for that period.

5.

The petition is disposed of in the above terms.”

6.

CONCLUSION:

6.1. In view of the above, particularly the complete acquittal of the applicant in FIR No. 188 dated 17.11.2018, the cancellation of his candidature is wholly unsustainable. We therefore, quash and set aside the orders dated 07.10.2021 and 18.01.2021 passed by the respondents.

6.2. We are of the considered view that no legal or moral impediment now exists to the applicant’s appointment to the post off Warder (Post Code 86//17). Accordingly, the respondents are directed to permit the applicant to join the post of Warder within four weeks from the date of this order. The applicant shall be entitled to all notional benefits with effect from 18.09.2020, i.e., the date of the original offer of appointment. However, the actual monetary benefits shall be admissible only from the date on which the applicant assumes charge of the said post.

6.3.We make it clear that in the event the applicant’s acquittal is overturned in appeal, the respondents may take appropriate action in accordance with law.

6.4. The Original Application is allowed in the above terms. Pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, stand disposed of. No costs.