AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
The present complaint has been filed by Sh. Devender Kumar on 07.05.2019 against M/s Parasvnath Realcon Pvt. Ltd. claiming that he has booked a flat in Feb, 2012 in the project known as Parasvnath Paramount, Subhash Nagar New Delhi. The possession was to be handed over in August, 2014 and during that period he has paid a sum of Rs. 1,46,06,922/- to the respondent. He has submitted that even after a delay of 57 months there was no hope of completion of the project and therefore he has sought the relief for refund of the amount paid to the Respondent, with interest as per Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. He has enclosed copy of the statement of account which shows the payment received by the respondent with a copy of Flats Buyers Agreement dated 05.03.2012. As per clause 11(a) of agreement construction of the flats was to be completed within a period of 30 months from the date of commencement of the construction of the particular tower in which flat is located or from the date of booking whichever is later with grace period of six months and as per his submissions it was to be completed by August, 2014.
The complaint was heard on 30.05.2019 and the notices were issued to the Respondent for their reply. The Respondent filed their reply on 08.07.2019 with detailed reasons regarding delay of construction of the project. It was submitted by the Respondent that they stuck between the objections raised by the South Delhi Municipal Corporation (SDMC), Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) and the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) in relation to sanctioning of building plans. They have stated in the reply that their revised building plans were held up due to No Objection Certificate from the DDA and they were pursuing for the NOC from them vigorously. It was also mentioned in their reply that SDMC vide letter dated 28.03.2012 informed that their Building Plan Committee has sanctioned revised plan subject to NOC from the DDA and also directed to comply certain conditions mentioned in the letter of information. It was submitted in the reply that while Respondent were pursuing for obtaining the NOC from DDA for the sanction of the revised building plans, the SDMC vide their letter dated 20.03.2013 without application of mind again insisted for submission of NOC from DDA and rejected the building plans on 21.08.2014 without providing any opportunity of hearing. Giving further details of their persuasion with different agencies it is mentioned in their reply that they were compelled to file Writ Petition before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi as W.P. 5468 of 2018 titled M/s Parasvnath Developers Vs. DDA and others impleading DDA, SDMC & Land & Development Office (L&DO) in the case and after a prolong hearing the Hon'ble court while listing the case for final disposal clarified vide order dt.10.01.2019 that the DDA, DMRC and M/o Urban Development are not precluded for taking a conscious decision on the issue of grant of NOC to the Respondent and therefore the issue of NOC was resolved. The Respondents emphasis while giving the details that they could not complete the project as stipulated in the builder buyer agreement due to inter-se-dispute between Govt. agencies. It was further submitted by the Respondent that clause 11 (a) of the flat buyers agreement mentions about likely completion of the flat within a period of 30 months with and several other conditions. They further took a plea that there were recession in the real estate sector all over India and therefore the facts mentioned in their reply may be considered while considering the complaint that the circumstances were beyond the control of the Respondent and clause 11 (a) of the flats buyer agreement stipulated this conditions.
Heard Complainant in person and Counsel for Respondent. During the course of the hearing on 24.07.2019 a request was made on behalf of the respondents to seek instructions for refund of the amount paid by the complainant and thereafter on joint request of the Complainant and Respondent for amicable settlement the case was adjournment on several occasions. On 17.10.2019 the complainant submitted that he did not want to file any submission and the Counsel for Respondent requested for some time to file written submission with some documents as settlement is not in progress.
The Authority offered for mediation through a mediator to be appointed by the Authority but the complainant did not agree to it.
Finally the case was heard on 25.11.2019. The respondent has also filed written argument on behalf of the Respondent and merely relied upon the Clause 11 of the agreement and on the ground that they could not complete the project due to inter-se-dispute between the government agencies. They have further relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Case of Chand Rani Vs. Kamal Rani (1993) 1 SCC 519 on the issue of time limit provided in the contract/agreement and their willingness to complete the project. It is argued by the Counsel for the respondent that the time frame provided in the agreement in the Flats Buyer Agreement is essence of the contract but the intention of the parties was also for the relaxation. The Counsel for the Respondent further relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of M/s Hind Construction Contractors vs. State of Maharashtra (1979) 2 Supreme Court Cases 70. It was submitted by the Counsel that the Hon'ble Court has held time period is essence of the contract but other terms of the contract is also important, and where if in the contract a clause provided for extension of time in certain contingency or for payment of fine or penalty, such clause would be construed as effective and in the present case there is a provision of extension of time period in the clause 11(a) of the agreement.
We have considered the submission made by the parties and also gone through the record of the case. It is admitted fact that the complainant has booked the apartment in the year 2012 with a hope to get the flat within a period of two years, and flats buyers agreement also promises completion of the project in 30 months from the date of booking with grace period of six months. The mere reading of Clause 11 shows the intention of the parties that the project will be completed within time and relaxation period of six months is provided for any reason which may prevent respondent to complete the project in time and which is beyond his control. The intention of the averment made in the clause does not indicate that the period of six months can be extended indefinitely or such a longer period which may frustrate the object of the purchaser to get a flat in reasonable time. A buyer cannot be compelled to wait indefinitely for possession of a flat after paying a huge sum towards cost of the flat. The Respondent cannot compel buyer to wait indefinitely by putting such clause in the agreement.
The judgments cited by the Counsel for the Respondent are on different facts and circumstances of the case and are not applicable to the present case. The intention of the parties in the flat buyer agreement although provides for an extension but it still stipulates only for six months period which shows that the intention of the parties was extension of not more than six months. Therefore in this case the time is essence of the contract.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Pioneer Urban Land and Infrastructure Limited Vs. Govindan Raghavan in Civil Appeal No. 12238/2018 observed that the provision of the Builder – Buyer Agreement shall not be of final and binding if it is apparent that the purchaser had no option but to sign on the dotted lines. The builder has to fulfill his contractual obligation for obtaining the occupancy certificate and offering the possession of the flat to the allottee in time. While considering the judgment of the Hon'ble National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, and confirming the refund of entire amount deposited by the allottee with interest, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under:
"8.We also reject the submission made by the Appellant-Builder that the National Commission was not justified in awarding Interest @ 10.7% S.I. p.a. for the period commencing from the date of payment of each installment, till the date on which the amount was paid, excluding only the period during which the stay of cancellation of the allotment was in operation.
In Bangalore Development Authority v. Syndicate Bank, a Coordinate Bench of this Court held that when possession of the allotted plot/flat/house is not delivered within the specified time, the allottee is entitled to a refund of the amount paid, with reasonable Interest thereon from the date of payment till the date of refund.
8.1In the present case, the National Commission has passed an equitable Order. The Commission has not awarded any Interest for the period during which the Order of stay of cancellation of the allotment was in operation on the request of the Respondent – Flat Purchaser. The National Commission has rightly awarded Interest @ 10.7% S.I. p.a. by applying Rule 15 of the Haryana Real Estate (Regulation And Development) Rules, 2017 from the date of each installment till 05.02.2017 i.e. till the date after which the Order of stay of cancellation of the allotment was passed; and thereafter, from the date of the Commission's final Order till the date on which the amount is refunded with Interest.
9.We see no illegality in the Impugned Order dated 23.10.2018 passed by the National Commission. The Appellant – Builder failed to fulfill his contractual obligation of obtaining the Occupancy Certificate and offering possession of the flat to the Respondent-Purchaser within the time stipulated in the Agreement, or within a reasonable time thereafter. The Respondent-Flat Purchaser could not be compelled to take possession of the flat, even though it was offered almost 2 years after the grace period under the Agreement expired. During this period, the Respondent-Flat Purchaser had to service a loan that he had obtained for purchasing the flat, by paying interest @ 10% to the Bank. In the meanwhile, the respondent – Flat Purchaser also located an alternate property in Gurugram. In these circumstances, the Respondent – Flat Purchaser was entitled to be granted the relief prayed for, i.e, refund of the entire amount deposited by him with interest."
7.In the present case, even on the last date of hearing, the respondent was not in a position to make any statement before the Authority when the project is going to be completed and they will be in a position to hand over the flat to the complainant. This left Authority with no option but to take a view to order for refund of the amount paid by the complainant. The authority has given various adjournments for an amicable settlement as the Authority has to look towards the development part of the Act also but the respondent failed to convince the complainant about the completion of the project and offered to refund of the amount but in installments as per correspondence filed by the respondents. Therefore, refund is only the solution for settlement of dispute between the parties.
8.In view of the discussion above the respondent is directed to refund the amount Rs.1,46,06,922/- paid by the complainant with MCLR 7.65% + 2% as provided in the Real Estate (Regulation & Development) Act, 2016 within a period of 45 days from the date of order. It is made clear that the interest will be payable from the date when the respective amount was received by the respondents.
Ordered accordingly.
