Tribunals and CommissionsFull Bench(2023) 03 NGT CK 0035

Chanchal Devi vs Central Pollution Control Board & Ors

National Green Tribunal · Decided on 22 March 2023

RESULT
Disposed Of
CASE NUMBER
Original Application No. 204 Of 2021 (I. A. No. 76, 112 Of 2022, 07 Of 2023)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

23 paragraphs · 1,545 words
1.

Grievance in this application is against violation of environmental norms in operation of sugar factory by Wave Industries Pvt. Ltd. at Village Malaysia, Tehsil Dhanaura, District Amroha, U.P. It is alleged that the said industrial unit is bypassing the untreated waste and contaminated water in open area and into the fields of the farmers, resulting in damage to the environment. The waste water has toxic chemicals. 4–5 kilometer of area has been affected by the said pollution. Water coming from handpumps is brownish in colour in the area and is full of chemicals. It is resulting in hazard to the public health, affecting 5000 students of more than 20 schools and around 1.5 lakh residents of around 15 villages who are in close proximity of this unit. The unit is also illegally extracting groundwater without requisite permission even though the block in question is in the category of ‘over-exploited’. The applicant made representations dated 14.07.2021 and 30.07.2021 to the State PCB, Central Ground Water Authority (CGWA), Chief Secretary, UP and District Magistrate, Amroha but no action has been taken.

2.

Vide order dated 19.08.2021, the Tribunal constituted a joint Committee comprising CPCB, State PCB, CGWA and District Magistrate, Amroha to furnish a factual and action taken report. The Committee was to ascertain the compliance status of consent conditions, including ZLD conditions. It was further directed that if report is adverse to the industrial unit, a copy thereof be furnished to the said unit for its response, if any.

3.

Vide order dated 11.07.2022 the matter was further considered in the light of report of CPCB dated 20.01.2022, recording the violations and recommending further action. The Tribunal directed further action in the light of said recommendations and filing of action taken report.

4.

Thereafter, matter was considered on 11.01.2023 in the light of report of the State PCB dated 13.10.2022 mentioning the compliance status. However, the Tribunal found that accountability had not been fixed for the past violations on ‘Polluter Pays’ principle or by way of prosecution. Accordingly, the Tribunal directed response on these aspects from the State PCB. The Tribunal also considered I.A. No. 76/2022 seeking direction with regard incident dated 14.03.2022 when explosion took place in the distillery tank resulting in death of a worker and injuries to three workers. The Tribunal also directed the efficacy of ferti irrigation plan be evaluated.

5.

Accordingly, the matter has been put up for further consideration today.

6.

Response has been filed by the State PCB as well as by the Project Proponent (PP). The stand of the PP is that the incident took place at the Bio ethanol plant during testing phase of the unit. Distillery unit has no connection with the Sugar factory. The Bio ethanol plant is to enable ethanol blending in petrol. The work of Engineering Procurement and Commissioning of the plant was given to Excel Engineers and Consultants (now known as Regreen Excel EPC India Pvt. Ltd. and in terms of LOI, responsibility of the accident resulting in death of one person and injuries to another is of the said contractor. The said contractor has responded that family of deceased Hitesh Yadav has been paid compensation of Rs. 10 lakhs and the matter has been settled. With regard to past violations, it is stated that compensation of Rs. 12.90 lakhs has been proposed by the State PCB.

7.

The stand of the State PCB is evaluation has been done by National Sugar Institute, Kanpur on the issue of efficacy of ferti irrigation plan. For the past violations, apart from compensation of Rs. 1 lakh, Rs. 1.5 lakh and Rs. 8.20 lakhs on three earlier occasions, in the year 2019 and 2020, compensation of Rs. 12.90 lakhs has been imposed on 27.01.2023 for the deficiencies that the ETP has overcapacity for effluent treatment (i.e. 2800 KLD) in violation of the consent conditions and not installed Condensate Polishing Unit (CPU) as recommended by expert institute (NSI) in ETP validation report 2019-20 in view of pressure boiler of 105 kg/cm2.

8.

Question for consideration is whether the PP has liability for compensation to the heirs of the deceased during the course of installation of the project on 14.03.2022, as per grievance in I.A. No. 76/2022 and whether ferti irrigation plan to use treated effluent is as per norms.  Further  question  is  the  extent  to  which  intervention  of  the tribunal is necessary under section 15 of the NGT Act.

9.

We have heard learned Counsel for the appearing parties and perused the record.

10.

With regard to efficacy of ferti irrigation plan, we have considered the report of the National Sugar Institute, Kanpur dated 04.10.2017, relied upon by the PP which concludes as follows:-

“Conclusion:

1.

The irrigation management plan proposed by M/s Wave industries Pvt. Ltd. Dhanaura, may be considered to be in order for irrigation to be carried out for the autumn and spring planted Sugarcane & also for wheat. The proposed system shall be able to cope up with the requirement of utilization of the generated effluent for irrigation purposes.

2.

Since the factory visit was undertaken during off season when treated effluent was not available, as such, the actual assessment shall be possible during crushing only when the sugar plant will be in operation.

3.

However, the factory should strengthen its strength for supervising and maintaining the irrigation plan while using the treated effluent. They should clearly prepare a responsibility chart for implementation.”

11.

As shown by the above, the report is of study undertaken during off season and also suggests that the factory should prepare a responsibility chart for implementation which has not been done. Thus, we are of the view that in the light of the report and also otherwise generated effluent should be used only if ferti irrigation results in reduction of drawl of water for irrigation. The report shows that storage capacity for effluent is of 4000 KL while the water taken by the farmer is at 12-15 days intervals in cane field and three weeks interval for wheat field and not on daily basis. There has to be plan for water balance considering this aspect to ensure that ferti-irrigation plan is duly followed.

12.

With regard to compensation to the deceased and the injured, mere appointment of contractor does not absolve the PP of liability which is de horse inter se arrangement between the PP and the contractor. Minimum scale of compensation laid down by this Tribunal in such cases considering judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sarla Verma, (2009) 6 SCC 121, Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680 and Uphaar Tragedy (2014) 14 SCC 481 has to be followed which is Rs. 20 lakhs in case of death and Rs. 10 lac for major injuries, Order dated 08.03.2022 in O.A. No. 143/2022, In re: News item published in The Tribune dated 22.02.2022 titled “7 killed in blast at firecrackers factory in Himachal Una unless exceptional reason is shown. Liability of PP, even if not exclusive, is atleast joint and several in view of principle of Absolute Liability of the entity undertaking dangerous activity having potential for such incidents as laid down in M.C. Mehta v. UOI (1987) 1 SCC 395, para 31. Compensation has to be paid by the PP who may recover it from erring contractor as per its LOI, if so viable and permissible. In the said order, it was inter-alia observed:

“11. ……………Vide order dated 11.06.2021 in OA No. 44/2021 (which was reiterated on 03.03.2022, on remand by the Hon’ble Supreme Court), In re: News item published in The News Indian Express dated 12.02.2021 titled “At least 19 dead in Virudhunagar firecracker factory blast, more than 30 injured” compensation was held to be payable at a flat rate of Rs. 20 lakhs by the State on the principle of State’s liability for failure to perform regulatory functions. It was observed:

xxx ……………………………….xxx………………………….xxx

9.

…Compensation can be assessed on reasonable basis guided by restitution principle atleast at floor level, leaving other remedies of the victims open. Thus, broadly agreeing with the Committee, we direct that the scale of compensation should be Rs.20 lakhs in respect of each of the deceased victims and Rs.15 lakhs to persons who have burns in excess of 50% and Rs.10 lakhs for persons who have burns from 25 to 50% and Rs.5 lakhs for persons who have injuries between 5 to 25%. Victims who were treated as outpatients and who had but minor degree of burns or other forms of simple injuries shall be paid Rs.2 lakhs.”

13.

Compensation for past violations of Rs. 12.90 lakhs based on per day compensation of Rs. 30,000 needs to be revisited having regard to cost of restoration with deterrent element as per law laid down inter alia in Sterlite, (2013) 4 SCC 575 and Goel Ganga (2018) 18 SCC 257. The State PCB may take further action accordingly. Operation of the unit may be allowed for next crushing season only after compliance of the above and stabilizing of STPs and due compliance of CTO conditions.

The application is disposed of.

A copy of this order be forwarded to the State PCB by email for compliance.

In view of order in the main matter, all pending I.A.s also stands disposed of.