AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Hon'ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member (A) :
Since both OA Nos. 3032/2018 and 2361/2017 involve an identical controversy arising out of the same selection and promotion exercise undertaken by the Municipal Corporation of Delhi (MCD), they have been tagged and heard together. Both the applications question the decision of the respondents to restrict consideration for ad hoc promotion to the post of Junior Secretariat Assistant (JSA)/Lower Division Clerk (LDC) to certain employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre, thereby excluding other eligible Class-IV employees working in the General Wing of the three Municipal Corporations. Since the factual background, the applicable Recruitment Regulations and the principal grounds of challenge are substantially common, both the matters are being disposed of by this common order. However, the individual claims of the applicants in the two OAs were being considered with reference to their respective service particulars.
Following similar reliefs have been sought in both the OAs :-
“(i)To quash and set aside the Office Order dated 06.03.2017,
(ii)Consequently, to direct Respondent to consider the applicants also for ad hoc promotion to the post of LDC,
(iii)to pass such other order or orders as may be deemed fit and proper in the interests of justice.”
The brief facts of the case as per the counsel for the applicants is that the applicants in O.A. No. 2361/2017, led by Ram Pal Singh, had approached this Tribunal challenging Office Order No. AC/CED/NDMC/2017/551 dated 06.03.2017 issued by the Assistant Commissioner (Establishment), North Delhi Municipal Corporation. The applicants in other O.A. No. 3032/2018, led by Bhuvan Chandra Sharma, had also challenged the very same Office Order and had sought substantially similar reliefs. The said Office Order had been issued pursuant to the approval granted by the competent authority on 28.02.2017 for granting ad hoc promotion to 343 Class-IV employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre in all the three Municipal Corporations to the post of Junior Secretariat Assistant (JSA)/LDC in Pay Band-1 of Rs.5200-20200 with Grade Pay of Rs.1900, revised to Level-2 of the Pay Matrix under the Seventh Central Pay Commission. The promotions had been ordered with immediate effect, subject to the terms and conditions mentioned in the Office Order. The applicants in O.A. No. 2361/2017 consisted of 43 employees working in different capacities in the General Wing of the Municipal Corporations. They included Rickshaw Catchers, Swachhta Karamcharis, Beldars, Naala Beldars, Cattle Catchers, Chowkidars, Peons and Assistant Pump Drivers. Their dates of appointment ranged from 1989 to 2006. Some of them had entered service as far back as 19.09.1989 and 01.04.1994, while several others had joined during 1995, 1999, 2004, 2005 and 2006. Their case was that, despite having rendered the requisite regular service and possessing the prescribed educational and technical qualifications, they had not been afforded an opportunity to participate in the selection process for promotion to the post of LDC/JSA. The applicants in O.A. No. 3032/2018 were 15 employees working in the three Municipal Corporations in different capacities, including Beldars, Ward Boys, a Dresser and a Ward Aya. Their dates of appointment were as follows:
Bhuvan Chandra Sharma – 01.04.2005;
Amba Dutt – 01.04.2000;
Prakash Dhyani – 01.04.2006;
Kewalanand – 01.04.2004;
Gangandeep Verma – 01.04.2005;
Manoj Kumar – 01.04.2000;
Pankaj Parashar – 01.04.2006;
Kuldeep – 01.04.2006;
Bishan Dutt Sharma – 01.04.1999;
Surendra Singh Kandari – 01.04.2000;
Nagendra Singh – 01.04.2000;
Smt. Manju – 01.04.2006;
Gijender Singh – 01.04.2003;
Kamal – 01.04.2005; and
Mehkar Singh – 01.04.1999.
The applicants were working as Beldars, Ward Boys, Dresser and Ward Aya in the East, North and South Delhi Municipal Corporations. They claimed that they fulfilled the eligibility requirements prescribed for promotion to the post of LDC and had been unfairly excluded from consideration merely because they did not belong to the Centralised Cadre. The next promotional avenue available to Class-IV employees of the Corporation was the post of LDC. The recruitment to the said post was governed by the Recruitment Regulations for the post of Lower Division Clerk in the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, 2007, which had been notified by the Government of the National Capital Territory of Delhi in the Delhi Gazette dated 22.03.2007. The Regulations prescribed the post of LDC as a Group-C post and classified it as a selection post. The essential educational qualifications prescribed therein were matriculation/secondary school examination from a recognised Board or University or equivalent, together with the ability to type at a speed of not less than 30 words per minute in English and 25 words per minute in Hindi. The probation period prescribed for the post was two years. The Recruitment Regulations provided for three methods of recruitment to the post of LDC, namely, 80% by direct recruitment, 10% by promotion on the basis of Limited Departmental Competitive Examination, failing which by direct recruitment, and the remaining 10% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. In respect of the promotion quota, the Regulations specifically provided that Class-IV employees of the General Wing of MCD in the pay scale of Rs.2550-3200 with five years' regular service in the grade would be eligible. For appearing in the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination, such employees were also required to possess the educational and other qualifications prescribed for direct recruitment. The applicants contended that the expression used in the Recruitment Regulations was 'Class-IV employees of General Wing of MCD' and that the eligibility provision did not restrict the benefit of promotion to Peons and Chowkidars alone or to employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre. According to them, the Regulations had consciously extended the promotional avenue to all eligible Class-IV employees of the General Wing who fulfilled the prescribed conditions. The applicants maintained that they belonged to the very category of employees contemplated under the Regulations and that their respective designations could not be made a ground for excluding them from consideration. The applicants further submitted that the post of LDC had been specifically classified as a selection post. Therefore, the selection was required to be undertaken in accordance with the applicable Recruitment Regulations, after affording an equal opportunity to all eligible employees. Merit was required to be assessed in accordance with the prescribed selection criteria and the respondents could not restrict the field of consideration to a particular category of employees without any authority under the Regulations.
The grievance of the applicants had arisen when the respondents issued a circular dated 20.01.2017 inviting applications for the skill test from Peons and Chowkidars. According to the applicants, the said circular had confined the opportunity to only these two categories, although the Recruitment Regulations did not make such a distinction amongst eligible Class-IV employees of the General Wing. The applicants in O.A. No. 2361/2017 specifically pointed out that there were approximately 3,000 Class-IV employees working in the General Wing of the Corporation, including Beldars, Safai Karamcharis, Sewer Men, School Attendants, Malis, Kulis, Rickshaw Catchers, Cattle Catchers, Notice Surveyors, Nursery Ayas, Khalasis, Watermen, Peons and Chowkidars. It was further submitted that the respondents had fixed 04.02.2017 as the initial date for the skill test and had subsequently changed the date to 10.02.2017. The applicants alleged that proper intimation regarding the examination and the change in its date had not been communicated to the other eligible employees through their respective Heads of Departments/DDOs. Consequently, they had been deprived of an opportunity to apply and participate in the selection process. The applicants also alleged that the respondents had issued admit cards and roll numbers only to the Peons and Chowkidars who had been permitted to participate in the skill test. According to them, the process lacked transparency and the result of the skill test had not been disclosed in a manner that enabled other eligible employees to know the basis on which the selected candidates had been granted promotion. They also questioned the manner in which seniority and merit had been taken into consideration, contending that the Recruitment Regulations contemplated selection and did not authorise the respondents to confine consideration to the selected categories.
The applicants in both the OAs maintained that the Office Order dated 06.03.2017 had given effect to a selection process which had been undertaken without considering all eligible Class-IV employees of the General Wing. The Office Order had approved the ad hoc promotion of 343 employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre, principally Peons and Chowkidars, to the post of JSA/LDC. The applicants contended that the respondents could not first restrict participation in the selection process to only two categories and thereafter justify the resulting promotions on the ground that the selected employees had participated in the prescribed exercise. According to them, the very process of selection was defective because the field of eligible candidates had been unlawfully restricted. The applicants also drew attention to the terms and conditions incorporated in the Office Order dated 06.03.2017. Although the appointments had been described as purely ad hoc and as a stop-gap arrangement, initially for a period of one year or till the posts were filled on a regular basis or until further orders, the Office Order had also referred to a probationary period of two years. The applicants submitted that, in view of the possibility of continuation and subsequent regularisation of the persons so promoted, their exclusion from the initial exercise would cause serious prejudice to their service prospects. They, therefore, sought intervention of this Tribunal at the earliest stage.
Before approaching this Tribunal in O.A. No. 2361/2017, the applicants therein had submitted representations to the authorities, pointing out that the circular dated 20.01.2017 had excluded other General Wing employees from the skill test. They had requested the respondents to extend the opportunity to all eligible Class-IV employees in accordance with the Recruitment Regulations. However, their grievance had not been redressed. Hence, the applicants are before this Tribunal to redress their grievances.
To support his case, the counsel for the applicants argued assiduously on the following grounds :-
“1.The impugned order, issued for ad hoc promotion, is contrary to the Recruitment regulations, governing promotion to the post of LDC. The Recruitment Regulations does not provide for making ad hoc promotion without following the regulations. Promotions, whether ad hoc or on regular basis, has to be strictly governed by the recruitment regulations.
2.The post of LDC in the MCD is a selection post and, therefore, merit should have been the first consideration before making any ad hoc promotion. It is not clear from the impugned order that on what basis ad hoc promotions have been made. The applicants were not even informed about any such ad hoc promotions being made in the office of the respondent.
3.The Recruitment regulations for promotion to the post of LDC is same for Peons and Chowkidars in the centralized cadre and Class IV employees working in the three corporations of MCD. That being so, the respondent ought to have given equal opportunity to all the Class IV employees of the corporation before making any such promotion.
4.The impugned order nowhere states that the private respondents are being asked to only perform the duties of LDC owing to shortage of staff in the corporation. Therefore, the impugned order is liable to be set aside being violative of the recruitment regulations, governing promotion to the post of LDC.”
In response to the Original Application, the North Delhi Municipal Corporation filed a detailed counter-affidavit in O.A. No. 2361/2017. The respondents first referred to the Recruitment Regulations, 2007, and reproduced the eligibility conditions prescribed for promotion and for promotion through LDCE. They submitted that the Regulations provided for promotion of Class-IV employees of the General Wing of the MCD in the pay scale of Rs.2550-3200 with five years of regular service in the grade. In the case of the LDCE quota, the employees were also required to possess the educational and other qualifications prescribed for direct recruitment.
The North DMC submitted that the Central Establishment Department was dealing with promotion of the Centralised Cadre of Class-IV employees, namely Peons and Chowkidars, in accordance with the orders of the Director of Local Bodies dated 18.04.2012, which had been approved by the Lieutenant Governor at the time of trifurcation of the erstwhile MCD. It was stated that the applicants were working as Rickshaw Catchers in the Hackney Carriage Department, Cattle Catchers in the Veterinary Services Department and Malis in the Horticulture Department of the three Corporations. On the basis of the aforesaid arrangement and the directions of the higher authorities, their cases had not been considered for promotion to the post of LDC under the promotion quota. The North DMC further submitted that the Recruitment Regulations, 1983, had been superseded by Resolution No. 53 dated 10.05.1999, which had subsequently been notified as the Recruitment Regulations for the post of LDC in the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, 2007. It was contended that the expression “General Wing” had not been defined either in the said Recruitment Regulations or in any other document available with the Department. In view of this position, the matter had been considered by the Departmental Screening Committee in its meeting held on 10.05.2016. The Committee had decided that the expression “General Wing” occurring in the Recruitment Regulations should be treated as referring to the Centralised Cadre. The respondents further explained that, under the aforesaid decision, Peons, Chowkidars, Chair Caner/Re-caner and Watermen were considered as falling within the category of Centralised Cadre. However, for processing the promotion to the post of LDC, only Peons and Chowkidars had been taken into consideration in accordance with the order dated 18.04.2012 of the Director of Local Bodies. A separate proposal for incorporating Chair Caner/Re-caner and Watermen into the Centralised Cadre was to be placed before the competent authority. The respondents also stated that, while conducting the DPC for promotion by considering Peons and Chowkidars, ten posts had been kept vacant for Chair Re-caner and Watermen so that their legitimate rights would not be affected if their posts were subsequently included in the Centralised Cadre by the competent authority. The North DMC specifically raised a preliminary objection that the applicants had confused the two distinct promotion channels provided under the Recruitment Regulations. It was submitted that the present dispute related to the 10% quota filled by promotion on the basis of LDCE, whereas the impugned Office Order dated 06.03.2017 related to the other 10% quota, namely promotion failing which by direct recruitment. On this basis, the respondents contended that the applicants had no cause of action to challenge the impugned order and that the O.A was liable to be dismissed at the threshold. On the merits, the North DMC denied that the applicants were all eligible for promotion under the 10% promotion quota. It maintained that the promotion quota was restricted to Class-IV employees of the General Wing of the MCD in the prescribed pay scale with five years of regular service. Since the term “General Wing” had not been defined, the Departmental Screening Committee had considered the issue and the competent authority had approved the interpretation that the General Wing should be treated as the Centralised Cadre. The respondents accordingly denied that the restriction of the process to Peons and Chowkidars was arbitrary or discriminatory. The North DMC also denied the applicants’ contention that the post of LDC under the 10% promotion quota was a selection post. According to them the applicants had not established that merit was required to be the first consideration in the manner claimed by them. It maintained that the impugned promotions had been made in accordance with the Recruitment Regulations and that the applicants were not entitled to the reliefs sought. The respondents denied the grounds raised in the O.A and prayed for its dismissal as being devoid of merit and without any cause of action.
The East Delhi Municipal Corporation also filed a counter-reply in O.A. No. 2361/2017 wherein they submitted that after the trifurcation of the erstwhile MCD in February/March 2012, the North Delhi Municipal Corporation had been designated as the Lead Corporation for dealing with promotion and other establishment matters of all cadres on the basis of a common seniority list of employees working in the three Corporations. In support of this submission, it relied upon the minutes of the Fourth Coordination Meeting of the Commissioners of the Municipal Corporations. The East DMC contended that it was only a pro forma party and that the North DMC was the necessary and main respondent in the matter. Since the relief sought related to promotion and establishment matters being dealt with by the North DMC, the East DMC requested that its Commissioner be removed from the array of parties.
The South Delhi Municipal Corporation, in its counter-reply, similarly submitted that the matter pertained to the North DMC, which was the Nodal Corporation for dealing with the promotion process. It stated that the South DMC was only a pro forma party and that the relevant records were with the North DMC. It did not furnish any independent defence on the merits of the applicants’ challenge. It nevertheless prayed for dismissal of the O.A.
The applicants in O.A. No. 2361/2017 filed a rejoinder to the counter-affidavit of the North DMC. They specifically disputed the respondents’ reliance upon the order dated 18.04.2012 of the Director of Local Bodies. They submitted that the said order dealt with the creation, abolition, merger and distribution of existing Headquarter posts, Centralised Cadre posts and Engineering Cadre posts amongst the three Corporations following trifurcation of the erstwhile MCD. According to them, the said order merely identified and distributed posts amongst the Corporations and did not provide that promotion to the post of LDC could be restricted only to employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre. The applicants further submitted in their rejoinder that the issue in the O.A was not whether Peons, Chowkidars or Drivers formed part of the Centralised Cadre. The real issue was whether promotion to the post of LDC under the 10% promotion quota could be restricted only to employees of the Centralised Cadre or whether other Class-IV employees who fell within the expression “General Wing” under the Recruitment Regulations were also entitled to be considered. They contended that the order dated 18.04.2012 did not prohibit consideration of their cases and, therefore, could not be relied upon to justify their exclusion. In response to the preliminary objection regarding the two 10% promotion channels, the applicants clarified that they had never claimed promotion under the 10% LDCE quota. Their grievance related to the 10% quota meant for promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. They submitted that the respondents had incorrectly understood the case and had attempted to defeat the O.A by referring to the LDCE channel, which was not the subject matter of their claim. The applicants also challenged the decision of the Departmental Screening Committee dated 10.05.2016. They submitted that the Recruitment Regulations had not defined the expression “General Wing”, but this omission did not authorise the Departmental Screening Committee to substitute that expression with “Centralised Cadre”. According to them, such an interpretation had the effect of excluding a large category of Class-IV employees from the promotion channel and could not be introduced without amending the Recruitment Regulations in accordance with law. They contended that the decision had been taken without authority and had been used to benefit only a specified category of employees. The applicants further reiterated that the post of LDC had been categorised as a selection post in the Recruitment Regulations. They submitted that the respondents could not contend that the post was a non-selection post merely because the present claim related to the 10% promotion quota and not the LDCE quota. They pointed out that the Recruitment Regulations did not create a separate classification of the post for the two promotion channels. They also submitted that the respondents had failed to substantiate how the promotions made under the impugned order had complied with the Recruitment Regulations. They maintained that the promotions had been made in violation of the Rules and prayed that the O.A be allowed.
To support his case, counsel for the applicants handed across the Bar a copy of a recent order of this very Bench in OA No. 1352/2022 dated 29.06.2026 – Anil Kumar & Ors. vs. MCD wherein the Tribunal held as under :-
“41.In the present case, the respondents have specifically established that the promotions were never intended to be regular appointments under the LDCE quota. The skill test was not a statutory LDCE, Vacancies from direct recruitment quota were temporarily diverted only as a stop-gap measure. No regular DPC or statutory LDCE process under the Recruitment Regulations was undertaken. The applicants were consciously promoted on ad hoc basis to meet administrative exigencies. Therefore, the observations made in Harish Pal Singh cannot be extended to the facts of the present case.
42.Further, the principle laid down in Direct Recruit Class II Engineering Officers' Association would also not aid the applicants because the benefit of counting ad hoc service is available only where the initial appointment is made according to Rules and against substantive vacancies. Where the initial appointment itself is dehors the prescribed procedure or intended purely as a stop-gap arrangement, the period of officiation cannot be counted for seniority or regularisation.
43.It is also relevant that the respondents have categorically stated that regular DPC proceedings under the 10% promotion quota as well as LDCE process under the 10% LDCE quota are already under consideration and the cases of eligible employees, including the applicants, shall be considered in accordance with the Recruitment Regulations and applicable DoPT instructions. In such circumstances, issuance of a direction for retrospective regularisation from 2017 would amount to bypassing the statutory recruitment framework and adversely affecting rights of other eligible employees who may compete under the regular LDCE quota or be considered under the seniority quota.
44.In service jurisprudence, regularisation cannot be directed in a manner which defeats the Recruitment Rules or prejudices the rights of other employees who were not parties to the ad hoc arrangement. Acceptance of the applicants' contention would effectively convert a temporary administrative arrangement into a permanent mode of recruitment not contemplated by the statutory Rules.
45.In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered opinion that the applicants have failed to establish any enforceable legal right for grant of retrospective regular promotion to the post of LDC/JSA from March, 2017. The ad hoc promotions granted to them were purely stop-gap arrangements made to meet administrative exigencies and cannot be equated with regular promotion under the Recruitment Regulations. The judgments relied upon by the applicants are distinguishable and do not support the relief sought in the present case.
46.Accordingly, the Original Application being devoid of merit is dismissed. No order as to costs.”
The applicants, in their second rejoinder to the reply filed by R-2 & 3 further submitted that a plain reading of the order dated 18.04.2012 would show that it dealt only with the creation, abolition, merger and distribution of the existing Headquarter posts, Centralised Cadre posts and Engineering Cadre posts amongst the three Municipal Corporations. The annexure to the said order merely identified the posts falling within the Centralised Cadre. The applicants clarified that they were not disputing the inclusion of posts such as Driver, Peon or Chowkidar in the Centralised Cadre. Their grievance, however, was that the respondents had wrongly restricted consideration for promotion to the post of LDC only to employees belonging to the Centralised Cadre, whereas the issue raised in the OAs was whether employees holding other Class-IV posts in the establishment of the respondent Corporation were also entitled to be considered under the relevant promotion quota. They, therefore, contended that the order dated 18.04.2012 did not answer the controversy involved in the present OAs. They reiterated that the order dated 18.04.2012 did not contain any direction that employees holding the posts occupied by the applicants were not to be considered for promotion to the post of LDC under the promotion quota. They submitted that the said order concerned the distribution and reorganisation of posts amongst the three Corporations following trifurcation and had no bearing on the applicants’ entitlement to be considered for promotion under the Recruitment Rules. The applicants further submitted that the respondents had attempted to confuse the issue by contending that the present dispute related to the 10% quota for promotion through the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination, whereas the impugned order dated 06.03.2017 had been issued against the separate 10% quota for promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. According to the applicants, their claim throughout had been confined to the latter quota, namely, the 10% promotion quota not involving the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination. They had never claimed consideration under the LDCE quota. They, therefore, contended that the respondents’ objection was contrary to the pleadings in the OAs and deserved to be rejected. The applicants also challenged the respondents’ reliance upon the decision of the Departmental Screening Committee dated 10.05.2016. They submitted that although the Recruitment Rules used the expression “General Wing”, the expression had not been defined in the Rules. The Departmental Screening Committee had, however, interpreted the expression “General Wing” to mean only the “Centralised Cadre” and had consequently confined consideration for promotion to employees holding posts falling within that cadre. According to the applicants, such an interpretation was contrary to the Recruitment Rules and had the effect of conferring the benefit of consideration for promotion upon only a specified category of Class-IV employees, while excluding other Class-IV employees working in the establishment of the Corporation. They contended that an administrative decision of the Departmental Screening Committee could not amend, modify or restrict the scope of the Recruitment Rules, and that any such change could be made only by following the prescribed procedure for amendment of the Rules. They further submitted that, if the interpretation adopted by the Departmental Screening Committee were not accepted, the Class-IV employees falling within the expression “General Wing” would be entitled to consideration under the relevant 10% promotion quota, subject to fulfillment of the prescribed eligibility conditions. On merits, the applicants reiterated that the post of LDC had been expressly categorised as a “Selection” post in the Recruitment Rules. They submitted that the respondents had merely denied their contention without pointing out any provision in the Rules which treated the post of LDC as a non-selection post for the 10% promotion quota failing which direct recruitment. According to them, the Recruitment Rules did not create any such distinction in the nature of the post for the two promotion channels, and the respondents could not disregard the express categorisation of LDC as a selection post. They also submitted that the respondents had failed to substantiate how the promotions made through the impugned order dated 06.03.2017 had complied with the Recruitment Rules. They reiterated that the post of LDC was a selection post and that the respondents’ contention to the contrary was inconsistent with the express provisions of the Rules.
This matter was heard at some length on 24.02.2026 and the following order was recorded in the order sheet :-
“The issue involved in both the OAs concerns promotion from Class IV employees to the cadre of JSAS (LDCs).
2.Pursuant to an office order dated 6 March 2017, ad hoc promotions to the post of JSAs (LDCs) were granted from among Class IV employees belonging to the centralized cadre of all three Corporations existing at the relevant time.
3.Learned counsel for the applicants has drawn attention to the Recruitment Rules dated 19 March 2007, which provide for promotion from Class IV employees of the General Wing of the MCD. It is submitted that the Recruitment Rules do not define the term "General Wing." In the absence of such a definition, it is unclear how promotions were restricted to Chowkidars and Peons categories of Class IV employees, while excluding the applicants, who are serving as Beldar, Ward Boys, Dressers, Ward Aayas, etc., from consideration for promotion.
4.In the connected OA No. 2361/2017, it has specifically been contended that even Class IV employees serving as Chowkidars and Peons were not considered for promotion.
5.This is an old matter; counter-affidavits were filed in the year 2020. Since then, significant developments have occurred, most notably the unification of the 3 MCDs' in the year 2022.
6.Learned counsel for the respondents, relying upon the counter-affidavit, has admitted that the term "General Wing" is neither defined in the Recruitment Rules nor in the respondent department. It is further stated that, at the time of the Departmental Screening Committee meeting held on 10 May 2016, the competent authority decided to treat only the posts of Peon, Chowkidar, Chair Re-canner, and Waterman as forming part of the General Wing.
7.This gives rise to the question as to which competent authority took such a decision, and whether the Recruitment Rules-being statutory regulations framed by the MCD under Section 98 of the Delhi Municipal Corporation Act, 1957 and approved by the Lieutenant Governor-permitted such an insertion or restrictive interpretation of a term not defined in the Rules themselves.
8.Subsequent to the unification of the MCD in 2022, a further issue arises as to whether a common seniority list of Class IV employees is being maintained. Although the method of promotion prescribed is "selection," even a selection-based promotion requires the existence of a valid and properly maintained seniority list.
9.It has also been pointed out by learned counsel for the respondents that the designation of Class IV employees has since been changed, and they are now referred to as MTS. Additional categories have been included under the MTS designation beyond Peon, Chowkidar, Chair Re-canner, and Waterman.
10.In view of the multiple categories now included within MTS, a relevant question arises as to whether separate promotional avenues exist for different categories. However, for the present, the submissions on behalf of the applicants are confined to the limited issue of whether, among the various categories now designated as MTS (including Beldar, Ward Boys, Dressers, Ward Aayas etc.), any promotional channel exists after unification, particularly in respect of categories such as Beldar.
11.The applicants seek clarification on whether any distinct promotional avenues are available to such categories post-unification.
12.In OA No. 2361/2017, Mr. D.S. Mahendru, learned counsel for the respondents, is directed to take instructions with regard to Applicant Nos. 25, 27, 28, and 29 to 37. The issue that arises for consideration is whether these applicants were excluded from consideration at the time of issuance of the impugned order, inspite of they being Peon and Chowkidar.
13.It is the specific grievance of the applicants that they were, in fact, excluded from consideration while issuing the impugned order.
14.List the matter as Part-Heard on 17.04.2026.”
Today we have again carefully considered the rival contentions and examined the documents placed on record. We have observed that the respondents caused great prejudice and injury to the applicants by showing undue favour and favouritism to some peons and chowkidars posted in the centralised cadre by very narrowly interpreting the definition of 'general wing' as centralised cadre — peons and chowkidars posted with the Senior Officers of the North Delhi Municipal Corporation. The other categories of Class IV employees – Rikshaw Catchers; Cattle Catchers; Malis (gardeners); Swachhta Karamcharis, Beldars, Naala Beldars, Assistant Pump Operators, Drivers in outlying posts etc. were left out of the definition of 'general category' causing hostile and invidious discrimination to them. Moreover, it is not clear as to whether the LDC post (10% by promotion) was a selection post (based on skill test) or a non-selection post (based on seniority cum suitability). This is because we have observed that the respondents have failed to show us any skill test that was used to promote some favourite peons and chowkidars in the Centralised posts to the post of LDCs. Also if seniority cum suitability was employed as a criterion for promotion then the respondents have failed to show us any seniority list of the Grade IV employees which include all types of categories.
In the light of the above analysis and discussion, we are of the considered opinion that the balance of convenience in the both the OAs clearly lies with the applicants. The OAs have merit, deserve to be allowed and are accordingly allowed. The respondents are hereby directed to make the definition of 'general category' of Grade IV employees now rechristened as Multi Tasking Staff (MTS) comprehensive and inclusive by including all categories and types of Grade IV employees — like Rikshaw Catchers; Cattle Catchers; Malis (gardeners); Swachhta Karamcharis, Ward Boys, Ward Ayas, Beldars, Naala Beldars, Assistant Pump Operators, Drivers etc and frame appropriate Recruitment Rules (RRs) for the Multi Tasking Staff (MTS) and and consider promoting the applicants to the post of LDC whenever the next batch of vacancies arise. This exercise should be completed within a period of six months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. MAs if any are also disposed of in similar manner. However, there will be no order as to costs.
