High CourtsSingle Bench(2012) 02 P&H CK 0222

Apollo Public School and others vs Devinder Kaur

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 17 February 2012

HON’BLE JUDGES
L.N. Mittal, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Regular Second Appeal No. 712 of 2012

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

10 paragraphs · 1,065 words

L.N. Mittal, J.—Defendants Apollo Public School and its Principal and Chairman are in second appeal.

2.

Respondent-plaintiff Devinder Kaur filed suit against defendants/appellants for recovery of Rs. 3,39,700/-. The plaintiff was appointed as Principal of their school by defendants for five years since August, 2004 on salary of Rs. 20,000/-per month with annual increment of Rs. 1,000/-per month in the salary. Plaintiff's version is that as per contract between the parties, her services could be terminated by the defendants before expiry of the period of five years by paying her salary for one year. The defendants abruptly terminated the plaintiff's services on 16.12.2005.

3.

Accordingly, the plaintiff claimed amount of salary for one year, in addition to the amount of salary for 15 days, for which she worked in the month of December 2005, salary for one month in lieu of notice period and amount of Rs. 50,000/-as damages. Accordingly, the plaintiff sought recovery of Rs. 3,39,700/-.

4.

Defendants admitted that the plaintiff was appointed as Principal of the school. However, the defendants pleaded that the plaintiff intentionally created such atmosphere in the school that the defendants were forced to dispense with her services. The plaintiff created such atmosphere because she wanted to join back Budha Dal Public School, Patiala, where she was serving before joining the defendants. The plaintiff in fact joined the said Budha Dal Public School on 04.01.2006 immediately after her services were terminated by the defendants on 16.12.2005. Work and conduct of the plaintiff in the school of defendants was never satisfactory. She was warned many times to improve her work, but she failed to improve her work and conduct. It was, however, admitted that the plaintiff had been offered salary of Rs. 20,000/-per month with annual increment of Rs. 1,000/-per month in salary by the defendants. However, it was pleaded that there was no condition of paying salary for one year while terminating the plaintiff's services. Any such agreement is also void abnitio. Various other pleas were also raised.

5.

Learned Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Patiala, vide judgment and decree dated 14.03.2011, partly decreed the plaintiff's suit for recovery of Rs. 2,68,700/-, which included salary for one year and salary for 15 days of December 2005, for which the plaintiff had worked in the school of defendants. First appeal preferred by defendants has been dismissed by learned Additional District Judge, Patiala, vide judgment and decree dated 07.11.2011 along with appeal preferred by the plaintiff. Feeling aggrieved, defendants have filed the instant second appeal.

6.

I have heard learned counsel for the appellants and perused the case file.

7.

Appointment letter issued by defendants to the plaintiff contained specific stipulation that the appointment was for minimum period of five years and could be extended beyond five years by mutual agreement and if, for any reason, the defendants decided to terminate the plaintiff's services before completion of five years, the defendants would compensate the plaintiff by paying salary for one year and vice versa. In view of this condition in the appointment letter issued by the defendants to the plaintiff, there is no escape from the conclusion that plaintiff is entitled to salary for one year from the defendants because the defendants terminated the plaintiff's services before completion of minimum period of five years. Her services were terminated just about 11/2 years after she joined the defendants. This condition of paying salary for one year was imposed not only on the defendants, but also on the plaintiff, if she would have decided to leave the job before completion of minimum period of five years. In view thereof, the said condition cannot be said to be unconscionable in any manner because the condition was reciprocally imposed on both sides. Consequently, the suit of the plaintiff has been rightly decreed by the courts below to the extent it has been decreed.

8.

Counsel for the appellants contended that the plaintiff, immediately after termination of services by defendants, joined another school on 04.01.2006, and therefore, the plaintiff did not suffer any loss. The contention cannot be accepted. Counsel for the appellants submitted that the plaintiff is getting salary of Rs. 13,000/-per month only in the other school. However, her salary in school of defendants was Rs. 21,000/-per month, when her services were terminated and it was increasing by Rs. 1,000/-per month every year. Thus, the plaintiff, by joining other school at much low salary, was suffering recurring loss, not only during the period of one year, but also during subsequent period till completion of minimum period of five years stipulated between the parties. The said loss till completion of minimum period of five years with the defendants would be much more than the amount, with which the plaintiff has been compensated by the courts below in terms of the condition agreed to by the parties themselves.

9.

Counsel for the appellants also referred to conduct of the plaintiff-respondent, which allegedly forced the defendants to terminate the plaintiff's services. However, merely because the plaintiff had taken leave or was allegedly not present on certain dates in the school, as sought to be argued by counsel for the appellants, it cannot be said that the plaintiff's conduct was unworthy of continuing in service. On the contrary, in letter Ex.D-1, the plaintiff alleged that the atmosphere was not conducive and she found it difficult to work under such stressful condition and therefore, she sought leave for 15 days. From this letter, it cannot be said that conduct of the plaintiff was not desirable.

10.

For the reasons aforesaid, I find no merit in the instant second appeal. Plaintiff's claim has been rightly allowed by the courts below as per terms and conditions settled between the parties. There is no infirmity in the concurrent finding recorded by the courts below in partly decreeing the suit of the plaintiff-respondent. The said finding does not suffer from any perversity or illegality nor it is based on misappreciation or misreading of evidence so as to warrant interference in second appeal. No question of law, much less substantial question of law, arises for adjudication in this second appeal. On the contrary, in view of admitted terms and conditions, as contained in appointment letter issued by defendants/appellants themselves to the plaintiff/respondent, suit of the plaintiff has been rightly decreed partly in her favour. The appeal is meritless and is accordingly dismissed in limine.