Vedic Foundation Pvt. Ltd. Vs Income Tax Officer
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · Delhi · 23 Sept 2025 · Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member
Judgment
This assessee’s appeal for Assessment Year 2017-18, arises against the Addl./JCIT(A) , Panchkula’s DIN & order No. ITBA/APL/ S/250/2025-26/1077029340(1) dated 13.06.2025 , in proceedings u/s 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (in short “the Act”).
Case called twice . None appears at the assessee’s behest. It is accordingly proceeded ex-parte.
Coming to the assessee’s sole substantive grievance challenging correctness of both the lower authority’s action making sectio n 69 unexplained investment addition amounting to Rs.14,32,346/- in shares, in the course o f assessment framed on 30.12.2019 and upheld in the lo wer appellate proceedings, it emerges at the outset that it was a case of “limited” scrutiny on the basis of expenses incurred for earning exempt income and investment/advance/loans”.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the assessee’s instant sole substantive grievance as we ll as the Revenue’s vehement contentions. I am of the considered view that once the impugned issue of unexplained investment no where formed subject matter of “ limited” scrutiny exercise here in, bo th the learned lo wer authorities could not have added it in light of PCIT Vs. Weilburger Coatings India Pvt. Ltd. (2023) 155 taxmann.co m 580 (Cal.) settling the issue against the department as under:
“4 . The revenue has raised t he f ollowi ng substantial questi ons of law for consideration:
(a)Whether in t he fa cts and circ umstanc es of the cas e and i n law the Lear ned Tribunal has c ommitted subst antial error in law i n deleti ng t he disallowanc e of carry forward of losses of earlier years?
(b)Whether t he Learned Tribunal ha s substanti ally err ed i n law i n holdi ng that the Assessi ng Off icer exceeded his j uri sdictio n i n enqui ring i nto those issues whic h were beyond the sc ope of limited scr uti ny, wi thout ta ki ng i nt o c onsiderati on the fact that t he claim of t he assessee pertai ning to carried forwa rd l osses was inadmissible since the begi nni ng its elf and there fore t he Assessi ng Officer was justified i n disal lowi ng t he sa me without conver ti ng the cas e i nt o c ompl ete scrutiny?
5.We have he ard Mr. Amit Sha rma, l ear ned st andi ng Couns el appeari ng for the appellant and Mr. Abhratosh Maj umder, learned se nior Adv ocate for t he respo ndent.
6.The s hort iss ue which fall s for consi der ati on in the instant case is whet her t he Ass ess ing Officer excee ded his jurisdic tion i n compl eti ng t he assess ment on grounds whic h wer e not subjec t matt er of the l imited sc ruti ny.
7.The c ontention of t he l ear ned sta nding Counsel for the a ppellant is t hat the assessee was put on notice on tha t particular i ssue by the Assessi ng Officer, the assessee participated i n the proce edings and ther eafter the assessment was co mpl eted by order dated 2 7th December , 2017 unde r Section 143(3) of the Act. The assessee carried the matter on appeal before the Commissi o ner of Inco me Tax (A ppeals) 5 [C IT(A)] and the appeal was c ontested on m erits and the appeal st ood partly allo wed on certai n iss ues by order dated 14th January, 2019. The assessee bei ng aggri eved by the disal lowed portion of t he or der pa ssed by t he C IT(A) preferr ed appeal before the Trib unal and i n the appeal additi onal ground was raised c ontending that the acti on of the CIT(A ) i n confirmi ng the action of the Assessing Officer in maki ng additi ons in respect of iss ues not menti oned in limited scruti ny wer e beyond jurisdicti on of the Ass essing Officer as the sc rut iny assessment was selected f or limited sc ruti ny under Secti on 143(2) and not compl ete scrutiny. The Department objecte d to t he additi onal gr ound whic h were rais ed by the appell ant before the Tribunal. H owever , the learned Tribunal overrul ed the sai d objection hol ding that t he iss ue is jurisdictio nal issue a nd ca n be rais ed by the assessee at any poi nt of time . This fi nding of t he lear ned Tribunal is well j ustifi ed and in acco rdance with the settled legal pri nciple. Thereafter t he learne d Tribunal has re-exami ned t he factual positi on and found that the issue whic h was decided by t he Assessi ng Officer was not pa rt of the limited sc ruti ny for whic h the assessment was directed to be scruti nized. That apart, the l ear ned Tri bunal has als o take n not e of the CBDT Inst ruction No .5 of 2016 to hold t hat the Assessing Officer has exceeded his jurisdiction.
8.Le arned se ni or C ounsel for the respondent/assess ee has plac ed befo re us anot her I nstruction issued by the CBD T da ted 30th November, 2017, bei ng F.No. DG IT(Vig.)/H Q/SI/2017-18, wherei n the CB DT has no ted instanc es where some of the Assessi ng Office r were tr avelling beyond the iss ues while maki ng assessm ent in limited scr uti ny cases by initiati ng i nqui ries o n new issue without complyi ng with ma ndator y require ments of t he rel evant CB DT Instruction dated 26.09.2014, 29.12.2015 and 14.07.2016. It has been stated that the se i nstances hav e been vi ewed seri ously by t he CBDT and in one case the C entral Inspec tion Team of the C BD T was tas ked wi th exami nati on of ass essment records on receipt of allegati ons of several irregularitie s and among ot her irre gulari ti es it was found that no reasons had been rec orde d for expandi ng t he sc ope of limite d scruti ny , no appr oval was take n from the PCIT for conver sion of t he limited scruti ny case t o a compl ete scruti ny c ase and t he order sheet was maintained very perfunctoril y. Further , the CBDT has recorded that t his gave rise to a very strong suspicion o f mala fide i ntentions and the Offi cer concer ned has been placed under suspensi on. Therefore, it was reiterat ed that the Ass essing Officer sho uld a bi de by t he Instructio ns of CB DT whil e completi ng limited scruti ny assessment and should be scr upulous abo ut mai ntenance of note sheets i n ass es sm ent fold ers.
9.Thus, considering these aspects, we ar e of the view tha t t he l earned Tribunal ri ghtly al lowed the as se ss ee's appeal o n t he said issue. This Court had a n occ asion to consider a somewhat similar issue i n t he case of Pr. CIT v. Suk hdham Infrastructures LLP, in [ITA T No. 164 of 2023, dated 14-8-2023], In the said case an identi cal contention as raised befor e us was r aise d stati ng that at best the acti on of the Ass es sing Of ficer could be construed t o be an irregula rity. Whi le c onsideri ng s uch a contention i n Sukhdham Infrastr uctures LLP the Co urt rej ected the same with the followi ng obse rvati on:-
"Whil e considering the sai d issue, t he Hon'ble Supre me Court noted the distinction betwe en t he statutes af fe cti ng rights and those affecti ng mere procedure. The rev enue c annot rely upon t he s aid decision as the sche me of assessment as p rovided under Sectio n 143 of the Act is a compl ete code by itself and the circumstances under whi ch the power under sub-section (2 ) of Secti on 143 could be i nvoked has been clea rly spelt out and on a readi ng of sub-sectio n (3) of S ection 143, it s e vidently clear that on the day speci fied i n t he notice issued under sub-section (2 ), or as s oon after wards as may be, after heari ng such evidence as the assessee may produce and such other evidence as the Assessi ng Officer may require on speci fied poi nts, and after taki ng i nt o account all relevant mat erial which he has gathered, the Assessi ng Officer shall , by an order in writing, make an assessment of the total inc ome or l oss of the assess ee, and determi ne the sum payabl e by him or refund of any amount due to him on t he basis of suc h assessment .
Ther efore, the q uesti on of part of the pr ovision being proc edur al is an incorrect interpr et ation of t he s che me provided under Section 143 of the A ct. Further , as noted above, the CIT(A) has examined the merits of the matter and aft er taki ng note of the facts granted relief to t he assessee to t he extent indicated t herei n. Thus , for t he above r easons, we fi nd that the revenue has not m ade out any case for i nterference of the order passed by t he Tri bunal. Accordi ngly, the appeal fails and is di smissed.
The s ubstantial questions of law are answered agai ns t the revenue.
The applicati on f or stay bei ng GA 1 of 2023 is also dismissed. "
In the light of the abov e, no grounds have been made out to i nterfere with the or der pass ed by t he Tribunal.”
I adopt their lordships foregoing detailed discussion mutatis mutandis to delete the impugned addition in very terms. Ordered accordingly .
This assessee’s appeal is allowed.
