Manish Kumar & Anr. Vs M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited
Real Estate Regulatory Authority National Capital Territory Of Delhi · 08 Oct 2025 · Ajay Kumar Kuhar, Member · Devesh Singh, Member
Judgment
This order shall dispose of the complaint filed on 11.10.2023 by Mr. Manish Kumar & Kumari Ruchita (hereinafter referred to as “Complainants”) in Form ‘M’ stating that in the year 2019, the Complainants had booked a 3 BHK apartment in a project proposed to be developed by M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited (hereinafter referred to as “Respondents”) in village Daultpur, Dwarka, New Delhi and has paid an amount of Rs. 12,36,000/- till date. However, there is no progress in the project despite efflux of considerable time. The Complainants have therefore prayed for refund of the amount paid.
A preliminary hearing in the case was held on 21.12.2023. The Respondents appeared on 09.05.2024 and filed reply on 05.08.2024. The complainants filed their rejoinder on 12.12.2024. Subsequently, the Respondents filed sur-rejoinder on 15.04.2025. The arguments were heard on 19.08.2025 and the case was reserved for orders on 19.08.2025.
For the sake of convenience, the arguments and submissions made on behalf of the Complainants are summarized as under:
a. The Complainants were attracted by the Respondents’ advertisement for a project named “M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited” at L-Zone, Delhi, which was claimed to be developed as per MPD-2021 guidelines and land pooling policy.
b. The Complainants booked an apartment measuring 1025 sq.ft. in the said project. The Respondents confirmed membership of the Complainants and welcomed them as new resident of their proposed project.
c. The Complainants paid Admission Fee, Annual Operation Charges, Share Money, Booking Amount, Land Cost etc. The Complainants were informed by the Respondents that total cost of the aforesaid flat was Rs. 61,50,000/-. The Complainants have paid an amount of Rs. 12,36,000/- (Rupees Twelve Lakh Thirty-Six Thousand Only) to the Respondents till date.
d. The Respondents promised to deliver possession of the plot within the time specified in the agreement for sale and claimed that the society was registered with the Central Registrar of Co-operative Societies.
e. The Complainants alleged that the Respondents indulged in misrepresentation and deception by falsely advertised the project as being approved by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA), which they later discovered was not true.
f. After waiting for over four years without receiving possession and discovering the lack of DDA approval, the Complainants decided to withdraw from the project and seek a refund of their investment along with the interest. 4. For the sake of convenience, the arguments and submissions made on behalf of the Respondents are summarized as under:
a. The Respondents, M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited, is a society duly registered under the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2022, with Registration Certificate NO. MSCS/CR/1032/2014 dated 30.05.2014. The Respondents are bound by the laws of Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002.
b. The Respondents Society operates under the Land Pooling Policy introduced by the Ministry of Urban Development. The Respondents has entered into various agreements for procuring land for the benefit of its members and for onward submission to the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) and has already submitted land totalling 6.5 acres to the DDA under the Land Pooling Policy.
c. The payment made by the Complainants was not towards purchase/development of any flat or construction under any housing scheme, but solely for the procurement of land for onward submission to DDA to avail benefits under the Land Pooling Policy and for Annual Operation Charges to run the society.
d. The Complainants were fully aware of the terms and conditions of membership as clearly stated in the information Booklet Cum Membership Form. The said membership form explicitly mentioned that the society was not engaged in construction of apartments or buildings and that payments were solely for acquiring/procuring land.
e. The Membership Form also detailed the provisions regarding withdrawal, surrender and transfer of membership and clearly specified that members wishing to withdraw would not be refunded their Share Application & Membership Fee or any payment made towards acquiring/procuring land.
f. The Complainants signed undertakings acknowledging that they had read and understood the Master Plan of Delhi 2021, Land Pooling Policy and various notifications and that the society was not under the scope and ambit of RERA at that stage.
g. The Respondents further submitted that it does not qualify as a “promoter” under Section 2(zk) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016, as it neither engaged in construction of apartments or buildings for its members nor there are any apartments or buildings of which the Complainants claim to be an allottee.
h. The Respondents contended that since there is no “project” under Section 2(zj) or 2(zn) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016, the RERA, NCT Delhi has no jurisdiction to adjudicate the present matter.
The Respondents argued that the dispute between a member and the management is governed by the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002, particularly Sections 4, 21, 84, 86, 115 and 117 making the present proceedings not maintainable before Real Estate Regulatory Authority.
We have heard the arguments of the Ld. Counsels of both the parties and perused the documents available on record.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
The Respondents have argued that the RERA, NCT of Delhi has no jurisdiction in the matter because the Respondents do not fall within the definition of Promoter due to provisions contained in Sub Clause (iv) of Section 2 (zk).
The RE (RD) Act, 2016 has been enacted to induct professionalism and standardization in the real estate sector, paving the way for catalysing investments and accelerating growth of sector in the long run. It is a special law enacted to address issues in the real estate sector. To achieve these objectives, the Act created a Real Estate Regulatory Authority to supervise the conception, initiation and completion of a Real Estate Project. Therefore, all disputes between homebuyers/allottees and promoters/developers relating to any Real Estate Project covered under RE (RD) Act of 2016, can be raised before the concerned Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA). Section 79 of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 even bars jurisdiction of civil courts to entertain any suit or proceeding in respect of any matter which the Authority is empowered under the Act to determine. Moreover, section 89 of RE (RD) Act, 2016 says that provisions of this Act shall have an overriding effect on anything inconsistent in any other law in force.
As per Sub Clause (iv) of Section 2(zk) of the RE (RD) Act 2016, ‘promoter’ means:
“An apex State level co-operative housing finance society and a primary co-operative housing society which constructs apartments or buildings for its members or in respect of the allottees of such apartments or buildings;”
The Respondents are a multistate co-operative society. Therefore, the Respondents Society falls within the definition of "promoter" as provided in Section 2 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016.
Furthermore, the issue of whether a Multistate Co-operative Society falls under the purview of the RE (RD) Act, 2016, has been thoroughly discussed by the Hon’ble Real Estate Appellate Tribunal (‘REAT’), Delhi, in its order dated 12.05.2023, in case titled Jeevan Ashray Welfare Society Vs. Diwakar Garg. The relevant paragraph of the said order reads as follows:
“15.A literal interpretation of the definition of promoter under Section 2(zk) itself is clear and apparent, notably sub-clause (iv) which provides for an Apex State Level Cooperative Housing Finance Society and a Primary Cooperative Housing Finance Society, similar to the appellant society, which constructs apartments or buildings for its Members to be a promoter. Section 2(zg) of the Act, which defines the word ‘Person’ used while defining the word ‘Promoter,’ reinforces the above position of law. The appellant society is registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, and their activity as a society is confined to constructing a ‘real estate project,’ as defined under Section 2 (zn) comprising apartments for its members. The appellant society has a large number of members, who have been solicited for membership on assurances of a plot of land on a share of plot of land and an apartment to be constructed by the society. The appellant society admits having purchased land for development and construction of apartments and such activity makes them amenable to the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, and for prior registration of their project under Section 3 of the Act at the appropriate stage. The context of the activities of the appellant has been shown on record by way of documents that the members have been assured of a constructed apartment and that the Respondents have deposited moneys with the appellant from time to time as per the demands raised by the society. The contours of the activities and the conduct of the appellant do make them fall within the ambit of the definition of promoter as provided in Section 2 (zk) of the Act. Even though, we are not examining the felicity or correctness of their registration under the Societies Registration Act, but their amenability to the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, cannot be doubted. Even the elaborated definition of the word ‘Person’ used to define the promoter, as given in Section 2(zg) categorically includes in its fold a cooperative society registered under any law relating to cooperative societies, as also an association of persons or body of individuals, whether incorporated or not, thus shutting the door to prevent unscrupulous persons from hiding under the garb of their registration under any other law relating to cooperative societies."
The Respondents are Multi State Co-operative Housing Society. Therefore, the Authority under the RE (RD) Act, 2016 has jurisdiction over real estate projects promoted by the Respondents. Thus, Multistate Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 cannot put fetters on the jurisdiction of this Authority to decide disputes between homebuyers and the promoters/Respondents Society.
This Authority has held in catena of judgments that Respondents M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited is a Promoter. The Complainants have rightly pointed out that this Authority, vide its order dated 23.08.2023 in complaint no. Com/Dec/21/2021 titled Sh. Nabhranjan Pattnaik V/s M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited and “Sh. Kulwant Singh Bhalla V/s M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited” has categorically held that the Respondents herein is a “Promoter” as defined in the RE(RD) Act, 2016 and that this Hon’ble Authority has jurisdiction to adjudicate the matter.
The Respondents have further stated that Section 2(zn), of RE(RD) Act, 2016, defines “Real Estate Project”, to mean the development of a building or a building consisting of apartments or converting an existing building or a part thereof into apartments, as the case may be, for the purpose of selling all or some of the apartments or plots or building, as the case may be and includes the common areas, the development works, all improvements and structures thereof and all easements and rights appurtenances belonging thereto.” The Respondents have collected money only for procurement of land. The Complainants have paid money only towards land cost. The said land has been offered to DDA under Land Pooling Policy and has not yet been returned to the Respondents Society. The Respondents have stated that in the instant case the Respondents have neither engaged in construction of apartments or buildings for its members nor there exists any apartment or building of which the Complainants may claim to be an allottee. There is no real estate project, as defined under Section 2(zj) or 2(zn) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016 as on date. The Respondents have therefore argued that because they are not dealing with any real estate project at present, they cannot be stated to be promoter under the RE(RD) Act, 2016 and the Authority has no jurisdiction in the matter.
The above-mentioned submissions/arguments of the Respondents are not tenable. The Respondents have submitted that the Respondents are a duly registered Society under Multi State Co-operative Societies Act, 2002 and are governed by the provisions of the said Act, 2002. The Respondents, along with their reply, have furnished a copy of certificate of registration certificate issued by Joint Secretary to the Government of India and Central Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, Ministry of Agriculture, Government of India, New Delhi. As per said certificate of registration, the Central Registrar has registered the Society as “M/s Platinum Multistate Co-operative Housing Society Ltd”. This proves that the Respondents are a Co-operative Housing Society and are in the business of providing housing.
In its reply, the Respondents have also enclosed a copy of “Information Booklet-Cum-Membership Form”. In the said Membership Form the Respondents have clearly stated that “it will be an endeavour of the Society to provide housing in accordance with, and on availing the benefit of MPD-2021/Land Pooling Policy”. The Respondents have further emphasised that “The Society will aim to provide the highest quality housing to its members at affordable cost”. This also shows that the Respondents solicited membership to provide housing to the members.
The Respondents have also submitted a copy of “Housing Scheme Application Form”. A perusal of the application form shows that it is an application for housing scheme floated by the Respondents. The Application Form also gives details of various type of flats (LIG/MIG/HIG/Super HIG) offered for sale, their built-up area, total cost of unit, total land cost, membership + AOC charges and registration amount etc. It also gives details of payment plan, annual operation charge, surrender of membership and refund along with declaration cum expression of interest of the member. Therefore, it is clearly established that the Respondents invited membership for sale of flats and members joined the Society with an objective to own a flat. Therefore, the Respondents, being a co-operative housing society which intends to construct apartments or buildings for its members, are held to be a Promoter as per Section 2(zk) (iv) of the RE(RD) Act, 2016. The fact that Respondents have not yet started construction of flats/apartments shall not exempt Respondents from requirement of registration under the RE(RD) Act 2016.
It is also interesting to note that in their “Housing Scheme Application Form”, under the heading “Declaration-Cum-Expression of Interest”, the Respondents have specifically mentioned that “this dwelling unit option scheme shall be applicable upon all necessary approval sanctioned by Real Estate Regulatory Authority established under Sub Section (1) of Section 20 of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016”. In other words, the Respondents have already declared their housing scheme to fall under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016. Therefore, now at this stage, the Respondents cannot claim that they do not fall under jurisdiction of Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act 2016.
Respondents have also stated that Ministry of Urban Development vide its notification in Official Gazette dated 05.09.2013, read with Notification dated 11.10.2019 introduced a Land Pooling Policy for Delhi. The Delhi Development Authority made “Regulation for Operationalization of Land Pooling Policy 2018 vide Gazette notification dated 24.10.2018. The members were made aware of various aspects of Land Pooling Policy and by-laws of the Society by the Respondents through membership application form and other material. The Respondents entered into various agreements for procuring land for benefit of its members and submitted their expression of interest to participate in said Land Pooling Policy to DDA. The members were aware that object of the Society was to procure/acquire land with a view to avail maximum benefits of Land Pooling Policy for its members.
The Respondents have further argued that the members have made payments for shareholding in the land proposed to be procure for submission to DDA. The Respondents collected money only for the purpose of procurement of land. Even in the demand letters sent to the members it was clearly mentioned that money is being taken only towards land cost and land shareholding. There is no mention in the demand letter of any amount payable for the alleged flat/unit. DDA is yet to start said Land Pooling Policy Scheme. The Members are aware that flats would be constructed only when the Land Pooling Policy of DDA takes off. The Society is waiting for Land Pooling Policy to start so that Respondents may obtain the requisite approvals from DDA to proceed further.
The Complainants have denied that members of the Society, were aware of the various notifications regarding Land Pooling Policy and Master Plan of Delhi (MPD). The Complainants further denied that members made payments only towards land shareholding in the land proposed to be procured for the submission to DDA to avail the benefit of Land Pooling Policy. The Complainants has stated that the Respondents Society, in its membership application form, has clearly mentioned that “the Society will aim to provide the highest quality housing to its members at affordable cost” and has mentioned clearly the category (LIG, MIG, HIG and Super HIG) along with their specific built-up area and costs. The Complainants argued that the Respondents Society collected money for providing to its members a residential unit at a reasonable price, and, upon the representations and promises made by the Respondents Society, the Complainants along with various other members, had paid the money for allotment of flat.
The Complainants have further pointed out that the expression of interest submitted by the Respondents Society to DDA has been filed by one Mr. Pravesh Solanki and has not been filed in the name of the Respondents Society.
Along with his reply, Respondents have also enclosed copy of Agreement to Sell and Purchase dated 16.05.2021 executed between M/s Achal Infrastructure (P) Ltd. and M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited for purchase of Agriculture Land admeasuring 24 bighas and 7 biswa in village Asalatpur Khawad, Tehsil Kapashera, New Delhi. The total sale consideration is Rs. Fifteen Crores Seventy-Five Lakhs Fifty-Seven Thousand & Five Hundred only (Rs.15,75,57,500/- only), out of which an amount of Rs. 2.72 crores have been paid to the seller. The said Agreement to Sell is not registered and is only notarised.
Along with his reply, the Respondents have also placed another Agreement to Sell dated 19.04.2021 between M/s Max Fort Infra Pvt. Ltd. and M/s Platinum Multi State Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. for purchase of 1/8 share in agricultural land admeasuring 55 bigha and 14 biswa at village Daulat Pur, Tehsil Kapashera, New Delhi. The total sale consideration is Rs. Eight Crores Thirty-Four Lakhs (Rs.8,34,00,000/-). Entire sale consideration has been paid by the purchaser i.e. the Respondents Society has been received by the seller. The said Agreement to Sell also appears to be only notarised, it is not registered. It has not been clarified why the Respondents Society did not execute a sale deed when the full sale consideration for purchase of land had been made by the Respondents Society to the seller of the land.
Thus, it may be seen that the Respondents Society has entered into Agreements to Sell for lands, in village Asalatpur Khawad and in village Daulat Pur and sale deeds have not been executed till date. Therefore, the Respondents Society does not have legal title to the land and cannot be said to be owner of the said lands.
As per point no. 4 of the Gazette Notification S.O 5220(E) dated 11.10.2018, the Land Pooling Policy is open only to land owners who own land in areas notified. The Respondents Society, which does not own any land in above mentioned villages, cannot be considered to be eligible to participate in the Land Pooling Policy.
Further, as per “Regulations for operationalization of land policy, 2018” published vide notification no. S.O 5384 (E) dated 24.10.2018, only the land owners who have lands in the urban areas notified DDA/Government may register and express their interest to participate by submitting the prescribed application form.
A copy of expression of willingness for participation under Land Pooling Scheme of DDA has been submitted by the Respondents Society along with their reply for Asalatpur Khawad village as well as for Daulat Pur village. A perusal of copy of willingness show that the willingness has been filed by one Mr. Parvesh Solanki. The willingness has not been filed by the Respondents Society M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited or any one on its behalf.
In view of above facts, the Respondents cannot even be considered to have shown willingness to DDA for participation in the Land Pooling Scheme for the reasons that they are not the land owners. Further, the Society has also not applied to DDA validly because the application has not been made by the Respondents Society. For the same reasons the arguments of the Respondents Society that they are awaiting the Land Pooling Policy to take off to provide housing to its members is also rejected because the Respondents Society neither owns any land nor it has submitted its expression of interest before DDA within prescribed time window.
The Respondents have further argued that the Complainants are hit by law of estoppel because the Complainants have waived its right to seek refund in any manner other then what has been specifically agreed in the membership application form i.e. by introducing a new member so as to protect interest of other remaining members. The Society has already purchased/entered into various agreements for purchase of land and has already submitted land to DDA. Having altered its position on the strength of promise of timely payments by the Complainants, the interest of the other members cannot be prejudiced by permitting the Complainants herein to back track and negatively affect the interest of the Society and its members.
The Respondents have furnished copy of Bye-Laws of the M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited. Clause 16 of the Bye-Laws deals with withdrawal and resignation of member. Copy of Clause 16 of the Bye-Laws is reproduced as under:
“Withdrawal and Resignation of Member:
i.A member may withdraw and resign from the membership after two years and giving at least 3 months’ notice in writing and withdraw his share capital with the approval of the Board of Directors. The approval shall not be given while such a member is indebted, to the society. During any co-operative year, the aggregated withdrawals shall not exceed 10% of the total paid-up share capital as on 31st March of the preceding year.
ii.A member who withdraws or resigns from the membership will not be allowed to become a member again for a period of two years from the date of his resignation unless he repays the amount withdrawn by him from the society.”
Respondents have also submitted a copy of “Housing Scheme Application Form”. Point no. 25 of the Declaration cum Expression of Interest attached with said Application Form provides as under:
“A member may withdraw and resign from the membership after two years and giving at least three months’ notice in writing and withdraw his share capital and deposit with the approval of the Board of Directors. The approval shall not be given while such a member is indebted to the society or until he has given replacement of his membership. During any co-operative year, the aggregated withdrawals shall not exceed 10% of the total paid-up share capital as on 31st march of the preceding year.”
From the above, it is seen that the provisions regarding withdrawal by a member stipulated in Bye-Laws of the Society are different from the provisions regarding withdrawal by a member stipulated in “Housing Scheme Application Form”. The Bye-Laws of the Society provide that a member may withdraw from the membership after two years giving three months’ notice with the approval of Board of Directors. The approval shall not be given while such member is indebted to the Society and the aggregated withdrawals in a co-operative year shall not exceed 10% of the total paid-up share capital as on 31st March of the preceding year. However, the Point no. 25 mentioned in Housing Scheme Application Form states that the approval shall not be given while such a member is indebted to the Society or until he has given replacement of his membership.
The above-mentioned condition in the “Housing Scheme Application Form” of providing a replacement member for seeking refund is not as per the Bye Laws. The Society has not claimed that it has ever amended its Bye Laws. As per Section 11 of the Multi State Co-operative Societies Act 2002 amendment of any Bye Law of a Multi-State Co-operative Society is valid only when it is approved by the Central Registrar and is registered under the said Act 2002. Because the Society has failed to show that it has amended and registered its Bye Laws, the condition of insisting for a replacement member is invalid and is void ab initio.
In the instant case we have seen that the Society has already paid the full sale consideration for land at village Daulat Pur, Tehsil Kapashera, New Delhi as recorded in the Agreement to Sell dated 19.04.2021. Thus, there is no reason to believe that the Complainants are indebted to the Society because the entire sale consideration has been paid by the Society to the seller and Society is not in debt to anyone. Respondents have also not shown that withdrawal in the year is more than 10% of the total paid-up share capital as on 31st march of the preceding year. Therefore, the Society is bound to refund the share capital and land cost paid by the Complainants as per provisions of its Bye Laws. Any insistence by the Society on member to bring in a new replacement member in his place is not as per Bye-Laws and cannot be sustained. Therefore, the argument of the Society that the Complainants are hit by law of estoppel and therefore cannot seek refund without introducing a new member is hereby rejected.
The Respondents have argued that the Respondents Society is governed by the laws of the Multi State Co-operative Act, 2002. The Society has therefore contended that the appropriate remedy in the facts of the present matter i.e., a dispute between a member and the management under the Multi State Co-Operative Societies Act, 2002. The Respondents have, therefore, submitted that the present proceedings are not maintainable in view of Sections 4, 21, 84, 86, 115, 117 of MSCS Act, 2002.
The Respondent Society has also placed reliance on various clauses, in their Bye Laws, particularly Clause 58 which provides that "All the dispute shall be referred to Arbitration in accordance with the provisions of the Act and Rules". The Respondents have contended that by virtue of these bye laws, the dispute resolution mechanism for controversy between the society and its members is clearly established under the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, and therefore, the present complaint is not maintainable before this Authority.
Further, in Aftab Singh and Ors. v. Emaar MGF Land Ltd and Ors., Consumer case no. 701 of 2015 decided on 13.07.2017, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi (NCDRC) has held that the arbitration clause in agreements between the Complainant and builders could not circumscribe the jurisdiction of a consumer forum.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in case titled as M/s Emaar MGF Land Ltd. V. Aftab Singh in revision petition no. 2629-30/2018 in civil appeal no. 23512-23513 of 2017 decided on 10.12.2018 has upheld the aforesaid judgement of NCDRC and as provided in Article 141 of the Constitution of India, the law declared by the Supreme Court shall be binding on all courts within the territory of India and accordingly, the authority is bound by the aforesaid view.
It is also pertinent to note that Section 79 of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 even bars the jurisdiction of civil courts to entertain any suit or proceeding in respect of any matter which the Authority is empowered under the Act to determine. Moreover, section 89 of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 says that provisions of this Act shall have an overriding effect on anything inconsistent with any other law in force.
Therefore, this Authority determines that it possesses full jurisdiction to adjudicate the present case, notwithstanding the arbitration clause contained in the Respondents Society's bye laws. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has unequivocally established that remedies under consumer protection laws operate in addition to other legal provisions, and has specifically upheld that arbitration clauses cannot oust the jurisdiction of specialized forums. Furthermore, the RE (RD) Act, 2016 explicitly bars civil courts from entertaining matters within this Authority's domain and establishes an overriding effect over inconsistent provisions in other laws. Therefore, the objection regarding maintainability of this complaint is rejected, and this Authority shall proceed to hear the matter on merits.
The Respondents have further argued that DDA has published Flow Chart giving details of “Procedure for Land Pooling Policy”. As per the said Flow Chart the consortium/DE (Developer Entity) is required to be registered under RERA at stage 17.
The said flow chart has been perused. It is noted that the said flow chart is titled “Land Pooling Procedure” and is a graphical representation of various stages of Land Pooling Policy announced by DDA. At the bottom of said flow chart DDA has categorically mentioned that the graphics are for non-profit educational purpose only and that the provisions of RERA Act 2016 prevail over the above-mentioned Land Pooling Procedure and all DE(s)/Promoter(s) are to mandatorily register their projects under RERA.
The said flow chart shows 18 stages of Land Pooling Procedure namely: 1. Web Portal, 2. Online Registration, 3. Verification by GNCTD, 4. Notice to form consortium, 5. DDA will prepare Sector Land, 6. Provisional Entitlement Certificate, 7. Grievance Redressal, 8. Final Entitlement Certificate, 9. Layout Plan prepare by consortium, 10,11. Development Agreement with Consortium, 12. Provisional Development Licence,13. Application by Consortium/DE for final Development Licence, 14. Payment of EDC, 15. Layout Plan approval, 16. Approval by DDA, 17. Consortium/DE will register under RERA, 18. Execution of project and completion.
Thus, the said flow chart shows various stages of Land Pooling Policy of DDA for the awareness/education of the DE(s)/Promoter(s). It rightly mentions that the Promoters should obtain all due scrutiny/approvals from DDA first and thereafter, they must register their real estate project with RERA before execution of the project.
Section 3 of the RE(RD) Act, 2016 provides that no promoter shall advertise, market, book, sell or offer for sale any plot or apartment in any real estate project without registering the real estate project with the Real Estate Regulatory Authority. Thus, the Respondents were required to register their project with RERA before offering the apartments for sale. The flow chart of DDA does not advise that the apartments can be sold before registration with RERA. Therefore, the arguments of the Respondents that they would seek registration of the project once Land Pooling Policy is made operational by DDA and all approvals are granted to the Respondents is found to be against the provision of the RE(RD) Act 2016 and therefore, is hereby rejected.
It is also noted that the certificate of registration dated 30.05.2014 of the Central Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Ministry of Agriculture, Govt. of India, has granted registration to the Respondents Society on the condition that “ the Society is registered with the stipulation that the Society shall commence business in both the states (of Delhi and Uttar Pradesh) and furnish evidence/documents regarding procurement of land within a period of six months from the date of registration. If the land is not procured within the stipulated time, the registration shall stand cancelled”. In the instant case Society has not shown whether it has procured any land within six months from the date of registration or even till date and whether the registration of the Society still stands or not. The Respondents have further failed to show how they are eligible to participate in Land Pooling Scheme of DDA and whether they validly applied on the Web Portal of DDA for participation under Land Pooling Scheme. This casts serious doubts on the intentions of the Respondents to develop a real estate project.
The statement of objects and reasons of the RE(RD) Act, 2016 attempts to balance the interests of consumers and promoters by imposing certain responsibilities on both. It seeks to establish symmetry of information between the promoters and purchasers, enhance transparency of contractual conditions, set minimum standards of accountability and establish a fast-track dispute resolution mechanism.
Under section 18 of RE (RD) Act, 2016, an allottee/house buyer can seek refund of amount invested/deposited with the promoter, along with interest and compensation, if the promoter fails to complete the project by the date specified in Agreement to Sale, and also under section 12 of RE (RD) Act, 2016, if he/she was misled by any information furnished by the promoter, with regard to the project, either through advertisement or otherwise.
In the present complaint, the Complainants intend to withdraw from the project on the ground of delay and are seeking refund of the amount paid to the Respondents in respect of the unit under section 18(1) of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 which reads as under:
“Section 18. Return of amount and compensation: -
18(1). If the promoter fails to complete or is unable to give possession of an apartment, plot, or building, —
(a). in accordance with the terms of the agreement for sale or, as the case may be, duly completed by the date specified therein; or
(b). due to discontinuance of his business as a developer on account of suspension or revocation of the registration under this Act or for any other reason,
he shall be liable on demand to the allottees, in case the allottee wishes to withdraw from the project, without prejudice to any other remedy available, to return the amount received by him in respect of that apartment, plot, building, as the case may be, with interest at such rate as may be prescribed in this behalf including compensation in the manner as provided under this Act.”
As stated earlier, section 12 of the RE (RD) Act, 2016 casts a duty upon the promoter to provide correct and updated information to allottees regarding the project. It reads as under:
“Section 12. Obligations of promoter regarding veracity of the advertisement or prospectus: -
Where any person makes an advance or a deposit on the basis of the information contained in the notice advertisement or prospectus, or on the basis of any model apartment, plot or building, as the case may be, and sustains any loss or damage by reason of any incorrect, false statement included therein, he shall be compensated by the promoter in the manner as provided under this Act:
Provided that if the person affected by such incorrect, false statement contained in the notice, advertisement or prospectus, or the model apartment, plot or building, as the case may be, intends to withdraw from the proposed project, he shall be returned his entire investment along with interest at such rate as may be prescribed and the compensation in the manner provided under this Act.”
The Respondents, in complete disregard to their duties, not only failed to furnish correct information to the Complainants but also misled them at the time of allotment itself by concealing information that they do not have any license or approval from the concerned authorities for construction of housing project and that no housing project can be developed on agricultural land proposed to be purchased by them unless its use is changed. They also did not disclose the risks associated with the project to the society members including the Complainants. The promoters gave part information and concealed material facts, thereby cheating the members of public at large. The discrepancy between the exit clause mentioned in the brochure and its absence in the bye laws, the failure to disclose the complexities of Multi State Cooperative Housing Society laws, and the premature offering of units without requisite DDA approvals, all constitute material misrepresentation and unfair trade practices.
From the facts produced before us, it is clear that the Respondents have collected deposits from the Complainants for the flat in their proposed project after 01.05.2017, the day RE(RD) Act, 2016 came into force, without registering the project with RERA, Delhi under section 3 of RE (RD) Act, 2016. Thus, if the Complainants wish to withdraw from the project, the Respondents do not have any legal or moral authority to keep money deposited by the Complainants.
The law is well settled that the allottees/homebuyers hold an unqualified right to seek refund of the amount with interest at such rate as may be prescribed in this behalf. A conscious decision has been taken by the legislature to cast an obligation upon the promoter to refund the amount on demand along with interest at rate prescribed. It has also been held through the recent judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that the Regulatory Authorities have exclusive jurisdiction to direct refund of the amount deposited along with interest to the allottees. (Vide: Imperia Structures Ltd. Vs. Anil Patni and Another, 2020 (10) SCC 783, and Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of UP And Ors. LL 2021 SC 641).
On perusal of the documents on record and submissions made by the Complainants, the Authority is of view that the Respondents are in contravention of the sections 18 and 12 of RE (RD) Act, 2016. As such, the Complainants are entitled to get the refund of the amount paid by them along with interest at prescribed rate @ 10.80% p.a. (i.e., MCLR plus 2%) as per provisions of sections 18 and 12 of RE (RD) Act, 2016 read with rule 15 of the National Capital Territory of Delhi Real Estate (Regulation and Development) (General) Rules, 2016.
In the light of the aforesaid, we direct the Respondents, M/s Platinum Multi-State Cooperative Housing Society Limited to refund the entire amount of Rs. 12,36,000/- (Rupees Twelve Lakh Thirty-Six Thousand Only), deposited with the Respondents, to the Complainants i.e. Mr. Manish Kumar & Kumari Ruchita, within 45 days of issuance of this order along with interest at the rate of 10.80% per annum (MCLR+2%) from the date of payment of each sum until the date of its actual return.
The case is disposed of accordingly.
No order as to costs.
