Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 01 NCDRC CK 3432

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. & Anr. Vs Shahid

National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission · New Delhi · 05 Jan 2026 · A.P. Sahi, J · Bharatkumar Pandya, Member

Open full page

Judgment

124 paragraphs · 4,511 words
1.

These two appeals arise out of a common order passed in CC/133/2015 by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Uttar Pradesh at Lucknow. The impugned order dated 06.05.2022 has been assailed by the Insurance Company questioning the correctness of the order whereas the complainant - Shahid has filed the other appeal praying for the grant of the entire relief to the maximum of Rs.15,00,000/- along with interest as against the total loss of Rs.16,88,992/-.

2.

FA/747/2022 was heard earlier and was admitted on 30.04.2024 and the following order was passed:

"Admit.

Issue notice.

IA/9442/2022 has been filed for condoning the delay in filing the appeal. The Office has reported delay of 118 days in filing the appeal. The impugned order was passed on 06.05.2022 and free copy was supplied on 11.05.2022, while the appeal has been filed on 06.10.2022. In the IA the Appellant has stated that after receiving the certified copy of the judgment, the Appellant has taken opinion from local Counsel and after obtaining the opinion for filing the appeal, it was sent to Head Office, New Delhi only in 1st week of August 2022. The Head Office thereafter appointed a Counsel for the National Commission and papers were handed over to him on 30.09.2022 and thereafter the appeals were drafted and sent for approval of the department and after approval it was received on 30.09.2022 and filed on 06.10.2022. Although, the Opposite Party has filed a reply in the IA and contested the IA, but, the Opposite Party has also filed a cross appeal that is FA/365/2023, looking, into the fact that there is cross appeal, we condoned the delay in filing the appeal. Accordingly, IA is allowed.

The Counsel appearing for the Punjab National Bank states that the Punjab National Bank which was arrayed as Opposite Party No.2&3 in the complaint has been deleted by the order of State Commission dated 14.07.2017. The Punjab National Bank has been wrongly impleaded as Respondent. As Punjab National Bank has already been deleted we direct for deletion of Punjab National Bank from both the Appeals.

List for hearing on 30.07.2024."

3.

Thereafter FA/365/2023 was also connected and was taken up on the same date by the following order:

"The office has submitted report that the appeal has been filed with delay of 290 days. The Appellant has filed IA/3817/2023 for condoning the - delay in filing the appeal. In the affidavit it has been stated that after the judgment dated 06.05.2022, the Appellant has consulted with the Counsel on 02.09.2022, who then advised to file appeal as the entire relief has not been granted to the Appellant, thereafter, he consulted a Counsel in New Delhi, who asked for a translation of the papers which were in Hindi language and thereafter translation has been provided and the appeal has been drafted and filed on 22.03.2023.

Since there is already a cross appeal i.e. FA/747/2022, we condoned the delay in filing the appeal.

Admit and connect with FA/747/2022.

Six weeks' time is allowed to the Respondents to file reply in the appeal. Both the Parties may file their written arguments if they want to do so within 6 weeks.

The Counsel appearing for the Punjab National Bank states that the Punjab National Bank who was arrayed as Opposite Party No.2&3 in the complaint has been deleted by the order of State Commission dated 14.07.2017. The Punjab National Bank has been wrongly impleaded as Respondent in the appeal. As Punjab National Bank has already been deleted, we direct for deletion of Punjab National Bank from both the Appeals.

List for hearing on 30.07.2024."

4.

Both the appeals thereafter were taken up on 30.07.2024, when the following order was passed. The matter was adjourned on a couple of occasions and then on 30.04.2025, the following order was passed:

"After brief arguments, it is evident that there is an incomplete surveyor report that was prepared in the case on account of certain allegations of non-cooperation between the parties and that an estimate has been made by fire department personnel which is part of the record.

Learned Counsel for both the parties undertake to cooperate in the process wherein the Complainant will provide all necessary details with respect to the incident in question to the surveyor appointed by the Opposite Party insurer.

Opposite Party is directed to notify the details of the surveyor along with necessary documents/records and other details they seek from the Complainant within a period of one month from today. On receipt of notice, the Complainant may produce the records as required within a period of four weeks thereafter.

Opposite Party is directed to file a report to the surveyor within a period of further four weeks.

Both the parties are at liberty to file fresh brief synopsis of arguments within a period of four weeks thereafter.

List the matter on 04.09.2025.

Parties are directed to adhere to the timelines and it is made clear that no further adjournment shall be granted in the matter."

5.

In terms of the above quoted order dated 30.04.2025, the Insurance Company called upon its surveyor to tender its survey and assessment report. The surveyor tendered his report on 22.11.2025 that has been brought on record by the learned counsel for the complainant through his additional short arguments filed on 26.12.2025 through diary no. 34065. The said report is extracted herein under:

Ref. No. TISLA/Fire/2025-26/641

Dated: 22-11-2025

Survey & Assessment Report

The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Regional Office, 24 A. NCR Plaza III Floor, New Cantt. Road, Dehradun.

Re : Reported loss due to fire at Insured's premises located at Daud Sarai, Behind Power House, Amroha on dated 08-01-2014 at about 00:30 A.M.

The Insured: M/S Tara Traders, Daud Sarai, Amroha, U.P. 244 221 433

The Insurers: The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, 253502- BO Gajraula, NH-24, Alipur Chopra, Delhi Road, Gajraula, U.P. 244235.

Loss dated : 08-01-2014 at about 00:30 A.M.

Policy No. : 253502/11/2014/323

Policy Type : Standard Fire & Special Perils Policy

Dear Sir,

This has ref to our earlier report ST-346 dated 16-9-2025 & now instruction received from Underwriters HO & RO, we contacted the Insured & advised them to submit the required documents/ information to enable us to proceed further in the matter. Based on whatever documents submitted now, verification of various documents, we issue our addendum report in the matter for the information of the Underwriters as under :-

1.0 Insurance Policy :-

Policy No. : 253502/11/2014 323 Type of Policy : Standard Fire & Special Perils Policy Period of Policy : 26/06/2013 to 25/06/2014 Sum Insured : Rs. 15,00,000.00 on cotton & cotton waste. Location covered : Dau Sarai Road, Amroha, JP Nagar.

Copy of Policy is enclosed & marked as Annexure-B.

2.0 Loss Particulars:-

Date of loss:08-01-2014
Date of our deputation:09-01-2014
Date of survey:10-01-2014

3.0 Fire brigade report & Police report :-

Insured have now provided us Police Report & fire brigade report in the matter which confirm the damages & quantum of loss. copy of Police intimations & fire brigade report is enclosed & marked as Annexure-C & D.

4.0 News paper cuttings :-

The incident was widely covered by local newspapers & copies of newspaper cuttings are enclosed & marked as Annexure-F.

5.0 Commercial tax details :-

Now Insured have provided commercial tax registration & returns for the period with tax deposit challans, copies of the same are enclosed & marked as Annexure-F. The same document proves that Insured was registered with commercial tax & was maintaining proper returns & challans which were not provided earlier.

6.0 Bank details & stock statement :-

During verification of documents, we confirmed that Insured is submitting bank stock statement in Punjab National Bank, Amroha & have submitted bank stock statements in this regard as on the date of loss from April 2013 to 8-1-2014 & after the loss is on 9-1-2014, copies of the bank stock statement & bank account statement is enclosed & marked as Annexure-G.

7.0 Stock register & sale & purchase statement :-

Insured provided us copies of stock register & also the sale & purchase statement from 1-4-2013 to date of loss & have confirmed that total stock as on the date of loss of Chindi (white), Chindi (Rangeen) & textile waste of weight 664.83 qtl. was lying there in the premises having value as Rs. 1742519.00, out of which 647.90 qtl burnt in this incident worth Rs. 1688992.00 & only 24 bags of chindi white having weight 16.93 qtl remained balance or worth Rs. 53527.00 copies of stock statement, stock register & sale & purchase statement are enclosed & marked as Annexure-H.

8.0 Electricity bill & land documents :-

During verification Insured provided us receipt of electricity bills & land documents & it has been confirmed that the premises was of their own, copy of the layout & related documents are enclosed & marked as Annexure-I.

9.0 Books of accounts & balance sheets :-

Insured have provided audited balance sheets & trading account of previous 3 years including as on the 9-1-2014 the date of loss & value of closing stock confirmed as Rs. 1742519.00 as on the date of loss which were not provided to us earlier. As these records are duly audited and also backed up by stock register & tax statements, the same can be relied upon & to be considered for the calculation of assessment of loss as detailed below in assessment paragraph. Copy of trading account & the audited balance sheets are enclosed & marked as Annexure-J.

10.0 Circumstances of loss :-

As already mentioned in our earlier report that as stated by Insured's representative, Mr. Shahabuddin & his brother Shahid & as narrated to us that on dated 08-01-2014 at about 00:30 A.M. Mr. Shahid received a call from his neighbor factory labour intimating him that a fire has taken place in his godown and smoke and flames are coming out. He immediately rushed to godown and found that the flames had engulfed the two rooms of the godown where stock of waste was lying. Third room was completely empty. In the meantime the Fire Brigade was intimated about the incident which reached the site and started fire fighting operations. It took more than three hours to control the fire with the help of fire tenders and neighbours but smoldering still continued. When we visited the site smoldering was still there and water was still being poured on the burnt stock as the fire was erupting again & again from the heap. Smell of burnt cotton chindis and textile waste was there in the atmosphere.

11.0 Nature & extent of damages :-

We, during our earlier visit on 10/01/2014 after our deputation on 09-01-2014, observed that :-

1.

11.1 Two front rooms were totally blackened due to smoke, flame, soot and carbon.

2.

11.2 Heaps of chindies and cloth cuttings which were there in the rooms had caught fire and the burning stock was dragged outside in front of the rooms to facilitate firefighting.

3.

11.3 A burnt wire of the light point outside the room was lying hanging and it appeared that some spark from there might have fallen on the heap of chindies which caught fire.

4.

11.4 A hand pump was there outside the rooms but that was not working. No fire extinguishers was observed in the godowns.

5.

11.5 Stock was still smoldering & water pouring was in progress to control the same.

6.

11.6 Marks of flames & smoke were there on the walls & semi burnt stock was dragged out in the open area for extinguishing the same.

7.

11.7 Third room of the godown was empty & fire was only in the front two rooms.

12.0 Cause of damage :-

Although no particular cause could be attributed towards the occurrence of fire but in view of the circumstances, extent & nature of damages, as per our inspection at site, discussion with Insured representatives & eyewitnesses, we are of opinion that fire accident has taken place due to short circuit in electric wire of lighting point & electricity bill & connection documents in this regard has now been provided by Insured.

13.0 Insured's claim :-

Insured have submitted their claim bill for Rs. 1688992.00 for the burnt stock in this incident. Copy of claim bill is enclosed & marked as Annexure-K.

14.0 Adequacy of coverage :-

Considering the stock statement now submitted & trading account as on the date of loss, the value of stock as on the date of loss was confirmed as Rs. 1742519.00. As the sum insured available is Rs. 15 lakh, therefore stock has been found to be under insured to the extent of 13.92%. Copy of trading account & other books of accounts as on the date of loss duly audited are enclosed & marked as Annexure-J.

15.0 Salvage :-

Although stock was badly burnt but some semi burnt or partially burnt, pcs were there & estimation deduction of Rs. 50000.00 has been considered as reasonable on account of salvage while assessing the loss.

16.0 Our verifications :-

During verification of documents now submitted, we confirmed that :-

As per the documents submitted & verification of the balance sheet & stock records submitted the assessment of loss has been prepared as under assessment paragraph.

Regarding the cost of the affected material, the same has been confirmed from various purchase bills submitted, & average rates considered as detailed in Annexure-A. Copies of various purchase bills are enclosed & marked as Annexure-L.

However taking into consideration the nature of business some old & non moving stock might be there in the inventory. Therefore for the purpose of assessment of loss a deduction of 10% has been made on this head as reasonable while assessing the loss.

It may further be noted that as verified now the firm Tara Traders have already been inactive as per records & firm closed due to non business. Copy of screen shot at site, mail of insured above closure of firm & partnership deed are enclosed & marked as Annexure-M.

17.0 Assessment of loss: -

In view of the above verifications, the assessment of loss has been worked out as under for the information only of the Underwriters:-

S.NO.ITEM NAMEAs Claimed by InsuredAs considered by us
Qty bagsweight QtlRate QtlAmountQtyWeightRateAmount
1Chindi white516376.783159.971190612.00516376.783125.001177437.50
2Chindi Rangeen339244.71675.00409373.00339244.71675.00409372.50
3Cotton waste4626.423350.0088507.004626.423125.0082562.50
Total1688992.001689572.50
Less deduction @ 10% on account of old & non moving stock & quantity & price variation168537.25
Total1502835.25
Less salvage50000.00
Total1452835.25
Less under insurance @ 13.92%202241.63
Less Excess1250643.62
Therefore Net1000.00
Assessed Loss1240643.62

Therefore net assessed loss Or say : Rs. 1240643.62 : Rs. 1240644.00

Thus the net assessed loss as per the given documents & verification has been worked out as Rs. 1240644.00 (Twelve lakh forty thousand six hundred forty four only) Underwriters are requested to take necessary decisions at their end accordingly.

This independent report is issued without prejudice.

For Taarani Insurance Surveyors & Loss Assessors Pvt. Ltd., Surveyor

6.

A copy of the said report has already been supplied to the learned counsel for the Insurance Company, who has advanced her submissions contending that the surveyor estimated the loss at Rs.12,40,644/-, which the Insurance Company had offered to pay to the respondent/ complainant. She further submits that this delay in survey was not on account of any laxity on the part of the Insurance Company, but it was on account of the complainant having not submitted complete documents. It is therefore submitted that the lack of survey report cannot be attributed to the Insurance Company at all. She therefore submits that the claim of the complainant of interest is unwarranted and therefore the State Commission has erroneously allowed interest which should be set aside and the award should stand reduced to the sum of Rs.12,40,644/- only.

7.

She has then urged that inspite of the claim of the complainant which was on the higher side the maximum liability payable is only Rs.15,00,000/- and therefore the claim was otherwise also untenable. Nonetheless, the surveyor has assessed the claim at an amount which is within limits of the insured amount and consequently no further amount is admissible.

8.

The State Commission has allowed the claim to the maximum limit of Rs.15,00,000/- together with interest thereon.

9.

Learned counsel for the complainant, who has filed FA/365/2023 urges that the interest amount should be enhanced to 9% and the entire claim should be awarded.

10.

Learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the following three judgments of the Apex Court:

i.

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pradeep Kumar, Civil Appeal No. 3253 of 2022, decided on 09.04.2009.

ii.

United India Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Bansai Wood Products Pvt. Ltd., Civil Appeal No. 104 of 2025, decided on 08.01.2025.

iii.

The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Niru @ Niharika & Ors., Special Leave Petition (C) No. 11340 of 2020, decided on 14.07.2025.

11.

Having considered the same, we are not impressed by the arguments of the learned counsel for the complainant for any enhancement either in respect of the amount awarded or the rate of interest which has been rightly calculated at 6% by the State Commission.

12.

We however find force in the argument of the learned counsel for the complainant that the surveyor in the report dated 22.11.2025 has erroneously deducted Rs.50,000/- under the head of salvage. The contention is that the salvage was of cotton fibre which was burnt to ashes and therefore no salvage was left to be accounted for. We have not found any material in the report of the surveyor so as to justify the deduction of Rs.50,000/- on the head of salvage. We therefore do not accept the said conclusion of the surveyor and in addition to the amount assessed by the surveyor, we further award a sum of Rs.50,000/- thereby enhancing the amount assessed as Rs.12,90,644/-. This amount is payable to the complainant together with interest as awarded by the State Commission @ 6% from the date of filing of the complaint keeping in view the law laid down by the Apex Court that failure to award interest, when there is a delay in payment, results in injustice. This matter was considered by the Apex Court in the case of LIC of India and Anr. versus S. Sindhu reported in (2006) 5 SCC 258 the provisions of the Interest Act, 1978. Following the aforesaid principle this Commission in the case of Soni Singh & Ors. Vs. M/s. Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd., FA/958/2023 decided on 29.08.2025, in paragraphs 12 to 16 has observed as under:

"12.

We may point out that award of interest in consumer complaints of different varieties has been upheld and the Apex Court has gone to the extent of observing that failure to award interest, when there is a delay in payment, results in injustice and therefore interest should be awarded in all cases subject to of course the discretion to be exercised in these matters depending upon the facts of each case. This matter was considered by the Apex Court in the case of LIC of India and Anr. versus S. Sindhu reported in (2006) 5 SCC 258S the provisions of the Interest Act, 1978, where in Paragraph No. 12 to 15 it was observed as under:

"12.

Where a statute provides for payment of interest, such interest will have to be paid in accordance with the provisions of such statute. Admittedly there is no enactment, or rules made under any enactment, either relating to contracts in general or insurance in particular, which provides for payment of interest in regard to the amount payable under such a policy.

13.

Let us now consider the provisions of the Interest Act, 1978 ("the Act" for short) which deals with payment of interest up to the date of suit/claim. The Act was enacted to consolidate and amend the law relating to the allowance of interest in certain cases. The objects and reasons state that the Act was enacted to prescribe the general law of interest in a comprehensive and precise manner, which becomes applicable in the absence of any contractual or statutory provision specifically dealing with interest. Sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the Act provides that in any proceedings for the recovery of any debt or damages, or in any proceedings in which a claim for interest in respect of any debt or damages already paid is made, the court may, if it thinks fit, allow interest to the person entitled to the debt or damages or to the person making such claim, as the case may be, at a rate not exceeding the current rate of interest, for the whole or part of the following period, that is to say—

if the proceedings relate to a debt payable by virtue of a written instrument at a certain time, then, from the date when the debt is payable to the date of institution of the proceedings;

if the proceedings do not relate to any such debt, then, from the date mentioned in that regard in a written notice given by the person entitled or the person making the claim to the person liable that interest will be claimed, to the date of institution of the proceedings.

14.

Sub-section (3) of Section 3 makes it clear that nothing in Section 3 shall apply in relation to any debt or damages upon which interest is payable as of right, by virtue of any agreement, or any debt or damages upon which payment of interest is barred, by virtue of an express agreement. Clause (a) of Section 2 of the Act defines "court" as including a tribunal and an arbitrator; clause (c) of Section 2 defines "debt" as any liability for an ascertained sum of money and includes a debt payable in kind but does not include a judgment debt; and clause (b) defines "current rate of interest". Sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the Act provides that notwithstanding anything contained in Section 3, interest shall be payable in all cases in which it is payable by virtue of any enactment or other rule of law or usage having the force of law. Sub-section (2) of Section 4 provides that notwithstanding what is stated in Section 3 or Section 4(1) of the Act, in the cases of money deposited as security for performance of an obligation, interest is payable from the date of deposit; and in the case of money payable by virtue of a fiduciary relationship, money/property obtained/retained by fraud and money due as dower/maintenance, interest is payable from the date of cause of action. A claim for interest on the amounts of premium paid, from the respective dates of payment of premium to date of settlement of claim, does not find support from any of the provisions of the Act.

15.

Even assuming that interest can be awarded on grounds of equity, it can be awarded only on the reduced sum to be quantified and paid from the date when it becomes due under the policy (that is on the date of death of the assured) and not from any earlier date. We do not propose to examine the question as to whether interest can be awarded at all, on equitable grounds, in view of the enactment of the Interest Act, 1978 making a significant departure from the old Interest Act (32 of 1839). The present Act does not contain the following provision contained in the proviso to Section 1 of the old Act: "interest shall be payable in all cases in which it is now payable by law". How far the decisions of this Court in Satinder Singh v. Amrao Singh [(1961) 3 SCR 676 : AIR 1961 SC 908] and Hirachand Kothari v. State of Rajasthan [1985 Supp SCC 17] and the decision of the Privy Council in Bengal Nagpur Rly. Co. Ltd. v. Ruttanji Ramji [(1937-38) 65 IA 66 : AIR 1938 PC 67] holding that interest can be awarded on equitable grounds, all rendered with reference to the said proviso to Section 1 of the old Interest Act (Act of 1839), will be useful to interpret the provisions of the new Act (Act of 1978) may require detailed examination in an appropriate case."

13.

Learned counsel for the appellant has also relied on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Alok Shanker Pandey Vs. Union of India & Ors., (2007) 3 SCC 545, and prays for award of 12% interest.

14.

We may point out that in insurance matters the IRDA Regulations regarding Protection of Policy Holders Interest, 2002 provides for payment of interest in case of delay beyond the stipulated 45 days after the settlement of the claim with the rate of interest payable @ 2% above the bank rate.

15.

In matters of medical negligence the Apex Court in the case of Balram Prasad versus Kunal Saha reported in (2014) 1 SCC 384, observed that a rate of 6% would be reasonable and the observation made in paragraph 131 of the said decision is extracted herein under:

'131. Therefore, the National Commission in not awarding interest on the compensation amount from the date of filing of the original complaint up to the date of payment of entire compensation by the appellant doctors and AMRI Hospital to the claimant is most unreasonable and the same is opposed to the provision of the Interest Act, 1978. Therefore, we are awarding the interest on the compensation that is determined by this Court in the appeal filed by the claimant at the rate of 6% per annum on the compensation awarded in these appeals from the date of complaint till the date of payment of compensation awarded by this Court. The justification made by the learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the appellant doctors and AMRI Hospital in not awarding interest on the compensation awarded by the National Commission is contrary to law laid down by this Court and also the provisions of the Interest Act, 1978. Hence, their submissions cannot be accepted as the same are wholly untenable in law and misplaced. Accordingly, the aforesaid point is answered in favour of the claimant."

13.

However, at the same time, we find that the rest of the calculations and the assessment made by the surveyor in the report dated 22.11.2025 appears to be adequate and just. There is no material to contradict the same. Consequently, the contention of the complainant deserves acceptance as the fire had taken place due to short circuit that has been accepted by the surveyor, and therefore once the cause of damage has been confirmed and the stocks have been verified, we do not find any error in the calculations made except for the deduction of salvage as already indicated above.

14.

We therefore modify the impugned order of the State Commission and substitute the award of Rs.12,90,644/- instead of Rs.15,00,000/- as awarded by the State Commission together with 6% simple interest payable from the date of the filing of the complaint. Both the appeals stands disposed off accordingly.