Results
Tribunals and Commissions(2025) 09 ITAT CK 2794

Elan Limited Vs DCIT

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · Delhi · 23 Sept 2025 · Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member · S. Rifaur Rahman, Accountant Member

Open full page

Judgment

11 paragraphs · 896 words

Per Satbeer Singh Godara, Judicial Member:

The instant batch of four appeals invo lves the twin assessee’s here in M/s Elan Ltd . and M/s Elan Buildcon Pvt. Ltd. Both these assessee’s have filed the respective ap peals i.e. ITA No. 759/Del/2025 in assessme nt year 2014-15 and ITA Nos. 773, 771 & 769/Del/2025 in assessment years 2017-18 to 2019-20; against the C IT(A)-24, New De lhi’s DIN & order No. ITBA/APL/M/250/2024-25/1071035168(1), 1070939629(1), 1070970906(1) & 1070978946(1) dated 05.12.2024, 06.12.2024, 09.12.2024, in proce edings u/s 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Inco me Tax Act, 1961 (in short “the Act”), respectively.

2.

Heard both these assessee s as well as the department thro ugh their respective learned representatives. Case files perused.

3.

It tr anspires at the outset that both these assessee’s raise the ir first and foremost id entical substantive ground challenging validity of the impugned section 153C assessme nts itself. There is not dispute betwe en the parties that the learned departmental authorities had carried out the search in question in M/s Elan Group on 29.05.2018. Learned CIT-DR vehemently submits that it w as the said search which led to seizure of the correspond ing incriminating material followed by section 153C satisfaction recorded in the se tw in assessee’s cases on 19.01.2021. That being the case, there would be hardly any quarrel in light of PCIT vs. Jasjit Singh (2024) 336 CTR 634 (Delhi) and PCIT vs. Ojjus Medicare Pvt. Ltd. (2 024) 465 ITR 101 (Del.) that the date of initiation of the search in question s t in an instance of invocation of section 153C(1) 1 proviso co uld be that of record ing of the satisfaction itself which comes to be on 19.01.2021 only.

4.

A perusal of the case records next indicates that the learned Assessing Officer had r ecorded his satisfaction on 19.01.2021 followed by issuance of his notice dated 27.01.2021 to the assessee(s) as follow s:

“I have gone thr ough t he above ment ioned documents and I am satisfied that above me nti oned documents sei zed from the premis es of M/a Elan India Pvt . Ltd., M/s Best Selling R ealty Pvt. Ltd., M/s K & T Realty Service s Pvt. Ltd, Golf view C orporate Tower, 2n d /3r d Fl oor, Golf Course Road, Sector-12, Gurugr am, Haryana-122001 party AP-6 & Ap-6A duri ng the course of sear ch belong to/c ont ain informati on whic h rel ates M/s Elan Ltd. (PAN : AADCE3341G) and have a bearing o n the dete rmi natio n of its t otal income . Hence, noti ce u/s 153C of the Income Tax Act, 1961 is bei ng issue d for A. Ys . 2013-14 to 2018-19 and notic e u/s 143(2) for A. Y. 2019-20.”

5.

Faced with this situation, Mr. Sid hu vehemently argues that the learned asse ssing authority had rightly proceeded against the asse ssee(s) after recording his satisfaction that the seized material in quest ion “belong to/contain information which re lates to M/s Elan Ltd .” His endeavour therefore is to support the above section 153C satisfaction as strictly in tune with the provisio ns of the Act.

6.

We have given our thoughtful consideration to the assessee’s and the Revenue’s foregoing vehement contentions regarding validity of the impugned satisfaction. We find no merit to express our concurrence with the Revenue’s stand herein. We make it clear first of all that the lear ned Assessing Officer had admittedly invo lved both the foregoing statutory expressions “belongs to” as well as “relates to” herein which could not be he ld as a proper satisfactio n in accordance with law. This is for the precise reaso n that the legislature has itself incorporated the foregoing former expression of “belongs to ” as involving “any money, bullion, jewellery...........” etc. in sub-clause (a) and the latter category of “pertains to” or “relates to”; for any books of account or docume nts etc.; respectively. Lear ned CIT-DR couldn’t rebut the clinching fact that the assessing authority’s foregoing satisfaction has used both the above statutory expressions as inter changeab le which is not in accordance with stricter interpretation in light of Commissioner Vs. Dilip Kumar (2018) 9 SSC 1 (SC). This is indeed coupled with the fact that the tribunal’s learned “Third Member” in Prashant Premchand Bafana Vs. Addl. CIT [IT-462-IT AT-2025 (Pine)] has already settled the issue in the assessee’s favour that the above three statutory expressions have to be used in the specified circumstances thus treating them as interchangeable one. We are accordingly of the considered view that given the fact that the instant issue stand settled upto hon’b le Third Member u/s 255(4) of the Act, the impug ned satisfaction herein has not been validly recorded which renders the corresponding assessment(s) herein as not sustainable in law. The same stand quashed in very terms therefore.

7.

Same order to follow in the latter assessee M/s Elan Buildcon Pvt. Ltd. three appeals ITA No . 769, 771 & 773/Del/2025 since involving identical se t of facts/issues.

8.

All other pleadings on merits between the par ties stand rendered acade mic.

9.

To sum up, these twin assessee’ s four appeals ITA Nos. 759, 769, 771 & 773/Del/2025 are allowed in above terms. A copy of this common order be placed in the respective case files.