Results
↑↓
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 10 ITAT CK 5145

Sh. Shashi Kant Chaurasia Vs Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · New Delhi · 29 Oct 2026 · M Balaganesh, Accountant Member · Sudhir Kumar, Judicial Member

Open full page

Judgment

205 paragraphs · 10,372 words

PER SHRI M BALAGANESH, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:

1.

The appeals in the case of Shri Shashi Kant Chaurasia in ITA No.6743/Del/2025 filed by the assessee and ITA 8178/Del/2025 filed by the revenue for AY 2020-21, arise out of the order of the Id. Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-29, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as 'Id. CIT(A)', in short] dated 12.08.2025 against the order of assessment passed u/s 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') dated 30.09.2021 by the Assessing Officer, DCIT, Central Circle-27, New Delhi.

2.

As these are cross appeals they are taken up together and disposed of by this common order for the sake of convenience.

ITA 8178/Del/2025 for AY 2020-21 (revenue appeal)

3.

The only effective issue to be decided in this appeal is as to whether the sale proceeds received on sale of diamonds could be construed as an accommodation entry by treating it as unexplained cash credit, warranting addition u/s 68 of the Act in the facts and circumstances of the instant case. The interconnected issue involved therein is as to whether the ld CIT(A) was justified in confirming the addition on account of alleged commission as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act for the purpose of obtaining accommodation entry in the facts and circumstances of the instant case.

4.

We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. The assessee, Sh. Shashi Kant Chaurasia, is an individual and a resident for tax purposes in India. For the previous year relevant to the assessment year 2020-21, the assessee filed original return of income on 14.02.2021 declaring total income Rs.59,94,49,120. A search and seizure operation was carried out on 15.01.2020 at the premises of the assessee and his family members and also at the farm-house at Delhi. Further, a search and seizure operation was also purportedly carried out on 27.01.2020 at the residence of one third party, viz., Sh. Yogendra Raj Singhvi (hereinafter referred to as ‘Sh. Singhvi’) at his farm-house/ residence at Ajmer, Rajasthan, wherein statement of Sh. Singhvi was recorded under section 132(4) of the Act. Pursuant to the search, the learned assessing officer issued notice under section 153A of the Act dated 15.03.2021 directing the assessee to file return of income for, inter-alia, the impugned assessment year 2020-21. Assessment proceedings under section 153A r.w.s. 143(3) of the Act were completed vide order dated 30.09.2021 assessing the income of the assessee at Rs.69,20,48,370 after making the following additions:-

No.ParticularsSectionAmount
1.Returned Income-59,94,49,120
2.Addition on account of alleged unexplained investment in bullion69A57,35,478
3.Addition qua sale of diamonds and LTCG declared on sale of diamonds derecognized6862,13,03,750
4.Commission expenditure on sale of diamonds @0.18% of sale consideration69C11,18,347
5.Addition on account of bullion and jewellery recovered from premises of Sh Kamal Kishore Chaurasia (on a protective basis)2,05,13,134
6.Assessed Income69,20,48,370
5.

Against the assessment order dated 30.09.2021, the assessee preferred appeal before the learned CIT(A). The learned CIT(A) partly allowed the appeal vide order dated 12.08.2025 wherein the additions pertaining to issues listed in Serial Nos. 3, 4 and 5 above were deleted. However, with regard to Serial No. 2, the learned CIT(A) upheld the addition made by the learned assessing officer. Against the aforesaid order passed by the learned CIT(A), the assessee and the revenue have preferred the captioned appeals.

6.

The assessee along with various members of the Chaurasia family declared rough diamonds in their respective declarations filed under the Income Disclosure Scheme, 2016 (IDS 2016) and taxes due were paid thereon. The declarations were duly accepted by the ld Principal Commissioner of Income Tax and the same attained finality. During the year under consideration, the assessee got the entire rough diamonds of the family processed (cut, polished, etc). The processed diamonds belonging to him and the family members were later sold by the assessee to various diamond merchants as important financial affairs of the family and decisions were majorly handled/taken by the assessee. Accordingly, the assessee and the family members in their respective income tax returns, declared long-term capital gains (LTCG) arising on sale of processed diamonds and paid due taxes thereon. The sale consideration received on sale of processed diamonds were sought to be treated as accommodation entry obtained by the assessee thereby treating the same as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 of the Act, for which purpose, the ld AO sought for the details from the assessee vide issuance of notice u/s 142(1) of the Act from time to time. In response to the said notice, the assessee filed all the requisite details available in its possession to prove the veracity of these sales made by him. The assessee submitted that he had declared diamonds under Income Declaration Scheme, 2016 vide chapter IX of Finance Act, 2016 wherein rough diamonds were declared and by filing a declaration on 13.09.2016 declaring 12857.07 carats of rough diamonds. It was submitted by the assessee that these diamonds were received as gift from grandfather and were held since 1994 and declared as such in IDS 2016 declaration. It was also submitted that this declaration was made based on Valuation Report dated 22.08.2016 from the registered valuer, determining fair market value of diamonds as on 01.06.2016 at Rs. 49,42,79,680. The assessee also submitted that the said Valuation Report was furnished by the registered valuer after physical inspection of the diamonds, which fact is also mentioned in the valuation report. The assessee paid tax of Rs. 22,24,25,856 on the IDS declaration @45% on fair market value of diamonds declared thereon. During the year under consideration, the assessee sold cut/ polished diamonds i.e. processed diamonds and long-term capital gains arising thereon were duly offered to tax in the return. The ld AO doubted the existence of rough diamonds with the assessee per se and proceeded to treat the sale consideration of cut and polished diamonds as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 of the Act by making the following observations and allegations:-

“a)

The assessee and his family members failed to establish the source of acquisition and existence of diamonds, which were processed and thereafter sold, gains in respect of which was declared in the return of income;

b)

The assessee was unable to establish/corroborate that diamonds were actually processed [cut, polished etc.] in so far as :

i.

There was no proof of payment made to vendor/job-worker to process diamonds;

ii.

No details were furnished with respect to color, cut, clarity of the diamonds ; and

iii.

Identity and genuineness of vendors/job-workers remained to be established.

c)

The assessee was unable to establish / corroborate the transaction of sale of processed diamonds in so far as:

i.

in the ex-parte statements of Sh. Singhvi and one Sh. Nemi Chand Kawadia (in short “Sh.Kawadia”), it was alleged that the assessee had undertaken bogus transactions;

ii.

the assessee failed to establish the identity and genuineness of the buyers and such parties did not appear to be financially credible.

9.

Since the receipt of sale consideration of diamonds was treated as bogus by the ld AO by adding it u/s 68 of the Act, consequentially the ld AO also added commission expenditure @ 0.18% of sale consideration u/s 69C of the Act.”

7.

We find that the issue in dispute was subject matter of consideration by this Tribunal in assessee’s own case for AYs. 2018-19 and 2019-20 in ITA Nos. 3844 and 3845/Del/2023 dated 20.01.2025 where in the Tribunal granted relief to the assessee. The relevant operative portion of the Tribunal order dated 20.01.2025 reproduce here under:-

“11.

The ld AR filed detailed written submissions before us and he drew our attention to the various facets covered thereon and rebutted the entire allegations of the lower authorities by facts and figures. Per Contra, the ld DR submitted that the ld CITA never held that the gains on sale of diamonds to be LTCG or STCG and that the ld CITA had merely commented about the declaration made by the assessee in IDS 2016 and the same cannot be considered as sacrosanct. The ld DR submitted that the sale of diamonds (as claimed by the assessee) was never proved by the assessee before the lower authorities. He argued that the ld AO had relied on certain whatsapp chats of Sh Singhvi which are in pages 57 to 60 of the assessment order and that assessee had not proved the relationship with him and Sh Singhvi and further the customers to whom the sale of diamonds were made by the assessee were also not proved to be genuine. With these arguments, the ld DR heavily defended the orders of the lower authorities.

12.

At the outset, we hold that the existence of rough diamonds with the assessee cannot be doubted at all as admittedly the assessee had made declaration fo 12857.07 carats of diamonds in IDS 2016 and a certificate in Form NO. 4 dated 7.10.2017 was issued by the ld PCIT admitting the same after ensuring that the assessee had paid due tax thereon in the sum of Rs 22,24,25,856/-. This Certificate in Form No. 4 is enclosed in Page 18 of the Paper Book. Either way, dehors the IDS 2016, it is a fact that the rough diamonds of 12857.07 carats of rough diamonds had been brought into the books by the assessee after making payment of taxes of Rs 22,24,25,856/-.

13.

We hold that the statutory scheme of IDS declaration enacted by the Finance Act 2016 considered along with all subsequent clarifications (such as CBDT Circular No. 26 dt 30.6.2016, CBDT Circular No. 29 dt 18.8.2016 and Press Release dated 2.9.2016) clearly provides that IDS declaration is to be treated as conclusive proof of matters contained therein and binding on all the parties including the regulatory authorities. Hence the existence of rough diamonds to the extent of 12857.07 carats cannot be doubted by the revenue. If it is doubted, then the purpose of making payment of taxes of Rs 22.24 crores gets defeated. We hold that that IDS 2016 declaration cannot be doubted by the revenue in the light of sovereign commitment given by the Government of India. Further the observation of ld CITA that diamonds were not declared in earlier income tax or wealth tax returns by the assessee is absurd in view of the fact that the assessee had made the declaration of undisclosed asset under IDS 2016 and the same has been accepted by the ld PCIT by issuing Form No. 4 thereon. If the diamonds had earlier been declared in any tax returns, then why the assessee would even come forward to declare the same in IDS 2016. This argument of the revenue is simply absurd and only indicates the pre-determined mind in order to reach the pre-determined destination of taxing the receipt of sale consideration by any means whatsoever.

14.

It is a fact that assessee had got the rough diamonds processed by cutting , polishing etc from following 4 job workers in Surat which resulted in 2231.12 carats of processed diamonds:-

(i)

Rujal Anil Shah (HUF) – Prop. Aarushi Gems

(ii)

Nareshbhai Babulal Dhami (HUF) – Prop. Beena Impex

(iii)

Adesh Nareshbhai Dhami (HUF) – Prop. Niti Impex

(iv)

Nikunj N Kahar – Prop. Misty Enterprises

15.

The fact that processing of rough diamonds were undertaken by the assessee in assessment year 2017-18 is duly borne out of the invoices in support of the payments made to the job- workers, confirmations filed by the job workers along with their respective ITRs, proof of actual payments made to the job-workers as reflected in the bank statement of the assessee. These documents were duly furnished by the assessee before the lower authorities which fact is not in dispute.

16.

It is submitted that substantial portion of the processed diamonds were sold by the assessee for a total consideration of Rs.154,95,82,050/- in the relevant assessment year 2018-19 to the following four (4) parties:-

(i)

Bhairav Gems Pvt. Ltd.

(ii)

Garima Exports

(iii)

Gurudev Corporation

(iv)

Yogi Diam

The long-term capital gains of Rs.144,61,64,063/- arising on account thereof was duly offered to tax in the return of income. The ld AR even placed on record the sale of processed diamonds made by the assessee in subsequent assessment years 2019-20 to 2020-21 and the assessee received total consideration of Rs.323,30,50,550/- on sale of diamonds in assessment years 2018-19 to 2020-21. The details of LTCG tax paid on sale of those diamonds are tabulated hereunder:-

Assessment yearSale Amount (Rs.)Taxable LTCG (Rs.)Tax paid on LTCG (Rs.)
2018-19154,95,82,050144,46,86,07534,22,46,131
2019-20106,21,64,75097,80,50,62323,39,49,709
2020-2162,13,03,75055,60,81,45615,84,60,972
Total(Rs.)323,30,50,550297,88,18,15473,46,56,812
17.

Further we find that the assessee had substantiated the genuineness of sales made to 4 parties by furnishing the sale invoices, confirmations directly filed by the parties before the ld AO along with their respective ledger accounts, stock register, bank statements evidencing the credit on account of receipt of sale consideration, ITRs etc .

18.

It is pertinent to note that assessee had acquired the rough diamonds by way of gift from grandfather and that the diamonds (both rough as well as processed diamonds), were always kept in lockers maintained by the assessee and other family members for safe keeping and this fact has categorically been affirmed/ confirmed by all the family members and the assessee in their respective statements:-

- Relevant extracts of statement of the assessee dt. 15.01.2020 is enclosed in Pages 739 to 765 of Paper Book;

- Relevant extracts of statement of Sh. Mayank Chaurasia dt. 15.01.2020 is enclosed in Pages 857 to 867 of Paper Book;

- Relevant extracts of statement of Sh. Navneet Chaurasia dt .15.01.2020 is enclosed in Pages 815 to 833 of Paper Book;

- Relevant extracts of statement of Sh. Rajiv Chaurasia dt. 16.01.2020 is enclosed in Pages 896 to 904 of Paper Book;

- Relevant extracts of statement of Sh. Vijay Anand Chaurasia dt. 15.01.2020 is enclosed in Pages 868 to 879 of Paper Book.

19.

We find that all the family members, in their separate statements, categorically and consistently confirmed the following fundamental facts, without any contradiction:-

(a)

That they were in possession of diamonds, which was inherited by them;

(b)

That the diamonds were declared under IDS 2016 and tax paid thereon;

(c)

That the diamonds were cut/ polished;

(d)

That the polished diamonds were sold resulting in taxable long-term capital gains, which were declared in the tax returns.

20.

Now coming to the statement of Sh Kamla Kant Chaurasia , we find that the ld AO, in the impugned assessment order, has sought to draw adverse inference in respect of the very existence of the diamonds by placing reliance on statement dated 16.01.2020, of Sh. Kamla Kant Chaurasia (father of assessee) wherein he purportedly stated that he was not aware of the diamonds. The ld AR before us submitted that the aforesaid statement of Sh. Kamla Kant Chaurasia cannot be the basis for disputing the transactions due to the following reasons:-

He was non-resident for many years;

At the time of recording of statement, due to his old age coupled with ill-health and fading memory, was not in a position to recollect the facts correctly in respect of inheritance of diamonds;

He did not receive the diamonds from his father and therefore, was not necessarily required to be aware of distribution by his father to other family members;

His statement was subsequently clarified by him vide certificate dated 25.09.2021 which is enclosed in Pages 946 to 947 of the Paper Book;

The assessee was primarily in charge of managing the day-to-day financial affairs of the family and was solely involved in processing the rough diamonds and sale of cut and polished diamonds;

Other members of Chaurasia family in their respective statements recorded during search have confirmed the aforesaid facts.

21.

In fact, findings of ld CIT(A) are self-contradictory as initially the existence of diamonds has been accepted and sale transaction also accepted to be genuine by holding that the gains accruing on sale of diamonds should be treated as short term gains, but thereafter proceeds on a completely different premise to hold, without any cogent/ reliable basis, the same to be a bogus transaction. We are in complete agreement with this argument of the ld AR that the statement of Shri Kamla Kant Chaurasia is not to be relied upon in the facts of the instant case as it is contrary to the cogent evidences placed on record by the assessee.

22.

We find that the expenditure in respect of cutting and polishing of diamonds was undertaken by the assessee in the immediately preceding assessment year 2017-18, wherein no adverse inference has been drawn by the ld AO. What was declared by the assessee in IDS 2016 was only rough diamonds. Hence the said diamonds are to be processed in order to fetch better pricing in the market, thereby making the processing of diamonds imperative . Moreover, the price of diamonds is dependent upon its various features, size, colour, clarity grading , fineness/ cutting shape etc. It is a fact that processing of rough diamonds into cut and polished diamonds was undertaken by the assessee through various parties, which details in comprehensive manner were duly furnished by the assessee as under:-

- Complete details of parties including contact particulars of the job workers;

- Ledger accounts of the job-workers enlisting the expenses and payments;

- Copies of invoices issued by the job-workers;

- Copies of bank statements of the assessee highlighting the payments made to the job-workers – entire payment was made through banking channels.

23.

The details of contemporaneous documents filed by the assessee party wise in respect of 4 job workers for Assessment Year 2018-19 are as under:-

(i)

AarushiGems:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Page 237 of Paper Book

Copy of bill/invoice & inspection memo enclosed in Pages 238 to 239 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statements from which payment was made enclosed in Page 240 of Paper Book

Copy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing details of nature of business, address, transaction details with assessee and copy of ITRs enclosed in Pages 241 to 246 of Paper Book

(ii)

Beena Impex:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Page 247 of Paper Book

Copy of bills/invoices & inspection memo enclosed in Pages 248 to 251 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statements from where the payments were made enclosed in Page 252 of Paper Book

Copy of clarification dated 26.09.2021 along with acknowledgment filed in support of change of address of Niti Impex and Beena Impex enclosed in Pages 253 to 264 of Paper Book

Copy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing details of nature of business, address, transaction details with assessee and copy of ITRs enclosed in Pages 265 to 270 of Paper Book

Copy of letter dated 26.09.2021 filed by the assessee who apprised the ld AO that due to dilapidated conditions of the building, the office of Beena Impex had shifted , details of which are enclosed in Pages 983 to 993 of Paper Book

(iii)

NitiImpex:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Page 271 of Paper Book

Copy of bill/invoice & inspection memo enclosed in Pages 272 to 273 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statements from which payment was made enclosed in Page 274 of Paper Book

Copy of clarification dated 26.09.2021 along with acknowledgement filed in support of change of address of Niti Impex and Beena Impex enclosed in Pages 275 to 276 of Paper Book

Copy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing details of nature of business, address, transaction details with assessee and copy of ITRs enclosed in Pages 287 to 292 of Paper Book

Copy of letter dated 26.09.2021 filed by the assessee who apprised the ld AO that due to dilapidated conditions of the building the office of Niti Impex had shifted – enclosed in Pages 983 to 993 of Paper Book.

(iv)

Misty Enterprise:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Page 293 of Paper Book

Copy of bills/invoices& inspection memo enclosed in Pages 294 to 297 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statements from where the payments were made – enclosed in Pages 298 to 299 of the Paper Book

Copy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing details of nature of business, transaction details with assessee and copy of ITRs enclosed in Pages 300 to 301 of Paper Book.

24.

In so far as the specific allegations of the ld AO in respect of processing of diamonds are concerned, the same was rebutted by the ld AR as under:-

(a)

Allegation that the assessee failed to provide any details in respect of communication made with the parties who undertook cutting and polishing work done.

It was submitted that the transaction took place in the Assessment Year 2017-18 i.e more than 3 to 4 years before the search was undertaken and the assessee could not have been expected to retain the communication trail with the said parties. Further, communication by way of telephone calls, text messages and personal meetings cannot practically be documented as expected by the ld AO. Further, the assessee has provided all documents in support of the transaction in the form of copies of invoice, ledgers and payment trail to corroborate the genuineness of the transaction.

(b)

Allegation that the assessee failed to provide copy of bank statement in support of the payment trail.

The aforesaid allegation is factually incorrect. It was emphatically submitted that the assessee had, vide submissions filed on various dates before the ld AO, duly furnished copy of bank statements wherein the payments made to the job workers was specifically covered as stated hereinabove.

(c)

Allegation that the assessee did not even recollect the names of the job workers in so far as the name of the parties stated during the course of statement was different from the details file during the course of assessment.

It was submitted that as already explained above, the transaction was undertaken more than 3-4 years ago and the assessee could not have been expected to accurately remember names of all the parties, more so when he transacts with various persons day in and day out. It is of utmost importance to note that to verify the identity and genuineness of the job- workers, the ld AO independently issued notices u/s 133(6) of the Act to the said parties, which, as a matter of fact, was duly responded to by the said parties confirming that they undertook job work in the nature of cutting, polishing of diamonds in the financial year 2016-17.

(d)

At pages 29-31 of the assessment order, the ld AO has made reference to Inspectors’ report to allege that the three job workers namely: (i) Aarushi Gems, (ii) Niti Impex, and (iii) Beena Impex never existed at the stated premises.

In this regard it was submitted that only limited extracts of the ex-parte Inspector’s report have been reproduced in the assessment order and copy of the same has never been provided to the assessee till date, which was in gross violation of principles of natural justice, and the assessee is, therefore, unable to provide an effective rebuttal to the same. Even otherwise, factual rebuttal to the aforesaid allegation is specifically provided at Pages 1076 to 1156 of Paper Book, being the detailed submission filed before the ld CITA.

25.

It is pertinent to note here that notices issued by the ld AO u/s 133(6) of the Act were not only served but also responded to by the job workers directly before the ld AO leaving no scope for any doubt at all that the parties actually exist and had undertaken the job of cutting and polishing of diamonds. Hence the existence of rough diamonds with the assessee together with the activity of processing of rough diamonds into cut and polished diamonds is proved beyond reasonable doubt by the assessee herein.

26.

We find that the ld AO had also alleged that the transaction of sale of diamonds is also not genuine. We are unable to comprehend ourselves to accept to this allegation of the revenue in as much as the the customers to whom cut and polished diamonds were sold by the assessee had directly responded before the ld AO by furnishing direct replies / evidences in response to notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act confirming and submitting the following:-

(i)

having purchased diamonds from the assessee; (ii) ledger accounts and information with respect to quantity and weight of diamond purchased ;

(iii)

stock register along with relevant extract of stock register; (iv) party-wise purchase and sale register (including PAN and address of the party);

(v)

detailed list of sundry debtors through whom funds were received for the purchase of diamonds along with bank statement and GST return (GSTR – 1);

(vi)

copy of ITR, computation of income, Tax Audit Report, audited financial statements along with copy of income tax returns; (vii) bank statements of accounts from where payments were made to the assessee; (viii) ledger account of parties to whom the diamonds were sold after purchasing them from the assessee along with their PAN and address.

27.

The details of contemporaneous documents filed party wise in respect of sales made by the assessee during the year under consideration are as under:-

(i)

Garima Exports:Copy of ledger account enclosed in Page 302 of Paper BookCopy of purchase confirmation enclosed in Page 303 of Paper BookCopy of bank statement in which the sale proceeds were received enclosed in Page 304 of Paper BookCopies of KYC and business profile of the parties enclosed in Pages 305 to 309 of Paper BookDetails of Permanent Account Number (PAN) enclosed in Page 310 of Paper BookDetails of Aadhaar card enclosed in Page 311 of Paper BookCopy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing copy of ledger accounts, transaction details, stock register, bank statement, financial statements, GST return, ITR, Ledger account of parties to whom the diamonds were sold after purchasing them from the assessee along with their PAN and address etc enclosed in Pages 319 to 417 of Paper Book.

(ii)

Gurudev Corp.:Copy of ledger account enclosed in Pages 418 to 422 of Paper BookCopy of purchase confirmation enclosed in Pages 423 to 449 of Paper BookCopy of bank statement in which the sale proceeds were received enclosed in Pages 450 to 462 of Paper BookCopies of KYC and business profile of the parties enclosed in Pages 463 to 467 of Paper BookDetails of PAN enclosed in Page 468 of Paper BookCopy of Aadhar card enclosed in Page 469 of Paper BookCopy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing copy of ledger accounts, transaction details, stock register, bank statement, financial statements, GST return, ITR etc enclosed in Pages 470 to 589 of Paper Book.

(iii)

Yogi Diam:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Pages 590 to 591 of Paper Book

Copy of purchase confirmation enclosed in Pages 592 to 597 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statement in which the sale proceeds were received enclosed in Pages 598 to 603 of Paper Book

Copies of KYC and business profile of the parties enclosed in Pages 604 to 607 of Paper Book

Details of PAN enclosed in Page 608 of Paper Book

Copy of Aadhar card enclosed in Page 609 of Paper Book

Copy of response filed by the party to notice issued u/s 133(6) (received under RTI) of the Act – providing copy of ledger accounts, transaction details, stock register, bank statement, financial statements, GST return, ITR etc enclosed in Pages 610 to 686 of Paper Book.

(iv)

Bhairav Gems:

Copy of ledger account enclosed in Pages 687 to 691 of Paper Book

Copy of purchase confirmation enclosed in Pages 692 to 718 of Paper Book

Copy of bank statement in which the sale proceeds were received enclosed in Pages 719 to 729 of Paper Book

Copies of KYC and business profile of the parties enclosed in Pages 730 to 734 of Paper Book

Details of PAN enclosed in Pages 735 to 736 of Paper Book

Copy of passport enclosed in Page 737 of Paper Book

Copy of Aadhar card enclosed in Page 738 of Paper Book

28.

We find that the sale of diamonds made by the assessee to the aforesaid customers cannot be even remotely doubted in as much as those parties had directly responded to the notice issued u/s 133(6) of the Act by furnishing the contemporaneous documentary evidences as listed above. It is not the case of the revenue that the parties to whom the assessee had made sales are related to him in any manner whatsoever. Hence they are independent third parties and transactions were carried out with them at arm’s length in the ordinary course of business. The assessee need not ascertain the financial capacities of these customers as he had not borrowed any loan or not received any share capital / premium from them. On the contrary, the assessee’s interest would be only to receive the sale proceeds of diamonds from the said parties for the sales effected to them.

29.

From the above, it could be seen that the existence of rough diamonds with the assessee together with the activity of processing of rough diamonds into cut and polished diamonds and sale of those cut and polished diamonds to third party customers is proved beyond reasonable doubt by the assessee herein.

30.

With regard to the search action conducted in the premises of Sh. Singhvi on 27.1.2020 and one Sh. Kawadia on 3.3.2020 wherein statements were recorded from them u/s 132(4) of the Act, the ld AO had sought to draw adverse inference on the assessee herein merely by placing reliance on the said statements, despite the fact that there is no data / document seized from them which in an way directly or indirectly incriminates the assessee herein. Infact Sh. Singhvi , a third party, had merely stated that he knew the assessee as an acquaintance in certain social gatherings and had no financial transactions with assessee. Further the ld AR pointed out that statement of Sh. Singhvi was recorded on 27.1.2020 during the course of search under duress / pressure and his only daughter’s wedding was scheduled on 30.1.2020 and hence in order to complete the search proceedings, he at the end of his statement had stated that all transactions are bogus. But we find that soon after the marriage ceremonies were completed, Sh. Singhvi on 4.2.2020 itself i.e. within one week from the date of search, had retracted his statement clearly explaining the reasons and circumstances under which the said statement was recorded. This retraction statement is enclosed in Pages 155 to 161 of the Paper Book.

31.

Similarly even the statement of Sh. Kawadia who also gave statement u/s 132(4) of the Act during his search stating that the transactions are bogus, had retracted vide letter dated 9.2.2021 which is enclosed in Pages 231 to 234 of the Paper Book.

32.

Hence it could be safely concluded that no reliance in any manner whatsoever , could be placed on the statements of Sh. Singhvi and Sh. Kawadia to draw adverse inference against the assessee herein. In any event, the revenue had not even bothered to verify as to whether there was any financial transactions between the assessee and Sh. Singhvi and Sh. Kawadia. Factually there is none. This was not controverted by the revenue. On the contrary, the assessee was confronted with the selective portion of the statements recorded u/s 132(4) of the Act of Sh. Singhvi and Sh. Kawadia . Assessee sought for furnishing of complete copy of the statements recorded from these two parties, which was denied. Even the cross – examination of these two parties which were sought for by the assessee. The ld AO fixed the date of cross examination of these two parties on 20.9.2021 without furnishing the full text of the statements recorded from them, on which date, the assesee’s authorized representative was present and both the parties failed to appear before the ld AO. Hence these two parties, having become department’s witnesses, failed to appear for cross-examination before the ld AO. Again on 21.9.2021, the assessee requested the ld AO to provide cross examination of these two parties after providing legible copy of statements recorded from them. Again another request was made by the assessee on 26.9.2021. Copies of the statements were provided to the assessee only on 10.11.2021 at the fag end of completion of assessment proceedings. The ld AO however mentioned that no further opportunity to cross-examine the above-named witnesses will be provided stating that the assessee had failed to avail the opportunity of cross-examination and due to time- barring nature of the matter. We have already dealt this aspect hereinabove that those two parties, being department’s witnesses, had failed to appear for cross examination on the appointed dates before the ld AO and no fault could be attributed on the part of the assessee thereon. Despite that fact, the ld AO had stated that cross-examination will not be provided to the assessee. For this reason also, no reliance in any manner whatsoever could be placed on the statements of these two parties. In view of this fact, we hold that there is absolutely no need to give any credence to the statements recorded from these two parties and no adverse inference in any manner whatsoever could be drawn on the assessee herein , using those statements. Accordingly, the various other arguments advanced by the ld AR and ld DR before us about the veracity of the contents in the statements of these two parties, need not be gone into.

33.

As stated hereinabove, the existence of rough diamonds, processing of rough diamonds into cut and polished diamonds and sale of cut and polished diamonds had been proved by the assessee beyond reasonable doubt with contemporaneous documents in the instant case. The assessee had declared the gains arising on sale of diamonds as LTCG in the return of income. The ld CITA vide para 7.12 at page 31 of impugned order dated 31.10.2023, contrary to the primary allegation of doubting the very existence of diamonds, concluded that since the said diamonds were declared by the assessee under IDS 2016, the period of holding of such diamonds needs to be construed from 01.06.2016 and not from the actual date of their acquisition. While holding so, the ld CITA relied upon CBDT Circular No. 29 of 2016 dated 18.08.2016 read with subsequent clarification dated 19.08.2016. Accordingly, the ld CITA observed that capital gains arising on sale of the diamonds should be classified as ‘short term capital gains’ instead of ‘long term capital gains’ as declared by the assessee in his return of income.

34.

The aforesaid conclusion of ld CITA is self-contradictory, completely misplaced, illegal and arbitrary as the same operates in contravention to Explanation 1(i)(b) of section 2(42A) of the Act which specifically provides that in case of assets acquired by way of gift, the period of holding shall include the period for which such assets were held by the previous owner. Since in the present case, the diamonds were gifted to the assessee by his grandfather in the previous year relevant to assessment year 1994-95, while computing capital gains, the period of holding should be construed accordingly. Thus, such diamonds shall fall within the definition of ‘long term capital assets’ and consequently, ‘long term capital gains’ shall arise on their transfer. We find that the ld CITA had relied on CBDT Circulars referred supra to treat the gains arising on sale of diamonds as short term capital gains. In this regard, we find that the Circulars had taken oscillating positions with regard to the period of holding of assets which works contradictory to the existing provisions of the Act itself. Hence the provisions of the Act would prevail. The Explanation 1(i)(b) of Section 2(42A) of the Act clearly lays down the law regarding the period of holding of assets. Hence there is no need to place reliance on Circulars for this purpose. Either way, the Circulars are binding only on the revenue authorities and the same is not binding on the Tribunal. Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Commissioner of Customs vs Indian Oil Corporation Ltd reported in 267 ITR 272 (SC). The date of 1.6.2016 would be relevant only for the limited purpose of valuation of undisclosed assets irrespective of the period of holding of the same. That date cannot be considered as a relevant date for the purpose of reckoning the period of holding of assets. Hence we hold that the period of holding of diamonds need to be reckoned from Assessment Year 1994-95 in terms of provisions of the Act and accordingly the resultant gain on sale of diamonds would have to construed only as Long Term Capital Gains in the facts and circumstances of the instant case.

35.

In view of the aforesaid observations, we hold that the gains on sale of cut and polished diamonds is to be construed as LTCG which had already been offered to tax by the assessee in the return of income and the same cannot be treated as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 of the Act in the facts and circumstances of the instant case. Accordingly, the Ground Nos. 2 to 2.2. raised by the assessee are allowed.

36.

In view of our decision for Ground Nos. 2 to 2.2. above, the Ground No.3 raised by the assessee requires to be allowed as there is no question of treating the sale proceeds of diamonds as accommodation entries warranting incurrence of commission expenditure. Accordingly, the Ground No. 3 raised by the assessee is allowed.”

8.

We find from the perusal of the order of the ld CIT(A) that the ld CIT(A) had relied on the aforesaid order of the tribunal and granted relief to the assessee. Hence, we do not find any infirmity in the order of the ld CIT(A) in this regard. Accordingly, the grounds raised by the revenue are hereby dismissed.

9.

In the result, the appeal of the revenue in ITA No. 8178/Del/2025 for AY 2020-21 is dismissed.

ITA No. 6743/Del/2025 for AY 2020-21 (assessee’s appeal) – Shri Shashi Kant Chaurasia

10.

Ground Nos. 2 to 2.1 raised by the assessee were stated to be not pressed by the ld AR at the time of hearing. Hence, the same is hereby dismissed as not pressed by reckoning the same to be a statement made from the Bar by the ld AR.

11.

The only issue to be decided in this appeal is as to whether the ld CIT(A) was justified in confirming the addition on account of alleged unexplained investment in bullion amounting to Rs. 57,45,478 u/s 69A of the Act in the facts and circumstances of the instant case.

12.

We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. During the course of search operation, bullion weighing 1422.50 grams was seized from the office premises situated at B-71, Chaurasia House, Paschimi Marg, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi. The statement of Shri Saurabh Srivastava, Sr. Manager, was recorded on oath. He was asked to explain the source of gold bullions weighing 1422.50 grams. In response, he stated that the bullions were given to him by assessee and Shri Navneet Chaurasia. The assessee based on this 3rd party statement, was confronted by the ld AO to explain the source of acquisition of gold bullion weighing 1422.50 grams and show cause as to why the same should not be added as unexplained money u/s 69A of the Act. The assessee responded that gold bullion weighing 1422.50 grams, which was found at the time of search belongs to Sri Rajiv Chaurasia, which was out of gold, jewellery, bullions and diamonds declared by him in his ITR for AY 2019-20. The assessee also provided the statement giving breakup of jewellery as per Schedule AL of the ITR of various family members to justify his stand. The ld AO, however, disregarded this contention of the assessee on the ground that the assessee did not furnish the valuation report for bullion in this regard. The ld AO noted that jewellery and gold in respect of Shri Rajiv Chaurasia is provided in respect of premises at B-56, Paschimi Marg, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi whereas, the explanation given by the assessee states that bullion seized from premises at B-71, Chaurasia House, Paschimi Mark, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi belongs to Shri Rajiv Chaurasia. This explanation was accordingly not accepted. The ld AO further, heavily relied on the statement of Shri Saurabh Srivastava, Sr. Manager, who was present at the premises at the time of search, who had categorically stated that the bullions were given to Shri Saurabh Srivastava by the assessee and Shri Navneet Chaurasia. Accordingly, the ld AO disbelieved the entire contentions of the assessee and proceeded to add the bullion weighing 1422.50 grams valued at Rs. 57,45,478 as unexplained money u/s 69A of the Act.

13.

The assessee furnished detailed reply before the ld AO on 11.09.2021 wherein it was specifically stated that the bullion weighing 1422.50 grams belongs to Shri Rajiv Chaurasia who in turn had declared the same in his ITR for AY 2019-20. It was also pointed out that Shri Rajiv Chaurasia had also made declaration in IDS 2016 stating that he had jewellery right from AY 1994-95 to the extent of 150 standard gold bars of 1 KG each, having purity of 0.995 weighing 150 KGs. The income tax return of Shri Rajiv Chaurasia for AY 2017-18 had been duly placed on record by the assessee. The bullion had been duly disclosed by the by Shri Rajiv Chaurasia for AY 2017-18 in Schedule AL (i.e. assets and liabilities at the end of the year in ITR) at Rs. 31,27,55,447. The ld AR drew over attention to page number 76 to 79 of the paperbook containing the computation of total income of Shri Rajiv Chaurasia for AY 2017-18 which also included computation of long-term capital gains, from which it is noticed that 147 kgs had been sold out of 150 kgs disclosed in IDS, 2016 and remaining 3 kgs were retained by Shri Rajiv Chaurasia and which is also disclosed in the ITR filed for AY 2019-20. Further, it was submitted that both Shri Rajiv Chaurasia and the assessee were not present in the office premises at B-71 – Paschimi Marg, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi at the time of search on 15.01.2020.

14.

During the course of assessment proceedings, a confirmation of Shri Rajiv Chaurasia was filed who owned the said bullion weighing 1422.50 grams and also mentioned that it was part of the declaration made by him under IDS, 2016. In fact, the confirmation was also given by Shri Rajiv Chaurasia on 01.02.2021 before the Deputy Director of Income Tax (Investigation), Unit-7(3), New Delhi weighing 1422.50 grams, which were seized from the premises of B-71, Paschimi Marg, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi seeking release of the same against furnishing of bank guarantee. Shri Rajiv Chaurasia in the said letter filed before Investigation Wing had come forward to furnish bank guarantee for Rs. 60 lakhs in favour of the Income Tax Department for release of seized bullion weighing 1422.50 grams. It was also submitted that no addition has been made in the hands of Sri Rajiv Chaurasia indeed search assessment framed u/s 153C dated 30.03.2023 for AY 2020-21.

15.

The aforesaid explanation coupled with confirmation of Shri Rajiv Chaurasia clearly established that no part of gold bullion being 1422.50 grams could be added in the case of the assessee as Shri Rajiv Chaurasia had come forward to own up the said gold bullion weighing 1422.50 grams immediately after the search before the Investigation Wing and had also filed a letter before the Investigation Wing, seeking release of the seized bullion weighing 1422.20 by agreeing to furnish bank guarantee for Rs. 60 lakhs being equivalent value of gold bullion of 1422.50 grams. Further, Shri Rajiv Chaurasia had also filed confirmation before the ld AO owning up the gold bullion weighing 1422.50 gms which were seized from the premises B-71 – Paschimi Marg, Vasant Vihar, New Delhi. In addition to this, Shri Rajiv Chaurasia had also come forward to state that the said gold bullion weighing 1422.50 grams were out of the gold, bullion and diamonds, declared by him in IDS,2016. These explanations cannot be disregarded as they are supported by contemporaneous documentary evidences which are already available in the records of the Income Tax Department at various stages. Hence, we have no hesitation to delete the addition made on account of unexplained jewellery u/s 69A of the Act in the sum of Rs. 57,45,478 equivalent to seized gold bullion weighing 1422.50 grams in the hands of the assessee. Accordingly, the Ground Nos. 1 to 1.1 raised by the assessee are allowed.

16.

In view of the decision for Ground Nos. 1 to 1.1 above the adjudication of Ground No.1.2 raised by the assessee becomes academic in nature.

17.

In the result, the appeal of the assessee in ITA No. 6743/Del/2025 for AY 2020-21 is partly allowed.

ITA No. 8449/Del/2025 for AY 2018-19 (Vijay Anand Chaurasia)(Revenue’s appeal)

18.

At the outset, we find that there is a delay in filing of appeal by the revenue before us by 16 days. Considering the reason adduced in the condonation petition, we hold that as the revenue was prevented from sufficient cause in not filing the appeal in time before us. Accordingly, in the interest of substantial justice, we are inclined to condone the delay and admit the appeal of the revenue for adjudication.

19.

The Grounds raised by the revenue in this appeal are identical to those raised in the case of Shashi Kant Chaurasia in ITA No. 8178/Del/2025 for AY 2020-21, hence the decision rendered by us hereinabove shall apply mutatis mutandis for this assessee and for this AY also except with variance in figures in view of identical facts.

20.

In the result, the appeal of the revenue in ITA No. 8449/Del/2025 is dismissed.

ITA No. 5817Del/2025(Assessee’s appeal)

21.

The additional grounds raised by the assessee, were challenging the validity of issuance of notice u/s 143(2) of the Act, were stated to be not pressed by the ld AR at the time of hearing. The same is reckoned as a statement made from the Bar. Accordingly, the additional grounds are not even admitted herein.

22.

The Ground Nos. 2.2 to 2.3 raised by the assessee were stated to be not pressed by the ld AR. The same is reckoned as a statement made from the Bar and accordingly Ground Nos. 2.2 and 2.3 raised by the assessee are hereby dismissed as not pressed.

23.

The Ground No. 1 raised by the assessee is general in nature.

24.

The Ground Nos. 2 and 2.1 raised by the assessee are challenging the validity of assumption of jurisdiction u/s 153C of the Act and consequential framing of assessment order u/s 153C of the Act. This goes to the root of the matter and hence we deem it fit to address the same first.

25.

We have heard the rival submissions and perused the materials available on record. The return of income for the AY 2018-19 was originally filed by the assessee on 31-08-2018 declaring total income of Rs. 92,23,11,860. Subsequently, based on search carried out in Kamla Pasand (KP) group of cases, assessment proceedings under section 153C/ 143(3) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 ('the Act') were initiated in the assessee's case, inter alia, for 2018-19 vide notice dated 27.03.2022. The said proceedings culminated vide assessment order dated 30.03.2023 under section 153C r.w.s. 143(3) of the Act wherein the following additions were made to assessee's returned income:-

No.ParticularsSectionAmount
1.Returned Income92,23,11,860
2.Addition on account of alleged unexplained travel expenditure69C25,32,878
3.Addition qua sale of diamonds and LTCG declared on sale of diamonds derecognized6896,31,21,350
4.Commission expenditure on sale of diamonds @0.18% of sale consideration69C17,33,618
5.Assessed Income100,04,21,120
26.

One of the facets of the argument of the ld AR in support of invalid assumption of jurisdiction by the ld AO was recording of consolidated satisfaction note by the ld AO for AYs 2014-15 to 2019-20 dated 20.04.2022. The said satisfaction note is enclosed in pages 19 to 38 of the paper book.

27.

It is not in dispute that the learned AO of the searched person had recorded consolidated satisfaction note for initiating proceedings under section 153C of the Act qua the Assessee herein for the assessment Years 2014-15 to 2019-20 as evident from the satisfaction note enclosed in Pages 19 to 38 of the paper book. Whether recording of consolidated satisfaction note for various assessment years would prove fatal to the assumption of jurisdiction of the learned AO and consequential framing of assessments under section 153C of the Act was subject matter of consideration by the Hon’ble Karnataka High Court in the case of DCIT vs Sunil Kumar Sharma reported in 159 taxmann.com 179 (Karnataka) dated 22-1-2024, wherein it was held as under:-

53.

Further, satisfaction note is required to be recorded under section 153C of the IT Act for each Assessment Year and in the impugned proceedings, a consolidated satisfaction note has been recorded for different Assessment Years, which also vitiates the entire assessment proceedings. In view of all these findings, it is said that the appeals do not have any substance for seeking intervention as sought for by the appellant/Revenue.

28.

We find that the Special Leave Petition filed by the revenue before the Hon’ble Supreme Court against the aforesaid judgement was dismissed which is reported in 165 taxmann.com 846 (SC). The relevant portion of the Head Notes and the order of Hon’ble Apex Court is reproduced hereunder:-

Section 153C, read with sections 132, 153 and 153A, of the Income-tax Act, 1961 -Search and seizure - Assessment of any other persons (General principles) -Assessment years 2012-13 to 2018-19 - High Court held that satisfaction note is required to be recorded under section 153C for each assessment year and where a consolidated satisfaction note had been recorded for different assessment years, it would vitiate entire assessment proceedings - Whether SLP filed against impugned order of High Court was to be dismissed - Held, yes [Para 3] [In favour of assessee]

ORDER

1.

Delay condoned.

2.

Heard the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants.

3.

We are not inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in Writ Appeal No. 831/2022 (T-IT) dated 22-01-2024/ Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax v. Sunil Kumar Sharma [2024] 159 taxmann.com 179 (Karnataka) .

4.

The Special Leave Petition is dismissed.

5.

Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.

29.

We find that in this regard, the observations made by the Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court in the case of Saksham Commodities Ltd vs ITO reported in 161 taxmann.com 458 (Del HC) are very much relevant in this regard as under:-

“39.

The principle that the AO of the searched person is only required to be satisfied that the documents or materials pertain to the "other person" at the stage of transmission of material or documents to the jurisdictional AO of the non-searched entity was reiterated in RRJ Securities. We deem it apposite to extract the following passages from that decision:

"13.

The first and foremost step for initiation of proceedings under Section 153C of the Act is for the AO of the searched person to be satisfied that the assets or documents seized belong to the Assessee (being a person other than the searched person). The AO of the Assessee, on receiving the documents and the assets seized, would have jurisdiction to commence proceedings under Section 153C of the Act. The AO of the searched person is not required to examine whether the assets or documents seized reflect undisclosed income. All that is required for him is to satisfy himself that the assets or documents do not belong to the searched person but to another person. Thereafter, the AO has to transfer the seized assets /documents to the AO having jurisdiction of the Assessee to whom such assets/documents belong. Section 153C(1) of the Act clearly postulates that once the AO of a person, other than the one searched, has received the assets or the documents, he is to issue a notice to assess/re-assess the income of such person - that is, the Assessee other than the person searched - in accordance with provisions of Section153A of the Act. ……..

63.

On an overall consideration of the structure of Sections 153A and 153C, we thus find that a reopening or abatement would be triggered only upon the discovery of material which is likely to "have a bearing on the determination of the total income" and would have to be examined bearing in mind the AYs' which are likely to be impacted. It would thus be incorrect to either interpret or construe Section 153C as envisaging incriminating material pertaining to a particular AY having a cascading effect and which would warrant a mechanical and inevitable assessment or reassessment for the entire block of the "relevant assessment year”.

64.

In our considered view, abatement of the six AYs' or the "relevant assessment year" under Section 153C would follow the formation of opinion and satisfaction being reached that the material received is likely to impact the computation of income for a particular AY or AYs' that may form part of the block of ten AYs'. Abatement would be triggered by the formation of that opinion rather than the other way around. This, in light of the discernibly distinguishable statutory regime underlying Sections 153A and 153C as explained above. While in the case of the former, a notice would inevitably be issued the moment a search is undertaken or documents requisitioned, whereas in the case of the latter, the proceedings would be liable to be commenced only upon the AO having formed the opinion that the material gathered is likely to inculpate the assessee. While in the case of a Section 153A assessment, the issue of whether additions are liable to be made based upon the material recovered is an aspect which would merit consideration in the course of the assessment proceedings, under Section 153C, the AO would have to be prima facie satisfied that the documents, data or asset recovered is likely to "have a bearing on the determination of the total income". It is only once an opinion in that regard is formed that the AO would be legally justified in issuing a notice under that provision and which in turn would culminate in the abatement of pending assessments or reassessments as the case may be.

65.

We would thus recognize the flow of events contemplated under Section 153C being firstly the receipt of books, accounts, documents or assets by the jurisdictional AO, an evaluation and examination of their contents and an assessment of the potential impact that they may have on the total income for the six AYs' immediately preceding the AY pertaining to the year of search and the "relevant assessment year". It is only once the AO of the non-searched entity is satisfied that the material coming into its possession is likely to "have a bearing on the determination of the total income" that a notice under Section 153C would be issued. Abatement would thus be a necessary corollary of that notice. However, both the issuance of notice as well as abatement would have to necessarily be preceded by the satisfaction spoken of above being reached by the jurisdictional AO of the non-searched entity.

66.

Therefore, and in our opinion, abatement of the six AYs' or the "relevant assessment year" would follow the formation of that opinion and satisfaction in that respect being reached.

67.

On an overall consideration of the aforesaid, we come to the firm conclusion that the "incriminating material" which is spoken of would have to be identified with respect to the AY to which it relates or may be likely to impact before the initiation of proceedings under Section 153C of the Act. A material, document or asset recovered in the course of a search or on the basis of a requisition made would justify abatement of only those pending assessments or reopening of such concluded assessments to which alone it relates or is likely to have a bearing on the estimation of income. The mere existence of a power to assess or reassess the six AYs' immediately preceding the AY corresponding to the year of search or the "relevant assessment year" would not justify a sweeping or indiscriminate invocation of Section 153C.

68.

The jurisdictional AO would have to firstly be satisfied that the material received is likely to have a bearing on or impact the total income of years or years which may form part of the block of six or ten AYs' and thereafter proceed to place the assessee on notice under Section 153C. The power to undertake such an assessment would stand confined to those years to which the material may relate or is likely to influence. Absent any material that may either cast a doubt on the estimation of total income for a particular year or years, the AO would not be justified in invoking its powers conferred by Section 153C. It would only be consequent to such satisfaction being reached that a notice would be liable to be issued and thus resulting in the abatement of pending proceedings and reopening of concluded assessments.”

(emphasis supplied by us)

30.

Further we find that the revenue had preferred Special Leave Petition (SLP) before the Hon’ble Supreme Court against the aforesaid decision of Hon’ble Jurisdictional High Court. The SLP was dismissed in the case of ITO vs Saksham Commodities Ltd reported in 170 taxmann.com 87 (SC). The Head Notes and the full order are reproduced hereunder:-

Section 153C, read with section 153A, of the Income-tax Act, 1961 - Search and seizure - Assessment of any other person - Assessment year 2015-16 - High Court by impugned order held that section 153C would apply only to such Assessment Years where jurisdictional Assessing Officer is satisfied and has incriminating material for those Assessment Years and which may be concerned with disclosed and undisclosed income - High Court also held that it is only once Assessing Officer of non-searched entity is satisfied that material coming into its possession is likely to “have a bearing on determination of total income” that a notice under section 153C would be issued and abatement would thus be a necessary corollary of that notice - High Court further held that since in instant case section 153C was invoked in respect of Assessment Years for which no incriminating material had been gathered or obtained and satisfaction notes also failed to record any reasons as to how material discovered and pertaining to a particular Assessment Year was likely to “have a bearing on determination of total income” for year which was sought to be abated or reopened in terms of impugned notices, in such circumstances, proceedings initiated under section 153C would not sustain and impugned notice was to be quashed - Whether SLP filed by revenue against impugned order of High Court was to be dismissed - Held, yes [Para 3] [In favour of assessee]

ORDER

1.

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners.

2.

There is a delay of 124 and 127 days in filing the Special Leave Petitions respectively, which has not been satisfactorily explained. Even otherwise, we have gone through the Special Leave Petition and do not find any merit in the same.

3.

The Special Leave Petitions are, therefore, dismissed on the ground of delay as well as on merits.

4.

Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.”

31.

Since individual satisfaction note was not recorded for each assessment year by the learned AO of the Assessee herein, the assumption of jurisdiction under section 153C of the Act becomes fatal. Respectfully following the aforesaid decisions of the Hon’ble High Courts, we hold that the assumption of jurisdiction under section 153C of the Act qua the Assessee herein is totally flawed.

32.

In view of the above, respectively following the aforesaid judicial precedents, the Ground No. 2 is hereby allowed by holding that there was an invalid assumption of jurisdiction u/s 153C of the Act by the ld AO by recording consolidated satisfaction note for various assessment years, which is not in consonance with the provisions of the Act.

33.

Since, the assessment is quashed on the aforesaid limited legal facet of argument, the adjudication of other legal and factual grounds raised by the assessee vide Ground No. 2.1 and grounds raised by the assessee on merits from Grounds 3 to 3.1, becomes academic in nature and they are left open.

34.

The Ground No. 4 is challenging the levy of interest u/s 234B of the Act, which is consequential in nature.

35.

The Ground No. 5 is challenging the initiation of penalty proceedings u/s 271 AAC of the Act, which would be premature for adjudication at this stage.

36.

In the result, the appeal of the assessee in ITA No. 5817/Del/2025 is partly allowed.

37.

To sum up,

ITA No.AYParty nameResult
8178/Del/20252020-21Shashi Kant ChaurasiaRevenue Appeal is Dismissed
6743/Del/20252020-21Shashi Kant ChaurasiaAssesse Appeal is Allowed
8449/Del/20252018-19Vijay Anand ChaurasiaRevenue Appeal is Dismissed
5817/Del/20252018-19Vijay Anand ChaurasiaAssessee Appeal is Partly allowed