Results
↑↓
High Courts(2026) 11 BOM CK 1979

Kalimshah S/o Babushah Muslim Vs State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court · Nagpur Bench · 04 Nov 2026 · Shivkumar Dige, J · Rohit W. Joshi, J

Open full page

Judgment

31 paragraphs · 3,468 words

(PER:-ROHIT W. JOSHI)

(1)

The appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 223 of 2019 is the accused in Sessions Trial No. 3 of 2008, which was decided by the learned Ad-Hoc Assistant Sessions Judge, Akot vide judgment and order dated 23/08/2011, thereby convicting him for the offence punishable under Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code and sentencing him to suffer simple imprisonment for 3 years and to pay fine of Rs.15,000/-, and in default, to undergo further simple imprisonment for a period of 1 year; and also for the offence punishable under Section 323 of the IPC, sentencing him to suffer simple imprisonment for 3 months and also for offence punishable under section 506 of the IPC and sentencing him to suffer simple imprisonment for 3 months. All sentences are ordered to run concurrently.

(2)

Apart from the said appeal, the State has preferred Criminal Appeal No. 198 of 2012 for enhancement of sentence. Likewise, the victim has filed Criminal Revision Application No. 166 of 2011 seeking enhancement of sentence and for order of compensation.

(3)

The appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 223 of 2019 will be referred to as "the accused" and the applicant in Criminal Revision Application No. 166 of 2011 will be referred to as "the victim".

(4)

On 19/10/2007, the victim lodged a report with Police Station, Dahihanda, pursuant to which, offences punishable under Sections 376, 323 and 506 of the IPC came to be registered against the accused vide FIR No. 64 of 2007. The victim stated that on the said date, when she had gone to attend nature's call, the accused committed forcible sexual intercourse with her. The age of the victim in the report is mentioned as 17 years. Pursuant to the FIR, investigation was conducted and a charge-sheet came to be filed. The learned Magistrate committed the case for trial to the Sessions Court, where it came to be registered as Sessions Trial No. 3 of 2008. On 02/07/2010, the learned Sessions Judge framed charges against the accused for offences punishable under Sections 376, 323 and 506 of the IPC vide Exhibit-10.

(5)

In order to bring home the charge, the prosecution examined the victim as PW-1, spot panch as PW-2, paternal aunt of the victim - Kundabee as PW-3, Investigating Officers as PW-4 and PW-9 and Medical Officer as PW-8. Although in the FIR, the age of the prosecutrix was mentioned as 17 years, the prosecution examined PW-7 – Headmaster, Zilla Parishad Primary School, Chohotta in support of its contention that her date of birth is 30/10/1993. Prosecution also examined the Medical Officer, Womens’ Hospital, Akola as PW-6 who had recorded the opinion with respect to the age of the prosecutrix by ossification test.

(6)

PW-1 (Prosecutrix) stated that on 19/10/2007 at about 1:00 pm, she had been to a lake (talav) near Takli B.K. Road and at that time, the accused came from the backside and held her. She has stated that she raised hue and cry on which the accused hit her with a sickle on her left arm and threatened to kill her if she further raised an alarm. She stated that the accused thereafter removed her salwar by breaking the lace (nada) and committed forcible sexual intercourse with her. She stated that she started crying, and her paternal aunt PW-3 - Kundabee arrived on hearing her cries. She stated that PW-3 chased the accused in order to catch him, but the accused freed himself from her clutches, threatened to eliminate the entire family and fled from the spot. Thereafter, she went home with PW-3, narrated the incident to her parents and went to the police station with her father and PW-3 to lodge report.

(7)

Perusal of the evidence of PW-1 will indicate that the police visited the spot of incident along with her and seized the salwar which she was wearing at the time of the incident (Exhibit-40). The police also seized broken pieces of bangles, two ear rings of white colour, a lace (nada) and a sickle from the spot. She identified those items during the trial. In cross- examination, she stated that the spot of incident is at a distance of around 30 to 40 feet from her house, and that the act continued for around half an hour. She also stated that after the incident, she had started crying. She denied the suggestion that she had a love affair with the accused or that she made a false allegation because PW-3 saw them in an awkward position. She denied the suggestion that the accused did not commit forcible sexual intercourse with her at the time of incident.

(8)

It will be pertinent to state that the accused did not give any suggestion to the victim that he did not commit sexual intercourse; the cross-examination was restricted to the claim that he did not commit forcible sexual intercourse. Perusal of the cross-examination indicates that a positive suggestion was given that since PW-3 saw the accused and victim in a compromising position, she made a false allegation of rape against the accused.

(9)

It will now be appropriate to refer to the evidence of PW-3 who is the paternal aunt of the victim. She has deposed that on the date of incident, when the victim had gone for attending nature's call, she did not return, therefore, searching for her, she proceeded in the direction in which the victim had gone for attending nature's call. She has stated that she found the victim crying and on making enquiries, the victim informed her that the accused committed forcible sexual intercourse with her while threatening to kill her by means of sickle. She has stated that she chased the accused. However, the accused pushed her and fled from the spot. In her cross-examination, a question was put to her as to whether the victim had informed her that she was going to attend the nature's call. Initially, she replied that since house of victim and her house are located opposite to each other, she had seen the victim while going to attend the nature’s call. After a pause of around 1 minute, she has stated that the victim had informed her. She has stated that she went to search the victim after a period of 1 to 2 hours from the time she left the house for attending the call of nature. She has denied the suggestion that she had seen the victim and accused at the spot of incident itself. She has denied the suggestion that the accused was being implicated in a false case of rape. Perusal of the cross- examination of PW-3 will also reveal that the accused has not disputed to have committed sexual intercourse with the victim. The cross-examination indicates that only forcible intercourse is disputed.

(10)

It would now be appropriate to refer to the evidence of the doctor who has conducted physical examination of the victim on 19/10/2007. On examination of private parts of the victim she has recorded that the pubic hair was well developed, vagina admitted one finger easily, hymen was ruptured, there was no bleeding or visible injury over the private part. In the cross-examination, the doctor has stated that firm opinion with respect to forcible intercourse cannot be given upon medical examination. She has stated that the hymen of victim was old ruptured. She has further stated that in case of forcible intercourse, injuries are caused on the internal as well as outer side of the private part of victim. She has further stated that she did not find any injury on the back or buttocks of the victim. In answer to suggestion that in case of discharge of semen in private part of a lady, traces of semen can be found up to 72 hours, she answered in the affirmative and then clarified that this is possible only if the lady does not take bath. She has stated that she did not enquire with the victim as to whether she had taken bath or cleaned the private part after the alleged incident. The doctor has also stated about injury in the nature of contusion on the arm of the victim. However, she has admitted in cross-examination that she has not mentioned the colour of the injury. She has admitted the suggestion that colour of the injury indicates the age of injury and assault.

(11)

Now, it will be pertinent to refer to C.A. report which indicates that the salwar seized from the victim had semen stains and blood group of semen was identified as ‘AB’. The blood group of the accused is also ‘AB’. It must also be stated that blood stains were not detected over the salwar. The C.A. report indicates that the underwear of accused did not have any semen stains.

(12)

Learned Advocate for the accused has made two fold submissions. He contends that the fact that there are no injuries on the private part of the victim is clearly indicative of the fact that she was not subjected to forcible sexual intercourse, as alleged. The learned Advocate further argues that the spot of incident is an open place around a nala, and therefore, if such an act of forcible intercourse was committed, abrasion marks would have certainly appeared on the back and buttocks of the victim. Drawing attention to the evidence of doctor, the learned Advocate contends that no such marks are found. He further contends that despite the residential proximity, since her house and that of her paternal aunt are situated at a distance of near 30 to 40 feet from the spot of incident, yet nobody from the family heard the alarm raised by the victim. As regards the injury on the arm of the victim, the learned Advocate would contend that the evidence on record is not sufficient to infer that the said injury was caused at the time of incident since the age of injury is not mentioned. The learned Advocate further contends that even colour of injury is not mentioned in order to ascertain the age of injury.

(13)

Per contra, the learned APP and the advocate for victim vehemently argued that in every case of rape, injuries may not appear on the private parts of the victim. It is contended that different persons react different to a situation of forcible sexual intercourse.

(14)

The learned senior advocate for the victim has placed reliance on judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Dalip Kumar @ Dalli versus State of Uttaranchal (Criminal Appeal No. 1005 of 2013 decided on 16.01.2025). Paragraphs 8 and 9 of the said judgment read thus:-

8.

*We must caution that bodily injuries are not necessary to prove sexual assault1 and neither it is important to raise a hue or cry. In this regard, the Supreme Court's Handbook on Gender stereotypes (2023) provides as under:*

“Different people react differently to traumatic events. For example, the death of a parent may cause one person to cry publicly whereas another person in a similar situation may not exhibit any emotion in public. Similarly, a woman’s reaction to being sexually assaulted or raped by a man may vary based on her individual characteristics. There is no “correct” or “appropriate” way in which a survivor or victim behaves.”

9.

It is a common myth that sexual assault must leave injuries. Victims respond to trauma in varied ways, influenced by factors such as fear, shock, social stigma or feelings of helplessness. It is neither realistic nor just to expect a uniform reaction. The stigma associated with sexual assault often creates significant barriers for women, making it difficult for them to disclose the incident to others. In the present case however, the prosecutrix herself had clearly indicated that she was not forcibly taken away by the appellant. The above evidence indicates that the ingredients for sustaining a charge under Section 366-A of the IPC of abductions with the intent to illicit intercourse of the prosecutrix, was totally absent in the present case. Therefore, the conviction of the appellant under Section 366-A IPC cannot be sustained.

(15)

As regards punishment, contention of learned senior advocate is that Section 376 of the IPC, as it stood at the relevant time, provided for minimum punishment of 7 years and yet the learned Sessions Court has awarded sentence of 3 years only. The contention is that sentence lesser than the minimum period prescribed under the statute cannot be sustained.

(16)

In reply, the learned advocate for the accused draws attention to proviso to Section 376 and contends that in a given case for reasons to be recorded, sentence for a period less than 7 years could be imposed for offence of rape at the relevant time. The learned advocate points out that proviso to Section 376 is deleted from the Statute w.e.f. 21.04.2018. It is contended that since the incident is dated 19.10.2007, the provision will have to be considered as it stood then.

(17)

We have considered the rival submissions as aforesaid and also perused the judgment delivered by the learned Sessions Court, depositions of witnesses and exhibited documents with the able assistance of the learned counsel.

(18)

At the outset, it must be stated that the accused has not disputed to having committed sexual intercourse with the victim. The said fact can be discerned from the cross-examinations of the prosecutrix and her paternal aunt. Apart from the fact that there is no suggestion to the prosecutrix that sexual intercourse had not taken place, there is a positive suggestion to her that since the paternal aunt of victim viz. PW-3 witnessed the victim and the accused in a compromising position, she made a false allegation of rape against him and lodged a false complaint. The suggestion to PW-1 is restricted to the accused not having committed forcible sexual intercourse. The suggestion is not that sexual intercourse had never occurred. Even to PW-3 (paternal aunt of victim), a positive suggestion is given that she had witnessed the victim and accused at the spot of incident itself. Apart from this, C.A. report indicates that stains of semen of ‘AB’ blood group are found on the salwar of the victim. The blood group of semen stains is ‘AB’ which is the blood group of the accused.

(19)

The fact that the back and buttocks of the victim do not have marks of bruises or abrasions may not be very relevant in view of the cross-examination of the victim (PW-1) and PW-3 and also in view of the spot inspection report which indicates that the act was committed over grass in the nala. The spot inspection report indicates presence of broken pieces of bangles, white metal earrings lying on the grass and an iron blade sickle with wooden handle was also found by the side of the shrubs near the grass.

(20)

The victim (PW-1) has stated that the broken lace (nada), pieces of bangles, earrings and sickle were found lying on the spot when she had shown the spot of incident to the police. There is no cross-examination of the victim on this aspect of broken bangles, earrings, broken nada and sickle being found at the spot. The fact that the lace (nada) of the salwar was broken and not opened is indicative of the fact that the intercourse was not consensual. If the intercourse were to be consensual, the lace (nada) would not have been broken in order to remove the salwar. The accused has not given any suggestion to the victim that the lace (nada) was broken due to any difficulty in opening the knot. Likewise, there is contused injury on the left arm of the victim. Although the colour of injury is not mentioned in the medical report, the medical certificate also indicates swelling along with contusion. Perusal of cross examination of victim will indicate that no suggestion is given to her that the accused did not inflict a blow on her arm with sickle. In the absence of such suggestion that the accused did not inflict blow, version of the victim in her examination-in-chief will have to be accepted as true. The fact that colour and age of injury on the arm is not mentioned in the medical report loses significance.

(21)

As against this, the factors which support the accused are that the house of the victim is merely at a distance of 30 to 40 feet from the place of incident. The house of paternal aunt of victim is also situated opposite to the house of the victim and is at a similar distance. The spot of incident is a nala, which is 7 to 8 feet below the level of the ground. Possibility of the cries of victim not reaching her house cannot be ruled out. Perusal of cross-examination does not indicate that any positive suggestion that the accused did not hit the victim by the sickle is given to the victim, although there is a suggestion denying forcible sexual intercourse. In view of the above, the contention of the accused that the act was consensual and not forcible cannot be accepted.

(22)

As regards the contention with respect to there being no injuries on the private part of the victim, it is now necessary to assess whether the intercourse was forcible or with the consent of the victim. The evidence would suggest that there is contused injury on the arm of the victim with minimal swelling.

(23)

As regards the age of the victim at the relevant time, she has mentioned her age in the FIR as 17 years. The FIR is lodged on the date of incident itself. She has not made any further clarification with respect to the age in her examination-in-chief. She has not explained the statement mentioning her age as 17 years. The charge-sheet also indicates that the age of victim is mentioned as 17 years. The school record, which records the date of birth of the victim as 30.10.1993, cannot be relied upon, since PW-7, the Headmaster of the school admitted that the entry was recorded without any document being produced by the grandfather of the victim at the time when the entry with respect to date of birth was recorded. The ossification test conducted records that the age of victim should be around 14 to 16 years. Adding 2 years to the opinion, as is the margin of error in determining age as per the said test, the age of the victim must be considered to be somewhere around 16 to 18 years as per the ossification test.

(24)

At the relevant time, Section 375 of the IPC provided that intercourse with or without consent of a girl under 16 years of age was included in the definition of rape. Since the victim was more than 16 years of age at the time of the incident, intercourse with her consent would not amount to rape. However, in view of the finding that the intercourse did not take place with consent of the accused, the offence is made out.

(25)

Section 376 of the IPC, as it stood on the date of offence, provided for a minimum sentence of 7 years. However, in view of the proviso to Section 376 of the IPC, the learned Sessions Court was vested with discretion to award a sentence for a term of less than 7 years. The discretion conferred by the proviso was required to be exercised for adequate and special reasons. Since then, the minimum sentence has been enhanced to 10 years, and the proviso has been deleted from the Statute. However, punishment will have to be imposed as per the provision existing on the date of the offence.

(26)

In the considered opinion of this Court, the learned Sessions Court has recorded appropriate reasons for reducing the sentence. It has recorded that the accused had no criminal antecedents and that the family of the accused was completely dependent upon him. The learned Sessions Court deemed it appropriate to impose punishment keeping in mind the principle of reformation. While imposing the sentence, the learned Judge also invoked Section 357(3) of the Cr.P.C. to impose a fine of Rs.15,000/- and directed that a sum of Rs.14,000/- be paid towards compensation to the victim. A period of around 19 years has elapsed since the date of offence. The judgment and order of conviction is dated 23.08.2011, and a period of around 15 years has elapsed since then. The age of the appellant is now more than 40 years. Having regard to the totality of circumstances, this Court does not deem it appropriate to interfere with the sentence imposed by the Sessions Court.

(27)

In the result, Criminal Appeal No. 223/2019, Criminal Appeal No. 198/2012 and Criminal Revision Application No. 166/2011 stand dismissed.