Results
↑↓
High Courts(2026) 11 BOM CK 2128

Smt. Prema w/o Santosh Waghmare Vs The State Of Maharashtra & Ors.

Bombay High Court · Aurangabad Bench · 05 Nov 2026 · Abasaheb D. Shinde, J · Nitin B. Suryawanshi, J

Open full page

Judgment

17 paragraphs · 1,213 words

[Per Nitin B. Suryawanshi, J.]

1.

This petition challenges order/communication dated 28.02.2023, passed by Respondent No. 2, Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad Latur, and order dated 18.07.2023, issued by Respondent No. 3, thereby directing recovery of amount of Rs. 4,87,000/- from the gratuity of petitioner’s husband.

2.

Undisputed facts are that, petitioner's husband namely Santosh Dashrath Waghmare, was working as Gramsevak with respondent no. 2. While petitioner's husband was working as Gramsevak at Village Panchayat Varvanti, a complaint was made against him. Show cause notice was issued to him in respect of non submission of crop inspection report within time. On 18.02.2021 final show cause notice was issued alleging misappropriation and he was directed to hand over charge of the concerned Village Panchayat. He was suspended by order dated 01.03.2021 passed by respondent no. 6. Thereafter departmental inquiry was initiated against petitioner's husband and charge sheet was served on 18.02.2021. His suspension was revoked on 21.04.2022. Inquiry officer and presenting officer were appointed on 26.07.2022. During the pendency of enquiry, petitioner's husband expired on 10.01.2023. By relying on circular of the General Administration Department dated 31.05.2018, inquiry against petitioner's husband was dropped by order dated 28.02.2023.

3.

The suspension period of petitioner's husband was treated as leave period in terms of Rule 72(7) of Maharashtra Civil Services (Joining Time, Foreign Service and Payments During Suspension, Dismissal and Removal) Rules, 1981 by order dated 28.02.2023. By the same order, three member committee of Assistant Block Development Officer, Panchayat Samiti, Ahmadpur, Joint Accounts Officer, Panchayat Samiti Ahmadpur and Junior Accounts Officer, Panchayat Samiti Ahmadpur was appointed to conduct an inquiry against deceased husband of the petitioner. The committee was directed to complete inquiry within 15 days and to submit report to Block Development Officer, Panchayat Samiti, Ahmadpur. If in the inquiry it is found that deceased husband of the petitioner has misappropriated the government funds, then misappropriated amount was to be recovered from the family pension of the petitioner and the same was to be done by concerned Block Development Officer, Panchayat Samiti, Devani.

4.

Pursuant to the said order, inquiry committee conducted an inquiry and submitted report dated 02.04.2023. It is stated in the said report that Sarpanch and deceased husband of the petitioner have failed in their duty and have not spent amount of Rs. 9,74,000/- as per Government rules. Therefore, it would be appropriate to recover said amount from Sarpanch and deceased husband of the petitioner. By relying on said report, respondent no. 3 by impugned order dated 18.07.2023 directed recovery of amount of Rs. 4,87,000/- from the gratuity amount of Rs. 5,42,000/- of the husband of the petitioner. Being aggrieved by said order, petitioner has approached this court.

5.

Heard learned advocate for the petitioner, learned AGP for State, learned advocate for respondent nos. 2 to 6. Perused the affidavit in reply filed by respondent no. 2 to 6.

6.

It is well settled principle of service jurisprudence that departmental inquiry abates on the death of government servant. Even a criminal prosecution abates on the death of an accused. Therefore, inquiry conducted after the death of deceased husband of the petitioner is without jurisdiction and therefore non est and void ab initio.

7.

In Basudeo Tiwary vs. Sido Kanhu University and Others, (1998) 8 SCC 194, the Apex Court has held that, neither direction for inquiry nor for reinstatement can be issued in case of deceased employee. It is further held;

“14.

The appellant has since demised during the pendency of these proceedings, no further direction either as to further inquiry or reinstatement can be given. We declare that the termination of the appellant by the respondent as per the notification referred to by us is invalid. Consequently, it would be deemed that the appellant had died in harness. Needless to say that the appellant would become entitled to the payment of arrears of salary from the date of termination of his services up to the date of his death on the basis of the last pay drawn by him. Let the respondent take action within a period of three months from today to work out the arrears due to the appellant from the date of his termination till his death and pay the same to his legal representatives.”

8.

The Division Bench of this Court at Nagpur in Hirabai Bhikanrao Deshmukh and another vs. State of Maharashtra and others, [Writ Petition No. 836 of 1984] has held;

“6.

The provisions with regard to dismissal, removal and suspension of the civil servant do not permit holding of any further enquiry into the conduct of such a civil servant after his death. Such proceedings are intended to impose departmental penalty and would abate by reason of the death of civil servant. The purpose of proceedings is to impose penalty, if misconduct is established against the civil servant. That can only be achieved if the civil servant continues to be in service. Upon broader view the proceedings are quasi-criminal in the sense it can result in fault finding and further imposition of penalty. The character of such proceedings has to be treated as quasi-judicial for this purpose. In the light of the character of the proceedings and the nature of penalty like dismissal or removal, or any other penalties, minor or major, it has nexus to the contract of service. Therefore, if the person who has undertaken that contract is not available, it should follow that no proceedings can continue. Thus when the proceedings are quite personal in relation to such a contract of service, the same should terminate upon death of the delinquent. By reason of death, such proceedings would terminate and abate. We think that such a result is also inferable from the provisions of Rule 152-B of the Bombay Civil Services Rules.”

9.

The aforesaid ratio squarely covers the case of the petitioner.

10.

The Respondents have contended in their reply that, petitioner was called upon and it was brought to her knowledge about the amount misappropriated by her husband. However, she has given an undertaking that if the said amount is required to be recovered then she has no objection for the same, it is to be recovered from the gratuity amount of her husband and as such petitioner has given undertaking to that aspect.

11.

There is absolutely no merit in the said contention inasmuch as when the enquiry conducted against the deceased husband of the petitioner is held to be void ab initio and non est, there is no question of relying on the undertaking given by the petitioner. Naturally, the petitioner must be in the dire need of money after sudden death of her husband and therefore she must have given the undertaking under duress. Therefore, we are not inclined to accept said contention of the respondents.

12.

For the aforestated reasons, writ petition is allowed.

13.

Impugned order/communication dated 28.02.2023 passed by Respondent No. 2, Latur and order dated 18.07.2023 issued by Respondent No. 3 are hereby quashed and set aside.

14.

Respondents shall repay the deducted amount of Rs. 4,87,000/-to the petitioner along with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date on which said amount became payable till its realization within a period of 12 weeks from the date of uploading of this order.