U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited Vs M/s Vrindavan Bihari Rubber Products Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.
National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission · New Delhi · 13 Oct 2026 · Dr. Inder Jit Singh, Presiding Member · Shashi Nandkeolyar, Member
Judgment
Heard learned counsels for both sides.
In compliance of earlier order, Appellant have placed before us during the course of hearing compliance affidavit along with certain relevant documents, including inter alia a letter dated 28.09.2026 from the CBI addressed to the CEO of the Appellant herein in which CBI has stated that the matter being subjudice the PE cannot be shared with UPSIDA, the Appellant herein and CBI is not in a position to offer any comment regarding the issue of handing over of the possession of the plots to the allottees.
In view of this, learned Counsel representing the Appellant, on instructions, reiterated their commitment and willingness to implement this Commission' order dated 16.07.2026 vide which directions were issued by this Commission to provisionally hand over the possession of the plots after expiry of two months even if final report is not received from CBI, making it subject to any adverse finding in the final report.
Respondents/Complainants were directed to give required undertaking/affidavit in this regard. Learned Counsel for the Appellant submits that the Respondent(s)/Complainant(s) have so far not given such undertakings/affidavit. Directions were also issued in this order that the Appellant will ensure that all encroachments are removed and the plots are finally made ready for giving possession.
Today during the course of hearing, learned Counsel for the Respondent submitted, on instructions, in all the cases that the requisite undertakings/affidavit shall be submitted to the Appellant herein within two weeks from today.
In FA/621/2025 Respondent was represented through its Finance Manager Mr. Pawan Agarwal and in FA/625/2025, Respondent was represented through one of its partners Mr. Ravi Kumar Rajpal.
In view of the foregoing, we hereby reiterate our directions to the Appellant herein to provisionally hand over the possession of the plots within a maximum of two weeks' period from the date of receipt of the requisite undertaking/affidavit from the concerned Respondent(s)/Complainant(s) in the cases covered under this order.
Further, within this four weeks' period it should be ensured that all encroachments are removed and the plots are finally made ready to give possession. Further, we direct the Respondents/Complainants to ensure that the requisite undertakings/affidavit is given within two weeks from today.
All the four FAs covered under this order stand disposed off as per above directions.
If the Complainants/Respondents fail to comply with their part of obligations in terms of submitting requisite undertakings/affidavit to Appellant within two weeks' period, the Appellant will have the liberty to revive their First Appeals, challenging the order of the State Commission on merits and the same shall be taken up on merits. If the Appellant herein fail to comply with the above said directions of handing over the provisional possession after removing the encroachments and after getting the undertakings/affidavit within four weeks' period, all the First Appeals would be deemed dismissed and the order of the State Commission shall come into force as it is.
Registry of NCDRC is directed to send a copy of this order (free certified copy) to both sides, within a maximum period of one week from the date of this order.
All other pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed off.
