Results
↑↓
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 11 ITAT CK 2939

Ms. Anuradha Bakshi & Anr. Vs Assistant Commissioner Of Income Tax

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · New Delhi · 18 Nov 2026 · Anubhav Sharma, Judicial Member · Sanjay Awasthi, Accountant Member

Open full page

Judgment

56 paragraphs · 6,378 words

PER SANJAY AWASTHI, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER:

1.

These are a batch of five appeals pertaining to two assessees viz. Ms. Anuradha Bakshi (ITAs 1791, 1792, 1793 & 1794) and Ms. Malika Bakshi (ITA 1795). Since there are certain common issues and also the impugned orders arise from the same search on the Triburg Group of cases, conducted on 02.03.2021, these five appeals are being disposed of through a common order.

2.

(i) ITA 1791/Del/2026 – Arises from order dated 09.12.2025, passed u/s 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereafter as “the Act”), by Ld. CIT(A)-24, New Delhi.

(ii)

ITA 1792/Del/2026 – Arises from order dated 09.12.2025, passed u/s 250 of the Act, by Ld. CIT(A)-24, New Delhi.

(iii)

ITA 1793/Del/2026 – Arises from order dated 09.12.2025, passed u/s 250 of the Act, by Ld. CIT(A)-24, New Delhi.

(iv)

ITA 1794/Del/2026 – Arises from order dated 15.12.2025, passed u/s 250 of the Act, by Ld. CIT(A)-24, New Delhi.

(v)

ITA 1795/Del/2026 – Arises from order dated 16.12.2025, passed u/s 250 of the Act, by Ld. CIT(A)-24, New Delhi.

All these cases emanate from search conducted on the Triburg Group on 02.03.2021 (it is seen that the AO has recorded the date of search as 01.03.2021 even though in other group cases this date is recorded as 02.03.2021). During the course of search several allegedly incriminating documents, WhatsApp chats, e-mails, etc. were seized on the basis of which adverse inferences were drawn in the case of the assessees under consideration. Both these assessees are seen to be connected to the Triburg Group and are either Directors in the group companies or having their own proprietary concerns. At this stage, we may capture, in brief the additions and issues, which are the subject matter of the present adjudication:

Issue/AdditionMs. Anuradha BakshiMs. Malika BakshiMs. Anuradha Bakshi
ITA No.1794/D/20261795/D/20261791/D/20261792/D/20261793/D/2026
Assessment Year2021-222021-222015-162016-172017-18
Additon made by assuming receipts of Rs.9,15,00,000/- each as cash consideration on sale of property located at 6, Hyde Park, Sultanpur, Delhi to M/s Lebosa Infocomm (P) Ltd. and Shop Direct TV Ltd.Rs 5,54,81,394Rs 9,31,96,472------
Addition made representing alleged cash sales and held as unexplained money u/s 69A of the Act read with section 115BBE of the Act.Rs 8,74,294---------
Addition made as alleged cash receipts and held as unexplained money u/s 69A of the act read with section 115BBE of the Act.Rs 6,26,100Rs 1,20,00,000------
Addition made representing alleged expenditure incurred on the basis of loose sheets marked as Annexure 19, 20 & 22 and held as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C r.w.s 115BBE of the Act.Rs 44,47,960--------
That addition made representing alleged expenditure incurred on the basis of loose paper marked as Annexure A-6 and held as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act r.w.s 115BBE of the Act.----Rs 5,06,150Rs 2,20,920Rs 5,07,006
That addition made representing alleged expenditure incurred on the basis of hand written page no. 34 marked as Annexure A-6, held as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C of the Act r.w.s 115BBE of the Act.--------Rs 14,56,000
2.1

All these additions have been sustained at first appellate stage by the Ld. CIT(A) and the aggrieved assessees have filed the present appeals challenging such additions on merits as well as on grounds of limitation, by contending that the assessment orders are barred by limitation considering the effective dates of the conclusion of search.

3.

Before us, the Ld. AR argued with the help of detailed paper books and written submissions. It was requested by the Ld. AR that the grounds on merits may be taken up first and thereafter, in case required, the legal grounds may also be taken up. The Ld. AR advanced his arguments with respect to each of the additions made, as pertaining to the individual assessees. We may record the gist of his arguments with respect to the additions made in the case of each assessee:

(i)

Addition of Rs.931,96,472/- (ITA 1795) & Rs.554,81,394/- (ITA 1794) made by assuming receipts of cash of Rs.9,15,00,000/- each by both the assessees, as alleged on-money received = It was informed that a property located at 6, Hyde Park, Sultanpur, Delhi measuring 2.5 acres and equally owned by M/s Triburg Sportswear (Prop. Mr. Tarun Bakshi) and M/s T. International (Prop. Ms. Anuradha Bakshi), was sold to one Mr. Raj Kumar N. Dhoot. Prior to the said sale of this property, Mr. Tarun Bakshi gifted his share in this property to his daughter Ms. Malika Bakshi. This property was admittedly sold for Rs.25 crores and as per the statement under oath recorded of Shri Robindra Sharma, CFO of the Triburg Group, an amount of Rs.4.7 crores was received over and above the value of Rs.25 crores registered in the sale deed. It was the submission that the Ld. AO based himself on WhatsApp chats and other allegedly unverified messages exchanged between various parties (brokers in the deal, Shri Dhoot & Shri Robindra Sharma) to arrive at a conclusion that actually the cash component on the sale was around Rs.23 crores, comprising of 4.7 crores admitted by Shri Robindra Sharma and another Rs.18.70 crores cash received as evidenced by messages exchanged between the representatives of the assessee and the buyers. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that the basis for believing that cash amount over and above the Rs.4.7 crores admitted by Shri Robindra Sharma, was actually paid and was on account of allegedly coded messages exchanged between the buyers and the sellers through which it was deciphered by the Ld. AO that actually Rs.18.70 crores was also received in cash. It was the submission that the so-called authors/owners of the chats were never allowed to be cross-examined by the assessee. It was also averred that there was no documentary evidence in the shape of any agreement or MOU or even any receipt found as a result of search to lend credence to the allegation that on-money was received to the tune of Rs.18.30 crores. It was the further submission that during the course of search no such document was found or seized and even any detail of such large amounts of cash received was never unearthed. It was submitted that Shri Robindra Sharma duly admitted that the assessees had received Rs.4.70 crores in addition to the amount mentioned in the registered sale deed. It was submitted by the Ld. AR that this amount has been declared by the two assessees in their returns of income as disclosures after the search action. The Ld. AR also placed some facts indicating that similarly situated properties, in the vicinity, had disclosed sale considerations considerably less than what has been disclosed by the two assessees. It was stated that the Ld. AO has relied on essentially circumstantial and unfounded evidence on the basis of chats on social media platforms regarding the business of the assessee and in some places where genuine transactions involving pieces of clothing are being discussed then those have been presumed to be amounts in lakhs of rupees etc. The Ld. AR relied on a number of authorities to canvass the point that in the absence of clear proof of receiving on-money from sale of property there was no basis to make any addition over and above the amount mentioned in the sale deed. It was a further submission that the assessees wanted to buy peace of mind and avoid unnecessary litigation and thus they had not contested the statement under oath given by Shri Robindra Sharma and had duly declared/surrendered Rs.4.70 crores in their returns of income. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that even for this surrendered amount there was no documentary evidence available with any of the authorities below. In this manner, the addition of Rs.9,15,00,000/- each in the hands of the two assessee’s was disputed. It was also pointed out by the Ld. AR that in the case of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi the amount actually added was Rs.5,54,81,394/- which was arrived at on pages 13 to 14 of AO (AY 2021-22), where the long-term capital gains of the impugned amount has been considered for addition after adding the alleged cash received of Rs.9,15,00,000/-. It was pointed out that in the case of Ms. Malika Bakshi also this amount has been added and considered (pages 18 to 19 of AO for AY 2021-22) and again long terms capital gains of Rs.931,96,472/- has been added to the income of the assessee.

(ii)

Rs.8,74,294 (ITA 1794) made in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi = The Ld. AR took us through the facts regarding the impugned addition and stated that some cash receipts were found amounting to Rs.40,00,000/-, which had been received on account of sales of leather and home products etc. It was pointed out that Shri Robindra Sharma, CFO has given a statement under oath that cash sales had actually been made during the year under consideration. It was the submission that while finalizing the assessment in the case of Shri Tarun Bakshi a query was raised by that AO regarding the cash sales and it was submitted by Shri Tarun Bakshi that the cash sales were only to the tune of Rs.31,25,706/- and all of them were accounted for in the case of M/s T. International, a Proprietary concern of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. Thereafter, the Ld. AO proceeded to add the differential of the receipts found and the cash sales disclosed, being Rs.8,74,294/-, and added this amount u/s 69A r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act. The Ld. AR submitted that the AO had made the addition after completely disregarding the explanation filed vide assessee’s reply dated 28.03.2023 (placed at pages 192 to 193 of the Paper Book). It was the submission that the differential amount added needed to be verified further since it represented a part of the cash disclosed and declared in the return of income, especially with respect to the on-money received from sale of property. The Ld. AR prayed that this matter may be restored to the file of Ld. AO for determination with respect to the claim of the assessee that she deserves the benefit of telescoping.

(iii)

Addition made of Rs.6,26,100 (ITA 1794) in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi and Rs.1,20,00,000 (ITA 1795) made in the hands of Ms. Malika Bakshi = The Ld. AR briefed about the facts surrounding these additions and stated that the Ld. AO has made this addition as per discussion at pages 15 to 16 of his order by stating that alleged unexplained cash receipts amounting to Rs.34,67,500/- were found in the name of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. It was the submission that the assessee had supplied evidence that this amount represented drawings from the proprietary concern (M/s T. International) and were duly explained. It was submitted that in spite of the explanation filed by the assessee the Ld. AO stated that only Rs.27,82,000/- was explained and thereafter made the addition of Rs.6,26,100/-. Here also the Ld. AR pointed out that replies had been submitted to the Ld. AO on as many as three occasions on 30.01.2023, 10.02.2023 and 28.03.2023, wherein a summary of the entries constituting Rs 34,67,500 were given, along with the sources from where these withdrawals were made. The assessee had also enclosed the Cash in Hand Account in the books of M/s T. International where all these withdrawals (Rs.34,17,500) have been recorded. It was submitted that Rs 50,000 was withdrawn directly from Savings Bank account of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. The bank details were placed on record through the paper book at page 243:

- T. International (Current Account No. 90311010000530) from where the withdrawals were made.

- Anuradha Bakshi (Savings Account No. 90312010024655) from where the withdrawals of Rs 50,000 were made by her.

Keeping in view of the above, the Ld. AR submitted that the entire cash withdrawals of Rs. 34,67,500/- have been duly explained and should not have been added to income u/s 69A of the Income Tax Act entailing any tax liability u/s 115 BBE and penalty u/s 271AAC of the Act. It was also the submission that there was no question of application of Section 115BBE of the Act. The Ld. AR assailed the action of Ld. AO in applying the provisions of Section 69A in this regard.

Regarding the addition of Rs.1,20,00,000/- in the hands of Ms. Malika Bakshi, it was stated that the Ld. AO has recorded on pages 19 & 20 of his order that there was alleged undisclosed cash receipts which indicated a receipt of Rs.1.20 crores from factories as undisclosed commission. It was pointed out that here also during the course of assessment of Shri Tarun Bakshi, he was pointedly asked vide response to notice dated 08.02.2023 about such cash receipts and vide his reply dated 03.03.2023 he had submitted that Rs.1.20 crores was received by his daughter, Ms. Malika Bakshi, and the said amount had already been disclosed in her revised Income tax return filed on 30.03.2022 under “income from other sources”. It was the submission that the Ld. AO proceeded to doubt this receipt and asked for details of vendors from whom such commission had been received and since details were not forthcoming, hence, he made the impugned addition and also applied the provisions of Section 115BBE of the Act. It was the submission that once the amount was disclosed as “income from other sources” and offered to tax in the return of income then there was no requirement for any further verification, since the amount was already offered to tax.

(iv)

Addition of Rs.44,47,960/- made in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi (ITA 1794) = The Ld. AR took us through the facts surrounding this addition and stated that the Ld. AO has recorded a finding on pages 16 & 17 of his order that as per the alleged incriminating material seized as Annexures-19, 20 & 22 during the course of search proceedings, expenses to the tune of Rs.44,47,960/- were seen to have been incurred during the year and through the statement of Shri Robindra Sharma it was inferred that allegedly undisclosed cash was used for incurring such expenditure. It was the submission that a reply had been filed on 28.03.2023 through which such expenditure was attributed to the on-money of Rs.4.7 crores received through sale of the impugned property. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that the AO did not find this explanation reasonable since he has recorded that the on-money of Rs.4.7 crores has been surrendered as Long Term Capital Gains (LTCG). It was argued by the Ld. AR that such expenses were made from time to time out of the on-money received by selling the property under consideration. At this stage, the Ld. AR averred that what is required to be considered was whether the expenses exceeded the on-money surrendered and disclosed. It was pointed out that the impugned expenses were considerably lesser than the on-money received by both Ms. Anuradha Bakshi and Ms. Malika Bakshi. It was also pointed out that both these assessees were proprietors or directors in group entities and were thus responsible for running the various businesses. Towards this end they were incurring expenses from whatever funds were available with them. It was the submission that it was nobody’s case that the on-money received was supposed to be kept locked up without there being any use for it in the businesses run by the assessees under consideration. The Ld. AR also stated that legally there were considerable judicial precedents which allowed the benefit of telescoping in cases where amounts had been surrendered by assessees. The Ld. AR drew our attention to some case laws, out of which a few may be mentioned:

a)

123 ITR 457 (SC) Anantharam Veerasinghaiah & Co. vs. CIT;

b)

165 ITR 453 (Raj.) CIT vs. Tyaryamal Balchand;

c)

149 ITR 127 (Mad.) CIT vs. K.S.M. Guruswamy Nadar & Sons;

d)

51 ITR 757 (Mad.) S. Kuppuswami Mudaliar vs. CIT.

The Ld. AR assailed the findings of Ld. CIT(A) also since they were largely based on the findings of Ld. AO, without considering the submissions of the assessee.

(v). (ITA 1791) addition of Rs 5,06,150 in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2015-16; Addition of Rs.2,20,920/- (ITA 1792) Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2016-17); & addition of Rs.5,07,006/- (ITA 1793) – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2017-18) = The Ld. AR took us through the findings of the authorities below and stated that the impugned amounts represented alleged unexplained expenditure inferred on the basis of loose sheets marked as Annexure A-6. It was the submission that before the Ld. AO and the Ld. CIT(A) detailed submissions and justifications were filed regarding these expenses and it has been the consistent stand of the assessee that these loose sheets of paper are “dumb” documents and should not be relied on for making any addition. Notwithstanding this initial objection to the additions made, the Ld. AR stated that the addition of Rs.5,06,150/- had been explained through copy of ledger account of drawings (Rs.13,97,470/-) from a proprietorship concern of Shri Tarun Bakshi and drawings (Rs.5,86,56/-) from a proprietorship concern of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. It was the submission that the drawings from these two concerns were sufficient to cover the expenses of Rs.5,06,150/- (AY 2015-16). Regarding the amount of Rs.2,20,920/-, it was the submission that for AY 2016-17 the copy of ledger account of drawings of Rs.7,03,505/- had been duly supplied to the authorities below to show availability of sufficient funds to have met the expense of Rs.2,20,920/-. Regarding the addition of Rs.5,07,006/- (AY 2017-18) it was further submitted by the Ld. AR that the copy of ledger account of drawings from M/s T. International, being the proprietary concern of M/s Anuradha Bakshi, was duly filed before the authorities below to show that such drawings amounted to Rs.20,42,306/-. It was the submission that these drawings were sufficient to cover the impugned addition of Rs.5,07,006/-.

(vi). Rs.14,56,000/- added as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act (ITA 1793 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi AY 2017-18) = The Ld. AR stated that the Ld. AO had relied on page 34 of the seized material marked as A-6 to infer that Rs.14,56,000/- was paid in cash to some employees of the Triburg Group by way of bonus. It was the submission that this bonus was paid out of the cash sourced from past savings accumulated in cash over the years. Notwithstanding the noting in the seized Annexure A-6 (page 34 thereon) it was argued that there was no signature of the assessee on that sheet of paper and therefore it could not be anything more than a “dumb” document. The Ld. AR relied on a number of authorities to canvass the point that handwritten unsigned, loose sheets of paper are merely “dumb” documents in the absence of any corroboratory evidence. For this purpose, the Ld. AR relied on the decisions rendered in the cases of Common Cause and others reported in 394 ITR 220 (SC) and also the case of P.V. Kalyansundaram reported in 294 ITR 49 (SC). Apart from this the Ld. AR also relied on a number of case laws of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court. The Ld. AR also took us through an extract from the cash book of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for the period 01.04.2013 to 31.03.2017 to canvass the point that there were considerable cash movement visible in the cash book to justify the said payments out of cash accumulated over a period of time.

3.1

Regarding the arguments that the impugned proceedings are barred by limitation on the ground that the dates of commencement and final conclusion of the search proceedings were factually determinable on the basis of the punchnamas drawn, for this purpose, the Ld. AR relied on detailed written submissions filed and placed on record. It was the prayer that the factual issues on merits may be decided first and in case required then only the legal and jurisdictional issues could be considered for adjudication. A copy of order of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Anuradha Bakshi was placed on record [ 465 ITR 793 (SC)]

4.

The Ld. DR argued with the help of written submissions and straightaway relied on the case of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi vs. PCIT (Central) reported in 465 ITR 786 (Del) to counter the assessee’s argument regarding the assessment orders being time barred. However, the Ld. DR was prompted to respond to the averments regarding the merits of the case as had been laid out in detail by the Ld. AR in his arguments. The Ld. DR argued with respect to each of the groups of additions as follows:

i.

Regarding the addition of Rs.554,81,394/- (ITA 1794 Ms. Anuradha Bakshi AY 2021-22); & Rs.931,96,472/- (ITA 1795, AY 2021-22 – Ms. Malika Bakshi), it was averred that there was a detailed finding of fact in the Ld. AO’s order at pages 2 to 13 (ITA 1794) which was relied on to canvass the point that the actual cash receipts were Rs 11.50 crores and not Rs.2.35 crores and therefore the impugned amount being taxed as LTCG was justified. It was the further submission that even in ITA 1795 the Ld. AO’s findings on pages 2 to 18 were worthy of note as they were detailed and had duly considered the seized material, WhatsApp chats and statements by relevant persons, including Shri Robindra Sharma, CFO of the Triburg Group. It was the submission that the assessee was disclosing only a fraction of the cash receipt at Rs.2.35 crores instead of Rs.11.50 crores which was actually received. Accordingly, even here the Ld. DR stated that the addition of Rs.931,96,472/- was justifiably made;

ii.

Regarding the addition of Rs.8,74,294/- (ITA 1794, AY 2021-22, in the case of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi), the Ld. DR stated that he had no objection in case the matter was to be remanded back for examination on facts by the Ld. AO;

iii.

Regarding the addition of Rs.6,26,100/- (ITA 1794, AY 2021-22 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi); & Rs.1,20,00,000/- (ITA 1795, AY 2021-22 – Ms. Malika Bakshi); It was the submission that the Ld. AO has given a detailed finding of fact, which has been duly considered by the Ld. CIT(A) to sustain these two additions. It was the submission that the explanation of the assessees regarding these amounts being from drawings or commission received from factories/vendors during the FY 2020-21, could not be accepted because even though this amount was disclosed in the revised Income tax return filed on 30.03.2022 as “income from other sources”, but since the details of such commission received with respect to the names of vendors etc. were not provided, the situation merited the invocation of Section 69A of the Act and taxing at special rate of 60% u/s 115BBE of the Act.

iv.

Regarding the addition of Rs.44,47,960/- (ITA 1794 AY 2021-22 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi) – The Ld. DR relied on the findings of Ld. AO at pages 16 to 17 of his order and stated that the mere submission by the assessee that this amount was expended from on-money received and declared in the return of income, was not sufficient to escape the rigours of Section 69C of the Act r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act.

v.

Regarding the additions of Rs.5,06,150/- (ITA 1791, AY 2015-16 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi); Rs.2,20,920 (ITA 1792, AY 2016-17 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi); and Rs.5,07,006/- (ITA 1793, AY 2017-18 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi); the Ld. DR relied on the detailed findings of Ld. AO and the discussion in the impugned orders for the three assessment years under consideration. It was the submission that these additions were justifiably made on the basis of seized material for which the assessee had not furnished any plausible explanation.

vi.

Rs.14,56,000/- (ITA 1793, AY 2017-18 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi); it was the submission that the Ld. AO had given a detailed finding of fact on page 3 to 4 of his order and he had relied exclusively on page no.34 of the seized material marked as ‘Annexure A-6’. It was pointed out by the Ld. AR that on page 4 of the Ld. AO’s order the said sheet of paper has been extracted and it could be seen that it indicated payment of bonus in cash, out of regular books of accounts to various employees of the Triburg Group. It was the submission that as per Section 292C of the Act this document had to be presumed to contain details of payments made by the assessee and since the names and amounts were quite specific, hence, they could not be “dumb” documents. It was also the submission that the contention of the assessee that this amount had been paid out of savings and accumulated cash over a period of several years was not backed by any credible evidence and also both the provisions of Section 69C & 115BBE of the Act had been correctly applied to the facts of the case since Section 69C of the Act provides for just such a situation where expenditure has been incurred outside of the books of account.

5.0

We have heard the rival contentions and have gone through all the documents placed before us. We may deal with the individual additions, item wise, for the present adjudication.

(A)

Addition of Rs.9,31,96,472/- (ITA 1795) & Rs.5,54,81,394/- (ITA 1794) made by assuming cash receipts of Rs.9,15,00,000/- in the hands of both the assessees, as alleged on-money received. In this regard we have gone through the entire set of alleged evidences mentioned by the Ld. AO and confirmed by the Ld. CIT(A). It is seen that during the course of search and seizure action nothing absolutely was recovered to indicate that on-money of Rs.9,15,00,000/- each was received by the two assessees. We notice that there is an absence of any MOU or agreement or any receipt in this regard and since it is expected that during the course of search such evidences could be obtained by the search parties and, importantly, in the absence of the same, we find that the Ld. AO has relied on WhatsApp chats etc. between third parties to make the addition. It needs to be emphasized that there is absolutely no statement or corroborating evidence to show that Rs.18,30,00,000/- was received over and above the value of the property as per the registered sale deed. We find that the only indication of on-money being received, from a credible source and that too through a statement under oath, is with regard to the statement given by Shri Robindra Sharma, CFO of the Triburg Group. At the expense of repetition, it needs to be mentioned that this person has clearly mentioned the receipt of Rs.4.70 crores over and above the registered sale deed amount and thus this is what we need to work with. It is seen that the two assessees have duly surrendered and disclosed 50% each of this amount in their respective returns of income. Also the Ld. AR has attempted to demonstrate that even the Rs.29.70 crores paid for 2.5 acres of land was far in excess of comparable sales in the vicinity to the extent that the three sale instances shown of Harish Kumari Gupta (dated 14.01.2021); Dwarkesh Developers P. Ltd. (dated 30.07.2021); and Dolphin Pharms P. Ltd. (dated 07.04.2021), show per acre sale price of between 2 crores to 5 crores. The Ld. AR has attempted to demonstrate that the value received by the assesses is a substantial Rs.11.88 crores per acre. We are conscious of the fact that such comparable instances would have very little evidentiary value for the present matter but there would be some persuasive value in terms of believing the assessees’ contention that the on-money received by them was totalling only Rs.4.70 crores. Furthermore, the statements of Shri Yatinder Veer Singh (an associate of the buyer) and the statement of one Shri Alok Pandey could have had some value in case there was some corroboratory material and the assessees had some chance to cross examine these two persons as material witnesses. Accordingly, it deserves to be held that the balance of evidence is in favour of the assessees in terms of the actual value realized for the sale of impugned property and it deserves to be held that this controversy needs to be laid to rest by accepting that Rs.4.70 crores was received as on-money and the same has been duly surrendered by the two assessees concerned. Since on facts alone this issue is adjudicable, hence, we do not deem it fit or even necessary to delve into the ratios of the numerous case laws relied upon by the Ld. AR. Accordingly, the addition made by the Ld. AO on account of on-money received to the tune of Rs.9,15,00,000/- each deserves to be deleted.

(B)

Rs.8,74,294 (ITA 1794) made in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. This amount has been added on account of details of cash receipts found, amounting to Rs.40,00,000/-, purportedly through sale of leather and home products, etc. We find that the Ld. AO has accepted the explanation amounting to Rs.31,25,706/- and has not believed the assessee that the amount represents a part of the cash disclosed and declared in the return of income. We find that there is inadequate fact finding in this regard and thus, we deem it fit to set aside the impugned order on this point and remit this matter back to the file of Ld. AO for examining the contention of the assessee and analyzing the fact to see if this amount can justifiably be treated as part of the cash disclosure made by the assessee (Ms. Anuradha Bakshi).

(C)

Addition made of Rs.6,26,100 (ITA 1794) in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi and Rs.1,20,00,000 (ITA 1795) made in the hands of Ms. Malika Bakshi. Regarding the addition of Rs.6,26,100/- it is seen that the authorities below have taken the base figure of Rs.34,67,500/- as alleged unexplained cash receipts found in the name of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi and thereafter concluded that the assessee could explain only Rs.27,82,000/-, leading to the impugned addition as the differential amount. The Ld. AR has been able to demonstrate that the total withdrawals from M/s T. International (Prop. Concern of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi) amounted to Rs.34,17,500/- and there was a further withdrawal of Rs.50,000/- from savings account no.90312010024655 of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi. It has been demonstrated that the total of these two figures comes to RS.34,67,500/- and thus, factually, we do not see any reason why the impugned addition has been made at all. We, accordingly, direct that it should be deleted.

Regarding the addition of Rs.1,20,00,000/- in the hands of Ms. Malika Bakshi, we observe that the Ld. AO has given a finding at pages 19 & 20 of his order that Shri Tarun Bakshi had given a statement that this amount was received by his daughter (present assessee) and the said amount had already been disclosed in her revised Income-Tax return filed on 30.03.2022. Specifically, this amount was disclosed as income from other sources. We find that the Ld. AO doubted this statement and required that the assessee submit details of all persons from whom the impugned amount had been received. We find that the Ld. AR has placed the copy of Income Tax return for AY 2021-22 of Ms. Malika Bakshi in the paper book at pages 1 to 11, in which at page 4 it is clearly visible that under the heading “income from other sources (chapter IV-F)” an amount of Rs.1,20,00,000/- has been shown as “Miscellaneous Income”. Once this amount has been duly disclosed in the return of income then a further addition of the same certainly amounts to a double addition. It is noteworthy that the Ld. AO has invoked the provisions of Section 69A of the Act to bring this amount to tax again and has also applied the provisions of Section 115BBE of the Act. A look at the provisions of Section 69A of the Act reveals that the money, bullion, etc. should not be recorded in the books of account and also the assessee should not be in a position to offer any explanation about the nature and source of such money, or bullion. We find that in this case, Shri Tarun Bakshi has given a statement under oath indicating the origin of such cash and the assessee has also duly disclosed the same in her return of income under the head “income from other sources”. To this extent, we find that the Ld. AR’s assertion about double taxation is correct and purely on the facts of the case, we find that Section 69A of the Act is not applicable at all. Needless to say, once Section 69A of the Act does not apply then Section 115BBE of the Act will also not be relevant for this issue.

In the result, the addition made of Rs.1,20,00,000/- is directed to be deleted.

(D)

Addition of Rs.44,47,960/- made in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi (ITA 1794). In this context it may be recalled that an addition has been made in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi on account of material seized as Annexure – 19, 20 & 22 during the course of search proceedings. It was stated by Shri Robindra Sharma, CFO that this amount was spent on incurring expenditure in various Group Companies. The assessee is seen to have replied that the source of this cash was on-money received by her and duly declared in her return of income to the tune of Rs.2.35 crores. We find that the Ld. AO has rejected this explanation on the ground that the on-money received by the assessee was disclosed as long term capital gains and hence no benefit could be given to the assessee regarding the said amount being used for incurring the impugned expenses. The assessee has filed replies on at least three occasions to reconcile this amount and have sought the benefit of telescoping with respect to the amount surrendered as on-money. We find that the amount of cash received as on-money has been duly brought into the books of account of the assessee and has also been surrendered through the return of income. On this basis, the assessee’s claim for telescoping appears genuine as the amount surrendered far exceeds the impugned amount of addition. Accordingly, we direct the deletion of this amount as well.

(E)

(ITA 1791) addition of Rs 5,06,150 in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2015-16; Addition of Rs.2,20,920/- (ITA 1792) in the hands of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2016-17; and addition of Rs.5,07,006/- (ITA 1793) in the case of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2017-18. We have captured the facts surrounding these additions while recording the submissions of Ld. AR on these issues. We find that while the loose sheets of papers are unsigned but since they have been found in the possession of the assessees concerned, hence, their value for assessing the income of the assessees, cannot be underestimated. However, we find that regarding the assessees’ submissions that the drawings from various bank accounts and the accounts of the concerns controlled by the assessees was sufficient enough to cover for the expenditures depicted on the loose sheets of papers, we find that the authorities below have not really applied themselves to verifying the claim of the assessees that their drawings were sufficient to cover these expenses. Accordingly, for all these three amounts we set aside the findings in the impugned order and remit these matters back to the file of Ld. AO for examining the facts surrounding these additions and analyzing the same after taking into consideration the assessees’ submissions.

(F)

Rs.14,56,000/- added as unexplained expenditure u/s 69C r.w.s. 115BBE of the Act (ITA 1793 – Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for AY 2017-18). We find that this matter pertains to AY 2017-18 and certainly for that particular year there cannot be any benefit of telescoping since no such evidences are available before us in that regard. We find that this particular item of expenditure has been computed from page 34 of Annexure-A6. Through this seized paper it was seen that bonus was paid out in cash to employees and the assessee (Ms. Anuradha Bakshi) had claimed that such amounts were paid from cash accumulated through past savings. The Ld. AR had filed extracts from the cash book of Ms. Anuradha Bakshi for the period 1.4.2013 to 31.3.2017, in an attempt to show that there was enough cash available over this period to have made the impugned payment. We find that the plausible availability of cash through drawings spread over three years has not been examined in depth by the authorities below. Accordingly, we deem it fit to set aside the findings in the impugned order, in this regard, and remit the same back to the file of Ld. AO for assessment. We would expect the Ld. AO to examine the assessee’s contention about the availability of cash and thereafter arrive at any conclusion regarding this amount. Since this is AY 2017-18, we would also like to remind the Ld. AO that considering the case of S.M.I.L.E. Micro Finance Limited reported in 179 taxmann.com 65 (Mad), there can be no application of Section 115BBE of the Act for this assessment year even if any addition has been made under the provisions of Section 68 to 69D of the Act.

5.1

We may point out that the assessees had dropped any challenge to an alleged illegal assumption of jurisdiction on account of approval given u/s 153D of the Act, as grounds not pressed.

5.2

Regarding the issue of limitation of the impugned assessment orders due to the effective dates of end of the search and seizure action as mentioned earlier, these grounds are not adjudicated at present since the assessees concerned have largely succeeded on the substantive ground of additions.

6.

In the result, ITA Nos. 1791, 1792 & 1793 are partly allowed for statistical purposes, since the additions therein have been remitted back to the file of Ld. AO.

6.1

In the result, ITA No.1794 is partly allowed since an addition of Rs.8,74,294/- has been remitted back. Additions of Rs.6,26,100/- and addition of Rs.5,54,81,394/- have been deleted in this appeal.

6.2

In the result, ITA No.1795 is allowed with the addition of Rs.9,31,96,472/- and Rs.1,20,00,000/- being deleted.