Hem Chand Aggarwal Vs Oriental Bank Of Commerce
Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal · 30 Jan 2014 · S.N.H. Zaidi, J
Judgment
S.N.H. Zaidi, J
Misc. Application No. 13/2012 has been filed by State Bank of Patiala, (SBoP) respondent No. 2, for review of the order dated 23.9.2012 passed on Misc. Application No. 645/2011 filed by respondent No. 3 along with Misc. Application No. 12/2012 seeking stay of the operation of the said order.
Briefly stated, necessary facts for the purposes of the review application are that S.A. No. 72/2005 filed by Oriental Bank of Commerce (respondent No. 1) challenging the actions of SBoP (respondent No. 2) taken qua the sale of mortgaged properties was disposed of by the DRT-III, Delhi on 8.2.2008 on the basis of a compromise and after setting aside the auction sale of the mortgaged properties the borrower/mortgagor (respondent No. 3) was permitted to redeem the mortgage with the direction to pay Rs. 5.5 lacs as compensation interest to the appellant/auction purchaser. Appeal No. 222/200S preferred by the auction purchaser against that order was disposed of by this Tribunal vide order dated 18.1.2010 and the amount of compensation interest was enhanced from Rs. 5.5 lacs to Rs. 11 lacs and the borrower/mortgagor was directed to deposit the enhanced amount with the DRT concerned within 45 days. The borrower/mortgagor had deposited Rs. 5.5 lacs along with the compromise amount with SBoP on 28.3.2008 in pursuance of the order of the DRT and pursuant to the order dated. 18.1.2010 of this Tribunal, he had deposited a further sum of Rs. 5.5 lacs on 22.1.2010 through Pay Order in favour of the Registrar of DRT-III, Delhi. On 9.3.2010, the borrower/mortgagor had deposited another amount of Rs. 5.5 lacs through a Pay Order dated 2.3.2010 before this Tribunal, which was directed to be sent to the DRT concerned.
On 11.2.2011, the application (No. 171/2010) seeking clarification/ modification of the order dated 18.1.2010 filed by respondent No. 3 was disposed of by this Tribunal with the observation that since the borrower had already deposited Rs. 11 lacs either with the bank or with the Registrar of DRT-III, Delhi, therefore, the bank was under an obligation to return the title deeds and the Registrar of DRT-III, Delhi was directed to deposit the amount with SBoP and the auction purchaser was allowed to withdraw the same from that bank. The borrower/mortgagor had assailed that order through a Writ Petition [W.P.(C) No. 3091/2011] before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court, which was disposed of on 23.5.2011 with the direction to the petitioner to move necessary application before this Tribunal for examination as to whether or not any excess amount of Rs. 5.5 lacs was deposited with SBoP. Consequently, an application (Misc. Case No. 645/2011) was filed by the borrower/mortgagor before this Tribunal, which was disposed of, vide order dated 23.9.2011, with the observation that the compromise amount of Rs. 1,63,62,500/- deposited by the borrower/mortgagor with SBoP also included the amount of Rs. 5.5 lacs, which was payable to the auction purchaser. It was also directed that since the amount had not been paid by the bank to the auction purchaser, the bank shall refund the said amount to the applicant (borrower/mortgagor) with interest, if the amount was deposited in FOR. The instant application has been filed by SBoP for the review of the said order.
I have heard Mr. Narender Pal, the learned counsel for the review applicant bank and Mr. K. Kumar the learned counsel for respondent No. 3, the borrower/mortgagor and perused the record.
The parties are not in conflict in respect of the fact that the amount of interest compensation of Rs. 5.5 lacs awarded by the DRT to the auction purchaser was enhanced in appeal to Rs. 11Iacs. It is also not disputed that pursuant to the order of the Tribunal below, SBoP had approved a compromise proposal of the borrower in Rs. 1,63,62,500/- vide its letter dated 17.3.2008 and, as per the terms of payment, an amount of Rs. 26,40,625/-, including Rs. 5.5 lacs for the auction purchaser, was required to be deposited by 26.3.2008. This amount appears to be deposited by the borrower/mortgagor with the bank on 28.3.2008, as such this Tribunal had rightly observed in its order dated 23.9.2011, which has been sought to be reviewed, that the amount of Rs. 5.5 lacs which was deposited by the borrower for the auction purchaser, is lying in deposit with the bank. It also appears from the record that besides the said deposit of Rs. 5.5 lacs on 28.3.2008 with the bank, the borrower/mortgagor had deposited Rs. 5.5 lacs through a Pay Order with the Registrar of DRT-III, Delhi on 22.1.2010 and a further sum of Rs. 5.5 lacs was deposited by the borrower/mortgagor before this Tribunal through a Pay Order dated 2.3.2010 on 9.3.2010, which was sent to the DRT-III, Delhi on 11.3.2010. As such, an amount of Rs. 11 lacs is lying in deposit with the DRT-III, Delhi which was to be given to the auction purchaser and another sum of Rs. 5.5 lacs is deposited with SBoP in terms of the order dated 8.2.2008 of the Tribunal below also for payment to the auction purchaser. Mr. Pratap Kumar, the AGM of SBoP has stated in his affidavit dated 15.3.2010 that the bank had sent a sum of Rs. 5.5 lacs to the auction purchaser, vide Draft dated 28.3.2008, but the same was not accepted by the auction purchaser and was returned with his letter dated 4.7.2008 on the ground that his appeal before this Tribunal was pending. He has further stated that the amount earlier tendered to the auction purchaser was lying in deposit with the bank. In the light of the afore-mentioned circumstances I am of the considered view that since the amount of Rs. 5.5.lacs deposited by the borrower/mortgagor with SBoP for payment to the auction purchaser has not been paid to him and is lying in deposit with it, this Tribunal had rightly directed for the refund of the said amount to the borrower, vide order dated 23.9.2011, which does not warrant any interference in review. No mistake apparent on the face of record is seen in the order dated 23.9.2011. The review application is, therefore, devoid of any force is liable to be dismissed and is dismissed accordingly. Misc. Application No. 12/2012 also stands dismissed in view of above.
Copy of this order be furnished to the parties as per law.
