Results
↑↓
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 11 ITAT CK 3696

DCIT, CC – 27, Delhi Vs M/s. Hero Motocorp Ltd.

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal · Delhi Bench “A”, New Delhi · 20 Nov 2026 · Mahavir Singh, Vice President · S. Rifaur Rahman, Accountant Member

Open full page

Judgment

720 paragraphs · 36,195 words

PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :

1.

The Revenue and assessee has filed appeals against the order of Ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-29, New Delhi [“Ld. CIT (A)”, for short] dated 09.03.2026 for the Assessment Years 2014-15 to 2017-18 and 2019-20. The assessee has also filed appeal in the aforesaid impugned order dated 09.03.2026 for the AY 2013-14.

2.

Since the issues are common and the cross appeals are connected, hence the same are heard together and being disposed off by this common order. We take cross appeals being ITA No.4958/Del/2026 (Assessee’s appeal) and ITA No. 7943/Del/2026 (Revenue’s appeal) for the Assessment Year 2015-16 as lead case.

3.

The relevant facts of the case are, the assessee company is a public limited listed company, engaged in design, development, manufacture and marketing of two-wheeler automobiles. It was further observed from the submissions of the assessee that it has eight world class manufacturing facilities, of which six are located in India and one each in Colombia and Bangladesh. It holds 48.3% market share in motorcycle market and 34.6% market share in the two-wheeler in India and has an annual combined production capacity of around 9.50 million units of two-wheelers and is the largest two-wheeler automobile manufacturer in the world with sales across 47 countries and also enjoys leadership position in home market in India. During the year the assessee company organised various business, promotional and marketing events in India and abroad.

4.

For the year under consideration i.e. AY 2015-16, the assessee company filed its return for year under consideration on 27.11.2015 declaring total income of Rs.2569,18,96,630/-. The original assessment under section 143(3) read with section 144C was completed on 30.10.2019 at Rs.3146,87,81,016/- under the normal provisions and at a book profit of Rs.3557,57,46,134/- under section 115JB of the Act. Against the additions made in the original assessment, the ITAT, by its order dated 13.04.2021 under section 254(1), deleted the major additions made in that assessment.

5.

Subsequent to search and seizure action under section 132 was carried out on 23.03.2022 on the SALT group, namely, SALT Experience & Management Pvt. Ltd. (SEMPL) and eight entities controlled by Sh. Sachin Mutreja and Sh. Sameer Mutreja, and assessee company was also searched. The Revenue’s case, drawn from the search material, is that:

(i)

the assessee paid funds to SEMPL against invoices described as brand-promotion events;

(ii)

SEMPL booked “travel arrangements” or “event purchases” in the names of M/s Dream Business Solutions (Dream) and M/s Fast Conversion (Fast), which paid M/s 365 Aviation Ltd., UK, for charter flights;

(iii)

the 365 Aviation Ltd. ledgers match the travel itinerary of Sh. Pawan Munjal, the Chairman and Managing Director (CMD) of the assessee; and

(iv)

Sh. Hemant Dahiya, MD of SEMPL, admitted in a statement under section 132(4) that SEMPL arranged the Chairman’s high-end charters.

6.

During the search and assessment proceedings, the assessee has denied the above allegations. The assessee stated that the events took place and were wholly for its business. Further, it was stated by the assessee that although search was conducted in the case of assessee, no incriminating material or undisclosed assets was recovered from the assessee and proceedings were initiated against the assessee merely on the basis of ex-parte material seized from the premises of M/s SEMPL and its connected entities, and not from the premises of the assessee.

7.

After the search, the assessee’s case was centralised from Circle 10(1), PCIT-4, Delhi to Central Circle-27, New Delhi by an order under section 127 dated 26.05.2022. A notice under section 148 dated 02.03.2023 was then issued for AY 2015-16. The assessment order records that it was issued with the prior approval of the “CCIT (Central), Delhi” under section 151(ii) on 01.03.2023.In response to the notice, the assessee filed a return on 24.03.2023 (under protest). The assessee raised preliminary legal objections by letters dated 31.03.2023, 12.04.2023, 01.05.2023 and 23.10.2023 and asked for the reasons, the satisfaction note and the approvals u/s 148/149 rws.151 of the Act. By a communication dated 22.12.2023 issued under section 142(1), the AO disposed of the objections and subsequently, supplied the reasons and the approval proforma u/s 151(ii) of the Act. The assessee then filed detailed legal objections challenging the initiation of reassessment proceedings vide letter dated 29.12.2023 which according to the assessee were never disposed off.

8.

Later, a show-cause notice (SCN) dated 10.02.2024 was issued asking the assessee that why payments to SEMPL and its linked entities should not be disallowed under section 37(1). The assessee replied vide letter dated 18.03.2024 objecting to the initiation of reassessment proceedings along with submission of necessary evidence(s) to counter the proposed disallowance u/s 37 of the Act. The AO subsequently passed the reassessment order on 30.03.2024 assessing total income at Rs.2664,86,28,202, after making the following three disallowances under section 37(1) as discussed below:

(a)

The first disallowance was Rs.88,67,03,816 the entire expenditure on domestic events organised through SEMPL, Scoop Brand Holdings Pvt. Ltd. (Scoop) and Space Monkey Media Project Pvt. Ltd. and their linked entities. This was the whole of the payments made to those entities for the year. The AO disallowed it on the basis that the payments were a means of diverting funds for the Chairman’s personal purposes, with no business nexus. The Assessing Officer has placed reliance on certain common features of the transactions undertaken with SEMPL, including the absence of a written agreement governing the provision of services aggregating to approximately ₹976 crore over a period of eight years and the absence of briefs, competing quotations, purchase-order trails and internal communications evidencing the procurement and execution of the services.

(b)

The second disallowance was Rs.2,97,88,716 on foreign travel, being two-thirds of Rs.4,46,83,075 (a charter cost of Rs.4,34,18,282 plus other expenses of Rs.12,64,793) for a trip to Colombia and the USA from 27.11.2014 to 09.12.2014. The AO attributed this share to the Chairman’s wife and daughter not related to the business of the assessee.

(c)

The third disallowance was Rs.4,02,39,040 out of Rs.34,80,39,258 paid to SEMPL for the FIFA World Cup 2014 event in Brazil. This was the cost of a 365 Aviation charter paid through Dream Business, which the AO found it not appear in the event invoices and treated as personal travel of the Chairman, masked within the event.

9.

In the appellate proceedings before CIT(A), the assessee raised ground on validity of reassessment as well as on the merits against the aforementioned disallowances made by the AO. The assessee filed detailed written submissions before CIT(A) along with corroborative evidence. On 19.03.2025, it also filed an application for admission of additional evidence in support of its Grounds 3 to 3.4 before Ld CIT(A), which relate to the foreign travel disallowance. Ld CIT(A) remanded the above submissions to the AO vide letter dated 08.08.2025 (F. No. CIT(A)-29/Remand Report/2025-26/262). The AO was directed to comment on the admission of the additional evidence and on the disallowance of expenses on domestic events organised through SEMPL and its linked entities. Ld CIT(A) gave this further opportunity after noting the assessee’s submission that the AO had examined evidence for only 14 events but had disallowed the entire domestic event expenditure. On the domestic events, Ld CIT(A) directed the AO to examine on three points :

(i)

Whether the documents relied on by the assessee had been filed during the assessment proceedings, as the assessee claimed.

(ii)

To verify the genuineness and correctness of those documents.

(iii)

To make such independent enquiry as he considered appropriate to verify whether the domestic events actually happened.

10.

During the remand proceedings the AO called for details from the assessee by a letter dated 30.09.2025, and the assessee replied on 08.10.2025. The AO further asked for a list of the domestic events, the internal process and standard operating procedures followed for planning them and for empanelling vendors, communications with vendors, permission letters from local authorities and details of invoices. The AO’s remand report dated 21.11.2025 (F. No. DCIT/CC-27/Remand Report/2025-26/927) was forwarded to Ld CIT(A) by the Addl. CIT, Central Range-7, under a letter dated 24.11.2025. On perusal of remand report received from AO, Ld CIT(A) recorded the following findings about that report:

(a)

That AO primarily reiterated the findings of the assessment order. The AO did not dispute that the assessee had filed documents with its submission dated 18.03.2024. The AO observed at paragraph 4.1 of the report that those documents had not been specifically discussed in the assessment order and stated that the material filed had been considered to the extent necessary.

(b)

That AO has stated in the remand proceedings, that the assessee had filed the same paper book as before and had not given a specific, point-wise reply. The AO mentioned that the assessee had produced no evidence that SALT was engaged under a predetermined internal policy or with the approval of a competent authority, no agreement or work order, no pre-event or post-event communication, and no internal approval or verification of the invoices. The AO said the rates charged were unsupported.

(c)

The AO repeated that the Tally screenshots of SEMPL, Space, Scoop and Fast showed that funds received from the assessee against invoices for domestic events were used to book charter flights for the Chairman through linked entities. The AO noted that Scoop and Space Monkey are similar entities managed by Sh. Hemant Dahiya and the Mutreja brothers.

(d)

The AO concluded that the evidence was not adequate to establish that the expenditure was incurred wholly and exclusively for business, and that the funds were diverted for the personal expenses of key persons. The AO therefore supported the disallowance made in the assessment order.

11.

On the additional evidence on foreign travel, which consisted of foreign currency purchase bills and a bank statement extract for USD 750 (Rs.46,821), the AO objected to its admission in the remand report. The AO pointed out that the assessee had been issued statutory notices dated 06.04.2023, 14.10.2023, 22.10.2023 and 16.02.2024 and had had sufficient opportunity. On the merits, the AO observed that the amount was paid through the bank account of Ms. Supriya Munjal, the Chairman’s daughter, and that such a small amount could not justify the expenditure of Rs.4,46,83,075 on the trip.

12.

Ld CIT(A) forwarded the remand report to the assessee on 24.11.2025, and the assessee filed replies dated 05.12.2025 and 23.01.2026. The assessee’s main points submitted before Ld CIT(A) were as follows :-

(a)

The remand report merely repeated the assessment order and set out nothing new. Even after two opportunities, the AO had not controverted any of the documentary evidence, and paragraph 4.1 of the report itself admitted that the AO had not discussed the evidence submitted with the letter of 18.03.2024.

(b)

The assessee had given a detailed reply on 08.10.2025 to the AO’s letter of 30.09.2025, so the AO’s statement that it gave no point-wise reply was factually incorrect. The information sought in the remand was largely the same as that sought in the notice of 14.10.2023 and the SCN of 10.02.2024, which the assessee had answered on 18.03.2024 with documentary evidence.

(c)

The procedural points raised by the AO, such as the absence of a standard operating procedure, were irrelevant because the assessee had placed on record evidence that the events actually took place, and many of the events were public events reported in the media. The assessee also filed a para-wise rebuttal of the remand report and a chart of the major domestic events.

13.

Ld CIT(A) eventually found that the AO had mainly reiterated the assessment order and had not verified the events despite the direction. Ld CIT(A) also found that the AO had in effect accepted that the expenditure was incurred on domestic events while noting that they were not verifiable. Ld CIT(A) vide its order dated 09.03.2026 upheld the validity of the reassessment. On various grounds raised by the assessee on validity of reassessment u/s 147 of the Act, Ld CIT(A) held that the requirement of “information” stands dispensed with in search cases. Further, Ld CIT(A) held that conditions of section 149(1)(b) of the Act were satisfied, because the escaped income was in the form of expenditure exceeding Rs.50 lakh. Ld CIT(A) rejected the plea of mechanical sanction on the ground that superior authorities monitor such cases as a matter of practice. Ld CIT(A) further held that, since the assessee itself was a searched person, no separate approval under Explanation 2(iii)/(iv) to section 148 was needed to rely on material found in the search of third parties. Ld CIT(A) dismissed the plea that the notice, having been issued by the jurisdictional Assessing Officer and not by the Faceless Assessing Officer, contravened section 151A of the Act, observing that the assessee had fairly admitted this plea to be covered against it by the judgment of the jurisdictional High Court in T.K.S. Builders (P.) Ltd. v. Income Tax Officer, (2024) 469 ITR 657 (Del.).

14.

However on the merits, Ld CIT(A) gave partial relief to the assessee, as follows :-

(a)

Domestic events. Ld CIT(A) held that the domestic events were of a routine nature, that many of them were public events, that the AO had pinpointed no discrepancy in the documents filed, and that the Chairman’s foreign travel had itself been accepted as official. On that basis Ld CIT(A) held that disallowing the entire expenditure was unwarranted. Ld CIT(A) referred the AO’s remand report dated 21.11.2025 accepting that the events did take place, but not their quantum. Ld CIT(A) nevertheless sustained the disallowance for the 14 events identified by the AO, which are spread across AYs 2014-15 to 2018-19, on the strength of the money trail, the statement of Sh. Hemant Dahiya and the absence of concrete rebuttal, observing that there was doubt whether the expenditure was wholly and exclusively for business. For the lead year AY 2015-16 under consideration, the quantum was taken from the assessee’s own year-wise break-up dated 23.01.2026, which showed four events with expenditure of Rs.9,05,92,334/-, of which Rs.8,06,26,855/- was debited to the profit and loss account . Ld CIT(A) deleted the balance of the disallowance, namely Rs.80,60,76,963/-.

(b)

Foreign travel. Ld CIT(A) admitted additional evidence, being foreign currency purchase bills of USD 750 (Rs.46,821/-), because no specific show-cause notice had been issued on the proportionate disallowance and the AO’s remand report did not specifically deny this. Ld CIT(A) deleted Rs.1,48,94,358, being the one-third attributed to the Chairman’s wife, following the decision of the Delhi Bench of the Tribunal in the appellant’s own case, Hero Honda Motors Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, [2006] 103 ITD 157 (Del.). Ld CIT(A) sustained Rs.1,48,94,358/-, being the one-third attributed to the daughter and other family members and rejected the argument that the charter cost would have been the same in any event.

(c)

Foreign event (FIFA 2014).Ld CIT(A) sustained the whole disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040/-. Ld CIT(A) examined the invoice and break-up sheet of invoice nos. 2094 and 2095 and found that the cost of the charter booked by Dream business or Fast Conversion through 365 Aviation was not separately included in them. Ld CIT(A) also noted that SEMPL had not responded to the notice under section 133(6).

15.

In summary, the key figures showing the amount of disallowance which are deleted and sustained by CIT(A) are summarised below :-

Nature of expenses Disallowance Amount deleted Amount made by AO by CIT(A) (Rs.) sustained by (Rs.) CIT(A) (Rs.) Domestic events (SEMPL, 88,67,03,816/- 80,60,76,963/- 8,06,26,855/-Scoop, Space) Foreign travel 2,97,88,716/- 1,48,94,358/- 1,48,94,358/-(Colombia/USA trip) Foreign event - FIFA 2014, 4,02,39,040/- Nil 4,02,39,040/-Brazil

16.

Aggrieved with the above order, both sides filed appeals before us. The assessee is in appeal on validity of initiation of reassessment proceedings u/s 147 of the Act as well on the part disallowances sustained by Ld CIT(A). The Revenue is in appeal against the deletion of Rs.80,60,76,963 (domestic events) and Rs.1,48,94,358/- (foreign travel, wife’s share) by Ld CIT(A). The relevant grounds raised by the parties are given below:

1.

The assessee’s grounds of appeal are as follows:

“Re: Validity of reassessment proceedings

1.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [‘CIT(A)’] erred in upholding the validity of the reassessment order dated 30.03.2024 and in not quashing the same by holding the assessment order to be illegal and bad in law.

1.1

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, Ld CIT(A) erred in not appreciating that reassessment order although dated 30.03.2024, was received by the appellant on 03.04.2024, and consequently the assessment order is barred by limitation prescribed u/s 153(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (“the Act”).

1.2

That Ld CIT(A) erred in law in upholding the validity of the re-assessment order, without appreciating that the impugned reassessment proceedings were initiated undisputedly without complying with the jurisdictional mandate of taking prior approval in terms of Explanation 2(iii)/(iv), and in instead wrongly relying upon Explanation 2(i) of section 148 of the Act.

1.3

That CIT(A) erred on facts and in law in not appreciating that jurisdictional approval in terms of Explanation 2(iii)/(iv) of section 148 is sine qua non for assumption of valid jurisdiction and in wrongly upholding the validity of the assessment order merely on the ground that search was carried out in the case of the Appellant.

1.4

That CIT(A) erred on facts and in law in not appreciating that the reassessment proceedings were barred by limitation under section 149 inasmuch as the reopening is barred by limitation of 3 years and also non-fulfilment of grandfathered condition of “asset” in terms of fourth proviso to section 153A(1) of the Act.

1.5

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the validity of the reassessment order without appreciating that the impugned order is bad in law since: (i) valid notice under section 143(2) had not been issued; (ii) invalid/mechanical sanction was granted u/s 151(ii) of the Act; and (iii) there is no DIN on proforma for seeking reasons and/or approval of sanctioning authority.

1.6

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the validity of the assessment order, without appreciating that the reassessment proceedings were wrongly initiated on the basis of invalid/unreliable third-party “information” and there has been blatant violation by the assessing officer of the mandatory procedure of disposing legal objections as laid down in GKN Driveshaft India Ltd. 259 ITR 19 (SC).

1.7

That CIT(A) erred in upholding the validity of the assessment order, without appreciating that the impugned assessment order, accompanying ITNS computation form and demand notice issued under section 156 of the Act, has been passed without affixing digital signature, which is sine qua non for passing a valid assessment order as part of the e-assessment proceedings.

1.8

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the validity of the assessment order, without appreciating that the impugned assessment order was passed in contravention of principles of natural justice and fair play, inasmuch as the assessing officer relied upon ex-parte/third-party material, without reasonable/proper opportunity of rebuttal/cross-examination to the Appellant.

Re: Disallowance of expense of Rs.8,06,26,855 incurred on domestic events

2.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the disallowance to the extent of Rs.8,06,26,855 (out of total disallowance of Rs.88,67,03,816), being expense incurred by the appellant on organizing 14 domestic events, holding the same to be non-allowable.

2.1

That on the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld CIT(A) erred in confirming the aforesaid part disallowance of Rs.8,06,26,855, despite agreeing with the appellant that: (a) domestic events actually took place, many of which were public events; (b) complete documentary evidences in support of the domestic events were duly filed; and (c) assessing officer, despite repeated opportunities including during remand proceedings, was not able to pinpoint any cogent material/evidence to substantiate his claim that the 14 identified domestic events did not happen.

2.2

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the part disallowance vaguely observing/concluding, “there is doubt with regard to the expenditure in respect of 14 identified events” as having been incurred for business purposes.

2.3

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the aforesaid disallowance partly, by merely reiterating conjectures and surmises of the assessing officer that there was some pattern/link regarding the 14 domestic events and the foreign travel undertaken by the Chairman/MD of the appellant, that too, based on presumed adverse inferences being drawn from unreliable third-party material.

2.4

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the aforesaid disallowance in respect of 14 domestic events despite accepting that entire foreign travel of the Chairman/MD has undisputedly been accepted even by the assessing officer to be for official/business purposes and without appreciating that in case of a corporate entity, being an artificial juridical person, there is, per se, no concept of any personal expense.

Re: Disallowance of expenses Rs.1,48,94,358 incurred on foreign travel

3.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the disallowance of Rs.1,48,94,358 (out of total disallowance of Rs.2,97,88,716), being proportionate air-travel cost/other expenses allegedly pertaining to the family members (other than spouse) of the Chairman of the appellant, as non-allowable.

3.1

That on the facts and circumstances of the case and in law, Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the said disallowance, without appreciating that expenses related to the family members were not borne/claimed by the appellant.

3.2

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the disallowance of business expenses by treating the same as personal expenses, without appreciating that in case of a corporate entity, being an artificial juridical person, there is, per se, no concept of any personal expense.

Re: Disallowance of expenses of Rs.4,02,39,040 incurred on foreign events

4.

That on the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040 out of payment of Rs.34,80,39,258 made to M/s SALT Experience & Management Pvt. Ltd. (M/s SEMPL) for organizing foreign events by alleging/treating the same as personal travel expenses of Chairman of the appellant.

4.1

That Ld CIT(A) erred in not appreciating that travel of the Chairman for attending foreign events sponsored by appellant/attending business meetings, was accepted as official/business purpose and only the component alleged to be attributable to the travel of family was disallowed under section 37(1) of the Act.

4.2

That on the facts and circumstances of the case, Ld CIT(A) erred in not appreciating the submissions/evidences furnished by the appellant and drawing adverse inference merely on the ground that M/s SEMPL failed to furnish response to notice issued under section 133(6) of the Act.

4.3

That Ld CIT(A) erred in upholding the disallowance of business expenses by treating the same as personal expenses, without appreciating that in case of a corporate entity, being an artificial juridical person, there is, per se, no concept of any personal expense.”

2.

The Revenue’s grounds of appeal in challenge to Ld CIT(A)’s order on two issues only. The grounds are as follows:

“1.

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the learned Commissioner of Income Tax Appeals erred in restricting the disallowance of domestic event expenditure from Rs.88,67,03,818 to Rs.8,06,26,855 without appreciating the evidence brought on record during the course of search, post-search investigations and assessment proceedings, which established a systematic diversion of funds for non-business purposes?

2.

Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in law and on facts in holding that the disallowance could be confined only to the 14 identified domestic events occurring during the relevant assessment year, ignoring that the said events were merely illustrative instances demonstrating the modus operandi adopted by the assessee for diversion of funds and not the sole basis of the disallowance?

3.

Whether the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that while examining the allowability of expenditure under section 37(1), the real nature of the transaction, surrounding circumstances, money trail and ultimate utilisation of funds are relevant considerations and cannot be ignored merely because supporting documents have been produced by the assessee?

4.

Whether the learned CIT(A) erred in restricting the disallowance of foreign travel from Rs.2,97,88,716 to Rs.1,48,94,358 by treating the expenditure incurred on the foreign travel of the spouse of Shri Pawan Munjal as allowable business expenditure without any evidence establishing that her participation in the foreign visits was necessitated by business expediency or that she performed any identifiable business function during such visits?

5.

Whether the learned CIT(A) failed to appreciate that, in the absence of evidence demonstrating business necessity, the expenditure incurred on the travel, boarding and lodging of the spouse constituted personal expenditure not allowable under section 37(1) of the Act and liable to be treated as a benefit/perquisite extended to the Chairman?”

17.

At the time of hearing, the ld. AR, Mr. Ajay Vohra, Senior Advocate, appearing on behalf of the assessee, submitted that the impugned reassessment order dated 30th March 2024, passed under section 147 read with section 143(3) of the Act, was unsustainable both on jurisdictional grounds and on merits. The assessee challenged the order of the learned Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)-29, New Delhi, insofar as the latter upheld the validity of the reassessment and sustained partial disallowances made by the Assessing Officer (“AO”). The assessee also supported the relief granted by the learned CIT(A) in respect of the domestic-event expenditure and the foreign-travel expenditure challenged by the Revenue.

18.

The ld. AR submitted that the assessee is a public listed company engaged in the manufacture and sale of two-wheelers and operates in a highly competitive market. Its expenditure on advertising, publicity, product promotion, customer engagement and brand-building activities is an integral part of its business operations. During the relevant previous year, the assessee incurred expenditure on domestic promotional events and an international event, besides expenditure on foreign travel undertaken by its Chairman and Managing Director (“CMD”) for business purposes.

19.

The ld. AR submitted that the reassessment arose out of the search conducted on 23th March 2022 in the case of the assessee and the search proceedings involving SALT Experience & Management Pvt. Ltd. (“SEMPL”) and other entities associated with the SALT group. The AO alleged that the assessee had routed funds through SEMPL and its connected entities, including Dream Business Solutions (“Dream”) and Fast Conversion (“Fast”), which were ultimately utilised to meet the cost of charter flights arranged through 365 Aviation Ltd., United Kingdom. The Revenue sought to connect the expenditure claimed by the assessee on promotional events with the alleged personal foreign-travel expenditure of the CMD.

20.

The ld. AR denied that the payments made by the assessee towards domestic events or the FIFA World Cup event were fictitious or represented personal expenditure. It was submitted that the events had taken place, that the expenditure was supported by invoices and other contemporaneous records, and that payments had been made through banking channels and duly recorded in the books of account. The assessee contended that the Revenue had relied upon material obtained from third parties without satisfying the statutory requirements governing the use of such material and without establishing, by reliable evidence, that the expenditure claimed by the assessee was not incurred for business purposes.

21.

The ld. AR accordingly submitted that the reassessment proceedings were liable to be quashed on jurisdictional grounds. Without prejudice to that primary contention, the AR submitted that the additions and disallowances made under section 37(1) were also unsustainable on merits for want of adequate evidence establishing that the expenditure was fictitious, personal or otherwise inadmissible.

22.

With regard to Ground Nos. 1.2 and 1.3: Applicability of Explanation 2(iii) and (iv) to section 148 and the alleged absence of the prescribed approval, the learned AR submitted that the AO had proceeded on the basis of documents and information obtained during search proceedings involving SEMPL and its connected entities. Although a search under section 132 had also been conducted in the case of the assessee on 23rd March 2022, the assessee disputed that the material forming the foundation of the impugned additions had been found in its own premises or that any incriminating material recovered from its premises established the alleged diversion of funds.

23.

In this regard, the ld. AR drew our attention to paragraph 3 of the communication dated 22th December 2023, by which the AO supplied the reasons recorded for reopening. According to the AR, the communication referred to material seized during search proceedings conducted on “the parties related to Hero MotoCorp Group”. It was submitted that this description supported the assessee’s contention that the reopening was founded, at least substantially, on third-party search material.

24.

The ld. AR submitted that the reasons recorded by the AO invoked Explanation 2(i) to section 148 on the footing that a search had been initiated in the case of the assessee. However, neither the reasons nor the approval under section 151(ii), according to the AR, demonstrated that the AO had separately considered the requirements contemplated by Explanation 2(iii) or Explanation 2(iv), insofar as the reopening was founded upon material seized from another person.

25.

Ld. AR contended that the statutory deeming provision could not be read as authorising the AO to disregard the safeguards applicable to material seized from third parties. Where the AO relies upon books of account, documents or other material found in the course of proceedings involving another person and seeks to use that material against the assessee, the statutory conditions governing the attribution of such material to the assessee must be satisfied. According to the assessee, the necessary satisfaction and approval were substantive jurisdictional requirements and could not be supplied retrospectively by the AO's subsequent explanation of the alleged modus operandi.

26.

The ld. AR relied upon the decisions of the Hyderabad Bench of the Tribunal in Exel Rubber Pvt. Ltd., ITA Nos. 1566 and 1571/Hyd/2025, and Vamsiram Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, ITA Nos. 661 to 667/Hyd/2026. As recorded in the assessee’s synopsis, the AR relied upon these decisions for the proposition that the statutory procedure governing third-party material cannot be bypassed merely because the AO seeks to invoke the reassessment machinery under sections 147 and 148.

27.

The ld. AR further submitted that the distinction between the material found during the assessee’s own search and material seized from third parties was material to the exercise of jurisdiction. The fact that the assessee was searched could not, according to the AR, dispense with the need to establish the statutory basis on which the particular material relied upon by the AO was deemed to constitute information suggesting escapement of income in the assessee’s case.

28.

It was accordingly submitted that, in the absence of the requisite satisfaction and approval contemplated by the applicable provisions, the notice issued under section 148 and the consequential reassessment proceedings were invalid. The ld. AR prayed that the reassessment be quashed on this ground.

29.

With regard to Ground no. 1.4, limitation u/s 149 and first proviso thereto, the ld. AR submitted that the notice under section 148 was issued on 2th March 2023 for AY 2015-16, whereas three years from the end of the relevant assessment year had expired on 31st March 2019. The notice was, therefore, beyond the ordinary three-year period contemplated by section 149(1)(a). According to the assessee, the Revenue could sustain the notice only if the statutory requirements for invoking the extended period under section 149(1)(b), together with the applicable provisos, were satisfied.

30.

Ld. AR submitted that the question of limitation could not be determined merely by observing that the notice had been issued within the outer period of ten years. The extended period was subject to substantive statutory conditions, and the AO was required to possess the prescribed books of account, documents or evidence revealing the requisite escapement of income. The statutory conditions had to be examined with reference to the material available when the notice was issued and the reasons recorded for reopening.

31.

The ld. AR placed particular reliance upon the first proviso to section 149(1), which provides a transitional or grandfathering restriction for notices relating to assessment years covered by the earlier limitation regime. According to the assessee, for AY 2021-22 or any earlier assessment year, a notice could not be issued under the amended provisions if it would have been time-barred under the applicable provisions of sections 149, 153A or 153C, as they stood before the relevant amendments.

32.

The ld. AR submitted that the search in the assessee’s case was conducted on 23rd March 2022, falling in AY 2022-23. Under the assessee’s computation, the ordinary six-year block under the erstwhile section 153A extended from AY 2016-17 to AY 2021-22. AY 2015-16 was, therefore, outside that block. The assessee contended that the Revenue could reach AY 2015-16 only by satisfying the additional conditions prescribed by the fourth proviso to section 153A(1), as applicable under the earlier statutory regime.

33.

According to the ld. AR, the fourth proviso to the erstwhile section 153A(1) permitted the extended reach to an assessment year beyond the ordinary six-year block only where the prescribed books of account, documents or evidence revealed income chargeable to tax represented in the form of an “asset”, of the nature contemplated by the statutory provision, and the monetary threshold was satisfied. The AR referred to the statutory explanation concerning assets, including immovable property, shares and securities, loans and advances, and deposits in bank accounts.

34.

The ld. AR submitted that the essential asset condition was absent in the present case. The alleged escapement arose from the AO’s proposed disallowance of expenditure claimed under section 37(1), on the allegation that expenditure recorded as business expenditure had allegedly been used to meet personal foreign-travel costs. The reasons recorded, according to the AR, did not identify any asset in which the alleged escaped income was represented. Nor did they state that the conditions of the fourth proviso to the erstwhile section 153A(1) had been satisfied.

35.

The ld. AR also invited our attention to Annexure 4 to the written synopsis, which sets out a detailed year-wise chart dealing with the applicability of the limitation provisions to the assessment years under consideration, which is reproduced as under:-

Annexure 4:

Applicability of limitation argument in each of the assessment years

Relevant Facts

1.

Date of Search – 23.03.2022 [Accordingly, Assessment Year 2022-23 is the year of search]

2.

Date of issuance of Notice under section 148 of the Act:

(i)

02.03.2023 for AYs 2013-14 to 2017-18

(ii)

18.08.2022 for AY 2019-20

3.

Tabular Chart basis the principle laid down by Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT vs. Ojjus Medicare (P.) Ltd.: [2024] 465 ITR 101 (Delhi), for computing the 6- year or 10-year assessment block is as under:

Date of Search: 23.03.2022 Relevant Financial Year of Search: FY 2021-22 Relevant Assessment Year: AY 2022-23 Immediately preceding year to the Relevant Assessment Year: AY 2021-22

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

-1
12
23
34
45
56
67

Erstwhile section AY2015-16 - 8 153AGrandfathered:

AY2014-15-9

evidence/documents of income AY2013-14 - 10 being represented by some undisclosed ‘asset’ and in excess of fifty lakh rupees

4.

Proceedings were reopened vide notice dated 02.03.2023 (for AYs 2013-14 to 2017-18) and 18.08.2022 (for AY 2019-20) issued under section 148 of the Act. Accordingly, the various years are categorised as under:

Assessment Period Relevant Whether applicable conditions satisfied or not years provisions AY 2019-20 Within 3 Section 149(1)(a) Conditions of section 149(1)(a) and the years of the Act fundamental requirement of escapement of income to be satisfied are fulfilled – satisfied AY 2018-19 Beyond 3 Section 149(1)(b) Reassessment proceedings are ongoing. years and of the Act read within 4 with first proviso years thereto and jurisprudence in context of earlier section 147 of the Act like change of opinion, etc. AY 2017-18 Beyond 4 Section 149(1)(b) 1. Income escaping assessment more than years but read with first Rs.50 Lakhs -within 6 proviso thereto satisfied 2. Case of change of years and also read opinion – no such finding given with first 3. AO has in his possession books of proviso to accounts/other earlier preamended documents or evidence of escaped section income represented in 147 of the Act form of (i) asset or (ii) expenditure in respect of a transaction/ event; or (iii) entry in the books – no such finding given 4. There must be failure on part of assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment – no such finding given AY 2016-17 Beyond 4 Section 149(1)(b) 1. Income escaping assessment more than years but read with first Rs.50 Lakhs -within 6 proviso thereto satisfied 2. Case of change of years and also read opinion – no such with first finding given 3. AO has in his proviso to possession books of accounts/other earlier preamended documents or section evidence of escaped income represented in 147 of the Act form of (i) asset or (ii) expenditure in respect of a transaction/ event; or (iii) entry in the books – Case of change of opinion – no such finding given 4. There must be failure on part of assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for assessment – no such finding given

AY 2015-16 7th year Section 149(1)(b) 1. Income escaping assessment more than preceding read with first Rs.50 Lakhs – the year of proviso thereto satisfied 2. Case of change of search and also read opinion – no such with fourth finding given 3. There must be failure proviso to on part of assessee to disclose fully and section 153A of truly all material facts the Act necessary for assessment – no such finding given 4. Condition of “Asset” in terms of fourth proviso to section 153A of the Act – no such finding given

AY 2014-15 8th year Section 149(1)(b) 1. Income escaping assessment more than preceding read with first Rs.50 Lakhs -the year of proviso thereto satisfied 2. Case of change of search and also read opinion – no such with fourth finding given 3. There must be failure proviso to on part of assessee to disclose fully and section 153A of truly all material facts the Act necessary for assessment – no such finding given 4. Condition of “Asset” in terms of fourth proviso to section 153A of the Act – no such finding given

AY 2013-14 9th year Section 149(1)(b) 1. Income escaping assessment more than preceding read with first Rs.50 Lakhs -the year of proviso thereto satisfied 2. Case of change of opinion – no such search and also read finding given 3. There must be failure with fourth on part of assessee to proviso to disclose fully and truly all material facts section 153A of necessary for the Act assessment – no such finding given 4. Condition of “Asset” in terms of fourth proviso to section 153A of the Act – no such finding given

36.

The learned AR further submitted that the approval obtained for issuance of the notice referred to expenditure in respect of a transaction or in relation to an event or occasion, which is associated with the amended section 149(1)(b). It did not, according to the assessee, establish the distinct asset condition necessary to bring AY 2015-16 within the extended period under the erstwhile section 153A. The satisfaction of the monetary threshold and the identification of an asset were separate statutory requirements and could not be treated as interchangeable.

37.

The assessee emphasised that the Revenue’s reliance upon bank transactions involving Dream, Fast and 365 Aviation did not establish that the alleged escaped income of the assessee was represented by an asset of the prescribed nature. The fact that money had passed through bank accounts maintained by third parties, or that such accounts recorded payments to an aviation company, did not by itself demonstrate the existence of an asset representing the assessee’s escaped income. According to the AR, the alleged expenditure was consumed in the procurement of services and was not shown to have resulted in the acquisition of an asset by the assessee.

38.

The relevant limitation framework relied upon by the assessee may be summarised as follows:

Period under Statutory provisions Principal conditions contended to be consideration relied upon applicable Within three years from Section 149(1)(a) Compliance with the applicable conditions the end of the relevant for issuance of notice within the ordinary assessment year limitation period Beyond three years and Section 149(1)(b), read Escaped income meeting the prescribed up to four years with the first proviso and threshold and the other applicable the applicable pre- statutory conditions amended law Beyond four years Section 149(1)(b), read In addition to the applicable conditions, with the first proviso to failure on the assessee’s part to disclose section 149 and the first fully and truly all material facts, where proviso to the erstwhile required under the former law section 147 Beyond six years from Section 149(1)(b), read The assessee contends that the escaped the relevant search-year with the first proviso to income must be represented by an “asset” framework and up to section 149 and the of the prescribed nature and meet the ten years fourth proviso to section Rs.50 lakh threshold, besides satisfying 153A(1) the applicable grandfathering conditions

39.

In support of this contention, the learned AR relied upon the following judicial authorities, as cited in the synopsis:

 Smart Chip (P) Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 476 ITR 389 (Delhi);

 Dinesh Jindal v. ACIT 469 ITR 32 (Delhi);

 Flowmore Ltd. v. DCIT 467 ITR 177 (Delhi);

 KAD Housing (Delhi High Court);

 Saurabh Gupta (Delhi High Court); and

 Span Developers (Mumbai Bench of the Tribunal).

40.

The AR relied upon these authorities for the proposition that the statutory conditions governing the extended limitation period must be strictly satisfied and that a mere allegation of escaped income, including a proposed disallowance of expenditure, does not dispense with the specific asset-related condition applicable under the former statutory regime.

41.

The assessee also referred to the decisions in Ratnagiri Gas and Power (P) Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 174 taxmann.com 331 (Delhi), Azim Premji Trustee Co. (Karnataka High Court), JKM Infra Projects (Delhi Bench of the Tribunal), Vamsiram Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT and Alsorg Interiors India Pvt. Ltd. v. DCIT, ITA Nos. 4631 to 4637/Del/2025. The AR relied upon these authorities in support of the broader submission that the validity of a notice issued beyond the ordinary limitation period must be tested against the applicable statutory conditions and the actual reasons and material relied upon by the AO.

42.

The assessee further submitted that the reasons recorded could not be supplemented at a later stage by a different jurisdictional basis not forming part of the recorded satisfaction. The validity of the notice had to be tested by reference to the reasons recorded and the approval granted at the time of initiation. According to the assessee, the Revenue could not cure the absence of the requisite asset-related satisfaction by subsequently arguing that bank deposits or transactions involving third parties should be treated as assets.

43.

The assessee also challenged the invocation of section 149(1)(b). It was submitted that the fact that expenditure had been debited in the regular books of account did not automatically establish that the case satisfied the statutory requirements for invoking the extended limitation period. The AO was required to identify the relevant statutory limb, the evidence revealing the alleged escapement and the basis for concluding that the prescribed monetary threshold was met. The assessee contended that the reasons did not adequately identify the particular statutory basis on which the extended period was invoked.

44.

The AR submitted that the recorded reasons referred to an alleged escapement of Rs.99,25,92,409/- in relation to domestic-event expenditure. However, the reassessment ultimately resulted in disallowances under three separate heads, namely domestic-event expenditure, foreign travel and the FIFA World Cup event. According to the assessee, the difference between the amount referred to in the reasons and the additions ultimately made further demonstrated the need to scrutinise whether the statutory requirements had been properly satisfied at the initiation stage.

45.

In view of the above, the learned AR submitted that the notice dated 2th March 2023 was beyond the ordinary three-year period and could not be sustained under the extended period unless the AO had satisfied the conditions of section 149(1)(b) and the applicable grandfathering provisions. Since the reasons and approval, according to the assessee, did not establish the asset condition necessary to reach AY 2015-16 under the erstwhile section 153A, the notice and the consequential reassessment were liable to be quashed.

46.

Without prejudice to the above submissions, the learned AR submitted that the reopening was also inconsistent with the restrictions governing reassessment under the provisions applicable before the relevant amendments. The assessee had originally filed its return for AY 2015-16 on 27th November 2015, declaring total income of Rs.2,569,18,96,630/-. The original assessment under section 143(3) read with section 144C was completed on 30th October 2019, determining total income of Rs.3,146,87,81,016/- under the normal provisions and book profit of Rs.3,557,57,46,134/- under section 115JB.

47.

The ld. AR submitted that the expenditure on advertising, publicity and promotional activities had been recorded in the books and disclosed in the course of the regular assessment proceedings. The reopening did not, according to the assessee, identify any failure on its part to disclose fully and truly all material facts necessary for the assessment. It was contended that the Revenue was seeking to revisit a claim already reflected in the regular books and examined in the earlier assessment.

48.

Learned AR relied upon CIT v. Kelvinator of India Ltd. (Supreme Court) and Ratnagiri Gas and Power (P) Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 174 taxmann.com 331 (Delhi) in support of the submission that reassessment cannot be used as a mechanism for reviewing a completed assessment in the absence of the statutory conditions and fresh tangible material required by law. Learned AR submitted that the AO could not substitute a subsequent inference regarding the commercial character of disclosed expenditure for the conditions necessary to assume reassessment jurisdiction.

49.

It was accordingly submitted that the reopening was an impermissible review of disclosed expenditure and was not supported by the necessary allegation of failure to disclose fully and truly all material facts. This contention was advanced as an additional ground supporting the assessee’s primary challenge to the validity of the notice.

50.

With regard to ground no.1.5, alleged invalidity/mechanical grant of sanction, ld. AR submitted that the approval granted for issuance of the notice under section 148 was not a valid exercise of the statutory power. According to the assessee, the approval was in the nature of a mechanical endorsement and did not demonstrate independent consideration of the jurisdictional requirements governing the proposed reassessment.

51.

It was submitted that the approval did not adequately address whether the information relied upon by the AO was derived from the assessee’s own search or from searches conducted in the cases of third parties. Nor did it demonstrate consideration of the special limitation conditions applicable to AY 2015-16, which, according to the assessee, fell outside the ordinary six-year block under the erstwhile section 153A.

52.

Ld. AR relied upon Chhugamal Rajpal v. S.P. Chaliha (1971) 79 ITR 603 (SC), United Electrical Co. (P) Ltd. v. CIT 258 ITR 317 (Delhi) and Yum! Restaurants (India) Pvt. Ltd. 397 ITR 665 (Delhi). These authorities were cited in support of the proposition that the sanctioning authority must exercise the statutory power with due application of mind and that approval cannot be treated as a mere formality where the statute requires prior satisfaction.

53.

Learned AR accordingly submitted that the approval should be examined in conjunction with the recorded reasons and the applicable limitation provisions. The discrepancy between the reference in the assessment order to approval by the CCIT (Central), Delhi, dated 1 March 2023, and the Revenue’s assertion that approval had been granted by the PCCIT on 24 February 2023 was also stated to require verification from the original approval record.

54.

As regards the notice under section 143(2), the assessee’s acknowledged the decision of the Special Bench of the Tribunal in MD Sons v. ITO [2026] 188 taxmann.com 703 (Bengaluru-Tribunal, Special Bench), which was averse to the assessee on the issue. The AR’s synopsis did not advance a separate substantive argument beyond identifying the ground. The assessee’s overall challenge to jurisdiction, however, was maintained on the other grounds relating to limitation, sanction and the use of third-party information.

55.

With regard to DIN and approval proforma, learned AR also challenged the absence of a Document Identification Number (“DIN”) on the proforma relating to the request for reasons and approval. According to the assessee, the statutory and administrative requirements governing the issuance of communications could not be treated as satisfied merely because a separate communication or covering notice bore a DIN, if the relevant document itself was required to comply with those requirements.

56.

The assessee’s contention was that the original proforma and approval documents should be examined to determine whether the prescribed requirements had been complied with. The AR submitted that the validity of the reassessment should be assessed on the basis of the actual documents issued and maintained on record, rather than on a general assertion that the communications were covered by a DIN.

57.

With regard to Ground No. 1.6, learned AR submitted that the reasons recorded for reopening contained a general description of an alleged modus operandi involving SEMPL and its connected entities but did not identify with sufficient clarity the material establishing the assessee’s alleged escapement of income. According to the AR, the reasons did not adequately identify the source of the appraisal report, the particular entities and transactions relied upon, or the manner in which the amount of Rs.99,25,92,409/- had been quantified for AY 2015-16.

58.

It was submitted that the amount mentioned in the reasons was not the same as the aggregate disallowances ultimately made in the reassessment. The AO made a disallowance of Rs.88,67,03,816/- in respect of domestic events, Rs.2,97,88,716/- in respect of foreign travel, and Rs.4,02,39,040/- in respect of the FIFA World Cup event. The AR contended that the difference in the figures reinforced the need for the AO to demonstrate a rational and evidentiary connection between the material relied upon and the income alleged to have escaped assessment.

59.

Learned AR submitted that Explanation 2 to section 148 could not be read as dispensing with the requirement that the AO should have material capable of supporting the particular reopening for the relevant assessment year. Even if the existence of information was deemed under the provision, the contents of that information, the amount allegedly escaping assessment and the connection with the assessee’s income remained material to the validity of the proceedings.

60.

In support of this contention, learned AR relied upon:

 ITO v. Lakhmani Mewal Das 103 ITR 437 (SC);

 Divya Capital One Pvt. Ltd. 445 ITR 436 (Delhi);

 Sagar Mukesh Sheth v. ITO [2026] 311 Taxman 57 (Gujarat); and

 Vamsiram Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT, ITA Nos. 661 to 667/Hyd/2026.

61.

Ld. AR relied upon these authorities for the proposition that the existence of a search or a general allegation of a modus operandi does not, without a legally sufficient nexus to the assessee and the relevant assessment year, conclude the question of valid reassessment jurisdiction.

62.

The learned AR further submitted that the transactions relied upon by the Revenue involved payments through banking channels and entries recorded in the books of account. The books had been audited, and the assessee contended that the Revenue had not established that the payments recorded as business expenditure were fictitious merely because the subsequent movement of funds through third-party entities was viewed with suspicion.

63.

It was accordingly submitted that the information relied upon was insufficient to support the reopening in the manner undertaken by the AO. The AR prayed that the reassessment be quashed for want of a valid jurisdictional foundation.

Alleged non-disposal of detailed objections

64.

With regard to alleged non-disposal of detailed objections, learned AR also referred to the preliminary objections raised by the assessee by letters dated 31st March 2023, 12th April 2023, 1st May 2023 and 23rd October 2023, followed by detailed objections dated 29th December 2023. The assessee contended that the detailed objections had not been disposed of by a reasoned order before completion of the reassessment.

65.

The assessee relied upon GKN Driveshafts (India) Ltd. v. ITO (2003) 259 ITR 19 (SC) in support of the requirement that objections to reopening be disposed of in accordance with the procedure prescribed by law. According to the assessee, the communication dated 22nd December 2023, which supplied the reasons and approval proforma, did not constitute a reasoned disposal of the detailed objections subsequently filed on 29 December 2023.

66.

The assessee accordingly submitted that the procedural requirements governing reassessment had not been duly followed. This contention was advanced in support of the challenge to the validity of the proceedings, although the synopsis did not develop this limb as a separate substantive argument to the same extent as the limitation and third-party-material objections.

67.

With regard to ground nos. 2 to 2.4, without prejudice to the jurisdictional objections, learned AR submitted that the AO had erred in disallowing Rs.88,67,03,816/-, being the expenditure recorded by the assessee in connection with domestic promotional events organised through SEMPL, Scoop Brand Holdings Pvt. Ltd. (“Scoop”), Space Monkey Media Project Pvt. Ltd. (“Space”) and connected entities.

68.

The learned AR submitted that the assessee is a leading manufacturer of two-wheelers operating in a highly competitive industry. Promotional activities, product launches, customer engagement programmes, brand activations, sporting events and media-related campaigns were necessary components of the assessee’s business. Such expenditure was incurred to promote its products, maintain brand recognition and support its commercial operations.

69.

The AR referred to the ratio of advertising and publicity expenditure to revenue from operations over the period FY 2012-13 to FY 2019-20. The figures relied upon in the synopsis were as follows:

Financial Revenue from Advertising and publicity Approximate year operations (₹ crore) expenditure (₹ crore) ratio

FY 2012-13 23,768 469 2.0%

FY 2013-14 25,275 493 2.0%

FY 2014-15 27,585 669 2.4%

FY 2015-16 30,701 725 2.4%

FY 2016-17 30,872 767 2.5%

FY 2017-18 32,872 838 2.5%

FY 2018-19 33,651 804 2.4%

FY 2019-20 28,836 720 2.5%

70.

According to the learned. AR, the above figures demonstrated that advertising and publicity expenditure remained within a broadly consistent range of approximately 2.0% to 2.5% of revenue from operations. The expenditure was not an isolated or abnormal feature of the relevant year but formed part of the assessee’s recurring business activity. The AR further submitted that expenditure of this nature had been claimed in earlier years and had been considered in the course of scrutiny assessments.

Documentary evidence and banking-channel payments

71.

With regard to documentary evidence and banking channel payments, learned AR submitted that the payments aggregating Rs.88,67,03,816/- were duly recorded in the books of account and were supported by event-wise details, invoices, purchase orders and cost break-ups. The AR referred to Paper Book Volume III, pages 1148 to 2454, and Volume IV, pages 2720 to 2730, as containing the relevant supporting documentation.

72.

It was submitted that the payments had been made through banking channels and were not unrecorded cash payments. The assessee maintained audited books of account, and the AR contended that the AO had not established that the invoices were fictitious or that the underlying events had not occurred. The assessee disputed the inference that the subsequent movement of funds between the event-management entities and other third parties automatically rendered the original expenditure non-business expenditure in the hands of the assessee.

73.

Learned AR submitted that the AO had examined only a limited number of events, whereas the assessee had undertaken a substantially larger number of events during the year. The assessee referred to approximately 184 events for the relevant year, of which the AO examined four in detail. Across the connected assessment years, the AO identified 14 events as illustrative instances of the alleged modus operandi.

74.

According to the AR, the AO had extrapolated the allegations arising from the selected events to the entire expenditure without undertaking an event-wise examination of the remaining transactions. The assessee submitted that a finding concerning one event or one transaction could not automatically justify disallowance of all payments made to an event-management company, particularly where the expenditure related to multiple programmes, campaigns and activities.

75.

In particular learned AR submitted the following specific documentary references:

(i) Consolidated event-wise details and supporting documents

 Complete list of domestic and foreign events handled/organised by the event management companies, containing the detailed particulars of the events and the corresponding business justification, was furnished as Annexure 1 to the assessee’s written submissions before the learned CIT(A), placed at pages 2720 to 2730 of Paper Book Volume IV.

 Complete event-wise details of domestic events organised during the relevant year, setting out the particulars of the events, dates, expenditure heads under which the amounts were debited in the Profit and Loss Account, names of the organising parties, amounts debited to the Profit and Loss Account, and supporting invoices, purchase orders and detailed cost break-ups, were placed at pages 1148 to 2454 of Paper Book Volume III.

 The assessee also furnished a detailed reply dated 18.03.2024 to the show-cause notice, along with contemporaneous documentary evidence, including invoices, cost break-ups and other supporting material. The said reply is placed at pages 2949 to 3018 of Paper Book Volume V.

(ii) Event-wise evidence relating to the 14 events identified by the Assessing Officer

Learned AR further referred to Annexure 5 to the Synopsis, appearing at page 236, which contains the complete list of 14 events identified by the Assessing Officer in the assessment order, together with the invoice amount, amount debited to the Profit and Loss Account and the corresponding Paper Book references. The same is reproduced hereunder for sake of ready reference :-

Annexure 5:

Hero Motocorp Limited

List of 14 events identified in assessment order

Assmt. YearEvent No.Event NameCarried out byInvoice Amount for Event (₹)Total Debited to P&L (₹)Reference to Paperbook
2014-15VI50 MILLION BIKE LAUNCH (FY 2013-14)SEMPL2,49,25,0052,21,83,165140-149 of PB Vol I & 546-724 of PB Vol II
VIIHMC Brand Promotion for the month of July, 2013 [Event code: HMC/57/13-14] (FY 2013-14)SEMPL2,07,34,6341,84,53,750150-165 of PB Vol I
2014-15 Total4,56,59,6394,06,36,915
2015-16IXHMC Training Programme at Crown Plaza, Gurgaon: 31st January to 1st February 2014 [Event code: HMC/261/14-15]SEMPL2,01,31,6501,79,17,097212-225 of PB Vol I
VIII'HERO HOCKEY WORLD CUP MATCH MALL ACTIVATION' FROM 11TH TO 13TH JUNE, 2014 [EVENT CODE: HMC/55/14-15] (FY 2014-15)SEMPL3,46,64,2913,08,51,096155-211 of PB Vol I
XHMC Training Programme at Crown Plaza, Gurgaon: 6th to 7th February, 2015 [Event code: HMC/262/14-15]SEMPL2,07,68,2431,84,83,662212-225 of PB Vol I
XIHero Master Production of Pleasure TVC (Discovery) AV [Event code: HMC/270/14-15]SEMPL1,50,28,1501,33,75,000226-228 of PB Vol I
2015-16 Total9,05,92,3348,06,26,855
2016-17IVSTAFF TRAINING PROGRAMMES (PROJECT CODE: HMC/648/2015-16) (FY 2015-16)SEMPL4,66,99,1604,07,85,29395-105 of PB Vol I
VR&D CENTRE LAUNCH- CIT KUKAS JAIPUR [PROJECT CODE: HMC/651/15-16] (FY 2015-16)SEMPL12,13,04,96710,59,43,203140-149 of PB Vol I & 725-774 of PB Vol II
XIIINDIAN OPEN GOLF- 2016 [EVENT CODE: HMC/745/15-16] (FY 2015-16)SEMPL4,34,41,6763,79,40,328229-242 of PB Vol I

2016-17 Total 21,14,45,803 18,46,68,824

2017-18IPRODUCT PROMOTION- HF DELUXE (FY 2016-17)Strokes6,02,71,2545,26,38,6501-35 of PB Vol I
II- 1st Part and 2nd PartPRODUCT PROMOTION- HERO MAESTRO EDGE & PRODUCT PROMOTION- SPRING CARNIVAL (FY 2016-17)Strokes11,44,95,93510,03,25,84936-85 of PB Vol I
2017-18 Total17,47,67,18915,29,64,499
2018-19IIITRAINING PROGRAM-GURGAON (2017-18)SEMPL2,56,60,4812,17,46,17086-94 of PB Vol I
XIIIHERO SPLENDOR CANTER ACTIVATION- SHURUWAT NAYE SAFAR KI FROM 28TH APRIL TO 7TH MAY, 2017 [EVENT CODE: HMC/1222/17-18].SEMPL8,04,53,7826,99,59,810243-356 of PB Vol I
XIVPASSION PRO SALES BOOST ACTIVITY- ASLI SUPERSTAR FROM 10TH TO 19TH AUGUST, 2017 [EVENT CODE: HMC/1342/17-18].SEMPL6,96,49,4355,90,24,945357-486 of PB Vol I
2018-19 Total17,57,63,69815,07,30,925
Grand Total69,82,28,66360,96,28,018
(iii)

Further corroborative evidence establishing the actual conduct and business purpose of events

Learned AR also referred to Annexure 6 to the Synopsis, appearing at pages 237 to 262, which contains a detailed rebuttal to the allegations made by the Assessing Officer. In particular, the assessee furnished event-specific material to establish that the domestic events were actually conducted and had a clear business purpose. The same is reproduced hereunder for sake of ready reference.

S. no.Name of the domestic events alongwith business justification thereofRemarks and supporting evidence
1.Participation in Auto-Expo(FY2014-15 2016-17 2017-18)

The assessee has been participating in The said event was a public event and Auto Expo exhibition held in the year 2014, 2016 and 2018 by setting up the the assessee’s participation in the Auto-stalls, displaying the new launches of Expo Exhibitions is publically vehicles in the presence of the higher documented and was covered by media management team and brand ambassadors outlets. In support thereof, detailed note of the company. on the aforesaid event alongwith supporting documents in form of The Auto Expo is the biennial (once every newspaper reports for each year two years) automotive show of India and containing the photos and key details of second large stauto show of the world, the exhibitions are enclosed at pages held in the National Capital Region of 501 to 512 of PB Vol. II which Delhi, attracting millions of visitors. unequivocally proves the fact that the It provides the good platform for the assessee had indeed participated in the launch of new products and for the OEMs said event. to demonstrate their value-propositions, strengths and technology capabilities to customers, amidst the current gloomy industry environment, since the long-term prospects are practically bright. Sunburn – the Music Festival and

2.

Visual Jockeying Sunburn, a Percept Intellectual Property, The assessee had sponsored/participated is Asia’s Premiere Electronic Dance in the Sunburn Music Festival/Visual Music (EDM) Festival, and is ranked Jockeying held in India for the years amongst the world’s biggest music 2013 and 2014. The said event was festivals.Startedin2007 as a 3 day music extensively covered by media. festival in Goa. In support thereof, newspaper cuttings In order to receive a lot of attention from and event photographs are being the Indian youth, the assessee had enclosed at pages 513 to 519 of PB Vol. sponsored the sunburn event to promote II its products and brand in the Sunburn music festival in 2013. Further, the link to the YouTube video Thanks to this tie-up, the assessee was for December 2013 event showcasing able to grab unprecedented attention in the assessee as a title sponsor is also youth conversations, and the country too available online at following links – was able to experience a never-before high- Noida Link :-octane association between biking and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6HY1 electronic dance music. HAw22qQ

3. Event – Neemrana Earth Breaking In support of the fact that the event was

Ceremony organized, the assessee is placing on In a major step towards meeting its record the following evidences at pages aggressive growth plans for the future, the 520 to 545 of PB Vol. II: assessee on 14th January 2013 commenced

 Event pictures of Bhoomi Poojan construction of its fourth manufacturing

 Proposed Minutewise Schedule for plant and a new Global Parts Centre the MD Visit for the Event. (GPC) at Neemrana in the northern Indian

 Internal Communication regarding state of Rajasthan. the timing and date of the ground breaking ceremony.

The Ground Breaking ceremony of

 Mail communication regarding the assessee’s 4th Plant and New Global Parts Helipad and landing permission for Centre happened in FY 2013-14, the MD Visit at Neemrana. foundation stone was laid for two new

 Mail Communication regarding the facilities which was attended by several Invitees list for the Procurement dignitaries including senior company team of HMCL. executives, key ancillaries of the

 Internal mail communication company, other associates and regarding Proposed schedule for the representatives from the state government Event and flow of MD Visit. of Rajasthan.

 Internal mail communication to the Leadership Team for the blocking of calendar for the Event on 14th January.

 Communication mail in respect of the Formal Invitation Mail to the HMCL Leadership Team and Senior Employees. Sample Invitation Mail communication from the SS&SC Team.

 Mail Communication regarding “Talk Points” for the Head of CEO’s Office at the Event.

 Part List of Invitees from the Supplier Side for the Ground Breaking Ceremony is attached. (Name of the Company, Person Invited & Communication Address)

 Official Press Release issued by Hero MotoCorp Limited on 15thJanuary 2013 titled “Hero MotoCorp commences Construction of its New Plant & Global Parts Centre.”

4.

Event – 50 million Celebration – FY In support of the event, the assessee is 2013-14 enclosing a detailed Note at pages 546 In FY 2013-14, the assessee-company to 724of PB Vol. II alongwith became the first two wheeler Company to supporting’s : reach the historic milestone of production of 50 million two wheelers.

 Media coverage related to 50 The 50 millionth motorcycle that was million celebrations rolled out was the ‘Xtreme’. The  Event pictures for celebration of 50 landmark of achievement of 50 million million achievement. was celebrated by organizing an event on

 Copy of Official Press Release done 8th August-2013. by Hero MotoCorp Limited– “50 MILLIONTH "HERO" ROLLS OUT” News Coverage regarding the celebration in different print media: - “Hero sets ambitious target, aims to boost sales 150%”- Mint - 09-August- 2013 - “Hero Eyes Highway to international expansion”- Mail Today - 09-August- 2013 - “Hero unveils 2020 plan to fend off Honda, aims to raise turnover 2.5 times”- Financial Express - 09-August- 2013. - “Hero Moto Eyes 50 new markets by 2020.”- Economic Times - 09-August- 2013 - “Hero eyes 50 new markets, Rs - 60,000-cr turnover by 2020”-Business Standard - 09-August-2013

 Presentation deck presented by the event agency for the ideas & theme for the celebration event.

 Presentation deck on the schedule of activities to be carried out during the event.

 The media coverage of the said event is also available at the following Video link also available https://www.ndtv.com/video/auto/th e-carand-bike-show/hero-hits-50-million-286257

5.

EVENT – CENTRE OF In support of the event, the assessee is INNOVATION &TECHNOLOGY enclosing a detailed Note at pages 725 (CIT) LAUNCH 15-16 to 774of PB Vol. II alongwith

The assessee-company on 10th following supportings: March2016 inaugurated its world class

•

Media coverage related to CIT-“Global Centre of Innovation & Technology”(CIT) in Jaipur, Rajasthan. launch.

•

Performa Invoices/Terms of

Built with an investment of Rs.850crores, engagements submitted by M/s the CIT is a reinforcement of assessee’s SEMPL for the purpose of making commitment to innovate sustainable launch arrangements. mobility solutions. Amplified visibility of • Event pictures for launch of CIT. the launch was important for attracting

•

Formal Invitation circulated for the right global talent, forge technical inauguration of CIT collaborations, engage with institutional investors (FIIs) and create excitement in • Mail communication to Board the mind of the customers. Members for CIT inauguration containing brief Itinerary.

An event was organised for laying down • Invitation to the Chief Minister of the foundation of CIT centre. Rajasthan for the inauguration ceremony of CIT.

•

Mail communications from M/s SEMPL regarding cost discussion and finalization.

•

Email Invite sent to guests for inauguration ceremony of CIT.

•

Official Press Release issued by assessee “Hero MotoCorp showcases inhouse R&D capabilities with the inauguration of Hero Centre of Innovation and Technology CIT”

- News-paper coverage of the launch is supported by following newspaper clippings:–

- “Hero MotoCorp to start work on new models in kukas with the investment of Rs 850 cr” – Dainik Bhaskar - “We will continue to increase our R&D spending” – Business Standard - “Hero MotoCorp eyes new market opens Global R&D centre in Jaipur” Deccan Herald - “States first Global Research Centre setup in Kukas 500 engineers to work in centre” – Rajasthan Patrika - “Hero MotoCorp inaugurates R&D Centre at Jaipur” – The Pioneer

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

6.

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

The assessee had started the construction of the prestigious “Hero Centre of Global Innovation and Research & Design (R&D)”spread over an area of 250acres at Kukas, near Jaipurin Rajasthan during the FY 2013-14. The Company laid down the foundation stone during the year 2013 and the Research and Development centre became operational in the year 2016 at an investment of Rs. 850 crores approx.

An Ground Breaking Ceremony was organised at the Centre of

In support of the event, a detailed note along with supporting such as news-paper coverage of the launch are placed pages 775 to 777 of PB Vol. II

Innovation and Technology (CIT), Kukas, Rajasthan, wherein Dr. Pawan Munjal alongwith partners of the company’s global technology partners – Erik Buell of Erik buell racing of the US, Alberto Strazzari of Engines Engineering of Italy, and Markus Feichtner of AVL, Austria were also present.

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

7.

FOUNDATION STONE – HITTOORPLANT, SRI CITY, ANDHRA PRADESH(FY 2017-18)

The company had started the construction of sixth manufacturing facility spread over 600 acres at Sri City in Chittoor District in the state of Andhra Pradesh with a proposed capacity of 1.8 million units per annum during the financial year 2017-18. The Company has invested 1,600 crores in setting up this manufacturing facility. In this regard, an event was organised for laying down the foundation stone of the Chittoor plant during the year 2018, which eventually started operations from March 2020.

The then Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh Sh. Chandrababu Naidu laid the foundation stone of the

In support of the event, a detailed note alongwith supportings such as newspaper cuttings and photo clippings etc. are placed at

Judgment image

.

company’s new manufacturing facility at Chittoor district.

8.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Hero Moto Sports is a cross functional team of experts who In support of the event, the assessee is live and breathe racing by enclosing a detailed note alongwith supporting participating in national and such as Newspaper extracts along with the international rally races, it has photoclippings of the events howing the race, headquarters at the Global Centre bikers’ recognitions, event decorations, etc. at for Innovation and Technology (CIT) and works in closeJudgment image collaboration with Hero Tech Centre Germany (HTCG), a wholly owned subsidiary of the assessee. As kick-off, the assessee had conducted the motor sports rally during September 2016 in CIT Kukas by inviting the bikers. The riders of Hero MotoSports Team Rally-CSSantosh and Joaquim Rodrigues were gearing upto blaze the Dkar Rally 2017. They showcased a glimpse of their off-roading prowess at the Hero Centre of Innovation and Technology (CIT) in Jaipur.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

9. AUDIO/VIDEO CONTENT (FY2015-16, 2016--17 & 2018-19)

In support of the same, the newspaper

Audio/Video (AV), is frequently clippings for launching new models of used a generic term for audio and scooters such as Glamour, Destini 125 and video components and capability in Duet, youtube links for advertisements, home entertainment systems and photoshoot photographs of new models, are related product descriptions and placed atJudgment image PB Vol. II reviews. The term AV is also used to describe any form of media that involves both sound and visual elements. During the specific year’s company has arranged short films, not only for product advertisement on television channels but also for better communication with large audiences on various platforms as mentioned above. Time to time company has availed services from various technical professionals and one of which is the “Spaces Moneky” as well.

10.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Duringtheyears2014-15,2016--17&2019-20, The assessee organises annual National Dealers Conferences (NDC) were Dealers/Distributors Conferences conducted in Gurgaon, Delhi & Goa and for business activities, showcasing these events were organised through event new product launches, technical management company. specification of new products, review of business progress & In support of the event, a detailed note having feedbacks of dealers, alongwith supporting such as Invitation mails, annual meeting etc. Agenda & photograph of events etc., are

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

placed atJudgment image In these meetings, dealers/ distributors are invited. These meetings were organised by assessee domestically as well as overseas and locations were finalised by the Sales & Marketing department For organising these meetings, activities are assigned to outside professional event management companies as company neither has internal expertise or time to manage the larger events.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
11.

HERO INDIAN OPEN GOLF – MEN AND WOMEN TOURNAMENT (FY 2013 TO 2019) The assessee-company sponsors In support of the event, a detailed note golf tournaments which provides a alongwith supportings such as extracts from unique opportunity for brands to magazine having the details of event, photos, connect with affluent audiences, award distributions, etc., are placed atJudgment image enhance brand visibility and credibility, build relationships, andJudgment image demonstrate corporate responsibility. Further, the below mentioned website could be referred for more details on Hero Indian

The assessee has sponsored these Open Golf Tournaments for both Men and tournaments in Delhi Golf Club Women for various years: -Delhi and DLF golf club in WebsiteLink:-https://heroindianopen.com/ Gurgaon. Though sponsorship agreements are signed with professional golf associations but an event management company is hired to place hoarding etc., on the grounds for brand visibility through signage etc. and Other miscellaneous activities.

12.

EMPLOYEE BUSINESS MEETING (FY 2013-14 TO 2017-18)

The assessee-company, throughout In support of the event, detailed note along the year, conducts various staff with supportings such as mail meets for finalisation of semi - communications related to ABP, Strategy, annual, annual business plans, new EMT, Scenario planning meetings etc, which product awareness to sales & were managed by event management marketing teams, departmental company, are placed at pages 1080 to 1124 of review meetings and strategies PB Vol. II meetings on future prospective.

These meetings are called in office premises as well as outside locations to build motivation & moral boosting of staff. Although the in-house meetings are managed by administration department of the company, but outside events are assigned to an event management company.

13.

FAMILY DAY EVENTS (FY 2017-18)

The assessee also organises annual In support of the event, a detailed Note event namely Family Day to boost alongwith supporting such as photo the morale of its employees, clippings, invitation mails to employee promote work-life balance, having the details of event, employee recognize the importance of family registration, stalls, award distributions etc., ties and support their commitments are placed at to their families. pages 1125 to1137 of PB Vol . II Thus, the assessee uses the services of an event management company for hiring entertainers, offering food, or doing as cavenger hunt.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
14.

Brand / Product promotion In support of the aforesaid, a detailed Note Events(FY 2018-19) Alongwith supportings such as pictures of For enhancing brand and product Brand Promotion of Xtreme 200R model acceptance, various methods of display on 1st and 3rd March, 2019 at advertisings are used by the Falcon Ground and Chandigarh Golf Club assessee company to have face to and pictures of brand promotions events at face interaction with customers shopping malls, mobile vans display, wall such Wall paintings in rural areas, paintings, hoardings, are placed at pages hoardings in towns, mobile vans, 1138 to 1147of PB Vol. II and mall activations to connect with potential customers are initiated. After digitisation, with the availability of internet connectives and smart phones, digital marketing concept is emerging in larger scale.

(iv) Evidence furnished during remand proceedings

The learned AR also pointed out that the learned CIT(A), having noticed that the Assessing Officer had examined only a limited number of events, afforded the Assessing Officer a further opportunity to examine the entire material and specifically directed him to furnish a remand report with regard to the admissibility, genuineness and factual correctness of the expenditure.

In response to the enquiries made during remand proceedings, the assessee furnished further details vide its letter dated 08.10.2025, in response to the Assessing Officer’s communication dated 30.09.2025. The relevant correspondence is placed at pages 2731 to 2737 of Paper Book Volume IV/V,. The Assessing Officer thereafter furnished a remand report dated 21.11.2025.

The learned AR submitted that even in the remand proceedings, despite being specifically directed to examine the supporting evidence and being afforded a further opportunity to undertake enquiries, the Assessing Officer did not identify any specific defect, discrepancy or falsity in the invoices, purchase orders, cost break-ups or other contemporaneous documents furnished by the assessee. The remand report substantially reiterated the allegations made in the assessment order and did not bring any fresh material to establish that the events had not taken place or that the expenditure was not incurred for the assessee’s business.

76.

On the issue of alleged money trial and third party material by the revenue, learned AR disputed the Revenue’s inference that the movement of funds from SEMPL through Dream and Fast to 365 Aviation established that the assessee had incurred personal expenditure in the guise of event-management charges. It was submitted that the transactions involving third parties had to be examined in their proper context and that the Revenue was required to establish a reliable connection between the expenditure claimed by the assessee and the alleged personal use of the funds.

77.

Learned AR contended that the mere existence of bank transfers, ledger entries or similarities between the amounts recorded by third parties and the alleged travel itineraries did not, without corroboration, prove that the invoices raised upon the assessee were fictitious or that the expenditure claimed in the books was not incurred for business purposes. The assessee submitted that the actual nature of the services rendered, the occurrence of the events and the contemporaneous documents supporting the expenditure had to be evaluated cumulatively.

78.

Learned AR also referred to the statement of Shri Hemant Dahiya, Managing Director of SEMPL. According to him, the statement did not deny the occurrence of the domestic promotional events. He contended that the Revenue had relied upon the alleged admission concerning charter arrangements without adequately demonstrating how that statement established that each of the domestic-event invoices was fictitious or represented personal expenditure of the CMD.

79.

Learned AR further submitted that the material relied upon by the Revenue included information obtained from third-party searches and material associated with the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (“DRI”). The assessee relied upon the observations concerning the reliability of such material, as recorded in the appellate proceedings, and contended that the material could not be treated as conclusive proof of the alleged diversion of the assessee’s funds without establishing the necessary connection with the particular expenditure.

80.

Learned AR submitted that the addition had been made by the Assessing Officer on the basis of an alleged modus operandi involving layering of entities and routing of funds through event management companies and their vendors. However, no tangible evidence had been brought on record to establish any collusion or connivance between the assessee and the event management companies for raising bogus invoices or for routing the assessee’s business expenditure towards the personal foreign travel of its Chairman.

81.

It was submitted that the Assessing Officer had sought to draw an adverse inference primarily on the basis of certain third-party ledger accounts and alleged movement of funds between M/s SEMPL, its vendors and M/s 365 Aviation. Learned AR contended that the mere fact that certain payments appeared in the books of third-party vendors, or that the dates of certain domestic events coincided with the foreign travel of the Chairman, could not establish that the domestic events had not taken place or that the expenditure incurred by the assessee had been utilised for personal purposes.

82.

In this regard, learned AR specifically referred to Annexure 6 to the synopsis, beginning at page 251, which contains a detailed event-wise rebuttal of the allegations made in the assessment order. The assessee demonstrated, with reference to the relevant invoices, cost break-up sheets, purchase orders, photographs, media reports, invitations and other contemporaneous documents, that the events had in fact been organised and that the expenditure was incurred for the stated business purposes. The relevant submission in form of rebuttal is as under:

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

I.

Promoti on-Hf Deluxe

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

of AO order)

Copies of invoices, cost break-up sheets, more than 40 pictures of the organized event.Judgment image

The amounts stated at each leg of transaction which are being linked do not reconcile:

- Amount paid by assessee to M/s SEMPL is Rs.6,02,71,254

- Bill of M/s 365 Aviationof Invoice of 365 (USD690,000) equivalent to Rs.4,65,75,000 (considering exchange rate of 67.5 prevalent in May’16) is mapped to a booking of Rs 4,85,45,965/-in the books of M/s Dream. Difference of Rs. 20 lakhs remains unexplained.

- This is mapped to purchase of “Manpower, Collaterals, sound light, & other misc.” from M/s Dream by M/s Strokes booked at Rs 4,77,70,175/- i.e., again at a difference of Rs. 9 lacs, which remains unexplained.

The aforesaid establishes that mere on surmises and conjectures, separate transactions are being linked, without any basis.

II. Product Copies of The amounts stated at each leg of transaction which are Promot invoices, being linked do not reconcile: ion- cost break-Hero up sheets, - Invoice of M/s Aviation365 to M/s Dream Maestr more thanJudgment image (USD640,000) equivalent to Rs4,25,60,000/-o Edge 40picturesJudgment image (considering exchange rate of 66.5) has been (FY of the mapped to invoice of Rs11,44,95,935/- raised by 2016- organized M/s Strokes on assessee for a domestic event; 17) event.

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

II

Product Promoti on-Spring Carnival (FY 2016-17)

Judgment image

of AO order)

Copies of invoices, cost break Up sheets, more than 10 pictures of the organized event.Judgment image

- There is no evidence of any payment or booking of invoice by M/s Dreamin the books of M/s Strokes being brought on record by the Assessing Officer nor any linkage between M/s Stroke and M/s Dream has been placed on record to even remotely suggest that the said amount has been clubbed in the domestic event.

The only basis for linking the foreign travel with the domestic event is that days of domestic travel and foreign travel overlap. The foreign travel was on account of attending the Championship trophy which was held in June 2016, and invoice of Rs 8.42 Crores is enclosed

Thus, the allegation that expense for foreign travel was included in the bill for domestic event is factually erroneous.

III.

Training Program-Gurga on (2017-18)

Judgment image

of AO order)

Copies of invoices, cost break up sheets and pictures of the organized event.Judgment image

The amounts stated at each leg of transaction which are being linked do not reconcile:

- The AO have selectively singled out only 1 invoices (2.56 Cr.) out of 8 invoices (10.88 Cr.) to establish the allegation, thereby accepting the remaining invoices.

- M/s 365 Aviation has raised invoice USD 540,000/-equivalent to Rs.3,48,30,000 (considering exchange rate of 64.5), which has been mapped to a cost recovery of Rs.1.08cr (Rs.59,40,404+Rs.48,85,161) as per the exhibits in the books of M/s SEMPL from

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

M/s Dream. It is wholly

Judgment image

Judgment image

- Illogical and absurd that

49

- That apart, the foreign travel being linked is for participation in Milan Auto Expo which is an annual event.Fortheyear2017, the M/s SEMPL and travel cost of Rs 1.66 Cr. for the event has been billed therein (Invoice enclosed ). Thus, the allegation that included in the bill for domestic erroneous.

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

of The amounts stated at each leg of being linked do not reconcile: cost break

Judgment image

Judgment image

than 10 picturesJudgment image the

The AO has selectively (4.67Cr.) out of 16 invoices (18.14 Cr.) to establish this allegation which is being arrangement procured by M/s to the tune of Rs.3,50,42,000/-, to a payment to M/s 365 without bringing out on record any invoice of M/s 365 Aviation spelling out the underlying travel details). It is wholly illogical and absurd that be recovered against an expense of Rs.5.90 cr.

ITA Nos.7942, 7943, 7967, 7968 & 8179/DEL/2026 ITA Nos.4956 to 4961/Del/2026

event was organized by

expense for foreign travel was event is factually

Judgment image

transaction which are

Judgment image

singled out only 2 invoices

mapped some travel SEMPL from M/s Dream which is in turn mapped Aviation for Rs.590,79,309/-

only Rs.4.67 cr would

ITA Nos.7942, 7943, 7967, 7968 &
ITA Nos.4956 to 4961/Del/2026
That apart, the foreign travel being linked is for
participation in Milan Auto Expo which is an annual
M/s SEMPL and travel cost of Rs 1.66 Cr. for the
event has been billed therein (Invoice enclosed ).
domesticevent is

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

IV.

Staff Training Progra mmes (FY 2015-16)

Judgment image

of AO order)

Copies of invoices, cost break up sheets, more than 10 pictures of the organized event.Judgment image

The amounts stated at each leg of transaction which are being linked do not reconcile:

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

The AO has selectively singled out only 2 invoices (4.67Cr.) out of 16 invoices (18.14 Cr.) to establish this allegation which is being mapped some travel arrangement procured by M/s SEMPL from M/s Dream to the tune of Rs.3,50,42,000/-, which is in turn mapped to a payment to M/s 365 Aviation for Rs.590,79,309/-without bringing out on record any invoice of M/s 365 Aviation spelling out the underlying travel details). It is wholly illogical and absurd that only Rs.4.67 cr would be recovered against an expense of Rs.5.90 cr.

V. Launch Performa It is, at the outset, submitted that the said event was a of Invoices/Te public event covered by media and thus, the fact that the R&D rms of Centre engagemen event occurred cannot be denied. Launch t s, CopiesJudgment image -CIT of invoices, Kuka cost break The amounts stated at each leg ofof transaction which are s up sheets, Jaipur pictures, being linked do not reconcile: invitations to Guests The total event cost incurred on the launch was Rs.12.13 Judgment imagefor event, of Mail Cr., however, allegation of travel is for Rs. 3.24 Cr. A communica O tions from M/s 365 Aviation has raised an invoice USD 670,000 order) M/s SEMPL, equivalent to Rs4.45Cr (considering exchange rate of Official 66.5) on M/s Dream which has been mapped to a Press Release, payment of Rs 3,56,39,145/- (1,14,07,000 + News- 2,42,32,145) in books of Dreams. paper coverage It is wholly illogical and absurd that a payment of only Rs.3.56 Cr would be made against an expense of Rs.4.45 cr. This allegation where payment linkage is done without any logical linkage, is completely absurd.

VI. 50 Copies of It is, at the outset, submitted that the said event was a

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Millio invoices, public event covered by media and thus, the fact that the n Bike cost break Launc up sheets, event occurred cannot be denied. h (FY Media 2013- coverage, The amounts stated at each leg ofof transaction which are 14) Event pictures being linked do not reconcile: , press An invoice of M/s 365 Aviation in the books of M/s Fast for EUR 544,000/- when converted to the prevailing

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

release, exchange rate (Rs85/EURO) translates to Rs 4.6 Cr., News however this has been mapped toto a payment of Rs3.38 Judgment imagecoverage in of print Cr. A media, O presentatio order) n deck by

It is alleged that Rs.2.68 Cr. (15596442 + 11266920) event agency on paid by M/s SEMPL to M/s FAST & VISTAJET has ideas, been covered in an Invoice to HMCL of Rs 2.49 Cr. theme and schedule of

activities These amounts do not reconcile and it is absurd why one company would recover lesser amount from another company. Thus, it is clear that linkages being done are incorrect, based on figment of imagination and not on any tangible material.

II. HMC Copies of M/s365 Aviation Invoice of EUR 206,500/- equivalent to Brand invoices, Rs.1.63 Cr to M/s Fast is being linked to payment of Rs.1.70 Promoti cost breakJudgment image Cr by M/s SEMPL to M/s FAST, merely on conjectures and surmises. On For up sheets, The more than Month 40pictures of July, of the 2013 organized (FY event. 2013-14)

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

of AO order)

VIII. Hero Copies of Invoice of M/s365 Aviation billed to M/s Dream was for

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Hockey invoices, Rs.4.15 Cr (EUR 490,000) whereas it has been alleged World cost break that this amount has been billed toto the assessee in an Cup Up sheets, invoice of Rs. 3.46Cr. Match more than Mall 40 pictures It is wholly illogical and absurd that M/s SEMPL would Activati of the have made an under-recovery and suffered a loss on this on organized transaction and the only possible explanation is that the 'From event. transaction have been incorrectly mapped/linked. 11th To 13th June, 2014 (FY 2014-15)

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

of AO order)

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

IX. HMC Copies of The AO has clubbed three different events in this case

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Trainin invoices, and mapped the same towards ar and om travel invoice of g cost break M/s365 Aviation. Progra up sheets, In the books of M/s SEMPL, the assessee has been mme at more than billed of Rs.5.59 cr against three different events held. It Crown 4 pictures is alleged that the expenses against this billing has come Plaza, of the from M/s Dream (1.27cr) & M/s FAST (0.51cr+0.14cr). Gurgao organized However, the payment by M/s SEMPL to M/s FAST has n: 31st event. been shown to be Rs.5.54 Cr in the exhibit. January To 1st No mapping as be end one for payment of Rs.1.27 Cr. Februar made to M/s Dream. y 2014

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

The amounts donot reconcile which establishes that mere of AO on surmises and conjectures, separate transactions are order) being linked, without any basis.

X.HMC Training Programme at Crown Plaza, Gurgaon: 6th To7th February,201 5Copies of invoices, cost brea k up sheets, morethan3 pictures of the organized event.Judgment image
XI.

Hero Master Product ion Of Pleasur eTVC (Discovery) AV

Judgment image

of AO order)

Copies of invoicesJudgment image
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image

Judgment image
XII.

Indian Open Golf-2016

Judgment image

Copies of invoices, cost break Up sheets, more than 5 pictures ofJudgment imageM/s SEMPL has made payment to M/s Fast of Rs. 1,90,78,528/- for event purchase for organizing this event and M/s SEMPL has also purchased airtickets from M/s Fast of Rs.2.1 Cr.

of AO the Two separate events are being connected without even order) organized establishing that airtickets were purchased for the event. assessee. It is also absurd that M/s SEMPL would purchase tickets of Rs. 2.1 Cr. for assessee and recover only Rs.1.90 Cr. It is wholly illogical and absurd that M/s SEMPL would have made an under-recovery and suffered a loss on this transaction and the only possible explanation is that the transaction have been incorrectly mapped/linked.

XIII. Hero Copies of Here instead of showing any linkages, merely because Splend invoices, M/s Dream has transferred funds purportedly received or cost break from M/s SEMPL to M/s 365 Aviation, it is alleged that Canter Up sheets,Judgment image amount received was used for personal foreign ravel Activati more than without any corroborative evidence. on- 50 pictures Shuruw of the at Naye organized SafarKi event and From Proposal 28th presented AprilTo by SALT 7th experiences May, & 2017 manageme nt.

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

of AO order)

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment
Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

IV. Passion Copies of The amounts stated at each leg ofof transaction which are

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

Pro invoices, being linked do not reconcile: Sales cost break

Boost up sheets, - Invoice of M/s 365 Aviation of USD 765,000/-Activit more than equivalent to INR 4,94,96,119/- raised on M/s Dream y 80 pictures is mapped to an invoice booking amount of INR -Asli of the 4,05,90,223/-raised by M/s SEMPL in the name of Superst organized M/s Dream done by SEMPL. It is wholly illogical ar event and and absurd that M/s Dream would have made an From Hero under-recovery and suffered a loss on this transaction 10th to Passion and the only possible explanation is that the 19th Pro transaction have been incorrectly mapped/linked. August, Activation

2017 Plan - The foreign travel allegedly connected to this event is presented the Hockey World league (15.06.17-25.06.17) is an

Exhibit reproduced from the original judgment

by SALT event organized by the assessee through M/s SEMPL Experience for which an invoice of Rs. 8.07 Cr. has been raised. of AO s & order) Manageme The aforesaid establishes that mere on surmises and nt Pvt. conjectures, separate transactions are being linked, Ltd. without any basis.

83.

The learned AR relied upon the following authorities in support of the proposition that business expenditure cannot be disallowed merely on suspicion or on the basis of an unsubstantiated inference:

 CIT v. Lalchand Bhagat Ambica Ram 37 ITR 288 (SC);

 Dhirajlal Girdharilal v. CIT 26 ITR 736 (SC), as relevant to the assessment of evidence and inference;

 D.C. Shah v. CIT 30 ITR 618 (SC), as cited in the assessee’s synopsis, if applicable to the proposition advanced;

 CIT v. Daulat Ram Rawatmull 87 ITR 349 (SC);

 K.P. Varghese v. ITO 131 ITR 597 (SC);

 J.K. Woollen Manufacturers v. CIT (1969) 72 ITR 612 (SC);

 Dalmia Cement (Bharat) Ltd. v. CIT (2002) 254 ITR 377 (Delhi);

 S.A. Builders Ltd. v. CIT (Appeals) (2007) 288 ITR 1 (SC);

 CIT v. Walchand & Co. Pvt. Ltd. (1967) 65 ITR 381 (SC); and

 CIT v. Panipat Woollen & General Mills Co. Ltd. (1976) 103 ITR 66 (SC).

84.

Ld. AR relied upon the above authorities for the propositions that an inference of non-business expenditure must rest on relevant evidence; that the apparent state of affairs cannot be rejected merely on conjecture and that the AO should not substitute his own subjective assessment of commercial expediency for that of the businessman. The assessee submitted that the tax authorities were not entitled to disallow expenditure merely because they considered the expenditure excessive or because the transactions appeared unusual, unless the applicable statutory requirements for disallowance were established.

85.

The learned AR also relied upon Sayaji Iron & Engineering Co. v. CIT 253 ITR 749 (Gujarat) and related authorities in support of the submission that the concept of personal expenditure must be applied with due regard to the fact that the assessee is a corporate entity. According to the AR, the Revenue could not simply characterise expenditure as personal without establishing the underlying facts and the connection between the corporate expenditure and the alleged personal benefit.

86.

It was accordingly submitted that the AO’s approach of disallowing the entire expenditure paid to the event-management entities was excessive and unsupported by adequate evidence. The learned AR prayed that the relief granted by Ld CIT(A) be upheld and that the disallowance of Rs.8,06,26,855 sustained by Ld CIT(A) in respect of the four identified events also be deleted.

87.

The learned AR submitted that the four events identified for AY 2015-16 were supported by invoices and had been included in the assessee’s event-wise reconciliation. The details recorded in the working papers were as follows:

Event Invoice value Amount debited to profit and (₹) loss account (₹) Hero Hockey WorLd Cup Mall 3,46,64,291 3,08,51,096 Activation, 11–13 June 2014 HMC Training, Crown Plaza, 31 2,01,31,650 1,79,17,097 January–1 February 2014 HMC Training, Crown Plaza, 6–7 2,07,68,243 1,84,83,662 February 2015 Hero Master Production of Pleasure TVC 1,50,28,150 1,33,75,000 Total 9,05,92,334/- 8,06,26,855/-

88.

The learned AR submitted that the expenditure relating to the Hero Hockey World Cup Mall Activation represented a promotional activity undertaken from 11th to 13th June 2014. The invoice value was Rs.3,46,64,291/-, of which Rs.3,08,51,096/- was debited to the profit and loss account. The AR disputed the inference that the alleged subsequent payment by Dream to 365 Aviation established that the event expenditure was fictitious or non-business expenditure.

89.

In respect of the HMC Training programme at Crown Plaza dated 31st January to 1st February 2014, the learned AR relied upon the supporting invoice and the amount of Rs.1,79,17,097/- debited to the profit and loss account. The assessee disputed the treatment of the event expenditure as personal expenditure merely because the Revenue alleged that funds passed through SEMPL and intermediary entities. The assessee further submitted that the event’s date and the year in which the expenditure accrued should be examined separately from the allegation regarding the nature of the expenditure.

90.

In respect of the second HMC Training programme at Crown Plaza, conducted on 6th and 7th February 2015, the invoice was for Rs.2,07,68,243/-, of which Rs.1,84,83,662/- was debited to the profit and loss account. The assessee submitted that this was a separate programme and that the allegation concerning one transaction could not automatically determine the allowability of another event without examination of the corresponding evidence.

91.

In respect of the Hero Master Production of Pleasure TVC, the invoice value was Rs.1,50,28,150/-, of which Rs.1,33,75,000/- was debited to the profit and loss account. The assessee submitted that production of promotional material and television commercials was directly connected with its business of manufacturing and marketing two-wheelers. The assessee disputed the disallowance on the basis of an alleged general modus operandi without establishing that the particular production expenditure was fictitious or personal.

92.

The learned AR further submitted that the amount of Rs.8,06,26,855 sustained by Ld CIT(A) represented the aggregate expenditure debited to the profit and loss account in respect of these four events. The assessee contended that the sustained amount should not be treated as non-business expenditure merely because the AO had identified a possible connection between payments to event-management entities and charter arrangements. The evidence relating to each event, the nature of the services and the actual payments was required to be examined separately.

93.

The ld. AR placed reliance upon the findings recorded by the learned CIT(A), who had accepted that the domestic events were routinely undertaken, that many were public events and that there was no abnormal increase in the relevant expenditure. Ld CIT(A) had also noted that the AO had not identified specific discrepancies in the documents supporting the events and that the Chairman’s foreign travel had itself been accepted as official in the context discussed in the appellate order.

94.

The AR submitted that the remand proceedings afforded the AO a further opportunity to examine the supporting material and identify specific deficiencies. However, according to the assessee, the remand report dated 21st November 2025 did not establish any event-specific discrepancy sufficient to justify the sustained disallowance and substantially reiterated the allegations made in the assessment order.

95.

The learned AR contended that, having accepted the occurrence of the events and having granted substantial relief, the learned CIT(A) could not sustain the disallowance of 14 selected events merely because some doubt remained regarding the quantum or the alleged movement of funds. Learned AR submitted that the conclusion had to be supported by evidence demonstrating that the particular expenditure was not incurred for the purposes of its business.

96.

Accordingly, the learned AR prayed that the assessee’s appeal be allowed in respect of the Rs.8,06,26,855/- sustained by Ld CIT(A), and that the Revenue’s appeal seeking restoration of the amount of Rs.80,60,76,963/- deleted by Ld CIT(A) be dismissed.

97.

With regard to Ground nos. 3 to 3.2, learned AR submitted that the AO had disallowed Rs.2,97,88,716 in respect of foreign-travel expenditure relating to the CMD’s trip to Colombia and the United States of America from 27th November 2014 to 9th December 2014. The trip was stated to have been undertaken in connection with the Hero World Challenge and related business activities. The aggregate expenditure referred to in the assessment proceedings was Rs.4,46,83,075/-, comprising charter-flight expenditure of Rs.4,34,18,282/- and other expenses of Rs.12,64,793/-.

98.

The AO disallowed two-thirds of the aggregate expenditure, attributing the expenditure to the Chairman’s wife, daughter and other family members. Ld CIT(A) deleted Rs.1,48,94,358/-, being the amount attributed to the wife, but sustained a further Rs.1,48,94,358/-, attributed to the daughter and other family members.

99.

The ld. AR submitted that the AO had accepted the CMD’s travel as official but had nevertheless disallowed two-thirds of the expenditure on a proportionate basis. The assessee contended that the apportionment lacked a sufficient evidentiary basis and that the AO had not established the actual incremental expenditure, if any, attributable to the presence of family members.

100.

The ld. AR submitted that the CMD undertook approximately 14 to 15 foreign trips annually for business purposes. The trip under consideration was part of his business-related travel, and the assessee had borne the charter cost. According to the AR, the CMD was entitled to travel by charter and the aircraft would have been hired for his travel irrespective of whether the family members accompanied him.

101.

The assessee’s principal contention was that the charter cost was a fixed expenditure that would have been incurred for the CMD’s official travel in any event. In the absence of evidence that the presence of the family members increased the cost incurred by the assessee, a proportionate allocation based simply on the number of passengers was said to be arbitrary.

102.

The learned AR supported the deletion of Rs.1,48,94,358/- attributed to the Chairman’s wife. It was submitted that the presence of a spouse accompanying a senior business representative on an official foreign trip should not automatically result in the conclusion that the expenditure was personal. The circumstances of the trip, the nature of the business engagement and the commercial context of the travel were required to be considered.

103.

In support of this contention, learned AR relied upon Hero Honda Motors Ltd. v. JCIT (2006) 103 ITD 157 (Delhi), a decision in the assessee’s own case. The AR submitted that the Tribunal had considered the allowability of expenditure relating to the Chairman’s wife accompanying him on an official trip and that the principle emerging from that decision supported the assessee’s claim.

104.

The learned AR also referred to the decisions in Luwa India2012] 205 Taxman 342 (Karnataka); Alfa Laval [2006] 282 ITR 445 (Bombay); Apollo Tyres [2000] 237 ITR 706 (Kerala); and J.K. Industries [2011] 335 ITR 170 (Calcutta), in support of the contention that the nature and purpose of travel expenditure must be examined in the context of the business and the actual circumstances of the trip. The precise citations and propositions relied upon from these decisions should be verified against the authorities contained in the paper book before the order is finalised.

105.

The AR accordingly submitted that the learned CIT(A) had correctly deleted the amount attributed to the wife and that the Revenue’s challenge to this relief ought to be dismissed.

106.

As regards the amount of Rs.1,48,94,358/- sustained by the ld. CIT(A), the AR submitted that the AO had not adequately investigated whether the expenditure attributed to the family members was in fact borne by the assessee or whether any additional cost had been incurred by the assessee on account of their presence. According to learned AR, the AO had adopted a proportionate allocation without first establishing the actual cost attributable to the family members.

107.

Learned AR has stated that the family members had purchased foreign currency of USD 750, equivalent to Rs.46,821, for the trip. The assessee relied upon the foreign-currency purchase documentation admitted by the ld. CIT(A) as additional evidence. According to the AR, this evidence was relevant to the question of the expenses borne personally by the family members, although the assessee’s principal argument concerning the charter cost remained that the aircraft would have been hired for the CMD irrespective of the accompanying passengers.

108.

Learned AR relied upon Sassoon J. David & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT (1979) 118 ITR 261 (SC), in support of the proposition that expenditure may remain deductible where it is incurred for the purposes of the business even if it incidentally benefits another person. According to the assessee, the mere fact that family members travelled with the CMD did not establish that the company had incurred additional personal expenditure or that the entire proportionate share of the charter cost was inadmissible.

109.

Ld. AR submitted that the AO had not demonstrated that the charter cost would have been lower if the CMD had travelled alone, nor had the AO established that the company had incurred additional expenditure specifically attributable to the daughter or other family members. The assessee accordingly challenged the sustenance of Rs.1,48,94,358/-and prayed that the amount be deleted.

110.

The ld. AR submitted that the ld. CIT(A) had admitted additional evidence comprising foreign-currency purchase bills and related documentation. The assessee’s position was that the evidence was relevant to the apportionment of travel expenditure and that the AO had been afforded an opportunity to examine the material in the remand proceedings.

111.

The assessee disputed the contention that the additional evidence should be disregarded. According to the AR, the precise basis on which the AO proposed to apportion the charter expenditure had not been adequately established during the assessment proceedings, and the evidence was relevant to the issue that arose for determination in appeal. The AR therefore supported the consideration of the additional evidence by Ld CIT(A).

112.

In conclusion, the learned AR prayed that the assessee’s appeal be allowed in respect of the Rs.1,48,94,358/- sustained by Ld CIT(A) and that the Revenue’s appeal against the deletion of an equivalent amount attributed to the wife be dismissed.

113.

With regard to ground nos. 4 to 4.3, ld. AR submitted that the assessee had incurred expenditure in connection with its participation in and promotional activities surrounding the FIFA World Cup 2014 event in Brazil. The event was undertaken to promote the assessee’s brand, recognise meritocracy and support its marketing and brand-building activities in the Latin American market.

114.

Ld. AR submitted that the occurrence of the event was not in dispute. The event was supported by invoices, cost break-up sheets, photographs, ticket details and media coverage. According to the assessee, the evidence included approximately 20 photographs, details showing that 208 out of 497 tickets had been used, and a sample third-party bill from Cutting Edge Events Pvt. Ltd. relating to 256 tickets for approximately Rs.8.01 crore.

115.

Ld. AR submitted that the event was consistent with the assessee’s wider marketing and promotional activities and that the expenditure had been incurred for business purposes. The assessee disputed the AO’s inference that a charter flight used by the CMD was necessarily personal expenditure merely because the Revenue alleged that the charter cost was not separately identified in particular event invoices.

116.

The AO disallowed Rs.4,02,39,040/- out of the total amount of Rs.34,80,39,258/- paid to SEMPL in connection with the FIFA World Cup event. According to the assessment order, the disallowed amount represented the cost of a charter flight arranged through 365 Aviation, the payment for which was allegedly routed through Dream or Fast. The AO treated the amount as personal foreign-travel expenditure of the CMD allegedly masked within the expenditure claimed for the event.

117.

Ld. AR submitted that the AO’s conclusion was based upon an incomplete reading of the invoice documentation. Particular reliance was placed on the break-up sheets accompanying SEMPL invoice Nos. 2094 and 2095, contained in Paper Book Volume IV, pages 2559 to 2562. According to the assessee, those break-up sheets included charges relating to airfare, visas and travel arrangements.

118.

Ld. AR disputed the inference that the absence of a separately itemised line expressly describing the 365 Aviation charter established that the charter cost had not been included within the overall expenditure charged by SEMPL. The assessee submitted that the invoices and their accompanying break-up sheets had to be examined as a whole and in conjunction with the other event-related invoices, payment records and supporting documents.

119.

Ld. AR further contended that the invoice issued by 365 Aviation was a document obtained from third-party search proceedings and did not, by itself, establish the character of the expenditure recorded by the assessee. The Revenue was required to establish how the particular charter cost had been funded, how it was connected with the invoices raised upon the assessee and why it should be characterised as personal rather than business expenditure.

120.

Ld. AR submitted that the AO had relied upon SEMPL’s failure to respond to a notice issued under section 133(6). According to the assessee, a third party’s failure to furnish a response could not, by itself, establish that the expenditure claimed by the assessee was fictitious or that the underlying event had not occurred.

121.

In support of this contention, the learned AR relied upon CIT v. Fancy International 166 Taxman 183 (Delhi), as cited in the synopsis. The AR relied upon this authority for the proposition that an adverse inference against the assessee cannot be founded solely on a third party’s failure to respond where the assessee’s own evidence and the surrounding circumstances require independent consideration.

122.

Ld. AR also submitted that the amount of Rs.4,02,39,040/- had been taken from a screenshot reproduced at page 129 of the assessment order, without the source of the figure being adequately established in the manner required to sustain the disallowance. The assessee disputed the sufficiency of the material relied upon to quantify the alleged personal component.

123.

It was accordingly submitted that the AO had not established that the entire amount of Rs.4,02,39,040 represented personal expenditure or that it was otherwise inadmissible under section 37(1). The assessee prayed that the disallowance be deleted.

124.

The ld. AR accordingly prayed that the assessee’s appeal be allowed by quashing the reassessment proceedings on the jurisdictional grounds and, in the alternative, by deleting the disallowances challenged by the assessee. The AR further prayed that the Revenue’s appeal be dismissed, including its challenge to the relief granted by the learned CIT(A) in respect of domestic-event expenditure and foreign-travel expenditure attributed to the CMD’s wife.

125.

On the other hand, ld. Departmental Representative (DR) opposed the assessee’s appeal and supported the order of Ld CIT(A) insofar as it upheld the validity of the reassessment proceedings. Ld. DR, however, submitted that learned CIT(A) was not justified in granting relief in respect of domestic-event expenditure and foreign-travel expenditure, and prayed that the Revenue’s appeal be allowed.

126.

In this regard, Ld. DR submitted that the search conducted in the case of the assessee and the SEMPL group, including entities controlled by Shri Sachin and Shri Sameer Mujal, revealed a modus operandi whereby expenditure purportedly incurred on domestic promotional events was used to route funds towards the personal foreign travel and related expenditure of Shri Pawan Munjal, Chairman and Managing Director of the assessee.

127.

It was submitted that statements recorded during the search and post-search proceedings, including the statement of Shri Hemant Dahiya, Managing Director of SEMPL, together with the seized documents and the money trail, supported the AO’s conclusion that the expenditure claimed under the head of event management was not wholly incurred for the assessee’s business purposes.

128.

The Ld. DR submitted that the AO had traced payments made by the assessee to SEMPL and other entities, the onward payments by those entities to Dream Business Solutions and other intermediaries, and the subsequent payments to 365 Aviation Ltd., UK, for charter flights used by Shri Pawan Munjal. The DR relied upon the relevant findings in the assessment order and Ld CIT(A)’s order, particularly the discussion concerning the money trail and the statement of Shri Hemant Dahiya.

129.

In response to the assessee’s contention that the reassessment order dated 30th March 2024 was barred by limitation under section 153(2), ld. DR submitted that the order was passed within the prescribed period. Ld. DR further submitted that the assessment order was booked in the Income Tax Business Application system and dispatched through India Post on 31st March 2024, which was a Sunday. According to the DR, the order was within time even if the date of dispatch or delivery was considered, and the assessee’s ground deserved to be rejected.

130.

Ld. DR opposed the assessee’s contention that the reassessment proceedings were initiated without compliance with Explanation 2(iii) or (iv) to section 148. It was submitted that the search had been conducted in the assessee’s own case on 23rd March 2022 and that the notice under section 148 was issued after obtaining the requisite approval.

131.

Ld. DR relied upon the decisions cited in the written submissions, including PCIT v. Abhisar Buildwell (P.) Ltd. [2023] 454 ITR 212 (SC), and contended that the assessee’s reliance on decisions dealing with cases where the assessee itself had not been searched was misplaced.

132.

Ld. DR opposed the assessee’s contention that the notice under section 148 was barred by the first proviso to section 149(1), read with the fourth proviso to section 153A(1) as it stood under the earlier law. It was submitted that section 149(1)(b), as applicable to the notice in question, permitted issuance of a notice within ten years from the end of the relevant assessment year where the prescribed conditions were fulfilled. According to the Revenue, the notice for AY 2015-16 was issued within the applicable ten-year period and the case satisfied the statutory requirement concerning escaped income exceeding ₹50 lakh.

133.

In response to the challenge to the notice under section 143(2), the ld. DR submitted that the issue had not been raised before Ld CIT(A) and that the assessee had participated in the reassessment proceedings. It was further submitted that the return filed by the assessee in response to the notice under section 148 had been followed by a notice under section 143(2) dated 25th April 2023, served through ITBA on 26th April 2023, and that further notices had also been issued and complied with.

134.

With regard to the approval under section 151(ii), the ld. DR submitted that the proposal for reopening had been examined and approved by the competent authorities. The written submission refers to the approval proforma and records the approval of the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Central-1, Delhi, dated 24th February 2023, following the proposal submitted by the jurisdictional authority.

135.

With regard to ground nos. 1 to 3 of revenue appeal, ld. DR submitted that Ld CIT(A) erred in restricting the disallowance of domestic-event expenditure from Rs.88,67,03,818/- to Rs.8,06,26,855/-, thereby deleting Rs.80,60,76,963/-. According to the Revenue, the AO had established a systematic diversion of funds through SEMPL and related entities towards non-business purposes, and Ld CIT(A) failed to give due weight to the search material, the subsequent investigations and the money trail.

136.

The ld. DR submitted that the AO had identified a pattern whereby SEMPL and other entities raised invoices for domestic events, while funds were routed through intermediary entities and ultimately used for charter flights and related expenditure. According to the Revenue, the relevant transactions were not isolated accounting discrepancies but formed part of a systematic arrangement for disguising personal expenditure as promotional expenditure.

137.

The ld. DR further submitted that the statement of Shri Hemant Dahiya and the material seized during the search supported the Revenue’s case. According to the DR, Ld CIT(A) had correctly relied on the surrounding circumstances and the money trail in sustaining the disallowance relating to the four identified events but erred in deleting the balance expenditure.

138.

The ld. DR submitted that the burden of establishing the allowability of a deduction rested upon the assessee. According to the Revenue, the assessee had not sufficiently demonstrated that the invoices raised by SEMPL represented services actually rendered for the amounts claimed or that the payments were wholly applied towards the stated events.

139.

It was submitted that the AO had identified deficiencies in the supporting evidence, including the absence of adequate contemporaneous records or internal communications corroborating certain events and the lack of a satisfactory explanation for the connection between event invoices and the charter-flight payments. The DR contended that the assessee’s reliance on invoices and cost break-ups did not adequately rebut the specific findings recorded by the AO.

140.

The ld. DR submitted that Ld CIT(A) had confined the disallowance to the 14 events identified by the AO, whereas those events were illustrative instances of the alleged modus operandi and were not intended to represent the only transactions in which the arrangement had operated.

141.

The DR contended that Ld CIT(A) had placed undue reliance on the existence of invoices and event-related material without adequately addressing the money trail, the statements recorded during the search and the alleged absence of evidence corroborating the actual quantum and nature of services rendered.

142.

Without prejudice to the submission that the disallowance ought to be restored, the ld. DR submitted that the matter be restored to the AO for event-wise verification if this Tribunal considered further factual examination necessary.

143.

The ld. DR accordingly prayed that the relief of Rs.80,60,76,963 granted by Ld CIT(A) be withdrawn and the disallowance restored to the extent warranted by the evidence, or, alternatively, that the matter be remanded to the AO for event-wise verification.

144.

With regard to ground nos. 4 and 5 of revenue appeal, learned DR submitted that Ld. CIT(A) erred in deleting ₹1,48,94,358 out of the foreign-travel disallowance of Rs.2,97,88,716, attributing the deleted amount to the Chairman’s wife. According to him, the assessee had failed to establish that the wife’s participation in the foreign trip was required by business expediency or that she performed any identifiable business function.

145.

With regard to FIFA World cup even in Brazil, Learned DR brought to our notice the written submissions addressed to the disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040 sustained by Ld CIT(A) in respect of the FIFA World Cup 2014 event in Brazil. The learned DR submitted that the AO had found that the cost of the charter flight booked through Dream or Fast and paid to 365 Aviation was not separately reflected in the event invoices issued by SEMPL.

146.

The ld. DR relied upon the findings recorded by the AO concerning invoice Nos. 2094 and 2095 and the corresponding cost break-up sheets. It was submitted that the absence of the charter-flight cost from the event invoices supported the Revenue’s allegation that the expenditure on the Chairman’s travel had been routed through the event-management arrangements.

147.

The ld. DR also submitted that SEMPL had not responded to the notice issued under section 133(6) of the Act. Learned DR contended that the assessee’s production of event-related documents did not sufficiently rebut the specific finding that the charter-flight expenditure was not shown as part of the cost of the FIFA event. The learned DR accordingly supported Ld CIT(A)’s decision to sustain the disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040/-.

148.

Considered the rival submissions, perused the material placed on record and the relevant grounds raised by the assessee and the Revenue. The controversy in the present appeals concerns, firstly, the validity of the reassessment proceedings and, secondly, the allowability of expenditure claimed in respect of domestic promotional events, foreign travel and the FIFA World Cup 2014 event.

149.

Since the assessee has challenged the very assumption of jurisdiction by the Assessing Officer (AO), the jurisdictional grounds are required to be examined first. If the reassessment proceedings are found to be invalid, the additions made pursuant thereto cannot survive. Nevertheless, having regard to the detailed arguments advanced by both sides on the merits, we also consider it appropriate to record our findings on the substantive issues, in the alternative, so that the controversy is addressed comprehensively.

150.

At the outset the delay in filing of revenue appeals which is approx. 41 days is hereby condoned.

151.

As regards the ground no.1.1 of the assessee on the issue, whether the order dated 30.03.2024, received on 03.04.2024, was made within the period allowed by section 153(2). The learned DR pointed to the assessee’s own document showing dispatch by Speed Post on 31.03.2024 (20:32 hrs), and the Hon’ble Delhi High Court judgement in case of Suman Jeet Agarwal v. Income Tax Officer, (2022) 449 ITR 517 (Del.), as cited which treats dispatch as issue.

152.

The statutory period, on the basis of the notice having been served during financial year 2022-23, is stated by the parties to have expired on 31th March 2024. The assessment order bears the date 30th March 2024. The assessee’s objection proceeds on the distinction between the date borne by the order and the date of its receipt. The Revenue, on the other hand, contends that the statutory expression “made” does not require actual receipt by the assessee before expiry of the period. The Synopsis of assessee does not press this specific ground. The ground no.1.1 of the assessee does not appear sustainable and hence dismissed.

153.

With regard to Ground no. 1.2 and 1.3, ld. AR submitted that although a search was conducted in the assessee’s case on 23th March 2022, the material forming the basis of the impugned additions was substantially obtained from searches conducted in the case of SEMPL and its related entities. The Ld. DR, on the other hand, submitted that Explanation 2(i) to section 148 was applicable because the assessee itself had been searched and that separate approval under Explanation 2(iii)/(iv) was consequently unnecessary.

154.

In this regard, ld. AR relied, inter alia, on Exel Rubber Pvt. Ltd. (ITAT Hyderabad, ITA Nos. 1566 and 1571/Hyd/2025) and Vamsiram Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT (ITAT Hyderabad, ITA Nos. 661–667/Hyd/2026). The proposition advanced is that where the reopening is founded on material seized from a third party, the Assessing Officer must follow the applicable statutory procedure and cannot substitute a different statutory route merely because a search was also conducted in the assessee’s case.

155.

The ld. DR also submitted that the search warrant was issued in the assessee’s name and that the show-cause notice dated 10th February 2024 records that papers and documents belonging to the assessee were found and seized from various premises. It contends that the reference to material seized from parties related to the Hero MotoCorp Group must be read with the reasons as a whole, which expressly invoke Explanation 2(i). The Revenue further relied upon Principal Commissioner of Income Tax v. Abhisar Buildwell (P.) Ltd. (2023) 454 ITR 212 (SC) and Principal Commissioner of Income Tax v. Naveen Kumar Gupta (2025) 479 ITR 586 (Delhi),

156.

We have considered the rival submissions. The fact that a search was conducted in the assessee’s own case is material to the applicability of Explanation 2(i). At the same time, the mere fact that the AO was statutorily deemed to possess information suggesting escapement of income does not dispense with the requirement that the notice be issued within the period prescribed by section 149 of the Act or that the other jurisdictional conditions applicable to the case be satisfied.

157.

We observed that ld. AR has drawn our attention to paragraph 3 of the annexure to the notice dated 22nd December 2023, which refers to material seized during search proceedings conducted on parties related to the Hero MotoCorp Group. He has also pointed out that the recorded reasons invoked Explanation 2(i), whereas the approval under section 151(ii), according to him, did not separately address the applicability of Explanation 2(iii)/(iv).

158.

In our considered view, the issue cannot be determined merely by reference to the identity of the person searched. The source and nature of the material, the statutory provision invoked in the recorded reasons and the approval actually granted must be examined together. Nevertheless, it is not necessary to rest our ultimate conclusion exclusively on this controversy, since the assessee’s objection regarding limitation requires independent consideration which in our view is more important to examine compared to other jurisdictional issues raised by the assessee. Therefore, this issue is not adjudicated by us and dismissed on the ground of hyper technicalities involved.

159.

With regard to Ground no 1.4 raised by the assessee, the assessee has challenged the validity of reassessment proceedings on the ground that the issue of notice was beyond the period of 3 years contemplated in the section 149 of the Act. Further, the assessee has challenged the reopening on account of limitation owing to grandfathered condition of ‘asset’ in terms of 4th proviso to section 153A(1) imported in the section 149. We herewith deal with the limitation under each such scenarios.

160.

The assessee has challenged the notice under section 148 dated 2nd March 2023 on the ground that it was issued beyond three years from the end of AY 2015–16. The ld. DR on the other hand submitted that the notice is covered by section 149(1)(b), since the alleged escaped income exceeds Rs.50 lakh and the information available to the Assessing Officer concerns expenditure incurred in connection with transactions and events.

161.

We have considered the rival submissions. The relevant assessment year ended on 31 March 2016. The regular three-year period expired on 31st March 2019, and the notice dated 2nd March 2023 was issued beyond that period. However, section 149(1)(b), as applicable on the date of issue of the impugned notice, permitted the issue of a notice after three years, but within ten years from the end of the relevant assessment year, where the prescribed statutory conditions were fulfilled.

162.

It is important to note that after amendment made by the Finance Act, 2022, the applicable provision expressly covered income chargeable to tax which had escaped assessment and was represented in the form of an asset, expenditure in respect of a transaction or in relation to an event or occasion, or an entry or entries in the books of account, where the amount involved is Rs.50 lakh or more. The relevant amendment in section 149(1) made by Finance Act, 2022 which is effective from 1st April, 2022 is reproduced hereunder for ready reference:

“47.

In section 149 of the Income-tax Act, in sub-section (1),—

(i)

for clause (b), the following clause shall be substituted, namely:—

“(b)

if three years, but not more than ten years, have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year unless the Assessing Officer has in his possession books of account or other documents or evidence which reveal that the income chargeable to tax, represented in the form of—

(i)

an asset;

(ii)

expenditure in respect of a transaction or in relation to an event or occasion; or

(iii)

an entry or entries in the books of account, which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more:”;

163.

After above the amendment statutory test was therefore not confined to income represented in the form of an asset. Expenditure relating to a transaction or event were also brought within the provision. In the present case, the recorded reasons refer to an appraisal report suggesting alleged non-business expenditure of Rs.99,25,92,409/- for AY 2015–16. The amounts alleged to have escaped assessment thus exceeded the monetary threshold specified in section 149(1)(b), and the allegations concerned expenditure relating to transactions and events.

164.

In these circumstances, we are unable to accept the assessee’s submission that the notice must be invalidated solely because three years had elapsed from the end of AY 2015–16. The relevant statutory provision expressly contemplated the issue of a notice beyond three years where its conditions were fulfilled. The three-year limitation objection, considered in isolation, is accordingly rejected.

165.

The assessee’s principal contention is that AY 2015–16 falls outside the six-year block associated with the search conducted on 23rd March 2022 and that the notice under section 148 could be issued for that year only if the conditions prescribed by the applicable grandfathering provisions were satisfied. The ld. DR submitted that the notice was issued within ten years from the end of AY 2015-16 and that the alleged escapement exceeded Rs.50 lakh.

166.

We have considered the rival submissions in the context of the statutory scheme relied upon by the parties. The first proviso to amended section 149(1) contains a restriction on the issuance of notices for earlier assessment years by reference to the limitation provisions applicable under the pre-amended law. The question, therefore, is not answered merely by establishing that the notice dated 2nd March 2023 fell within the outer ten-year period. It is also necessary to determine whether the notice survives the restriction imposed by the first proviso and whether the conditions for reaching an assessment year outside the relevant six-year search block stand fulfilled.

167.

The search in the present case was conducted on 23th March 2022, relevant to AY 2022-23. The assessee’s case, AY 2015-16 falls outside the six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the search. The assessee has accordingly relied upon the fourth proviso to section 153A(1), as it stood under the erstwhile regime, which permits action in respect of an assessment year beyond the ordinary search block only in the circumstances and subject to the conditions specified therein. The ld. DR has contended that the AO possessed books of account, documents and bank records evidencing expenditure exceeding Rs.50 lakh and that the alleged diversion of funds through SEMPL, Dream Business Solutions, Fast and 365 Aviation satisfied the applicable statutory threshold.

168.

In our view, the quantum of the alleged escaped income and the statutory requirement that such income be represented by an “asset” are distinct conditions and cannot be treated as interchangeable. The fact that the AO has alleged a disallowance of expenditure exceeding Rs.50 lakh does not, by itself, establish that the escaped income is represented by an asset of the nature contemplated by the applicable provision. The first proviso to section 149 of the Act was enacted to ensure that the substituted reassessment provisions did not revive proceedings which had already become time-barred under the applicable earlier provisions. The extended period prescribed under the substituted section must therefore be read subject to this grandfathering restriction. The proviso to section 149 of the Act is reproduced below for ready reference:

“[Time limit for notice.

149.

(1) No notice under section 148 shall be issued for the relevant assessment year,—

(a)

if three years have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year, unless the case falls under clause (b);

[(b) if three years, but not more than ten years, have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year unless the Assessing Officer has in his possession books of account or other documents or evidence which reveal that the income chargeable to tax, represented in the form of—

(i)

an asset;

(ii)

expenditure in respect of a transaction or in relation to an event or occasion; or

(iii)

an entry or entries in the books of account, which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more:]

Provided that no notice under section 148 shall be issued at any time in a case for the relevant assessment year beginning on or before 1st day of April, 2021, if [a notice under section 148 or section 153A or section 153C could not have been issued at that time on account of being beyond the time limit specified under the provisions of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of this section or section 153A or section 153C, as the case may be], as they stood immediately before the commencement of the Finance Act, 2021:” The provisions of section 153A providing period of limitation with reference to existence of asset is as under:

“Assessment in case of search or requisition.

153A. (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 139, section 147, section 148, section 149, section 151 and section 153, in the case of a person where a search is initiated under section 132 or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned under section 132A after the 31st day of May, 2003 9[but on or before the 31st day of March, 2021], the Assessing Officer shall—

(a)

issue notice to such person requiring him to furnish within such period, as may be specified in the notice, the return of income in respect of each assessment year falling within six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years referred to in clause (b), in the prescribed form and verified in the prescribed manner and setting forth such other particulars as may be prescribed and the provisions of this Act shall, so far as may be, apply accordingly as if such return were a return required to be furnished under section 139;

(b)

assess or reassess the total income of six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which such search is conducted or requisition is made and for the relevant assessment year or years :

Provided that the Assessing Officer shall assess or reassess the total income in respect of each assessment year falling within such six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years :

Provided further that assessment or reassessment, if any, relating to any assessment year falling within the period of six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years referred to in this sub-section pending on the date of initiation of the search under section 132 or making of requisition under section 132A, as the case may be, shall abate:

Provided also that the Central Government may by rules10 made by it and published in the Official Gazette (except in cases where any assessment or reassessment has abated under the second proviso), specify the class or classes of cases in which the Assessing Officer shall not be required to issue notice for assessing or reassessing the total income for six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made and for the relevant assessment year or years :

Provided also that no notice for assessment or reassessment shall be issued by the Assessing Officer for the relevant assessment year or years unless—

(a)

the Assessing Officer has in his possession books of account or other documents or evidence which reveal that the income, represented in the form of asset, which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more in the relevant assessment year or in aggregate in the relevant assessment years;

(b)

the income referred to in clause (a) or part thereof has escaped assessment for such year or years; and

(c)

the search under section 132 is initiated or requisition under section 132A is made on or after the 1st day of April, 2017.

Explanation 1.—For the purposes of this sub-section, the expression "relevant assessment year" shall mean an assessment year preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made which falls beyond six assessment years but not later than ten assessment years from the end of the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made.

Explanation 2.—For the purposes of the fourth proviso, "asset" shall include immovable property being land or building or both, shares and securities, loans and advances, deposits in bank account.”

169.

The additions in the impugned assessment arise principally from the AO’s allegation that expenditure claimed under section 37(1) of the Act was, in substance, expenditure incurred for non-business purposes. The recorded case, as described in the material before us, concerns the alleged diversion of payments made towards event-management services to meet charter-flight and related expenses. The Revenue has not demonstrated, merely by referring to the aggregate quantum of the disallowances, that the alleged escaped income was represented by an asset falling within the statutory definition applicable to the extended search-year framework.

170.

The ld. DR has relied upon the bank statements, transaction records and the alleged money trail through the intermediary entities. However, the existence of bank transactions evidencing payments does not, without further analysis, establish that the escaped income itself was represented by an asset of the prescribed nature. The statutory condition must be satisfied on the facts of the case and cannot be replaced by a general finding that the amount involved exceeded Rs.50 lakh.

171.

We have also considered the decisions relied upon by the assessee, including Smart Chip (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 476 ITR 389 (Del.), Dinesh Jindal v. ACIT 469 ITR 32 (Del.) and Flowmore Ltd. v. DCIT 467 ITR 177 (Del.), insofar as they have been cited in support of the distinction between escaped income and income represented by an asset. The principle sought to be applied by the assessee is that the statutory asset condition cannot be satisfied merely by quantifying an alleged disallowance or expenditure. The relevant paras of judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in case of Smart Chip (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT [2025] 476 ITR 389 (Del.) are being reproduced hereunder which are directly relevant to the issue under consideration :-

“Reasons & Conclusion

7.

At the outset, it is relevant to refer the relevant extract of Section 149 of the Act, as was in force at the material time. The same is set out below:

"149.

Time limit for notice: - (1) No notice under section 148 shall be issued for the relevant assessment year,—

(a)

if three years have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year, unless the case falls under clause (b);

(b)

if three years, but not more than ten years, have elapsed from the end of the relevant assessment year unless the Assessing Officer has in his possession books of account or other documents or evidence which reveal that the income chargeable to tax, represented in the form of—

(i)

an asset;

(ii)

expenditure in respect of a transaction or in relation to an event or occasion; or

(iii)

an entry or entries in the books of account, which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more:

Provided that no notice under section 148 shall be issued at any time in a case for the relevant assessment year beginning on or before 1st day of April, 2021, if a notice under section 148 or section 153A or section 153C could not have been issued at that time on account of being beyond the time limit specified under the provisions of clause (b) of sub-section (1) of this section or section 153A or section 153C, as the case may be, as they stood immediately before the commencement of the Finance Act, 2021:

Provided further that the provisions of this sub-section shall not apply in a case, where a notice under section 153A, or section 153C read with section 153A, is required to be issued in relation to a search initiated under section 132 or books of account, other documents or any assets requisitioned under section 132A, on or before the 31st day of March, 2021:"

8.

A plain reading of the first proviso to Section 149(1) of the Act indicates that the issuance of a notice under Section 148 of the Act is proscribed if a notice under Sections 148, 153A or 153C of the Act could not have been issued at that time on account of the time limit specified under Clause (b) of Section 149(1) of the Act, or under Section 153A or Section 153C, as in force at that time.

9.

We also consider it apposite to refer to the following observations made by the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Rajeev Bansal: 2024 SCC OnLine SC 2693/ [2024] 167 taxmann.com 70/301 Taxman 238/469 ITR 46 (SC):

"49.

The first proviso to Section 149(1)(b) requires the determination of whether the time limit prescribed under section 149(1)(b) of the oLd regime continues to exist for the assessment year 2021-2022 and before. Resultantly, a notice under Section 148 of the new regime cannot be issued if the period of six years from the end of the relevant assessment year has expired at the time of issuance of the notice. This also ensures that the new time limit of ten years prescribed under section 149(1)(b) of the new regime applies prospectively. For example, for the assessment year 2012-2013, the ten year period would have expired on 31 March 2023, while the six year period expired on 31 March 2019. Without the proviso to Section 149(1)(b) of the new regime, the Revenue could have had the power to reopen assessments for the year 2012-2013 if the escaped assessment amounted to Rupees fifty lakhs or more. The proviso limits the retrospective operation of Section149(1)(b) to protect the interests of the assesses.

*** *** ***

54.

The proviso to Section 149(1)(b) of the new regime uses the expression "beyond the time limit specified under the provisions of clause (b) of sub section (1) of this section, as they stood immediately before the commencement of the Finance Act, 2021." Thus, the proviso specifically refers to the time limits specified under section 149(1)(b) of the old regime. The Revenue accepts that without application of Taxation and other Laws (Relaxation and Amendment of Certain Provisions) Act, 2020, the time limit for issuance of reassessment notices after 1 April 2021 expires for assessment years 2013-2014, 2014-2015, 2015-2016, 2016-2017, and 2017-2018 in the following manner:

(i)

for the assessment years 2013-2014 and 2014-2015, the six year period expires on 31 March 2020 and 31 March 2021 respectively; and

(ii)

for the assessment years 2016-2017 and 2017-2018, the three year period expires on 31 March 2020 and 31 March 2021 respectively."

(Emphasis supplied)

10.

The aforesaid observations in Rajeev Bansal (supra) were made in the context of time limits for issuing notice under Section 148 of the Act under the provisions as were in force prior to 31.03.2021, as imputed by virtue of the first proviso to Section 149(1) of the Act. This principle would be equally applicable for proscribing the issuance of a notice under Section 148 of the Act, if the proceedings for reassessment could not be initiated under the provisions of Section 153A or 153C of the Act, or under Section 153A or Section 153C of the Act as referred to in the first proviso to Section 149(1) of the Act. There is no cavil that the impugned notice would be unsustainable if such a notice could not be issued under the provision of Section 153A of the Act as was applicable in respect of a search conducted prior to 31.03.2021. It thus requires us to determine the period of limitation within which a notice under Section 153A could be issued in respect of AY 2016-17.

11.

It is the petitioner's case that the time limit for issuance of such notice is confined to the six assessment years preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search was conducted. However, the Revenue contends that by virtue of Explanation 1 to Section 153A(1) of the Act, the Revenue can travel back ten years from the end of the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the search under Section 132 was conducted or a requisition under Section 132A of the Act was made. Plainly, the said controversy is required to be addressed by referring to Section 153A of the Act. Section 153A(1) of the Act is set out below:

"153A. Assessment in case of search or requisition.- (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 139, section 147, section 148, section 149, section 151 and section 153, in the case of a person where a search is initiated under section 132 or books of account, other documents or any assets are requisitioned under section 132A after the 31st day of May, 2003 [but on or before the 31st day of March, 2021], the Assessing Officer shall—

(a)

issue notice to such person requiring him to furnish within such period, as may be specified in the notice, the return of income in respect of each assessment year falling within six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years referred to in clause (b), in the prescribed form and verified in the prescribed manner and setting forth such other particulars as may be prescribed and the provisions of this Act shall, so far as may be, apply accordingly as if such return were a return required to be furnished under section 139;

(b)

assess or reassess the total income of six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which such search is conducted or requisition is made and of the relevant assessment year or years:

Provided that the Assessing Officer shall assess or reassess the total income in respect of each assessment year falling within such six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years:

Provided further that assessment or reassessment, if any, relating to any assessment year falling within the period of six assessment years and for the relevant assessment year or years referred to in this subsection pending on the date of initiation of the search under section 132 or making of requisition under section 132A, as the case may be, shall abate:

Provided also that the Central Government may by rules made by it and published in the Official Gazette (except in cases where any assessment or reassessment has abated under the second proviso), specify the class or classes of cases in which the Assessing Officer shall not be required to issue notice for assessing or reassessing the total income for six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made and for the relevant assessment year or years:

Provided also that no notice for assessment or reassessment shall be issued by the Assessing Officer for the relevant assessment year or years unless—

the Assessing Officer has in his possession books of account or other documents or evidence which reveal that the income, represented in the form of asset, which has escaped assessment amounts to or is likely to amount to fifty lakh rupees or more in the relevant assessment year or in aggregate in the relevant assessment years;

the income referred to in clause (a) or part thereof has escaped assessment for such year or years; and

the search under section 132 is initiated or requisition under section 132A is made on or after the 1st day of April, 2017.

Explanation 1.—For the purposes of this sub-section, the expression "relevant assessment year" shall mean an assessment year preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made which falls beyond six assessment years but not later than ten assessment years from the end of the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made.

Explanation 2.—For the purposes of the fourth proviso, "asset" shall include immovable property being land or building or both, shares and securities, loans and advances, deposits in bank account."

12.

It is apparent from the above that Section 153A of the Act refers to time periods within which the assessments could be reopened. In terms of Section 153A(1) of the Act, the assessments can be reopened for a block of six years preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search under Section 132 of the Act is conducted or requisition is made under Section 132A of the Act as well as the relevant assessment year or years.

13.

As is apparent from the plain language of Section 153A(1) of the Act, the AO has the jurisdiction to issue a notice in respect of each of the assessment years falling within six assessment years as well as for the relevant year or years as referred to in Clause (b) of Section 153A(1) of the Act. However, the fourth proviso to Section 153A(1) of the Act proscribes issuance of any notice for assessment or reassessment in respect of a relevant assessment year unless the conditions as stipulated in the fourth proviso are satisfied.

14.

The expression "relevant assessment year" is defined under Explanation 1 to sub-section (i) of Section 153A of the Act to mean a year that falls beyond the period of six assessment years preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made, but not later than ten assessment years from the end of the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which search is conducted or requisition is made.

15.

Mr. Maratha's contention that the extended period of limitation under Section 153A of the Act would be applicable for the purpose of the proviso to Section 149(1) of the Act notwithstanding that the conditions, as stipulated in the fourth proviso to Section 153A of the Act are not satisfied, is unmerited.

Once, we accept that a notice under Section 148 of the Act cannot be issued if such a notice could not be issued under Section 153A of the Act; it would be necessary to determine the period of limitation for issuance of a notice under Section 153A of the Act. Since a block of six assessment years and a further period not exceeding the block of ten assessment years is contemplated under Section 153A of the Act, it follows that it would be necessary to determine whether the extended period of ten years is applicable in the facts of the present case. This necessitates considering the reasons as recorded for issuance of the impugned notice. The relevant extract of the reasons for reopening the reassessment, as furnished to the petitioner, is set out below:

"2.1

Information:-In the case, the search proceedings and post-search investigations of Idemia India and other group entities revealed that these entities are engaged in massive profit shifting outside India. It has been unearthed that Idemia India and its group entities have deployed various mechanisms through which it is shifting profit to their Associated Enterprises (AEs) especially Idemia France SAS and Idemia Germany GmBH.

Investigation have revealed various tax-avoiding arrangements operated by the group entities like export sales made to AEs at very low markup, import purchases made from AEs at unjustified markup, management fees paid to AEs without any actual services received, Purchase of RAW materials from AEs, R&D services provided to AEs at low mark-up, transaction with Non-Filers etc. A summary of the modus operandi is as under:

A. Expenses Debit to Non- Filers:

It was observed that Smart Chip Pvt Ltd had undertaken various transactions in the nature of contract, rent, professional charges with various parties who have not either never filed the ITR or not filed in the year in which transaction occurred. The details of transactions are tabulated below:

*** *** ***

In this regard, summons notices were issued to the above non-filers to verify the genuineness of the transactions by investigation wing. However, no response has been received from the parties till date. In the absence of any compliance by the party and in view of the fact that above parties are non-filer till date, the genuineness of contract/rent payments made by Smart Chip could not be verified.

In view of the above, assessee's income aggregating ?4,46,21,363/- has escaped assessment by way of various transactions during the FY 2015-16 to FY 2020-21 in the nature of contract, rent, professional charges with various parties who have not either never filed the ITR or not filed in the year in which transaction. Hence the genuineness of expenses of ?4,46,21,363/- with non-filers from FY 2015-16 to 2020-21 needs to be verified.

B. DISALLOWANCE OF PERSONAL EXPENSES

It is noticed that during the course of search proceedings, some incriminating evidences were seized from the premises of Mr. Matthew David Foxton (34, Jor Bagh, New Delhi-110003) annexurized as Annexure A-2 in Premise TDR-9, wherein some instances of personal expenses of the key persons of Smart Chip Pvt. Ltd. were claimed in the books of accounts of Smart Chip.

The incriminating evidences found are discussed as under:

*** *** ***

On perusal of the above, it can be noted that gold items worth Rs.2,42,646/were being purchased in FY 2015-16. Further, it can be noticed that Smart Chip has been regularly incurring expenses for the personal benefit of directors and key managerial personnel for example purchase of iPhones, Sarees, Purfume, Hotel bills, credit card payments, etc. Further, it has also been observed that the company is also regularly incurring expenses for alcohols for officers, IPL tickets for bank officials, travel bills of government officers for availing favours from them. These expenses incurred to illegally obtain undue favours are in infraction of law and cannot be allowed as deduction. Furthermore, such personal expenses cannot also be said to have been incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of business and needs to be examined.

C. Disallowance of expenses paid to VIHAAN INFRASYSTEMS LTD.

It is noticed that some incriminating evidences were seized from the premises of Mr. Matthew David Foxton (34, Jor Bagh, New Delhi-110003) annexurized as A-2 in Premise TDR-9, wherein some instances of unduly routing of money to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. in the garb of contractual manpower services and other support services and the said expense cost was being claimed in the books of the Smart Chip. The extracts of incriminating evidences as found during the course of search are discussed as under:

On perusal of the above observations as noted from the Memo of KPMG Paris seized during the course of search, Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. provided significant manpower services to Smart Chip along with other support services such as data management, training, IT services, business support rent etc. In this regard, the details of expenses incurred and paid by Smart Chip to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. in FY 2015-16 relevant to AY 2016-17 amounting to Rs.8,70,00,000 /-.

Various incriminating facts were noted from perusal of the seized memo which raised significant doubts over the genuineness of the payments made by Smart Chip to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd.:

■ Smart Chip is the major contributor to the total revenue of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. and in some financial years, the expenses paid by Smart Chip to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. even exceeded the total revenue of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd.;

■ Mr. Sanjeev Shriya, his family members and Mr. Alok Mukherjee were shareholders and key managerial persons of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. in the past years and can be said to have significant influence over the affairs of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. and thus, it can be observed that Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. was used to book non-genuine expenses in the books of Smart Chip and divert money for the benefit of specific persons;

■ Common address, website of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. and Smart Chip and other group companies;

■ Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. presented as a group company / related company of Idemia Group entities;

■ Mr. Sanjeev Kumar Jain, holding substantial shares in Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd., was the former employee of Smart Chip and having close relationship/connivance with Mr. Sanjeev Shriya;

■ The fees charged by Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. was much higher as compared to other contractual manpower company;

■ No proper documentation and proof of service existed in respect of expense transactions with Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd.

■ Discrepancies in employee's attendance record found which further establishes the non-receipt of any actual services and non-genuineness of the transaction with Vihaan lnfrasystems Ltd.

Further, the above observations in the seized Memo were also corroborated with detailed analysis in the Memo including list of shareholders as on 31.03.2016, Sanjeev Kumar Jain profile, extracts of Memorandum of Association of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. signed in 2004, Archived version of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. website, Linkedln profile of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd., consent form signed by Smart Chip's landlord providing permission to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. to use their office space and Vihan noted as related party, links of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. with Aadharshila and Smart Chip, related party disclosures in the other companies of Mr. Sanjeev Shriya (Goldrock Investment) showing Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. as related party in its Annual report for FY 20 16-17, domain name verification of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. wherein Smart Chip shown as registrant organization, proofs that Smart Chip's address noted as address of Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. on Government's website, MCA etc, analysis of invoices raised by Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd., physical verification of premises of Vihaan lnfrasystems Ltd., and various other analysis.

All the above incriminating evidences clearly showed that Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. was merely a conduit entity which was used to unduly transfer money from Smart Chip and book non-genuine expenses in the books of Smart Chip. The evidences establishes that no genuine services were provided by Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. to Smart Chip. This finding is in fact based on the internal report prepared by Idemia Group with the help of KPMG Paris. Hence, the payments made by Smart Chip to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. are found to be non-genuine and nowhere wholly and exclusively related to the business of the Smart Chip.

Thus, in view of the above, it is clearly corroborated that Smart Chip has been regularly making payments to Vihaan Infrasystems Limited without any actual receipt of any services and thus, claim of expenses of Rs.8,70,00,000/-cannot be said to be wholly and exclusively incurred for the purpose of business during the FY 20 15-16 relevant to AY 2016-17 and treated as escaped assessment and needs to be examined.

As discussed above, assessee's income of Rs.9.21 Crores by way of expenses debited to non -filers and personal expenses & payment made to Vihaan Infrasystems Limited for F.Y. 2015-16 relevant to A.Y. 2016-17 in the head of business expenses has escaped assessment and needs to be examined.

*** *** ***

2.

Evidently, warrant was issued in the name of the assessee and the case of the assessee was covered under Search u/s 132 of the Income Tax Act 1961 on 21.03.2023.

3.

Hence, in light of the provisions of Explanation-2 to Section 148 and first proviso to Section 148A, I am satisfied that I have 'information' which suggests that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in the case of the assessee for the year under consideration and it is a fit case to issue notice u/s 148 r.w.s 149 r.w.s 151(ii) of the Income Tax Act 1961 as amended by the Finance Act 2022.

4.

In view of the above, the assessee has misrepresent the amount of Rs.9.21 Crorcs [Rs.0.49 Crore expenses debited to non-filers + Rs.0.024 Crores as personal expenses + Rs.8.70 Crores as expenses debited to Vihaan Infrasystems Ltd. represented in the form of an entry and expenditure] in its ITR filed for F. Y. 201516 relevant to A. Y. 2016-17 by way of various tax-avoiding arrangements and shifting profits to their Associated Enterprises (AEs) outside India. Therefore, as specified u/s 149(l)(b) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 read with explanation thereto which suggests that income exceeding Rs.50 lakh chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in this case which is represented in the form of an entry and expenditure."

16.

It is apparent from the above that the AO believed that the petitioner's income had escaped assessment for AY 2016-17 on essentially three grounds. First, that the petitioner had deducted expenses relating to amounts paid to certain persons who had not filed their income tax returns and the AO thus doubted the genuineness of the said transactions. Second, that the petitioner had booked expenses, which according to the AO, were personal expenses of its directors and had not been incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of the petitioner's business. And third, that the petitioner had paid certain amounts as expenses for availing contractual manpower services and the AO doubted the genuineness of the said payments.

17.

It is clear from the above that there is no allegation that the income which has escaped assessment was represented in the form of an asset. Therefore, the conditions as stipulated in Clause (a) of the fourth proviso to Section 153A(1) of the Act are not satisfied. The AO does not have the possession any books of account, other documents or evidence, which reveals that the petitioner's income that is represented in the form of an asset has escaped assessment.

18.

In terms of Explanation 2 to Section 153A(1) of the Act, the term 'asset' is defined to include immovable property being land or building or both, shares and securities, loans and advances, deposits in bank accounts.

19.

The AO seeks to disallow expenses on account of doubting the genuineness for the reason that the same were not incurred wholly or exclusively for the purpose of the petitioner's business. Absent any further material to establish that such expenses had resulted in the acquisition of any asset, the conditions stipulated in the fourth proviso to Section 153A(1) of the Act would remain unsatisfied.

20.

In the aforesaid view the period of limitation for issuing a notice under Section 153A of the Act, in the given facts of this case, would necessarily have to be confined to a period of six assessment years immediately preceding the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the search under Section 132 of the Act was conducted.

21.

The search in question was conducted in financial year 2022-23; thus, the relevant block of six assessment years would be the six assessment years preceding AY 2023-24, being the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the search was conducted. Accordingly, AY 2016-17 falls beyond the block of six years.

22.

In view of the above, the impugned notice as well as the proceedings initiated pursuant thereto are set aside. The petition is allowed in the aforesaid terms. Pending applications also stand disposed of.”

172.

Applying the above ratio, the earlier six-year limitation, for AY 2015-16 expired on 31th March 2022. The notice under section 148 was not issued until 2nd March 2023, that is, after the expiry of the earlier six-year period. In the facts presented, the Revenue’s reliance on the alleged routing of expenditure through bank accounts does not, by itself, answer the statutory question. The AO was required to establish that the conditions for reopening an assessment year beyond the ordinary search block were satisfied in the manner prescribed by law. The Revenue cannot overcome the grandfathering restriction merely by relying upon the broader categories of expenditure and events subsequently included in section 149(1)(b). Those categories may be relevant to the extended-period test under the substituted provision, but they cannot be used to remove the limitation protection expressly preserved by the first proviso.

173.

The statutory distinction is decisive. While the substituted section 149(1)(b) may permit reopening beyond three years in a case involving qualifying expenditure of ₹50 lakh or more, the first proviso independently prohibits the issue of a notice where the applicable limitation under the earlier regime had already expired. The two provisions must be given effect to together. The extended-period provision cannot be interpreted so as to render the grandfathering protection redundant.

174.

We accordingly find merit in the contentions of the assessee. The first proviso to section 149 was enacted to ensure that the substituted reassessment provisions did not revive proceedings which had already become time-barred under the applicable earlier provisions. The extended period prescribed under the substituted section must therefore be read subject to this grandfathering restriction.

175.

We, therefore, hold that the reassessment proceedings for AY 2015-16 are barred by limitation and is liable to be quashed due to grandfathering restrictions. The assessee’s jurisdictional ground no.1.4 on this aspect viz. limitation u/s 149(1) rwt. Fourth proviso to section 153A(1) is accordingly allowed.

176.

Applying the above findings to other connected years, the period of limitation in other years are analysed in the table with our findings on the validity of notice and reassessment proceedings which shall apply to each such year.

Year-wise chart of limitation:

Assessment Last date for issue Actual date of Tribunal’s Finding year of notice under issue of notice section 149

AY 2013-14 31.03.2020 02.03.2023 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153A is time-barred and consequently the reassessment proceedings are quashed.

AY 2014-15 31.03.2021 02.03.2023 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153A is time-barred and consequently the reassessment proceedings are quashed.

AY 2015-16 31.03.2022 02.03.2023 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153A is time-barred and consequently the reassessment proceedings are quashed.

AY 2016-17 31.03.2023 02.03.2023 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153Ais within period of limitation and hence proceedings are not liable to be quashed on this ground.

AY 2017-18 31.03.2024 02.03.2023 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153Ais within period of limitation and hence proceedings are not liable to be quashed on this ground.

AY 2019-20 31.03.2026 18.08.2022 Notice u/s 149 rws. 153Ais within period of limitation and hence proceedings are not liable to be quashed on this ground.

177.

With regard to ground no.1.5 raised by the assessee, the assessee has under this ground challenged the validity of the notice issued under section 143(2) of the Act. The assessment order records that, following the filing of the return on 24th March 2023 in response to the notice under section 148, a notice under section 143(2) was issued on 25th April 2023. Ld. DR stated that the notice was generated through the ITBA system and served electronically on 26th April 2023, and that the assessee responded to it on 1st May 2023. Whereas learned AR has challenged the validity of the notice under section 143(2), while fairly acknowledging that the issue has been decided against the assessee by the Special Bench of the Tribunal in MD Sons v. Income Tax Officer [2026] 188 taxmann.com 703 (Bengaluru – Trib.) (Special Bench), dated 13 July 2026.

178.

Having regard to the position acknowledged by the assessee and the material referred to by the parties concerning the issuance and service of the notice, we do not consider it necessary to grant separate relief on this ground and therefore this ground of assessee hereby dismissed.

179.

With regard to sanction u/s 151(ii) of the Act raised in ground no 1.5, the assessee has also challenged the approval under section 151(ii) on the ground that it was granted mechanically, without adequate consideration of the source of the material, the applicable limitation conditions and the statutory basis for reopening. It relied upon United Electrical Co. v. CIT 258 ITR 317 (Delhi) and Yum Restaurants (India) Pvt. Ltd. 397 ITR 665 (Delhi), for the proposition that the statutory authority must exercise the judgment entrusted to it and cannot grant approval as a mere formality. The learned DR has submitted that the proposal was examined by the competent authority and that the approval proforma identified the alleged escaped income and the relevant transactions.

180.

After considering the rival submissions. We observed that the validity of a sanction must be examined with reference to the proposal placed before the sanctioning authority, the reasons recorded by the AO, the approval actually granted and the applicable statutory requirements. In the present case, since we have held the reassessment proceedings to be barred by limitation on the ground discussed above, it is not necessary to record a separate conclusive finding on the adequacy of the sanction. The objection concerning sanction is, therefore, not independently adjudicated beyond the observations made herein.

181.

With regard to ground no 1.6 raised by the assessee, before us it was contended that the recorded reasons were based on generic allegations and third-party material, without an adequate nexus between the information relied upon and the alleged escapement of income. The Revenue has relied upon the seized documents, bank statements, transaction records and the statement of Shri Hemant Dahiya to support the initiation of reassessment.

182.

We are of the view that the sufficiency or adequacy of the material must be distinguished from the existence of information capable of supporting reassessment jurisdiction. The existence of material obtained in a search may be relevant to the initiation of proceedings, but it does not override an express statutory bar on the issuance of notice. Since the reassessment is held to be barred by limitation, it is unnecessary to decide conclusively whether the material, considered independently, would otherwise have satisfied the applicable requirement of information suggesting escapement.

183.

Similarly, the assessee’s objections in ground no.1.7 and ground no. 1.8 concerning the digital signature and natural justice need not be adjudicated as independent grounds once the reassessment itself is held invalid on limitation. The relevant contentions are accordingly disposed of in the above terms.

184.

Summary of our findings on jurisdictional grounds raised by the assessee -ground wise and year-wise is as under:

Issue involved in jurisdictional Ground number Tribunal findings /conclusion grounds raised by the assessee in assessee’s appeal

General challenge to validity of Ground 1 - all General grounds and hence not reassessment six years specifically adjudicated - specific grounds discussed below

Limitation under section 153(2) Ground 1.1 - Dismiss as not pressed for all six years, AYs 2013-14 to as recorded in Annexure 7 of assessee’s 2019-20 synopsis.

Explanation 2(iii)/(iv) versus Grounds 1.2 and Not specifically adjudicated in lead case Explanation 2(i) to section 148 1.3 - all six years due to limitation ground and hence dismissed.

First proviso to section 149 / Ground 1.4 - As held in lead case (AY 2015-16), the grandfathering provision AYs 2013-14, assessments for AY 2015-16 and earlier 2014-15 and assessment years are time barred and 2015-16 hence reassessment orders passed u/s 147 for AY 2013-14, AY 2014-15 and AY 2015-16 are hereby quashed.

Extended limitation under section Ground 1.4 - Not allowed and hence dismissed. 149(1)(b) - 3 years AYs 2013-14 to 2017-18

Invalid notice under section Ground 1.5 - Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. 143(2), invalid/mechanical AYs 2013-14 to sanction and DIN on 2017-18 approval/proforma

Specific objection to approval by Ground 1.4 - AY Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. CCIT (OSD), Central-3, 2019-20 common/mechanical sanction for 22 cases and absence of DIN

Invalid/unreliable third-party Ground 1.6 - Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. information and failure to dispose AYs 2013-14 to of objections 2017-18; Ground 1.5 - AY 2019-20

Assessment order, demand notice Ground 1.7 - Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. or ITNS without digital signature AYs 2013-14 to 2017-18; Ground 1.6 - AY 2019-20

Natural justice, third-party Ground 1.8 - Not adjudicated and hence dismissed. material and denial of AYs 2013-14 to rebuttal/cross-examination 2017-18; Ground 1.7 - AY 2019-20

185.

The following findings are recorded on merits without prejudice to our conclusion that the reassessment proceedings are barred by limitation. We consider it appropriate to examine the substantive issues on merits of additions raised by the assessee and the Revenue in the alternative, since identical issues arise in the appeals relating to other assessment years, in respect of which the reassessment proceedings may not be held to be barred by limitation. The findings recorded herein are, therefore, intended to provide a consistent adjudicatory framework for consideration of the common issues across the relevant assessment years.

186.

However, for the avoidance of doubt, the alternative findings on the merits shall not dilute or modify our primary conclusion on limitation for the assessment year under consideration.

187.

First, we shall deal with the disallowance of domestic event expenditure, the assessee has challenged the disallowance of domestic event expenditure of ₹8,06,26,855/- sustained by Ld CIT(A) in respect of four identified events out original disallowance made of Rs.88,67,03,816/- by the Assessing Officer (“AO”) under section 37(1) of the Act. The corresponding grounds of appeal are Grounds Nos. 2 to 2.4 of the assessee’s appeal. The Revenue, on the other hand, has challenged the relief granted by Ld CIT(A) and seeks restoration of the disallowance to the extent of Rs.80,60,76,963/-.

188.

Considered the rival submissions with reference to the facts set out in paragraphs 77-121 of the assessee’s synopsis and the detailed rebuttal contained in Annexure 6 thereto as well the detailed submission of the Ld. DR. In our view the issue must be examined in the context of the assessee’s business, the nature of the activities undertaken, the documentary evidence furnished, the findings recorded by Ld CIT(A), AO’s order and two remand reports and the specific allegations made concerning the alleged diversion of funds through event-management companies and their vendors.

189.

As submitted, the assessee company is engaged in the design, development, manufacture and marketing of two-wheelers with a market share of approximately 48.3% in the motorcycle segment and 34.6% in the overall two-wheeler segment in India, an annual combined production capacity of approximately 9.50 million two-wheelers, and sales across 47 countries. In a business of this scale, expenditure on product launches, brand activation, dealer and distributor conferences, employee training, publicity, audio-visual production and other promotional activities forms an integral component of marketing and business development. The assessee is one of the largest corporate taxpayers and during the year has shown a gross revenue of approx.Rs.28,000 crores and has returned income offered to the tune of Rs.2,569 Crores.

190.

During the relevant previous year, the assessee incurred expenditure on domestic events through event-management companies, including M/s SALT Experience & Management Pvt. Ltd. (“SEMPL”), Scoop Brand Holdings Pvt. Ltd. (“Scoop”) and M/s Space Monkey Media Project Pvt. Ltd. (“Space”), along with entities engaged by those companies. According to paragraph 83 of the synopses, the assessee’s event-wise classification for AY 2015-16 identified 184 events, including 158 events handled through SEMPL, two through Scoop and 24 through Space. The figures appearing in the synopsis are reproduced as follows:

Event-management company Number of events shown Expenditure incurred

SEMPL 158 ₹77,78,16,818/-

Scoop 2 ₹10,78,17,000/-

Space 24 ₹1,70,000/-

Total 184 ₹88,67,03,818/-

191.

The AO proceeded to disallow the entire domestic event expenditure of Rs.88.67 Crores on the allegation that the events were not genuine and that expenditure recorded in the assessee’s books as domestic event management and brand promotion had, in substance, been used to meet the foreign travel expenses of the Chairman and Managing Director, Shri Pawan Munjal, including charter flights, hotels, air tickets and other travel-related expenditure. The AO’s inference was primarily founded on the examination of 14 selected domestic events spread over AYs 2014-15 to 2018-19, statements recorded from persons associated with the event-management entities, WhatsApp communications and an alleged chain of payments involving SEMPL, its vendors, M/s Dream, M/s Fast and M/s 365 Aviation.

192.

The assessee’s principal contention is that the AO extrapolated allegations concerning selected transactions into a sweeping conclusion that the domestic events did not occur and that the expenditure incurred on all such events was fictitious. The assessee submits that this conclusion is contrary to the contemporaneous documentary evidence furnished during the assessment proceedings, the supporting material produced during the appellate proceedings and the absence of any specific rebuttal in the remand report.

193.

The controversy is therefore not whether the Revenue could investigate the transactions or scrutinise the payments made to event-management companies. The decisive question is whether the AO established, by cogent and relevant evidence, that the particular expenditure claimed by the assessee was not incurred for the purposes of its business or represented personal expenditure booked under the guise of domestic events.

194.

We observe that Section 37(1) of the Act permits deduction of expenditure, not being expenditure of the nature described in sections 30 to 36 and not being capital or personal expenditure, laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business or profession. The provision does not require that every item of expenditure must generate an immediate or separately measurable return. Expenditure incurred to promote a product, strengthen brand recognition, introduce a new model, engage dealers, train employees or develop customer relationships may qualify for deduction where it is incurred for the purposes of the business and is supported by evidence.

195.

The assessee has relied upon various judgements for this proposition viz. CIT v. Malayalam Plantations Ltd. [1964] 53 ITR 140 (SC), CIT v. Birla Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills Ltd. [1971] 82 ITR 166 (SC) and Madhav Prasad Jatia v. CIT [1979] 118 ITR 200 (SC), as referred to in paragraph 94 of the synopsis. The assessee has further relied on J.K. Woollen Manufacturers v. CIT [1969] 72 ITR 612 (SC), CIT v. Walchand & Co. Ltd. [1967] 65 ITR 381 (SC), CIT v. Panipat Woollen & General Mills Co. Ltd. [1976] 103 ITR 66 (SC), CIT v. Dalmia Cement (P.) Ltd. [2002] 254 ITR 344 (Del). and S.A. Builders Ltd. v. CIT [2007] 288 ITR 1 (SC).

196.

These authorities support the principle that business expenditure must be evaluated in the context of commercial expediency and the requirements of the assessee’s business. The AO may examine the genuineness of the expenditure, whether the services were actually obtained and whether the expenditure was incurred for business purposes. However, the AO cannot disallow expenditure merely because a different commercial choice might have been cheaper or because the AO considers the arrangement commercially unusual.

197.

The assessee has also relied on judicial decisions concerning expenditure on advertisement and publicity, including CIT v. Salora International Ltd. [2009] 308 ITR 199 (Del.), CIT v. Spice Distribution Ltd. [2015] 374 ITR 30 (Del.), CIT v. Liberty Group Marketing Division [2008] 173 Taxman 439 (P&H), CIT v. Citi Financial Consumer Finance Ltd. [2011] 335 ITR 29 (Del.) and CIT v. Jubilant Foodworks Ltd. [2014] 271 CTR 227 (Del.).

198.

We observed that the commercial relevance of the expenditure is further demonstrated by the figures placed on record by the assessee. The assessee submitted the following relationship between revenue from operations and advertisement and publicity expenditure:

Financial year Revenue from Advertisement and Percentage of operations (₹ publicity (₹ crore) revenue crore)

FY 2012-13 23,768/- 469/- 2.0%

FY 2013-14 25,275/- 493/- 2.0%

FY 2014-15 27,585/- 669/- 2.4%

FY 2015-16 30,701/- 725/- 2.4%

FY 2016-17 30,872/- 767/- 2.5%

FY 2017-18 32,872/- 838/- 2.5%

FY 2018-19 33,651/- 804/- 2.4%

FY 2019-20 28,836/- 720/- 2.5%

199.

These figures show that expenditure on advertisement and publicity was a recurring component of the assessee’s operations, amounting to approximately 2.0% to 2.5% of revenue over the periods shown. They are consistent with the commercial need to maintain brand visibility, promote new launches and sustain engagement with customers and channel partners in a competitive automobile market.

200.

The assessee’s contention is that the expenditure must be viewed in that commercial context rather than being treated as inherently suspicious because the services were procured from event-management companies. We agree that the nature of the activities described above viz. product promotion, public-event participation, employee training, audiovisual production and dealer engagement etc. is capable of serving a legitimate business purpose. In the absence of evidence demonstrating that a particular event was fictitious or that the expenditure was personal, the claim cannot be rejected merely because it relates to an event-management arrangement.

201.

Further we noticed that in paragraphs 90-93 of the synopsis, the assessee has stated that it furnished complete details of the domestic events, identifying the events, its date, the event-management company, the amount debited to the profit and loss account, the invoice and the supporting cost break-up and in particular the following categories of evidence:

(a)

A complete list of domestic and foreign events handled or organised by the relevant event-management companies, containing particulars of the events and their business justification. The assessee refers to Annexure 1 of its submissions before Ld CIT(A), at pages 2720–2730 of Paper Book Volume IV.

(b)

Event-wise details setting out the name and date of the event, the expense head, the organising party and the amount debited to the profit and loss account.

(c)

Invoices, purchase orders and detailed cost break-ups, together with supporting documents for the events. The assessee refers to pages 1148– 2454 of Paper Book Volume III.

(d)

Photographs, publicity material, event notes, participant details, invitations, correspondence, press coverage and other contemporaneous documents in support of the events.

(e)

Payment records showing that the expenditure was recorded in the books and paid through regular banking channels.

202.

The assessee specifically stated that it submitted the complete supporting material during the assessment proceedings, including its detailed reply dated 18th March 2024, and that the supporting evidences were again placed before the AO during the remand proceedings. The assessee submits that the AO did not identify any specific defect in the evidence relating to the domestic events.

203.

Further, Ld CIT(A), accepted that the nature of the assessee’s business made the organisation of domestic promotional events commercially plausible. Learned CIT(A) also observed that some events were reported in the media or were independently verifiable from information available in the public domain, and that the assessee had supplied substantial documentary material, including invoices, cost break-ups and photographs.

204.

We attach significant weight to the nature and extent of the evidence described above. The assessee did not rely merely upon self-serving ledger entries or an assertion that the events had taken place. It furnished event-specific invoices and supporting documents, which were again made available during the appellate proceedings. Once such evidence was produced, the AO was required to evaluate the material and identify the particular event, invoice or component found to be unreliable.

205.

A general statement that the expenditure could not be conclusively verified does not displace the evidence unless the AO identifies what was not verifiable and why the documents produced by the assessee were insufficient or unreliable. The AO’s remand report dated 21th November 2025, substantially reiterated the earlier allegations and did not specifically rebut the contemporaneous evidence furnished in relation to the events.

206.

Ld. CIT(A) had afforded the AO a further opportunity to examine the evidence, including by calling for additional details through the letter dated 30th September 2025. The assessee furnished its response on 8th October 2025. The remand report did not establish that the events were fictitious or that the expenditure reflected in the invoices had been incurred for personal purposes.

207.

We accordingly find that the assessee discharged its evidentiary burden by producing event-wise documentation supporting the business nature and incurrence of the expenditure. The general allegations made by the AO did not rebut that material.

208.

The AO had alleged that SEMPL had provided services to the assessee aggregating to approximately Rs.976.40 crore during FYs 2012-13 to 2019-20 without executing detailed written service agreements comparable to those executed with certain other clients, including Pernod Ricard. The AO contrasted the assessee’s arrangement with the detailed agreements said to have been executed between SEMPL and other customers.

209.

The assessee on the other hand explained that it did not ordinarily enter into long-term agreements with event-management companies for every promotional activity. Instead, its requirements were discussed for individual events, following which the event-management company issued a proforma invoice or estimate. The terms of engagement were then reflected in the purchase order, invoice and supporting documentation. The assessee’s contention is that the purchase order or proforma invoice, read with the invoice and the subsequent performance of the agreed services, constitutes evidence of the commercial engagement. The assessee also relied upon Alka Bose v. Parmatma Devi (Civil Appeal No. 6197 of 2000) and Nanak Builders and Investors (P.) Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar Alag, AIR 1991 Delhi 315, in support of the proposition that a contract need not invariably be in writing unless the law requires it to be so.

210.

We find merit in the assessee’s submission. The absence of a consolidated written service agreement may be a relevant circumstance when assessing the manner in which a commercial relationship was documented, but it does not establish that no contractual relationship existed or that the services were not rendered. The legal and factual question is whether the engagement and the expenditure are substantiated by the documents and conduct of the parties.

211.

In the present case, the assessee has identified event-specific purchase orders, invoices, cost break-ups and supporting material. The AO has not established that the absence of a master agreement rendered those documents false or that no services were provided in return for the payments. Nor has it been established that the assessee’s transaction with SEMPL was a sham merely because SEMPL used a different form of documentation for other clients.

212.

Commercial arrangements need not be identical across clients. The terms may differ depending on the scope of services, the nature of the event, the duration of the engagement and the manner in which responsibilities are allocated. The fact that another client executed a more detailed agreement does not establish that the assessee’s transaction was non-genuine.

213.

We therefore hold that the absence of a consolidated written agreement with SEMPL does not justify the disallowance of domestic event expenditure. The event-wise purchase orders, invoices and other supporting material must be evaluated on their own merits, and the material summarised before us does not establish that the expenditure was fictitious merely because a separate long-term written agreement was not executed.

214.

The AO also questioned the agency fee charged by SEMPL, stated in the assessee’s submissions to be a mark-up of approximately 7% over cost, and compared it with mark-up of approximately 8% to 12% said to have been charged by SEMPL to other clients. We find that the existence of a mark-up is commercially consistent with an agency or event-management arrangement. The relevant question under section 37(1) is whether the expenditure was actually incurred and was for the purposes of the assessee’s business. Unless the Revenue establishes that the agency fee was fictitious, excessive in a legally relevant sense, or part of a demonstrated arrangement to divert funds for non-business purposes, the mere existence of a mark-up cannot justify disallowance. The allegation concerning the rate of the mark-up therefore does not support the disallowance made under section 37(1).

215.

The AO relied upon a statement recorded from Shri Hemant Dahiya, the managing director of SEMPL, on 23th March 2022, as well as WhatsApp communications concerning charter flights, hotels and travel arrangements.

216.

According to the assessee, the statement merely acknowledged that high-end charter flights were booked for the Chairman and did not establish that the flights represented personal expenditure or that the domestic events had not occurred. The assessee further submitted that the relevant questions in the statement concerned the booking of charter flights, their comparative cost and the pre-agreed rates indicating the travel options and costs finalised in advance and that invoices were raised on the agreed rates. The statement does not establish that the domestic-event invoices were fictitious or that the payments made by the assessee for those events were used for personal travel.

217.

We agree that an admission that charter flights were arranged for the Chairman is not equivalent to an admission that the domestic-event expenditure was fictitious. The two propositions are distinct. The statement must be read in its entirety and in the context of the questions asked and the answers given. A statement concerning arrangements for charter travel cannot be extended to establish that every domestic event organised by the same event-management company was bogus.

218.

The AO further relied upon WhatsApp communications relating to recommendations of hotels, travel itineraries and arrangements for charter flights. The assessee contended that these communications did not establish that the domestic events were fictitious and did not show that the payments made by the assessee for domestic events were diverted to personal expenditure.

219.

The assessee further relied on decisions concerning the evidentiary value of electronic communications and uncorroborated material, including A. Johnkumar v. DCIT, ITA No. 3028/Chny/2019; Monica Kumarpal Banda v. ACIT, ITA No. 170/Mum/2023; Designers Point (India) (P.) Ltd. v. ACIT, ITA No. 2517/Del/2022; and Atul Tantia v. DCIT, ITA No. 492/Kol/2021.

220.

We find that the WhatsApp communications, as described, concerns the travel arrangements and itinerary discussions. The material does not establish the necessary link between those communications and the falsity of the domestic events for which invoices were raised on the assessee. Even if the communications are treated as relevant to the investigation of charter travel, they do not establish that the particular domestic-event invoices were fictitious or represented personal expenditure.

221.

Accordingly, the statement of Shri Dahiya and the WhatsApp communications do not establish the allegation that domestic events were bogus. In the absence of a direct and corroborated connection with the particular expenditure claimed by the assessee, those materials cannot displace the event-wise documentary evidence.

222.

The central allegation in the assessment order was that amounts paid by the assessee to SEMPL and linked entities for domestic events were routed through vendors, including M/s Dream and M/s Fast, and ultimately applied towards charter flights arranged through M/s 365 Aviation for the alleged personal travel of the Chairman.

223.

We note that the assessee has specifically rebutted this allegation before AO and CIT(A) and also reproduced in Annexure 6 of the synopsis. Its principal contentions are that:

(a)

the AO relied on selected extracts of third-party Tally or ledger data rather than a complete and independently reconciled account of the transactions;

(b)

the alleged payments at the different stages of the chain do not reconcile with the amounts invoiced by the event-management companies to the assessee;

(c)

the AO did not produce the underlying charter invoices and travel details necessary to establish the alleged connection in several instances;

(d)

the assessee engaged the event-management company on a lump-sum basis and was not a party to the arrangements between SEMPL and its vendors;

(e)

the coincidence of the dates of a domestic event and the Chairman’s foreign travel does not establish that the domestic-event payment funded the foreign travel; and

(f)

the AO did not identify an instance of foreign travel of the Chairman that was not reflected in the records maintained by the assessee.

224.

The assessee also submitted that the selected 14 events represented only a limited portion of the domestic event expenditure incurred during the relevant period and that the AO extrapolated the allegations concerning selected transactions to the entire body of domestic-event expenditure. The selected events as accounted for approximately 7% to 8% of the total event expenditure for the years covered by the investigation.

225.

We find that the alleged fund trail does not establish the AO’s central conclusion. A payment made by the assessee to SEMPL for an event, followed by a payment made by SEMPL or its vendors to another entity, does not itself establish that the first payment was fictitious. The inference requires a reliable connection between the specific invoice, the service allegedly not rendered, the corresponding movement of funds and the alleged personal expenditure.

226.

The assessee’s relationship was with the event-management company, which was engaged to organise specified events and was responsible for managing the services and associated costs. The assessee was not necessarily a party to the contracts between SEMPL and each of its vendors. The manner in which SEMPL or its vendors recorded transactions in their own books cannot, without further evidence, establish that the assessee’s underlying purchase or event expenditure was fictitious.

227.

We also find that the amounts identified in the alleged trail do not reconcile in several of the examples set out by the assessee in Annexure 6 reproduced in the earlier part of this in the in the section dealing with the learned AR submissions. The disparity between the amount of a charter invoice, the amount allegedly recorded by the intermediate vendor and the amount invoiced to the assessee undermines the inference that the respective amounts represent the same transaction. The Revenue has not established that those discrepancies can be explained by a direct and demonstrable link between the domestic-event expenditure and the alleged personal travel.

228.

The AO also relied on the fact that some domestic events coincided in time with the Chairman’s foreign travel. We find that temporal coincidence does not establish that the cost of foreign travel was included in an invoice for a domestic event. The foreign travel of the Chairman was separately recorded and as summarised in the submissions, was treated as official travel. The mere coincidence of dates, without an invoice-level or payment-level reconciliation, does not establish diversion of the domestic-event expenditure.

229.

The assessee has further submitted the complete record of the Chairman’s foreign travel obtained from the Immigration Department and that the AO did not point out an instance of foreign travel omitted from the assessee’s books. This contention supports the assessee’s explanation that the travel was not concealed under domestic-event invoices. The Revenue has not demonstrated a specific instance in which a particular amount claimed for a domestic event was shown to have paid for personal travel rather than the services documented by the corresponding invoice.

230.

As correctly pointed out by the assessee that an adverse tax conclusion must be founded on evidence and that suspicion or an assumed inference cannot substitute for proof of the relevant facts. Reliance has been placed on CIT v. Daulat Ram Rawatmull[1973] 87 ITR 349 (SC), K.P. Varghese v. ITO [1981] 131 ITR 597 (SC), Lalchand Bhagat Ambica Ram v. CIT [1959] 37 ITR 288 (SC), J.J. Enterprises v. CIT [2002] 254 ITR 216 (SC) and Friends Clearing Agency (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2011] 332 ITR 269 (Del.).

231.

Applying those principles, we hold that the Revenue has not established the necessary evidentiary link between the domestic-event invoices and the alleged personal charter expenditure. The alleged money trail, as described in the assessment order and rebutted by the assessee, does not justify treating the events as fictitious or the expenditure as non-business expenditure.

232.

Further, the assessee submitted that the AO examined only a selected group of 14 events and extrapolated the findings to the entire domestic-event expenditure. For AY 2015-16, the assessee had identified 184 domestic events handled by the three event-management companies, while only four of those events were included in the 14-event list examined by the AO. The associated invoice and amount debited to profit-and-loss figures for those four events are set out below.

Event Invoice amount Amount debited to P&L

Hero Hockey World Cup Match Mall Activation, Rs.3,46,64,291/- Rs.3,08,51,096/-June 2014

HMC Training Programme, Crown Plaza, Gurgaon, Rs.2,01,31,650/- Rs.1,79,17,097/-Event Code HMC/261/14-15

HMC Training Programme, Crown Plaza, Gurgaon, Rs.2,07,68,243/- Rs.1,84,83,662/-Event Code HMC/262/14-15

Hero Master Production of Pleasure TVC Rs.1,50,28,150/- Rs.1,33,75,000/-(Discovery) AV

Total Rs.9,05,92,334/- Rs.8,06,26,855/-

233.

As stated above the AO identified 14 events across AYs 2014-15 to 2018-19. The event-wise details appearing in Annexure 5 to the assessee’s synopsis. It is therefore also important to examine these 14 events as AO has examined expenditure incurred on these 14 events spanning over multiple years including the current year and extrapolated his finding to rest of the events. We have broadly examined the evidence submitted in the relevant events and our finding to each such event are listed below. The findings are based on the event-wise supporting material and the rebuttal of the alleged fund trail.

No. Assessment Event Invoice amount Amount Our relevant year debited to P&L findings

1 AY 2014- 50 Million Bike Rs.2,49,25,005/- Rs.2,21,83,165/- The event is 15 Launch (FY supported by 2013-14) - invoices, cost SEMPL break-ups, photographs, media coverage and event-related material. Further, no cogent evidence establishes that the event was fictitious or that the amount debited represented personal expenditure. The expenditure of Rs.2,21,83,165 is allowable under section 37(1). 2 AY 2014- HMC Brand Rs.2,07,34,634/- Rs.1,84,53,750/- The event is 15 Promotion for supported by July 2013, Event invoices, cost Code break-ups and HMC/57/13-14 - photographs. The SEMPL alleged payment of a charter invoice through a vendor does not establish that the brand-promotion expenditure was fictitious. The absence of a reliable reconciliation and the supporting event records establish the allowability of Rs.1,84,53,750. 3 AY 2015- HMC Training Rs.2,01,31,650/- Rs.1,79,17,097/- The assessee 16 Programme, furnished invoices, Crown Plaza, cost break-ups and Gurgaon, Event photographs of the Code programme. The HMC/261/14-15 AO combined - SEMPL separate events and linked payments through Dream and Fast to charter expenditure without reconciling the amounts. No evidence establishes that this training programme was fictitious or that the amount claimed represented personal travel. The expenditure of Rs.1,79,17,097 is allowable.

4 AY 2015- Hero Hockey Rs.3,46,64,291/- Rs.3,08,51,096/- The event is 16 WorLd Cup supported by Match Mall invoices, cost Activation, 11– break-ups and 13 June 2014, photographs. The Event Code amount of the HMC/55/14-15 - charter invoice SEMPL allegedly connected with the event differs materially from the invoice raised on the assessee. The Revenue has not established a reliable link or reconciled the amounts. The expenditure of Rs.3,08,51,096 is allowable.

5 AY 2015- HMC Training Rs.2,07,68,243/- Rs.1,84,83,662/- The event is 16 Programme, supported by the Crown Plaza, event-wise Gurgaon, Event documents Code identified in the HMC/262/14-15 synopsis. No - SEMPL cogent evidence establishes that the training programme was fictitious or that the corresponding amount was applied to personal travel. The disallowance rests on an unsubstantiated fund-flow inference and is deleted. The expenditure of Rs.1,84,83,662 is allowable.

6 AY 2015- Hero Master Rs.1,50,28,150/- Rs.1,33,75,000/- The claim relates 16 Production of to promotional Pleasure TVC audio-visual (Discovery) AV, production and is Event Code supported by HMC/270/14-15 invoices and event-- SEMPL related documents. The Revenue did not establish that the production was fictitious or that the amount was personal expenditure. The expenditure of Rs.1,33,75,000 is allowable.

7 AY 2016- Staff Training Rs.4,66,99,160/- Rs.4,07,85,293/- The assessee 17 Programmes, furnished invoices, Project Code cost break-ups and HMC/648/2015- photographs. The 16 - SEMPL AO selectively examined two invoices and did not produce the underlying charter invoices or travel details necessary to substantiate the alleged linkage. The amounts at different stages of the alleged trail do not reconcile. The expenditure of Rs.4,07,85,293 is allowable.

8 AY 2016- R&D Centre Rs.12,13,04,967 Rs.10,59,43,203 The event is 17 Launch, CIT supported by KUKAS, Jaipur, engagement Project Code documents, HMC/651/15-16 invoices, cost - SEMPL break-ups, photographs, invitations, correspondence, press releases and newspaper coverage. The alleged charter expense does not reconcile with the amounts attributed to the payments through Dream. The event’s occurrence and the contemporaneous evidence establish the business purpose. The expenditure of Rs.10,59,43,203 is allowable.

9 AY 2016- Indian Open Rs.4,34,41,676 Rs.3,79,40,328 The event is for 17 Golf 2016, Event enhancing brand Code visibility and HMC/745/15-16 promotional - SEMPL purposes and is supported by invoices, cost break-ups and photographs. The Revenue has not demonstrated that the particular event invoice represented personal expenditure. The expenditure of Rs.3,79,40,328 is allowable.

10 AY 2017- Product Rs.6,02,71,254 Rs.5,26,38,650 The assessee 18 Promotion - HF furnished invoices, Deluxe (FY cost break-ups and 2016-17) - more than 40 Strokes photographs of the event. The figures at the different stages of the alleged charter-payment trail do not reconcile, and the necessary link between Dream and the domestic event was not established. The expenditure of Rs.5,26,38,650 is allowable.

11 AY 2017- Product Rs.11,44,95,935 Rs.10,03,25,849 The claim is 18 Promotion - supported by Hero Maestro invoices, cost Edge and Spring break-ups and Carnival (FY event photographs. 2016-17), first The AO did not and second parts establish a - Strokes corresponding payment or booking in Strokes’ books linking the charter invoice raised on Dream to the domestic promotional campaign. The coincidence of dates is insufficient to prove diversion of funds. The expenditure of Rs.10,03,25,849 is allowable.

12 AY 2018- Training Rs.2,56,60,481 Rs.2,17,46,170 The assessee 19 Programme, furnished invoices, Gurgaon (FY cost break-ups and 2017-18) - photographs. The SEMPL AO selectively relied on one invoice out of a larger set and attempted to connect it to charter expenditure without reconciling the amount alleged to have been recovered. The alleged linkage does not displace the event-wise evidence. The expenditure of Rs.2,17,46,170 is allowable.

13 AY 2018- Hero Splendor Rs.8,04,53,782 Rs.6,99,59,810 The event relates 19 Canter to a product Activation - activation and is “Shuruwat Naye supported by Safar Ki”, 28 invoices, cost April–7 May break-ups, 2017, Event photographs and Code event documents. HMC/1222/17- The Revenue did 18 - SEMPL not establish that the activation was fictitious or that the amount debited represented personal expenditure. The expenditure of Rs.6,99,59,810 is allowable.

14 AY 2018- Passion Pro Rs.6,96,49,435 Rs.5,90,24,945 The claim relates 19 Sales Boost to a sales-Activity - “Asli promotion activity Superstar”, 10– and is supported by 19 August 2017, invoices, cost Event Code break-ups and HMC/1342/17- photographs. The 18 - SEMPL Revenue did not establish a reliable, event-specific link between the amount claimed and personal charter expenditure. The expenditure of Rs.5,90,24,945 is allowable.

Total of the 14 Rs.69,82,28,663 Rs.60,96,28,018 events

234.

The above table shows that the 14 identified events were not of a single character. These include Auto Expo participation, Sunburn music-festival sponsorship, product launches and promotional activities, the ground-breaking ceremony for the Centre of Innovation and Technology at Kukas, the foundation-stone ceremony for the Chittoor manufacturing facility, motor-sports events, audio-visual production, dealer and distributor conferences, golf tournaments, employee business meetings, family-day activities and brand/product promotions. These events are broadly in the nature of product launches, brand promotions, training programmes, product activations, production of advertising material, a research and development centre launch and sporting-event promotions.

235.

The supporting material submitted by the assessee includes newspaper reports, photographs, press releases, presentations, invitations, event agendas, participant lists, email communications and other event-related records. The supporting material identified establishes that these were genuine business activities. The Revenue has not demonstrated that the particular amount debited to the profit and loss account represented personal expenditure of the Chairman.

236.

We have given event wise specific finding which shows that evidence submitted by the assessee directly contradicts the sweeping allegation that domestic events undertaken through event-management companies did not occur. Publicly documented events, photographs, event agendas, invitations, invoices and contemporaneous business communications are not displaced merely by a general allegation that funds moved through entities whose books were examined during a search.

237.

Ld CIT(A) rejected the AO’s conclusion that the entire domestic-event expenditure was fictitious and granted relief of Rs.80,60,76,963/-. However, Ld CIT(A) sustained Rs.8,06,26,855/-, representing the amount debited to the profit and loss account for four events in the relevant year, because the AO had identified an alleged money trail and the quantum of non-business expenditure was thought to be not verifiable.

238.

We observe that this approach of CIT(A) is inherently inconsistent. Having accepted that the events took place and having found that the entire expenditure could not be disallowed, learned CIT(A) nevertheless sustained the amount debited for the four selected events without identifying the precise amount of personal expenditure attributable to each event.

239.

We find merit in the contentions of the assessee. The occurrence of the events is supported by contemporaneous records, while the alleged connection between the event invoices and the charter expenditure has not been established by a reliable reconciliation. The fact that the quantum of any alleged non-business expenditure could not be determined does not justify disallowance of the whole amount claimed for the relevant event.

240.

Learned DR has also sought restoration of the matter to the file of the Assessing Officer for further verification and examination. We have considered the request. In our view, the request does not merit acceptance for the following reasons.

1.

First, the assessing officer was afforded multiple opportunities during the assessment proceedings to examine the supporting documentary evidence. The matter was thereafter also examined in the appellate proceedings, including through the remand process. The relevant material and the assessee’s explanations were, therefore, available for consideration before the lower authorities. A further remand cannot be directed merely to provide another opportunity to the Assessing Officer to undertake an enquiry which could and ought to have been undertaken during the course of assessment and remand proceedings.

2.

Secondly, the issue under consideration has already been adjudicated by us. We have given detailed findings on the evidence submitted including the evidence furnished for impugned 14 events examined by the assessing officer.

3.

The request made by the learned DR during the course of arguments and by way of written submissions without pointing out any discrepancy in the evidences filed by the assessees to support the allowance of expenditure incurred on the various events. The burden of proof has been discharged by the assessee right from the assessment stage and even during the remand and appellate proceedings. It was for the revenue to prove that evidence filed by the assessee were not bonafide so as to invite any disallowance.

241.

In the present case, having regard to the multiple opportunities already afforded to the Assessing Officer, the material available on record, and the fact that the issue has already been adjudicated by the Tribunal, we find no justification for restoring the matter to the Assessing Officer. Accordingly, the request of the learned DR for restoration of the matter to the file of the Assessing Officer is rejected.

242.

We accordingly hold that the disallowance of domestic event expenditure made by the AO is unsustainable. The relief granted by the learned CIT(A) of Rs.80,60,76,963/- is upheld, and the disallowance of Rs.8,06,26,855/- sustained by the learned CIT(A) is deleted. The assessee’s Grounds of appeal Nos. 2 to 2.4 are allowed, and the Revenue’s corresponding grounds challenging the relief granted by Ld CIT(A) are dismissed.

243.

The same findings on the evidentiary approach and the alleged fund trail shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding domestic-event disallowances in all connected assessment years. The chart below provides the application of above findings to remaining years as well.

AY Appeal Ground Amount ITAT finding number 2013-14 Assessee - - - NA ITA 4956/Del/2026 Assessee - Grounds 2 Rs.4,06,36,915/- The assessee’s grounds are ITA -2.4 allowed and disallowance 4957/Del/2026 sustained by CIT(A) are deleted. 2014-15 Revenue - ITA Grounds Rs.77,15,64,280/- Revenue’s grounds are 7942/Del/2026 1-3 dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee - Grounds Rs.8,06,26,855/- The assessee’s grounds are ITA 2-2.4 allowed and disallowance 4958/Del/2026 sustained by CIT(A) are deleted. 2015-16 Revenue - ITA Grounds Rs.80,60,76,961/- Revenue’s grounds are 7943/Del/2026 1-3 dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee -ITA Grounds Rs.18,46,68,824/- The assessee’s grounds are 4959/Del/2026 2-2.4 allowed and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) are deleted. 2016-17 Revenue - ITA Grounds Rs.1,22,40,21,731/- Revenue’s grounds are 7967/Del/2026 1-3 dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee - Grounds Rs.15,29,64,499/- The assessee’s grounds are 2017-18 ITA 2-2.4 allowed and disallowance 4960/Del/2026 sustained by CIT(A) are deleted. Revenue - ITA Grounds Rs.74,97,41,152/- Revenue’s grounds are 7968/Del/2026 1-3 dismissed and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee - NA - NA ITA 4961/Del/2026 2019-20 Revenue - Grounds Rs.69,13,79,094/- Revenue’s grounds are appeal number 1-3 dismissed and deletion of to be verified disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld

244.

With regard to second issue of disallowance of foreign travel expenditure, we noticed that the AO disallowed foreign travel expenditure aggregating to Rs.2,97,88,716/-. The trip principally referred to in the submissions was to Colombia and the United States from 27th November 2014 to 9th December 2014. The cost of the charter flight was stated to be Rs.4,34,18,282, while other travel-related expenses amounted to Rs.12,64,793/-, aggregating to Rs.4,46,83,075/-.

245.

Ld. CIT(A) deleted Rs.1,48,94,358/- attributed to the Chairman’s wife and sustained an equivalent amount attributed to the Chairman’s daughter and other family members. The Revenue challenges the relief granted in respect of the wife, whereas the assessee challenges the disallowance sustained in respect of the other family members.

246.

In this regard, the assessee submitted that the Chairman’s foreign travel was undertaken for official business purposes and that the charter flight was arranged for his travel in his capacity as Chairman and Managing Director. The assessee further submitted that the charter cost was a fixed expenditure which would have been incurred even if the Chairman had travelled alone. The AO has not demonstrated that the presence of the family members resulted in any additional charter expenditure being incurred by the assessee.

247.

We find considerable merit in the assessee’s contention that the expenditure should be examined in the context of the nature of its business and the products marketed by it. It is fair to perceive the assessee manufactures and sells two-wheelers, which are not merely personal transport products but are also commonly used by families for their day-to-day mobility. The family constitutes an important segment of the customer base for such products, and the manner in which the brand is perceived by families is commercially relevant to product acceptance, customer preference and brand loyalty.

248.

In this context, the presence of the spouse and family of the Chairman and Managing Director at business-related events, promotional engagements or social interactions associated with the company’s international business initiatives is not necessarily divorced from commercial considerations. Such presence may reinforce the perception of the company as a family-oriented brand, strengthen goodwill and contribute to the human and social dimensions of its brand positioning. Particularly where the company is seeking to establish or strengthen relationships with international business associates and channel partners, the participation of the senior leadership and, where appropriate, their families may complement the company’s broader relationship-building and promotional objectives.

249.

In our view, commercial expediency is not confined to expenditure that produces an immediate, measurable or exclusively direct return. Brand reputation, goodwill, relationship-building and the promotion of consumer confidence are legitimate commercial considerations. A business decision cannot be rejected merely because its benefit is intangible or because the Revenue considers that the presence of family members was unnecessary. The relevant question is whether the expenditure, viewed objectively in the context of the company’s business, had a reasonable commercial connection with its business activities.

250.

We are conscious that the family-oriented nature of the assessee’s products cannot, by itself, make every expenditure incurred on the family members of a director or promoter allowable under section 37(1). However, it is a relevant commercial circumstance which must be considered together with the accepted official purpose of the Chairman’s travel, the nature of the business engagements and the fact that the charter cost was not shown to have increased on account of the accompanying family members. The AO has not brought any cogent material on record to establish that the expenditure in question was incurred for an independent personal holiday or that the assessee incurred an additional expense exclusively for the private benefit of the family members.

251.

It is relevant that section 37(1) of the Act requires expenditure to be incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of business. The expression does not require the Revenue to be satisfied that the expenditure was indispensable or that no alternative, less expensive arrangement could have been made. The test is one of commercial expediency, considered from the standpoint of the business carried on by the assessee.

252.

The assessee relied upon the judgment in case of Hero Honda Motors Ltd. v. JCIT [2006] 103 ITD 157 (Del. Trib.), in which the coordinate bench considered the allowability of travel expenditure incurred on the wife of the Chairman and Managing Director accompanying him on a business-related visit. The principle relevant to the present case is that the spouse’s travel cannot be treated as personal expenditure solely on the basis of the relationship. The facts and business context must be examined to determine whether the expenditure bears a commercial nexus.

253.

The Revenue on the other hand contends that the decision in Hero Honda Motors Ltd. is distinguishable because the spouse in that case accompanied the Chairman on a CII delegation to Mauritius, whereas the present trip included attendance at a sponsored golf tournament. We are unable to accept that the distinction, by itself, concludes the issue against the assessee. The legal test does not depend upon the event being identical to that in an earlier case. It depends upon whether the expenditure in the particular circumstances is supported by a business purpose and commercial expediency.

254.

In the present case, the Chairman’s official travel was accepted by the AO. The foreign visit was undertaken in the context of the assessee’s business activities and international engagements. The assessee’s product profile, its need to maintain and strengthen brand perception, and the commercial relevance of goodwill and business relationships are relevant circumstances in assessing the expenditure. The AO has not established that the family’s presence transformed an otherwise official trip into a personal journey, nor has the AO demonstrated an incremental charter cost attributable to the family members.

255.

We further find that the charter-flight cost was a fixed expenditure incurred for the Chairman’s official travel. No material establishes that the company would have incurred a lower charter cost had the family members not accompanied him. In the absence of evidence of an incremental expense or a demonstrated diversion of company funds for a personal purpose, the allocation of one-third of the charter cost to the family members is arbitrary and cannot be sustained merely on a per-capita basis.

256.

As regards the other travel expenses of Rs.12,64,793, the assessee submitted that the family members bore their own incidental expenses and that they purchased foreign currency of USD 750, equivalent to Rs.46,821, for the trip. The AO has not established, by reference to the assessee’s books or payment records, that the incidental expenses attributed to the family members were separately borne by the company. The mere fact that family members accompanied the Chairman does not establish that every travel-related expense incurred during the trip was debited to the assessee.

257.

On an overall consideration of the business context, the accepted official purpose of the Chairman’s travel, the family-oriented nature of the products marketed by the assessee and the absence of evidence establishing an additional charter cost or a personal diversion of funds, we hold that the disallowance cannot be sustained. The Revenue has not discharged its evidentiary burden of establishing that the disputed amount represented inadmissible personal expenditure in the hands of the assessee.

258.

Therefore, we accordingly delete the entire disallowance of Rs.2,97,88,716/- u/s 37(1) of the Act. The assessee’s grounds relating to foreign travel expenditure are allowed, and the Revenue’s grounds challenging the deletion of ₹1,48,94,358/- attributed to the Chairman’s wife are dismissed.

259.

The same findings as recorded above shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding foreign travel expenses attributable to CMD’s wife, relatives etc. in all connected assessment years. The chart below provides the application of above findings to remaining years as well.

AY Appeal Ground Amount ITAT’s finding number 2013- Assessee- ITA Grounds 2- Rs.3,48,589/- The assessee’s grounds are allowed 14 4956/Del/2026 2.2 and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. Assessee - ITA Grounds 3- Rs.2,03,70,732/- The assessee’s grounds are allowed 4957/Del/2026 3.2 and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. 2014-15 Revenue - ITA Grounds 4- Rs.1,88,91,738/- Revenue’s grounds are dismissed the 7942/Del/2026 5 and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld 2015- Assessee - ITA Grounds 3- Rs.1,48,94,358/- The assessee’s grounds are allowed 16 4958/Del/2026 3.2 and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. Revenue - ITA Grounds 4- Rs.1,48,94,358/- Revenue’s grounds are dismissed the 7943/Del/2026 5 and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee — ITA NA - NA 4959/Del/2026 2016-17 Revenue - ITA Grounds 4- Rs.3,23,63,711/- Revenue’s grounds are dismissed the 7967/Del/2026 5 and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee- ITA Grounds 3- Rs.5,52,90,760/- The assessee’s grounds are allowed 4960/Del/2026 3.2 and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. 2017-18 Revenue - ITA Grounds 4- Rs.4,28,99,467/- Revenue’s grounds are dismissed the 7968/Del/2026 5 and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld Assessee- ITA NA - NA 4961/Del/2026 2019-20 Revenue - appeal Grounds 4- Rs.2,54,85,003/- Revenue’s grounds are dismissed the number to be verified 5 and deletion of disallowance made by Ld CIT(A) is upheld

260.

With regard to third issue of disallowance of expenditure, the assessee challenged the disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040 relating to expenditure incurred in connection with the FIFA World Cup 2014 event in Brazil. The assessee paid Rs.34,80,39,258 to SEMPL in relation to the event. The supporting records included invoices, expense break-up sheets, photographs, participant lists, match details, tickets, airfare details and other event-related documentation, as summarised in the synopsis.

261.

We noticed that the AO did not dispute the occurrence of the event. The disallowance was confined to Rs.4,02,39,040, alleged to represent charter-flight expenditure booked through 365 Aviation that was not separately identified in the SEMPL invoices. Learned CIT(A) sustained the disallowance on the basis that the charter cost was not separately included in the invoices and that SEMPL did not respond to a notice under section 133(6) of the Act.

262.

We find that the disputed amount was picked from a third-party data extract referred to in the assessment order, without the underlying source documents establishing that the amount was paid by the assessee for personal travel or that it represented a component of the event expenditure claimed. The assessee’s claim for the foreign event was supported by contemporaneous documents, and the AO did not establish that the event was fictitious or that the expenditure incurred for the event was not recorded in the books.

263.

The absence of a separate line item for charter travel in the two invoices examined by the ld. CIT(A) does not, in itself, establish that the disputed amount was personal expenditure. Nor does SEMPL’s failure to respond to a notice under section 133(6) of the Act conclusively establish that the expenditure claimed by the assessee was non-genuine. The assessee’s evidence must be considered on its own merits, and an adverse inference must rest on material that links the alleged personal expenditure to the specific amount claimed.

264.

In the present case, the Revenue has not established that Rs.4,02,39,040/- represented personal expenditure of the Chairman or that the assessee claimed a fictitious event expense. The amount was part of the expenditure recorded in the books in relation to the FIFA event, and the available evidence establishes the business purpose of the event. The disallowance rests on an unsubstantiated inference from the absence of separate charter-cost identification.

265.

We accordingly hold that the disallowance of Rs.4,02,39,040/- is unsustainable. The assessee’s grounds relating to the foreign event are allowed, and the entire disallowance is deleted. The same findings on the foreign event shall apply mutatis mutandis to the corresponding such events in all connected assessment years. The chart below provides the application of above findings to remaining years as well.

AY Appeal Ground Amount ITAT’s finding number 2013-14 Assessee- ITA NA - NA 4956/Del/2026 2014-15 Assessee- ITA NA - NA 4957/Del/2026 2015-16 Assessee- ITA Grounds Rs.4,02,39,040/- The assessee’s grounds are 4958/Del/2026 4-4.3 allowed and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. 2016-17 Assessee- ITA Grounds Rs.4,53,58,109/- The assessee’s grounds are 4959/Del/2026 3-3.2 allowed and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. 2017-18 Assessee- ITA Grounds Rs.5,32,30,532/- The assessee’s grounds are 4960/Del/2026 4-4.3 allowed and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted. 2019-20 Assessee- ITA Grounds Rs.10,03,28,225/- The assessee’s grounds are 4961/Del/2026 2–2.3 allowed and disallowance sustained by CIT(A) is deleted.

266.

In the result, all appeals of the assessee are allowed and all appeals of the Revenue are dismissed.