Results
↑↓
Tribunals and Commissions(2026) 11 CAT CK 3042

Natthi Lal Vs Union Of India & Ors.

Central Administrative Tribunal · Allahabad · 13 Nov 2026 · Rajnish Kumar Rai, J

Open full page

Judgment

19 paragraphs · 2,674 words

The applicant has approached this Tribunal under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking quashing of the transfer order dated 01.10.2025, insofar as it relates to the applicant, and the consequential order dated 09.02.2026, whereby he was deemed relieved from his present place of posting on 31.03.2026. The reliefs prayed for by the applicant are as under:-

“(A)

To issue an order or direction to set aside the impugned order dated 01.10.2025 in respect of applicant whose name is at serial No. 73 and impugned order dated 09.02.2026 by which applicant was deemed relieved on 31.03.2026(A/N) automatically in advance. (Annexure No. 1 & 11 of O.A. with compilation no.I).

(B)

To issue any other order or direction as this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.

(C)

To award cost to the applicant.”

2.

The present Original Application has been filed by the applicant, Shri Natthi Lal, challenging the transfer order dated 01.10.2025, whereby he was transferred from Agra to Allahabad, as well as the subsequent order dated 09.02.2026, rejecting his claim for retention and directing that he would be deemed relieved on 31.03.2026 (A/N). The applicant was posted as Executive Engineer (Civil) at Agra with effect from 02.07.2021. He claims that his name was not included in the annual rotational transfer order dated 05.06.2025 as his request for retention at Agra had been considered by the competent authority in the annual rotational transfer exercise. He further sought retention at Agra on account of his family circumstances, including the educational requirements of his two sons and the medical condition of his elder son. His wife also submitted a representation dated 23.10.2025 seeking his retention at Agra till May 2026. Earlier, in O.A. No. 1292 of 2025, this Tribunal, vide order dated 17.12.2025, directed the competent authority to consider the said representation in the light of the relevant provisions of the CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy and pass an appropriate order. Pursuant thereto, the respondents passed the impugned speaking order dated 09.02.2026.

3.

Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the applicant’s name was not included in the annual rotational transfer list dated 05.06.2025, as his request for retention at Agra for one year had been considered by the competent authority. However, the respondents subsequently issued the transfer order dated 01.10.2025, transferring him to Allahabad, in violation of the provisions of the CPWD Transfer/Posting Policy, particularly Clauses 12.1, 12.5(i) and 12.5(vi). He further submitted that the transfer was effected during the mid-academic session, without considering the educational needs of the applicant’s children and the serious medical condition of his elder son. The applicant’s wife had also submitted a detailed representation dated 23.10.2025 seeking retention of the applicant at Agra till May 2026, which was rejected by the impugned order dated 09.02.2026 without properly considering the relevant policy provisions. It was further contended that several other Executive Engineers who had completed their tenure were not disturbed, whereas the applicant was transferred despite his family circumstances. Hence, the impugned orders are arbitrary, discriminatory and liable to be quashed.

4.

Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the present Original Application is not maintainable, as the applicant had earlier challenged the same transfer order dated 01.10.2025 before this Tribunal in OA No. 1292 of 2025, which was disposed of vide order dated 17.12.2025 with limited directions to reconsider his representation and pass a reasoned and speaking order. In compliance thereof, the respondents passed a speaking order dated 09.02.2026, permitting the applicant to continue at Agra till 31.03.2026, whereafter he was relieved and joined at Allahabad on 16.04.2026. It was further submitted that the present OA seeks to reopen the same controversy on grounds already available to the applicant in the earlier proceedings and is barred by the principles of res judicata and constructive res judicata. The transfer order dated 01.10.2025 was issued in public interest, keeping in view administrative exigencies, cadre management and the placement of newly promoted Executive Engineers, in accordance with the applicable CPWD Transfer/Posting Policy. The applicant has no vested right to remain posted at a particular station, and mere personal hardship does not confer any enforceable right to retention.

5.

In the short counter reply, learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the applicant’s representation dated 11.10.2025 seeking retention was considered by the Transfer and Posting Review Committee in its meeting held on 04.12.2025, but the grounds mentioned therein were not found convincing. It was contended that the applicant had already served at Agra for more than four years and six months, against the normal tenure of three years, and that non-inclusion of his name in the annual transfer order dated 05.06.2025 did not confer any right upon him to remain at Agra. Learned counsel further submitted that Clauses 12.1 and 12.5(i) of the CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy permit transfers during the academic year on account of administrative necessity, while retention on medical grounds is permissible only in cases of terminal illness or specified conditions and on educational grounds only where a child is studying in Class XII. The applicant’s elder son, who was studying in B.Tech. first year, and younger son, who was studying in Class X, did not fall within the prescribed educational exception. It was also submitted that the medical documents relating to the elder son did not establish any terminal illness and that Allahabad has adequate medical facilities. The respondents further denied any discrimination, stating that transfers are decided on the basis of vacancies, administrative requirements, tenure and other relevant factors. They also explained that the applicant’s wife’s representation dated 23.10.2025 was not entertained with reference to the DoPT guidelines dated 31.08.2015. Accordingly, learned counsel prayed that the Original Application be dismissed.

6.

Applicant’s counsel, in rejoinder, submitted that the respondents have failed to comply with the directions issued by this Tribunal vide order dated 17.12.2025, as they did not properly consider the representation dated 23.10.2025 submitted by the applicant’s wife, particularly the issue of differential treatment given to several other Executive Engineers who had been allowed to continue at their respective stations despite completion of their tenure. Learned counsel further submitted that the earlier OA No. 1292 of 2025 was not decided on merits and, therefore, the present Original Application is not barred by the principles of res judicata or constructive res judicata. It was contended that the applicant had submitted his representation dated 12.03.2025 pursuant to the readiness list issued by the respondents, wherein he had sought retention at Agra and, alternatively, posting at Kanpur Nagar or Bareilly. However, despite the recommendation of the Transfer and Posting Committee for retention of the applicant for one year, the respondents issued the transfer order dated 01.10.2025 without properly considering the said recommendation. Learned counsel further submitted that the respondents had retained several other Executive Engineers who had completed longer periods of tenure, whereas the applicant was transferred during the mid-academic session, which reflects discriminatory treatment. It was also contended that vacancies were available at Agra and Kanpur Nagar, but the respondents deliberately failed to accommodate the applicant at either station. The applicant had joined at Allahabad only in compliance with the transfer order and subject to the outcome of the present Original Application, which does not render the matter infructuous. Learned counsel, therefore, submitted that the respondents had failed to consider the applicant’s family and medical circumstances, the relevant provisions of the CPWD Transfer/Posting Policy and the comparative treatment given to similarly situated officers. Accordingly, the impugned transfer order dated 01.10.2025 and the subsequent speaking order dated 09.02.2026 are liable to be set aside.

7.

Applicant’s counsel further submitted that, by way of the subsequent supplementary affidavit, the applicant has brought on record certain subsequent developments, including the relieving order dated 31.03.2026, whereby he was relieved from Agra and the charge was handed over to Shri Ram Swaroop Meena, who was already holding the additional charge of Valuation Officer, Jaipur and was due to retire in July 2026. Learned counsel submitted that despite the availability of the post at Agra and the vacancy at Kanpur Nagar, the respondents neither retained the applicant at Agra nor considered his alternative request for posting at Kanpur Nagar. He further submitted that the applicant was suffering from pain in his bones and joints and was undergoing medical treatment, for which he had sought leave vide application dated 06.04.2026. However, the respondents issued a communication dated 16.04.2026 regarding his joining at Allahabad, pursuant to which the applicant joined there on 16.04.2026 under protest and subject to the outcome of the present Original Application. Learned counsel also drew attention to the Office Memorandum dated 11.12.2018, modifying the transfer and posting guidelines and prescribing three years as the normal period of continuous stay at any post as well as at any station. He contended that several similarly situated Executive Engineers had been allowed to continue beyond the prescribed tenure, whereas the applicant was singled out for transfer. It was further submitted that the applicant had exercised his posting options pursuant to the readiness list dated 06.01.2026, but his request was still pending consideration. Thus, the subsequent developments and documents, according to learned counsel, further demonstrate the arbitrary and discriminatory action of the respondents and justify the relief sought in the present Original Application.

8.

I have considered the submissions made by Mr. N.P. Singh, learned counsel for the applicant, and Mr. Chakrapani Vatsyayan, learned counsel for the respondents, and have carefully examined the pleadings, documents and other material available on record.

9.

I have carefully considered the rival submissions advanced by learned counsel for the parties and have perused the pleadings and documents available on record. The principal question for consideration is whether the transfer order dated 01.10.2025, whereby the applicant was transferred from Agra to Allahabad, and the consequential speaking order dated 09.02.2026 suffer from any illegality, arbitrariness, discrimination or violation of the applicable CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy. It is not in dispute that the applicant was posted at Agra with effect from 02.07.2021 and had completed more than the normal tenure of three years. The fact that the applicant’s name was not included in the annual rotational transfer order dated 05.06.2025 does not, by itself, confer any vested right upon him to continue at Agra or prevent the competent authority from undertaking a subsequent transfer exercise on administrative grounds. The respondents have explained that the transfer order dated 01.10.2025 was issued keeping in view administrative requirements, including the placement of newly promoted Executive Engineers. The applicant has not established that the subsequent transfer exercise was prohibited by any statutory rule or binding provision of the applicable policy. Therefore, the subsequent transfer cannot be held illegal merely because his name was not included in the earlier transfer list.

10.

The applicant has also placed reliance upon the order dated 17.12.2025 passed by this Tribunal in O.A. No. 1292 of 2025. A perusal of the said order shows that the competent authority was directed to consider the representation dated 23.10.2025 submitted by the applicant’s wife in the light of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and Clauses 12.5(i) and 12.5(vi) of the CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy and to pass a reasoned and speaking order. The applicant was also permitted to continue at Agra at least till the end of March 2026 and, in any case, till the representation was finally decided. In compliance with the said order, the applicant was permitted to continue at Agra till 31.03.2026. The speaking order dated 09.02.2026 records the grounds relating to the applicant’s family circumstances, including the educational and medical grounds, and refers to the applicable DoPT guidelines and CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy. The earlier order, however, did not confer upon the applicant any unconditional or permanent right to remain posted at Agra. It required consideration of the matter in accordance with the applicable provisions and protected the applicant from being relieved during the stipulated period.

11.

As regards the alleged violation of Clauses 12.1, 12.5(i) and 12.5(vi) of the CPWD Transfer and Posting Policy, Clause 12.1 provides that transfers should, as far as possible, be planned to take effect after the end of the financial year or academic year, while permitting transfers during the remaining part of the year where absolutely necessary from an administrative point of view. Clause 12.5(i) requires personal difficulties to be considered, subject to the overriding priority of departmental requirements. Further, as recorded in the speaking order, the educational retention provision relied upon by the applicant contemplates a child studying in Class XII, whereas his elder son was pursuing B.Tech. first year and his younger son was studying in Class X. With regard to the medical condition of the elder son, the respondents have relied upon the medical documents and submitted that he was suffering from enteric fever with infectious mesenteric lymphadenopathy and was declared fit to join classes with effect from 01.09.2025. The material on record does not establish that the condition falls within the category of terminal diseases contemplated under the DoPT Office Memorandum dated 06.06.2014. These circumstances do not establish any absolute entitlement of the applicant to retention at Agra or render the impugned transfer order illegal.

12.

The applicant has further alleged discriminatory treatment on the ground that several other Executive Engineers having longer tenure at their respective stations were not transferred. He has relied upon comparative tenure particulars, the list of longest-serving Executive Engineers, the readiness list, the Office Memorandum dated 06.01.2026 and vacancy particulars of different stations, including Kanpur. However, mere comparison of the length of stay of different officers is not sufficient to establish discrimination unless it is shown that they were similarly situated in all material respects. The subsequent Office Memorandum dated 06.01.2026 and the readiness and vacancy particulars cannot, by themselves, conclusively establish the vacancy position as on 01.10.2025 or confer upon the applicant an enforceable right to remain at Agra or to be posted at Kanpur. Likewise, the subsequent arrangement of additional charge in favour of Shri Ram Swaroop Meena, the applicant’s medical leave request dated 06.04.2026 and his joining at Allahabad on 16.04.2026 do not, by themselves, establish that the original transfer order was actuated by mala fides. It is further pleaded by the applicant that Shri Ram Swaroop Meena, who is posted as Valuation Officer at Jaipur and is holding additional charge of the post of Valuation Officer, Agra, is due to retire in the month of July 2026, and that the post of Valuation Officer at Kanpur Nagar is vacant. The applicant has, therefore, sought consideration for his posting at Agra, Kanpur Nagar or Jaipur against an available vacant post. No specific and cogent material has been placed on record to establish personal mala fides against the competent authority. Transfer is an incidence of service, and an employee has no vested right to remain posted at a station of his choice.

13.

In view of the facts and circumstances of the case and the material available on record, I do not find any merit in the challenge to the impugned transfer order dated 01.10.2025 and the consequential speaking order dated 09.02.2026. However, liberty is granted to the applicant to submit a fresh representation before the competent authority, seeking his transfer to a suitable place at Agra, Kanpur or Jaipur against an available vacant post, in accordance with the applicable Transfer and Posting Policy.

14.

In the event such a representation is submitted by the applicant, the competent authority shall consider the same in accordance with the applicable Transfer and Posting Policy and, if found feasible, accommodate the applicant against a suitable vacant post at Agra, Kanpur or Jaipur, by passing a reasoned and speaking order within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.

15.

With the aforesaid observations and directions, the Original Application stands disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.

16.

All pending Miscellaneous Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.