Sanika Sandi Purti Vs The State Of Jharkhand
Jharkhand High Court · Ranchi · 18 Nov 2026 · Rajesh Kumar, J
Judgment
Heard Mr. Amit Kumar, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Fahad Allam, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State.
The present appeal is directed against the Judgment of conviction dated 21.07.2023 and order of sentence dated 24.07.2023, passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Khunti, in NDPS Case No.22 of 2018, arising out of Khunti P.S Case No.180 of 2018, whereby the appellant has been convicted for the offence under Section 18(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (NDPS Act), and has been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven years and to pay fine of Rs.75,000/- (Seventy five thousand) and in default of fine, the appellant is further directed to undergo simple imprisonment for one year and six months.
The prosecution story is based on the self recorded statement of Rajesh Prasad Rajak, officer-in-charge of Khunti Police Station, who is also informant of this case and he has alleged that on 17-11-2018 at 13:00 PM he received source information that some drug mafia have assembled near Birsa College Gate from their Apache Motorcycle No.JH-01W-0784 to deal the huge quantity of opium there. On this information, the informant constituted a raiding team and proceeded towards the Birsa College Gate where the informant and patrolling party witnessed that one person was standing near his black colour apache motorcycle. On seeing the police party, he has started fleeing but was intercepted by the patrolling party and apprehended. It is further alleged that after serving a notice u/s 50 of NDPS Act the apprehended person was searched by the raiding team in presence of two independent witnesses namely Mukesh Singh and Manoj Singh and in course of search one black colour bag in which pasti opium was kept and when it was tested by D.D. Kit, the result was found to be positive. It was opium measuring approx 1 Kg 600 grams. Besides opium cash of Rs.35,000/- was also recovered from the pocket of the accused. Accordingly the SDPO, Khunti seized all these materials and prepared the seizure list and one copy of the seizure list was also handed over to the accused. Thereafter, a case has been registered under Section 18 of the NDPS Act against the accused being Khunti P.S. Case No.180 of 2018.
The police after completing the investigation has submitted the charge-sheet against the accused-appellant for the offence under Sections 18/ 25 of the NDPS Act and the charge has been framed under Sections 18(c)/ 25 of the NDPS Act. Thereafter, the case has been committed to the court of Sessions to which the appellant has pleaded innocence and claimed to be tried and accordingly, the trial has commenced.
To substantiate the charges, the prosecution has examined altogether 10 witnesses and their depositions, in short, are as follows :-
P.W.-1, Ignasiyus Toppo, is the Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police and a member of the raiding team. He has supported the case. During cross examination he has admitted that he cannot say the name of the person who has prepared the seizure list and also not about the contents as he was standing at some distance.
P.W.-2, Md. Anwar Alam, is Sub- Inspector of Police and a member of raiding team and he has also supported the prosecution story. During his cross examination he has clearly deposed that the seizure list was prepared by the Inspector and Dy.S.P. and he cannot say about the manufacturing of DD Kit.
P.W.-3, Upendra Kumar, is Constable and a member of the raiding team. In his cross examination he has not stated any relevant fact about the occurrence.
P.W.-4, Rajesh Kumar Rajak, is Inspector of Police and also informant of this case. He has supported the case. In his examination in chief he has deposed that after recovery, he has weighed the seized article and also sealed it. He prepared the exhibit slip marked as ext-4. In paragraph 29 of the cross examination, he has clearly stated that the seized opium was weighed by electronic balance from the nearby shop of the place of occurrence. He has not deposed any relevant fact during his evidence about the occurrence.
P.W.-5, Sundar Hembrom, is Assistant Sub-Inspector and member of the raiding team. He has also supported the case. During cross examination he has deposed in Paragraph Nos. 15, 16 & 17 that he is not a seizure list witness. At paragraph no. 20 he has deposed that he was involved in surrounding the accused. This witness has not stated any other relevant fact regarding the occurrence.
P.W.-6, Kuldeep Kumar, is the then SDPO, Khunti and he has supported the case. He has weighed the seized article and found that the recovered opium was 1 kg 600 gms. He has identified his signature on the seizure list. In his cross examination he has clearly deposed that Gopal Hembrom is the investigating officer and his statement is not recorded in the case dairy.
P.W.-7, Gopal Hembrom, is the Investigating Officer and he has investigated in the matter and recorded the statements of the witnesses. During cross examination he has deposed that he has not recorded the statement of Kuldeep Kumar, the then SDPO, Khunti. of this Case.
P.W.-8, Satya Prakash Rajhans, is the Assistant Director, State Forensic Laboratory, Ranchi, who has examined the seized article. During cross examination he has deposed that the weight of the sample used in the chemical examination and remaining weight of the sample after the examination was not mentioned in the report.
P.W.-9, Mukesh Singh, is an independent seizure list witness and he has declared hostile by the prosecution.
P.W.-10, Manoj Singh, is also an independent seizure list witness and he has also declared hostile by the prosecution.
The trial Court, on the basis of above materials available on record, has convicted the appellant under Section 18(c) of the NDPS Act and sentenced him as stated above.
Learned counsel for the appellant has relied upon Section 32-B of the NDPS Act, 1985, which reads as under :-
“32-B. Factors to be taken into account for imposing higher than the minimum punishment.
— Where a minimum term of imprisonment or amount of fine is prescribed for any offence committed under this Act, the court may, in addition to such factors as it may deem fit, take into account the following factors for imposing a punishment higher than the minimum term of imprisonment or amount of fine, namely:--
(a)the use or threat of use of violence or arms by the offender;
(b)the fact that the offender holds a public office and that he has taken advantage of that office in committing the offence;
(c)the fact that the minors are affected by the offence or the minors are used for the commission of an offence;
(d)the fact that the offence is committed in an educational institution or social service facility or in the immediate vicinity of such institution or faculty or in other place to which school children and students resort for educational, sports and social activities.;
(e)the fact that the offender belongs to organised international or any other criminal group which is involved in the commission of the offences; and
(f)the fact that the offender is involved in other illegal activities facilitated by commission of the offence.”
Learned counsel for the appellant has basically assailed the sentencing part of the impugned judgment and it has been submitted that in the absence of any aggravating circumstances, giving punishment for more than five years, is bad in law.
It has further been submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that there is a mitigating circumstances, as it is a first offence and the appellant is the sole bread earner of his family and he has remained in custody for more than four years and seven months.
On above basis, prayer has been made by the learned counsel for the appellant for reduction of the sentence for the period already undergone by the appellant.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State has opposed the prayer, but could not dispute the above fact that no aggravating circumstances has been brought on record.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and considering the evidence brought on record, this Court finds that the conviction of the appellant is sustainable and accordingly it is, hereby upheld, but so far as the sentencing part is concerned, in the absence of any aggravating circumstances, giving punishment for more than five years is not warranted and accordingly, the same, is, hereby, reduced to the period already undergone by the appellant.
The appellant is in custody and as such, he is directed to be released from the jail custody forthwith, if not wanted in any other case.
With above modification in the sentencing part, the present appeal is, hereby, disposed of.
Let the Trial Court Records be sent back to the Court concerned forthwith, along with a copy of this Judgment.
