Harnek Singh & Ors. Vs State Of Haryana & Ors.
Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · 31 Oct 2026 · Rajesh Bhardwaj, J · Puja Chopra, J
Judgment
Rajesh Bhardwaj, J.
CRM-45063-2026
Application is allowed, as prayed for.
Annexures A-1 and A-2 are taken on record.
Main case
Present appeal has been filed impugning the judgment and order dated 28.01.2025 passed by learned Additional Sessions Judge, Ambala, acquitting accused-respondents No.2 to 4 from the charges framed against them under Sections 307 and 325 read with Section 34 of IPC.
BRIEF FACTS:
Succinctly facts of the case are that FIR No.136 dated 22.04.2018, under Sections 307 read with Section 34 of IPC at Police Station Naraingarh, was registered by appellant/complainant. It was alleged by appellant/complainant that on 12.04.2018 at about 05:00 AM, he was going to vegetable market of Shahzadpur on his motorcycle alongwith Rajat and Naresh Kumar riding pillion. When they reached near Floor Mill, Village Akbarpur, he had noticed that Anshul, Akshay and Sandeep, along with 2-3 other boys were following them in a car bearing registration No.HR05-AE-6179. They tried to kill complainant by hitting his motorcycle with their car from back side, due to which, complainant, Rajat and Naresh Kumar fell on the road and suffered injuries. The complainant suspected that the accused persons had followed him and has committed alleged attack on account of the fact that he had seen them consuming liquor on 11.04.2018 and earlier also, the accused persons had attacked him. Thus, he made a request to take legal action against the accused persons. On the basis of the complaint, FIR was registered and investigation commenced. During investigation, site plan was prepared, statements of witnesses were recorded and accused were arrested and subsequently, released on bail by the Court. Upon completion of the investigation, the case was found proved against the accused namely, Vikrant, Akshay and Sandeep Kumar (respondents No.2 to 4). Accordingly, final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. was submitted against them before the learned trial Court. On framing of charges, the trial commenced. To prove its case, prosecution has got examined 16 witnesses. Statement of accused persons under Section 313 Cr.P.C. were recorded. Thereafter, on the conclusion of the trial, learned trial Court after hearing both the sides and appreciating the evidence, acquitted the accused-respondents No.2 to 4 from the charges framed against them vide impugned judgment dated 28.01.2025. Aggrieved by the same, the appellant/complainant has approached this Court by way of filing the present appeal.
SUBMISSIONS OF LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANTS:
It has been vehemently contended by learned counsel for the appellant/complainant that learned trial Court has miserably failed in appreciating the evidence on record. She submits that allegations against accused/respondents No.2 to 4 are specific and serious in nature. She submits that the learned trial Court failed to appreciate the direct and credible testimonies of the injured complainant, namely, Harnek Singh (PW-4) and eye-witnesses, Rajat Kumar (PW-2) and Naresh Kumar (PW-3), which clearly established the involvement of the accused in the commission of offence. She submits that the learned trial Court has observed that there was delay of four days in lodging of the FIR. However, the delay occurred because the injured were undergoing treatment and the police was informed about the incident promptly. She submits that the offence under Section 307 IPC is made out against accused/respondents No.2 to 4 as actual injury is not necessary for constituting the offence, the intention to cause death can be seen as well. She submits that as per medical reports it is clearly established that the appellants have suffered serious injuries with a deliberate attempt to cause death. She, thus, submits that learned trial Court failed to appreciate the settled legal position and the evidence on record while acquitting the accused/respondents No.2 to 4. Therefore, the opinion drawn by learned trial Court in acquitting the accused being perverse, deserves to be set aside and accused-respondents No.2 to 4 be convicted for the charges framed against them.
SUBMISSIONS OF LEARNED STATE COUNSEL:-
Learned State counsel submits that though the prosecution had led evidence before the trial Court, however, learned Additional Sessions Judge, Ambala, on appreciation of the entire evidence passed an order of acquittal.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS OF THE COURT:
Having heard the submissions made by counsel for the appellant and perused the material available on record, this Court finds that learned trial Court has carefully appreciated the evidence brought on record and has rightly extended the benefit of doubt to the accused/respondents No.2 to 4. There is an unexplained delay of 09 days in lodging of the FIR as alleged incident took place on 12.04.2018, whereas, the FIR was lodged on 22.04.2018. There is no satisfactory explanation furnished by the appellants for such an inordinate delay. The appellants in FIR, have stated that accused persons had hit their car from backside of the motorcycle on which complainant was riding due to which Harnek & Naresh fell in ditches, whereas, Rajat fell on the road and suffered injuries. Thereafter, accused persons ran away from the spot. However, while appearing in witness box, these witnesses have improved their version and have stated that accused persons had premeditatedly planned to kill the complainant and in pursuance of which, accused persons hit their car from backside of the motorcycle with intention to kill the appellants. However, the prosecution has failed to produce any of such evidence to prove that accused persons in a premeditated manner planned to kill the complainant. As alleged, accused persons are cousin brothers of the persons whose cases are pending, but there is no evidence on record to prove such fact. The complainant himself admitted that he had previous enmity with accused persons, however, the FIR was lodged after four days from the date of alleged occurrence. Perusal of MLRs of complainant & injured persons transpire that after the incident, they were conscious and were responding to doctors. In both MLRs, it is mentioned that complainant & injured persons were brought to hospital after a road side accident. It is no where mentioned in the MLRs that accused persons had assaulted them or intended to kill them. Despite being conscious and having sufficient time to narrate the occurrence, the complainant and injured persons failed to disclose the relevant facts. It is stated by learned State counsel along with learned counsel for the complainant before the trial Court that medical ruqa was sent on the same day of the incident. However, there is no such document on file to show that police had received medical ruqa on the same day. Prosecution relied upon the MLCs prepared by doctor. In the present case, in MLCs, it is written that ruqa be sent. However, there is no evidence on record that whether ruqa was sent or not. Moreover, there is no evidence on record to show that the accused persons had an intention to kill the complainant as they only hit the motorcycle once. There is no such allegation that after hitting the car from back side of the motorcycle, accused persons had again hit or tried to hit the complainant simultaneously or that the accused persons had taken any other action against the complainant party. Even when they were in injured condition. In the FIR, the complainant did not mention whether the lights of the car were on or off at the time of the occurrence. However, while appearing in the witness box, PW2 to PW4 stated that the accused persons had switched on the car lights. Thus, if the respondents/accused persons had any intention to kill or injure the appellant, there was no reason for them to switch on the lights and reveal their identity, rather, they would have tried to conceal their identity and escape from the spot. There was no other act which shows the intention of the respondents was to kill the complainant. Moreover, Rajat Kumar, Naresh Kumar and Harnek Singh are stated to be eyewitnesses to the occurrence, they have made several material improvements in their statements while appearing before the Court.
It is well settled that in an appeal against acquittal, the appellate Court should not interfere merely because another view is possible. Unless the findings recorded by the trial Court are perverse, unreasonable, or based on misappreciation of evidence, the order of acquittal does not warrant interference. The evidence on record does not conclusively establish the essential ingredients of the offence under Sections 307 and 325 read with Section 34 of IPC. Learned trial Court has rightly considered the circumstances and discrepancies appearing in the prosecution evidence while acquitting the accused.
As per the law settled, the appeal against conviction and that against acquittal rests entirely on different pedestal. As per the criminal jurisprudence, every accused is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty. As per the law settled by Hon'ble Supreme Court, once the accused is acquitted by the Court of law, there lies double presumption of innocence in his favour. Hence, an Appellate Court should not disturb the findings of acquittal arrived at by the trial Court in a cavalier manner and it is only in case of perversity of the findings, the Appellate Court should interfere in the acquittal order passed by the trial Court. In Jafarudheen and others vs State of Kerala 2022 SCC Online SC 495, it is held that Appellate Court has to be relatively slow in reversing order of trial Court rendering acquittal, relevant para of the same reads thus:
“25.While dealing with an appeal against acquittal by invoking Section 378 of the Cr.P.C., the appellate Court has to consider whether the trial Court's view can be termed as a possible one, particularly when evidence on record has been analyzed. The reason is that an order of acquittal adds up to the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused. Thus, the Appellate Court has to be relatively slow in reversing the order of the Trial Court rendering acquittal. Therefore, the presumption in favour of the accused does not get weakened but only strengthened. Such a double presumption that enures in favour of the accused has to be disturbed only by thorough scrutiny on the accepted legal parameters.”
In Sadhu Saran Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others, AIR 2026 Supreme Court 1160, learned Appellate Court has held as under:-
18.Generally, an appeal against acquittal has always been altogether on a different pedestal from that of an appeal against conviction. In an appeal against acquittal where the presumption of innocence in favour of the accused is reinforced, the appellate Court would interfere with the order of acquittal only when there is perversity of fact and law. However, we believe that the paramount consideration of the Court is to do substantial justice and avoid miscarriage of justice which can arise by acquitting the accused who is guilty of an offence. A miscarriage of justice that may occur by the acquittal of the guilty is no less than from the conviction of an innocent. This Court, while enunciating the principles with regard to the scope of powers of the appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal, in the case of Sambasivan and Others V. State of Kerala, (1998) 5 SCC 412, has held :
“The principles with regard to the scope of the powers of the appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal are well settled. The powers of the appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal are no less than in an appeal against conviction. But where on the basis of evidence on record two views are reasonably possible the appellate Court cannot substitute its view in the place of that of the trial Court. It is only when the approach of the trial Court in acquitting an accused is found to be clearly erroneous in its consideration of evidence on record and in deducing conclusions therefrom that the appellate Court can interfere with the order of acquittal”.
Weighing the facts and circumstances of the present case on the anvil of law settled, this Court finds no perversity in the order passed by the trial Court. Therefore, the view taken by learned trial Court cannot be said to be perverse or contrary to the evidence available on record. The impugned judgment of acquittal is based on proper appreciation of evidence and does not call for any interference by this Court. Consequently, the appeal against acquittal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed.
