Med Singh Vs The State Of Haryana & Anr.
Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · 05 Nov 2026 · Harsimran Singh Sethi, J · Minderjeet Yadav, J
Judgment
Harsimran Singh Sethi, J. (Oral)
Present appeal has been filed challenging the impugned order dated 12.01.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in CWP-4226-2015 titled as Med Singh vs. State of Haryana and another by which, the claim of the appellant for the grant of benefit of stepping up of pay at par with one Suresh Kumar, who is junior to the appellant, has not been accepted and the claim of the appellant has been rejected.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argues that though, the appellant was working as a clerk and said Suresh Kumar was working in the cadre of Steno and both entered into service on a different cadre namely, Steno and Clerk respectively but as both are the feeder cadre for promotion to the post of Assistant, such two different cadres are to be taken as one, so as to decide whether the appellant can claim seniority over Suresh Kumar in order to claim the benefit of stepping up, which has been ignored by the learned Single Judge while declining the relief.
Certain facts need to be mentioned for the correct appreciation of the issue in hand.
The appellant herein joined as Steno-Typist on 15.09.1982 whereas, Suresh Kumar joined as Clerk on 21.09.1982. Suresh Kumar was promoted as Industrial Extension Officer (Industries) on 28.01.1997 after granting him the benefit of reservation whereas, the appellant was promoted on 25.06.2010. As the cadres were different, the appellant herein was not held entitled for stepping up of pay with his junior namely Suresh Kumar who belonged to reserved category.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone through the record with their able assistance.
It may be noticed that merely that two cadres of Clerk and Steno respectively are eligible for further promotion in the same cadre of Assistant, it does not mean that both the cadres are the same in order to even claim the benefit of stepping up of pay so as to treat somebody working in a different cadre on the basis of the joint seniority list maintained, which is only for the purpose of further promotion. There is no inter-se seniority between the separate cadre but, there is a different seniority of both the cadres maintained separately, but only for the purpose of further promotion, a joint seniority has been prepared as both the posts of Steno and Clerk are in the feeder cadre for further promotion as Assistant. Hence, the said Suresh Kumar is being claimed to be junior than the appellant so as to claim the stepping up of pay has rightly been appreciated by the learned Single Judge to decline the relief.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant further argues that on the basis of the joint seniority list, an employee from the cadre of Steno has superseded an employee in the cadre of Clerk and therefore, on being getting promotion to the promoted cadre, the appellant is entitled for getting of the seniority over the other cadres by applying catch-up rule so as to get the benefit of stepping of pay.
It may be noticed that once, two people are working in different cadre and only for the further promotion, there is a joint seniority list, it cannot be said that the senior employee/candidate in the other cadre, has been superseded.
Further, learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of R.B. Desai vs. S.K. Khanolker Civil Appeal No.4587-1999 decided on 19.08.1999
It may be noticed that the said judgment is not applicable having different facts. In the said case, the only direction given was that in case there has to be a joint seniority of two cadres, the continuous officiate in the cadre has to be taken into account for fixing the inter-se seniority for further promotion, which concededly is being done by the respondent. But the question which has been raised in the present appeal is whether, two employees working in the different cadre have to be treated in the same cadre for the purpose of stepping up of the pay, as well or not. Hence, the judgment in R.B. Desai (supra) cannot be made applicable in the facts and circumstances of the case.
Keeping in view the facts and circumstances recorded, no ground for interference by this Court is made out and the present appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Civil miscellaneous application pending, if any, is also disposed of.
