Results
↑↓
High Courts(2026) 11 P&H CK 2992

Municpal Committee, Banur Vs Jagjit Singh

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · 18 Nov 2026 · Parmod Goyal, J

Open full page

Judgment

16 paragraphs · 795 words

Parmod Goyal, J.

Present appeal has been preferred by appellant-defendant, being aggrieved by judgment and decree dated 11.08.2000, passed by learned Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Rajpura vide which suit for permanent injunction preferred by respondent-plaintiff was decreed and appellant-defendant were restrained from interfering in peaceful possession of respondent-plaintiff over the land measuring 01 Bigha comprising in khasra No.1264 min situated in revenue limits of village Banur, except in due course of law and also by judgment and decree dated 30.04.2002 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Patiala, whereby first appeal preferred by appellant-defendant was dismissed.

2.

In the suit for permanent injunction, respondent-plaintiff had claimed that suit land which is part of khasra No.1264 min, measuring 01 bigha is in possession of respondent-plaintiff and is situated within abadi dehi of village Banur. Respondent-plaintiff claimed his possession over suit land being ‘Gair Mumking Maursai’. It was claimed that appellant-defendant had no right to interfere in his possession and since appellant-defendant are trying to illegally and forcibly dispossess him, he had sought permanent injunction.

3.

Appellant-defendant had contested the suit and claimed that suit property is owned by it and part of it was rented to Sh. Ram Sarup, Karnail Singh and Mangat Ram. Appellant-defendant had further claimed that said lessees had constructed their shop upon suit land with permission of appellant-defendant and municipal drain is also passing through the site in dispute. Possession of respondent-plaintiff over suit land was denied and accordingly, dismissal of suit was prayed for.

4.

Following issues were framed from the pleadings of the parties:-

i.

Whether the plaintiffs is entitled for permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP

ii.

Whether the plaintiff has no locus-standi to file the present suit? OPD

iii.

Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? OPD

iv.

Relief.

5.

Learned Court of first instance by relying upon jamabandi for year 1991-1992 as well as khasra girdawari from 1987 to 1999, concluded that suit property bearing khasra No.1264 min measuring 01 bigha, is in possession of respondent-plaintiff since long and since appellant-defendant had failed to bring any record showing its ownership or possession, had decreed the suit in favour of respondent-plaintiff. Learned Court of first instance had taken note of fact that appellant-defendant had not placed any document to show that property in dispute belongs to it, property register being maintained by it was not produced, nor any revenue record showing possession or ownership was placed in support of its claim by the appellant-defendant.

6.

Learned appellate Court had accepted the findings of learned Court of first instance and also found that from documents-site plans and building permits (Ex.D1 to Ex.D12), it cannot be concluded that they pertain to suit property, bearing khasra No.1264 min and accordingly had dismissed the first appeal preferred by appellant-defendant.

7.

On re-consideration of pleadings, evidence as well as findings of learned Courts below, I find no fault with findings of learned Courts below as same is based upon documentary evidence placed on record by respondent-plaintiff.

8.

It is admitted by both the parties that suit land falls in abadi deh and bears khasra No.1264 min. Jamabandi for year 1991-92 (Ex.P1) shows suit land bearing khasra No.1264 min to be under the possession of Makbuja Bashindgan Deh, whereas Ex.P2, copy of khasra girdawari from year 1987 to 1999 goes to show that the suit land is in possession of respondent-plaintiff as duly mentioned in column No.3 of Ex.P2. On the other hand, no documentary evidence to show possession over the suit land, has been placed by appellant-defendant. Though appellant-defendant had claimed that suit property is owned by it, was let out by it to various persons who had raised their shops with its permission and a drain is running through the suit land, however, no document was produced to show that suit land was in possession of appellant-defendant. The oral evidence of Joginder Singh, Clerk examined by appellant-defendant as DW1, in fact, is contradicted by revenue records Ex.P1 and Ex.P2. Perusal of site plans and building permits (Ex.D1 to Ex.D12) do not show that they pertain to suit property comprising in khasra No.1264 min.

9.

Therefore, the finding of fact that it is respondent-plaintiff who is in possession of suit land cannot be interfered with. In fact, appellant-defendant had failed to prove its ownership/possession. Therefore, learned Courts below had rightly decreed the suit of respondent-plaintiff and protected his possession by giving liberty to appellant-defendant to seek possession in due course of law, if permissible.

10.

In view of above discussion, I do not find any error in the finding of facts recorded by learned Courts below. No question of fact or law arises. Hence, present appeal is dismissed being without any merit.

11.

Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.