Results
↑↓
High Courts(2026) 11 KAR CK 3026

The Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co., Ltd. Vs Manjunath & Anr.

Karnataka High Court · Dharwad Bench · 17 Nov 2026 · Usharani, J

Open full page

Judgment

46 paragraphs · 1,010 words
1.

MFA No.102452/2016 is filed by the Insurance Company and MFA No.103464/2016 is filed by the claimant challenging the judgment and award dated 13.05.2016 passed in MVC No.941/2015 by the VI Additional District and Sessions Judge and Addl. MACT, Belagavi (hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’, for short).

2.

MVC No.941/2015 has been filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, ‘MV Act’).

3.

The Tribunal, after considering oral and documentary evidence held that, accident has occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the offending car bearing registration No.KA-19/MB-7521 by its driver. Further, the Tribunal computed the following compensation after assessing disability at 20% and has fastened entire liability on the Insurance Company:

Sl.No.HeadsAmount (Rs.)
1Pain and suffering50,000/-
2Loss of future happiness and amenities1,00,000/-
3Loss of income during the treatment period30,000/-
4Incidental expenses28,000/-
5Medical bills33,000/-
6Loss of future income3,24,000/-
7Future medical expenses15,000/-
Total5,80,000/-
4.

The learned counsel for the Insurance Company contended that, as per the papers pertaining to the criminal case, claimant was not walking on the side of the road, but was crossing NH-66 from east to west, which resulted in the accident. Therefore, he contributed to the accident by his negligence. As per the wound certificate, there were no fractures. Hence, the compensation awarded under various heads and interest fixed by the Tribunal is exorbitant.

5.

Per contra, learned counsel for the claimant contended that the Insurance Company had not led rebuttal evidence to prove the negligence of the claimant. Therefore, mere contention of the Insurance Company without cogent evidence cannot be considered. Claimant is a coolie, and considering disability certificate issued by the doctor, the Tribunal rightly assessed percentage of disability. However, Tribunal has failed to consider 45 days of hospitalization of the claimant, and incidental charges borne by the claimant during that period.

6.

Heard both the sides and perused materials available on record.

7.

The point that arises for consideration is:

i.

Whether interfering with the judgment and award passed by VI Additional District and Sessions Judge and Addl. MACT, Belagavi in MVC No.941/2015 is required?

8.

The learned counsel for the Insurance Company, in support of his contention that, claimant has also contributed to the accident, drew the attention of the Court to various documents forming part of the claim petition and highlighted Ex.P14-Mahazar, wherein it is stated that accident has occurred 24 feet away from western edge of NH-66. In this regard, Insurance Company has neither adduced any oral nor documentary evidence. Moreover, considering the entries in the criminal papers that the driver of the car drove the same in a rash and negligent manner and hit the claimant, the Tribunal concurred with the same.

9.

One more contention raised by the learned counsel for Insurance Company is that, as per the wound certificate – Ex.P15, there were no fractures and hence, the claimant has not suffered any disability, and that the Tribunal has wrongly awarded exorbitant compensation under the heads of ‘pain and suffering’ and ‘loss of amenities’.

10.

As per the disability certificate – Ex.P11, the claimant has suffered permanent physical disability of 30% in relation to right lower limb, whereas the wound certificate -Ex.P15, lists down the following injuries:

“1.

Reddish abrasion of 5 cm x 4cm on the outer aspect of upper 1/3rd of right forearm.

2.

Laceration of 3 cm x 2 cm x muscle deep on the base of right palm.

3.

Reddish contusion of 7 cm x 5 cm on the right knee with tear of medial collateral ligament.

4.

Reddish abrasion of 3 cm x 2 cm on the right great toe.

5.

Reddish abrasion of 4 cm x 1 cm on the left knee.

Treatment: MCL repair right knee done by Dr. Prashanth Mohan.”

11.

In the case of a ligament tear, even after reconstruction, the knee may not regain its normal stability and functional capacity. A coolie such as the claimant requires physical strength for his day to day activities and even for mowing grass, he would also require considerable strength. Therefore, disability assessed at 20% by the Tribunal is not interfered with. Since claimant was aged 22 years, multiplier applicable in this case is ‘18’. Further, no document has been produced regarding income of the claimant. Since accident has occurred in the year 2015, as per the notional income chart issued by Karnataka State Legal Services Authority, notional income would be Rs.8,000/-, loss of income due to disability comes to Rs.3,45,600/- (Rs.8,000/- x 12 x 18 x 20%). Thereafter, considering the medical bills, nature of the injuries suffered and period of hospitalization, modifying the compensation under various heads such as ‘Conveyance, food, nourishment and attendant charges’ is essential. Hence, considering all the above discussed facts, compensation awarded by the Tribunal is modified as follows:

Sl.No.HeadsAmount (Rs.)
1Pain and suffering50,000/-
2Loss of amenities1,00,000/-
3Loss of income during laid-up period30,000/-
4Conveyance, food, nourishment and attendant charges35,000/-
5Medical bills33,000/-
7Loss of future income (Rs.8,000/-x 12 x 18 x 20%)3,45,600/-
8Future medical expenses15,000/-
Total6,08,600/-
12.

Since the interest fixed by the Tribunal at the rate of 9% per annum is appropriate, it requires no interference. In light of the above, I proceed to pass the following, by answering Point No.1 in the affirmative:

ORDER

i.

MFA No.102452/2016 is dismissed.

ii.

MFA No.103464/2016 is allowed in part.

iii.

The judgment and award in MVC No.941/2015 dated 13.05.2016 by the VI Additional District and Sessions Judge and Addl. MACT, Belagavi, is modified.

iv.

The claimant is entitled to modified compensation of Rs.6,08,600/- with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of petition till realization.

v.

The Insurance Company shall deposit the compensation, together with accrued interest, before the Tribunal within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment.

vi.

No interference with the order of the Tribunal except what is ordered herein.

vii.

The Registry shall transmit the amount in deposit, if any, along with Trial Court Records to the concerned Tribunal forthwith.

viii.

Registry to draw modified award.