Bhartiya Shikshan Prasarak Sanstha, Ambejogai & Anr. Vs The Union Of India & Ors.
Bombay High Court · Aurangabad Bench · 05 Nov 2026 · Jitendra Jain, J · Kishore C. Sant, J
Judgment
[PER:- KISHORE C. SANT, J.]
1] Heard Mr. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the petitioner in both petitions, Mr. Pulkundwar, learned AGP for Respondent/State, Ms. Jadhav, learned Advocate for Respondent No.1 in WP/10086/2019 and Ms. Kasturkar, learned Advocate for respondent No.1 in WP/10093/2019.
2] Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. By consent of the parties, petitions are taken up for final disposal at the stage of admission.
3] By way of these Writ Petitions, the Petitioners have challenged common impugned order dated 01/03/2018 passed by Respondent No.2/Principal Secretary, School Education & Sports Department, Mumbai, thereby rejecting the proposals dated 23/10/2023 and 29/07/2013, respectively, submitted by petitioners/institutions for grant of unit recognition under Inclusive Education of the Disabled at Secondary Stage (hereinafter referred to as “IEDSS”) scheme to the units at Parampujaniy Golvalkar Guruji Secondary School, Mondha, Degloor in WP/10086/2019 and Zilla Parishad High School at Khanapur in WP/10093/2019 and to grant approval in favour of petitioner No.2 in both writ petitions or to absorb them in other granted unit in the State.
4] The petitioners are the Educational Trusts registered under the provisions of the Bombay Public Trusts Act, bearing registration No. F-14 and F-17633 (Nanded) respectively.
5] In 2009, the Central Government, through the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), took a decision and launched IEDSS Scheme for secondary-stage disabled students, replacing the earlier IEDC policy. Guidelines came to be issued to the Government of Maharashtra for implementing the schemes, which were 100% funded under the IEDSS scheme. The Government of Maharashtra, School Education Department, pursuant to the policy of Central Government, issued a Government Resolution adopting the IEDSS scheme.
6] On 01/07/2013, the petitioner in Petition No. 10086/2019, started the unit. The Petitioner No. 2 came to be appointed as a special teacher. This was done by publishing an advertisement. On 12/07/2013, the Block Education Officer of Panchayat Samiti, Degloor, inspected the school. Thereafter, on 23/10/2013, the petitioner/institution submitted a complete and detailed proposal to the Director of Education (Primary) (MS) Pune (R-4), seeking recognition and grant of permission under the IEDSS Scheme for the unit of the secondary school.
7] On receipt of the proposal, the Block Education Officer conducted a surprise inspection on 25/11/2013, and certified that all facilities are made available at the unit. On getting satisfaction, he recommended to grant recognition to the unit. The said proposal was forwarded by Respondent No.6 to Respondent No.5. The Deputy Director, Education (R-5) forwarded the said recommendation to Respondent No. 4. However, since no action was being taken and no proper communication was received, the petitioner submitted a representation to the Chief Secretary about the inaction on the proposal. The petitioner also made representation to the Minister of School Education. It is thereafter on 02/12/2014, the Director of Education (R-4) directed the Deputy Director, Latur (R-5) to submit a detailed factual report. The Deputy Director (R-5) directed the Education Officer, (Secondary), Zilla Parishad, Latur (R-6) to conduct an inspection and to submit a report. The Deputy Education Officer (Secondary) himself also paid a visit and inspected the unit on 30/12/2014, and found that the unit was functioning strictly as per norms. He found zero discrepancies. It is on this, he recommended to sanction the unit. The Education Officer also communicated a favorable inspection report. The report was thus submitted on 07/02/2015 to the Director of Education (R-4) communicating the inspection report, compliance etc.. However, no action was taken. The petitioner again made a representation to Respondent No. 4 and requested to grant unit a recognition on 07/11/2016. In spite of this, no action was taken. The petitioner, therefore, filed Writ Petition No. 12053 of 2016 in this Court, seeking directions to decide the proposal dated 23/10/2013. The said writ petition came to be disposed of by an order dated 14/03/2017, directing the respondents to decide the proposal within two months.
8] After all the exercise, Respondent No.2, the Section Officer of the State Education Department, issued a letter and positively recommended that permissions be granted to the petitioner's unit. However, Respondent No.2 thereafter, by an impugned order dated 01/03/2018 rejected the proposal dated 23/10/2013 only for the reason assigned being the closure of IEDSS.
9] The petitioner even filed a Contempt Petition No. 222/2018 against Respondent No.2 for deciding the proposal. The said Contempt Petition came to be disposed of by this Court after accepting the apology tendered by the respondent and granting permission to the petitioner to challenge the rejection order. It is the case of the petitioner that, however, till now, the Scheme is very much in operation. The petitioner, therefore, raised the challenge to the letter of rejection by approaching this Court.
10] So far as WP/10093/2019 is concerned, the facts are identical and are therefore not stated in details.
11] Mr. Deshmukh, learned Advocate for the Petitioners in both the petitions, vehemently argued that the action of Respondent No.2 in rejecting the proposals is arbitrary. When the petitioners’ units complied with all the criteria set out in the Scheme by the Central Government, there is no reason for the State Government to reject the proposals only citing the reason that the Scheme is closed. The Scheme is in fact continued even thereafter. In fact, the State Government is only an implementing agency and could not have rejected the proposals on any count once there were favorable reports received in favour of the petitioners.
12] He submits that, there are several instances where the units whose proposals were submitted even after the proposals of the petitioners were granted recognition. On one hand, the respondents did not act pursuant to the proposals for a long period without any justification, and on the other hand, now the permission is rejected solely on the ground that the Scheme is closed. This clearly shows that there is discrimination meted out in the case of the petitioners. The rejection is, therefore, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 of the Constitution of India.
13] His further argument is that, after receipt of the proposals, the authorities had duly inspected the units by personally visiting the schools. On satisfaction about the existence of the facilities as per the scheme, the recommendations were made. Once there were favorable recommendations in favour of the petitioners, the proposals could not have been rejected without giving any cogent reasons. There is no discussion appearing about the facilities made available or the merits of the proposals. It is clearly shown on the record that the school is having adequate infrastructure. The teacher-student ratio is properly maintained. There are no discrepancies. All these factors are not considered by Respondent No.2. His argument is also of violation of Articles 21, 21-A, and 45 of the Constitution of India.
14] He submits that Degloor, where the school is established, is a backward and rural taluka. There is significant population of disabled children from economically poor families. Not granting permission to the unit thus has the effect of depriving children with disabilities of their constitutional right to free education. When there are positive recommendations from all the authorities, there is a legitimate expectation of getting permission from the Government. By now, the petitioner No.2 has served for more than seven years. If no permission is granted, he would face hardship. He submits that the petition deserves to be allowed by quashing and setting aside the impugned orders dated 01/03/2018 passed by Respondent No.2.
15] In support of his submissions, learned Advocate for the petitioners relied upon the following judgments:
Shaikh Nasim Shaikh Ahmed Vs. The Union of India and Ors.1;
Government of Goa through Commissioner and Secretary (Finance) Vs. The Goa Urban Co-operative Bank Ltd. and Ors.2;
Achutrao Haribhau Khodwa and Ors. Vs. State of Maharashtra and Ors.3.
16] It is the stand of the Government that granting permission to such schools was a matter of policy. The Government stopped granting permissions to new IEDSS units from 01/01/2013. The proposals, in the present cases, are received after said cut-off date, when the Scheme was already closed. It is for this reason, the permissions are refused. No any fault can be found with the said decision. The State is only an implementing machinery. The scheme is totally funded by the Central Government. When the Central Government stopped the funding, the State Government had no option but to reject the proposals in absence of funding by the Central Government.
17] So far as the order in the earlier writ petition i.e. WP/12053/2018 is concerned, he submits that the order was duly complied with by the petitioners. The High Court had only directed the respondents to decide the proposal. The High Court had not directed as to what decision be taken. So far as the argument of the petitioners is concerned that the scheme is still running, it is submitted that there is no doubt that the scheme is continued. The submission is that it is continued to mean that the schools which are already granted permission are being run. What is stopped is the grant of fresh permissions. The action of the Government cannot be said to be arbitrary or discriminatory.
18] There is a new policy namely, Samagra Shiksha Program, is introduced, and there is reconstruction of special education. There is a circular issued on 24/10/2013, whereby fresh units are not granted recognition, and cases of teacher appointments are also not considered. So far as the rights of the petitioners is concerned, it is submitted that the petitioners do not have any vested and fundamental right to get the recognition. There is also no discrimination. It is only the schools where proposals are received before 01/01/2013, those are considered. There is no instance showing that any of the proposals received after the cut-off date is considered and is granted recognition. He therefore relies upon the judgment in the case of Ravindra Singh Vs. District Inspector of Schools and Ors.4 He thus prays for dismissal of the writ petitions.
19] The Court has considered the submissions of the learned Advocate for the petitioners, learned AGP for the State. The questions are whether the decision rejecting the proposals of the petitioners is illegal and whether the petitioners have made out a case to allow the petitions.
20] So far as in the case of Shaikh Nasim Shaikh Ahmed (supra), is concerned, in the said case, the Court considered the provisions of Sections 3 and 9 of the Right to Education Act. There, the petitioner No.2 was in service in the respondent No.6 school. The petitioner was appointed as special teacher in the educational institution under the IEDSS scheme. The petitioner's appointment was approved. The recognition was granted to the respective units in which the petitioners were appointed. The permanent approvals were also granted to the services. Pay scale was given to the petitioners. The name of the petitioner was forwarded to the authorities. Thereafter, Deputy Director of Education issued a show-cause notice to the petitioner, and later on, the approvals already granted to the petitioner came to be withdrawn. The petitioners therefore approached this court as even the salary was not paid for for some period even after approval. In that view, it is held that the action of the Deputy Director in withdrawing the affiliation was arbitrary and said was quashed and set aside. This court considered the provisions of Right to Education Act and held that there is a right vested in every child till he attains the age of 14 to receive free education.
21] The another question that was considered was that the authority had conducted state-wide survey in December 2013, where it was found that many of the institutions/units do not fulfill the criteria and there were discrepancies found in the appointment of special teachers. The permissions therefore were cancelled of such schools and the approvals of the teachers were withdrawn. This court does not find from the judgment that there it was the case that the proposal was sent after 01/01/2013 and the same was granted. It is appearing that it was the case where the permission was already granted to run the unit. This judgment would not help the petitioner, as in the present case, the petitioner's case that there is no recognition granted to the school at all. Thus, there was no question to grant approval to the petitioner No.2.
22] So far as judgment in the case of Government of Goa, through Commissioner (supra), in this petition also, this court finds the facts are different and would not help the petitioner in any way. The judgment in the case of Achutrao Khodwa (supra), is on medical negligence and tort. This Court finds that this judgment has no application to the present case.
23] So far as judgment in the case of Ravindra Singh (supra) relied upon by the learned AGP is concerned, it was a case where the teachers were appointed without following due procedure envisaged under law in filling substantive vacancy. Since the appointment itself was without following due procedure, the persons appointed were not given approval. In that view, this Court held that when the appointment by the management is not in accordance with law. Such appointment cannot be regularized. This court finds that in the present case, this judgment would be applicable so far as petitioner No.2 is concerned.
24] The letter of rejection shows that the only reason assigned is that the grant of recognition under the said Scheme is stopped from 01/01/2013. Except for this, there is no any justification given. The said letter is issued by Deputy Secretary, State of Maharashtra. There is another letter dated 29/01/2019 issued by the Education Deputy Director (Primary), giving reference to the letter dated 01/03/2018, communicating that the proposals of the petitioners cannot be accepted. Admittedly, in the present case, the proposals are dated 23/10/2013, and 29/07/2013 i.e. after 01/01/2013.
25] One of the arguments advanced by the learned Advocate for the petitioners was that, there is a permission granted even to the institutions/schools whose proposals were submitted even after cut-off date. No such actual incident is shown by the petitioners. The further argument that there is discrimination, therefore, cannot be accepted. About the scheme, there is no dispute that the scheme introduced by the Government. The question is only as to whether the decision to stop granting recognition to the proposals after 01/01/2013 can be said to be arbitrary. In view of the discussion, the answer is no.
26] To show that the petitioners have right to get the permission or sanction from the Government, they must show that there is a right vested in petitioners to get permission. It is seen that the scheme was introduced in the year 2009 by the Central Government. The funds are also allotted by the Central Government after particular period, if the scheme is stopped by the Central Government, the State Government or the authorities cannot be blamed for not granting sanction or permission to the new institutions. The second question would have bearing upon the first question. In the present case, this Court finds that the petitioners have failed to make out a case that the action of the respondent in not accepting the proposals of the petitioners is arbitrary, discriminatory or in any way against the law.
27] Considering above discussions, it is clearly seen that no case is made out to allow the petitions. The writ petitions therefore stands dismissed.
28] Rule stands discharged.
