Mohammed Azam Usmaan Siddiqui Vs The Divisional Commissioner of Police & Ors.
Bombay High Court · 03 Nov 2026 · Madhav J. Jamdar, J
Judgment
Heard Mr. Shaikh, learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner and Mr. Jadhav, learned APP, for the Respondent-State.
By this Writ Petition, the challenge is to the legality and validity of order dated 23rd December 2025 passed by Deputy Commissioner of Police, Zone-II, Bhiwandi in Externment Case No.5622 of 2025 as also order dated 27th October 2026 passed by Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai in Appeal No.99 of 2026.
It is the submission of Mr. Shaikh, learned Counsel appearing for the Applicant that total three offences are taken into consideration, while passing the externment order. Two offences are of the year 2017 and 2018 respectively and therefore, there is no live link between those offences and action of externment taken in the year 2025. As far as the third offence is concerned which is C.R.No.290 of 2025 registered with Bhoiwada Police Station, Bhiwandi, the same is under Sections 5(A) and 5(B) of Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act, 1976 and under Section 11(1)(d) of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960. He submits that the said offence was under investigation when the action of externment was taken and therefore the said offence could not have been taken into consideration. He submits that, in fact, as far as the said offence being C.R.No.290 of 2025 is concerned, the Division Bench of this Court by order dated 01st August 2025 has granted stay to the said offence. He therefore submits that, the subjective satisfaction recorded is without any material on record.
On the other hand, learned APP, submits that the subjective satisfaction recorded is on the basis of record. However, on instructions, learned APP, states that, after investigation the Police are proposing to file ‘C-Summary’ as far as C.R.No.290 of 2025 is concerned.
Before consideration of rival submission it is necessary to set out details of three offences which have taken into consideration by the Externing Authority as set out in the impugned order :-
| Sr. No. | Police Station | Crime Reg. No. | Present Status |
| 1 | Bhoiwada | 290/2025 Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act 1976 Section 5(A)(B) and Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act 1960 Section 11(1)(D) | Under Police Investigation |
| 2 | Bhoiwada | 98/2018 IPC Section 397 read with Mumbai Police Act Section 37(1), 135 | 1011/2018 |
| 3 | Bhoiwada | Non-Cognizable Crime Reg. No.530/2017 IPC Section 504, 506 | -- |
The above details show that one non-cognizable offence is taken into consideration and the same is of the year 2017 and another offence which is taken into consideration is of the year 2018. Therefore it cannot be said that there is any live link between the action of externment which has been taken in the year 2025 and the said offences of the year 2017 and 2018.
It is relevant to note that as far as C.R.No.290 of 2025 is concerned it was under investigation when the action of externment was taken.
A learned Single Judge in the case of Imtiyaz Hussain Sayyad v. State of Maharashtra & Ors1. in Writ Petition No.2805 of 2023 has held that, it is trite that the crimes which are still under investigation cannot be taken into consideration while passing externment order, as depending upon the outcome of the investigation, the investigating agency may or may not send the accused for trial. Thus the said observations are squarely applicable to the present case.
Apart from the above aspects there is one more aspect which is very significant. It is required to be noted that action of externment is taken mainly on the basis of said offence I.e. C.R.No.290 of 2025 concerning which a Division Bench of this Court has granted ad-interim protection by order dated 01st August 2025. The order dated 01st August 2025 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Criminal Writ Petition No.3321 of 2025, reads as under :-
“1)Perusal of record prima facie indicates that, the application of Sections 5A and 5B of the Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act, 1976, to the present crime is misplaced.
2)Learned APP seeks time to take instructions.
3)At his request, stand over to 22nd August, 2025.
4)Till the returnable date, ad-interim relief in terms of prayer clause (b).”
The said prayer Clause (b) reads as under :-
“b)Pending hearing and final disposal of the present Application stay may be granted on further proceeding arising out of FIR No.290 of 2025 registered with Bhoiwada Police Station Bhiwandi for the offences punishable under section 5A, 5B of Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act 1976 and under Section 11(1)(D) of Animal Cruelty Act 1960 in the interest of justice.”
Thus the further proceedings of said FIR No.290 of 2025 have been stayed by the Division Bench by observing that prima facie Sections 5A and 5B of the Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act, 1976 are not applicable. Although, Division Bench has stayed the proceedings and the same is brought to the notice of the Externing Authority the Respondent No.2 passed the Externment order which has been confirmed by the Respondent No.1-Appellate Authority on the basis of registration of the said C.R.No.290 of 2025.
Thus, it is clear that not only the subjective satisfaction recorded by the Deputy Commissioner, Zone-II, Bhiwandi as also by the Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai is without any material on record but the same is a mala fide action. By the mala fide action of the State of Maharashtra the fundamental rights of the Petitioner has been affected and therefore, it is necessary that the State of Maharashtra should be directed to pay the costs to the Petitioner. The mala fides are more apparent from the fact that as contended by the learned APP, on instructions, that, the State of Maharashtra is proposing to file ‘C-Summary’ in said C.R. No.290 of 2025 and that other offences taken into consideration are of the years 2017 and 2018.
It is settled legal position that an order of externment is an extraordinary measure and effect of such order is of depriving a citizen of his fundamental right of free movement throughout the territory of India2
It is shocking and surprising that after the Division Bench of this Court has granted stay to the further proceedings arising out of C.R.No.290 of 2025, on the basis of the same the Deputy Commissioner of Police as also Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division has passed the impugned orders. It is shocking that after the proceedings arising out of said C.R.No.290 of 2025 has been stayed by this Court, on the basis of same the externment order has been passed violating the fundamental rights of the Petitioner.
Considering the facts and circumstances, the following order is passed :-
Criminal Writ Petition is allowed by setting aside order dated 23rd December 2025 passed by Deputy Commissioner of Police, Zone-II, Bhiwandi in Externment Case No.5622 of 2025 as also order dated 27th October 2026 passed by Divisional Commissioner, Konkan Division, Mumbai in Appeal No.99 of 2026.
In the facts and circumstances, the State of Maharashtra shall pay cost of Rs.10,000/- to the Petitioner within a period of four weeks from today.
The Criminal Writ Petition is disposed of in above terms.
