Aniket Hemkant Kharkar & Anr. Vs Western Coalfields Ltd. & Ors.
Bombay High Court · Nagpur Bench · 05 Nov 2026 · Raj D. Wakode, J · Urmila Joshi-Phalke, J
Judgment
(PER : RAJ D. WAKODE, J.)
. Heard Shri. D. Y. Chatap, learned counsel for the petitioners and Shri. Ishant Tambi, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1 and 2. Respondent No. 3, though served by the usual mode, has chosen not to appear before this Court.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of learned counsel for the parties.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present petition are as follows:
The petitioners are the owners of land bearing Survey No.206/2, admeasuring 1.39 H.R., situated at Village Marda, Tah. Warora, Dist. Chandrapur (hereinafter referred to as “the aforesaid land”), by virtue of the Partition- deed dated 11.07.2019. A copy of the Partition deed is at record page No.40 (Annexure - 2). Respondent Nos.1 and 2 - WCL, acquired the aforesaid land under the provisions of the Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957 (hereinafter referred to as “the aforesaid Act”). The notification under Section 9(1) of the aforesaid Act was issued on 29.08.2020. Respondent Nos.1 and 2 executed agreements with the petitioners concerning the employment and compensation for the acquired land on 28.02.2021. A copy of the agreement is record page No.62 (Annexure - 4). The Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy-2012 (for short, ‘R & R Policy-2012’) which is applicable to the respondent-Western Coalfields Limited contains the provision for Monetary Compensation and employment which inter alia provides that one employment may be considered for every two acres of land acquired. However, respondent Nos.1 and 2 have not processed their claim for employment and Monetary Compensation on the ground that Regular Civil Suit No.25 of 2021, is pending before the competent Civil Court. Being aggrieved by the inaction on the part of respondent Nos.1 and 2 in considering their claim for Monetary Compensation and employment, the petitioners have approached this Court.
Shri. D. Y. Chatap, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, submits that respondent Nos.1 and 2 have kept the petitioners’ claim for Monetary Compensation and employment under the Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy, 2012 (R&R Policy, 2012) pending solely on the ground that Regular Civil Suit No.25 of 2021 (Regular Civil Suit No.74 of 2022), pertaining to the aforesaid land, is pending adjudication before the competent Civil Court. It is further submitted that no stay or prohibitory order has been passed in the said suit and that the names of the petitioners are reflected in the revenue records on the relevant date. It is, therefore, submitted that the claim of the petitioners deserves to be considered in accordance with the applicable R & R Policy-2012.
The learned counsel for the petitioners has also placed reliance upon the judgment of this Court dated 06.08.2026 passed in Writ Petition No.6869 of 2025, wherein this Court, after considering the judgment in the case of Mirabai Namdeo Gaurkar and Another v. Western Coalfields Limited and Another, Writ Petition No.1795 of 2021, decided on 27.04.2023, and the subsequent modification of the Standard Operating Procedure adopted by respondent - WCL on 22.01.2026, held that a claim for employment under R & R Policy-2012 cannot be rejected merely on the ground of pendency of a civil suit particularly when no stay or prohibitory order has been passed by the competent Court. It has been held that the claim can be processed in accordance with the applicable policy and the procedure adopted by respondent - WCL, subject to the claimant furnishing an appropriate undertaking that the employment shall remain subject to the final outcome of the pending civil litigation.
Shri. Ishant Tambi, learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1 and 2 does not dispute such legal and factual position as narrated above. He submits that respondent Nos.1 and 2 shall consider the proposal of the petitioners on its own merits and in accordance with law as enunciated by this Court and in view of the amended Standard Operating Procedure adopted by WCL.
The issue involved in the present petition is covered by the judgment of this Court dated 06.08.2026 passed in Writ Petition No.6869 of 2025, wherein this Court considered the law laid down in Mirabai Namdeo Gaurkar (supra). This Court, after considering the aforesaid judgment and the subsequent modification of the Standard Operating Procedure adopted by respondent - Western Coalfields Limited on 22.01.2026, has held that a claim for employment under the Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy cannot be rejected merely on the ground of pendency of a civil suit challenging the title to the acquired land, particularly when no stay or prohibitory order has been passed by the competent Court. The claim can be processed in accordance with the applicable policy and the procedure adopted by respondent - WCL, subject to the claimant furnishing an appropriate undertaking that the employment shall remain subject to the final outcome of the pending civil litigation. This Court, while relying upon the judgment in the case of Mirabai Namdeo Gaurkar (supra) and considering the SOP adopted by the respondent - Western Coalfields Limited on 22.01.2026, has held thus:
“14.We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. The issue involved in the present writ petition is no more res integra, as in a similar set of circumstances, this Court, vide its judgment dated 27.04.2023 in the case of Mirabai Namdeo Gaurkar and Another (supra), has held that civil litigation may consume substantial time and accordingly directed Western Coalfields Limited to process the proposal and grant employment upon furnishing an appropriate undertaking. The relevant paragraphs of the aforesaid judgment read thus:
“5.We do not appreciate the attitude and approach of the WCL, and which we have noticed in matters more than one. It is an admitted position that as on the date of the issuance of the Notification under Section 9 of the Act, and which is the relevant date, the name of Mrs. Mirabai Gaurkar is recorded as the owner of the subject land and as a fact, WCL has paid the monetary compensation to Mrs. Mirabai Gaurkar. The Rehabilitation Policy entitles the land owner to, apart from the monetary compensation, employment. WCL, in our considered view, could not have refused to consider the claim of Mrs. Mirabai Gaurkar on the specious ground that her title to the subject land is under cloud in view of the pendency of the Regular Civil Suit 172/2016.
6.We have considered a similar situation in Writ Petition 1123/2022 and we may extract the relevant observations therein.
“5.It is not in dispute that in the revenue record, names of petitioners 1 to 4 are shown as the owners of the agriculture land acquired, as on the date of the publication of Section 9 notification which is ordinarily treated as the relevant and cut off date by the acquiring body for the purpose of benefits under the Policy.
6.We see no reason why the nominees of the petitioners whose names are reflected in the revenue record as the owners of the land acquired, as on the date of the publication of Section 9 notification, should be denied employment only on the ground that there is a challenge to their title. The title dispute may take years and indeed decades. It would neither be in the interest of the petitioners nor WCL nor respondent 2 to keep the vacancy in limbo only on the ground of pendency of the title dispute.
7.We are conscious of the fact that if respondent 3 succeeds in the title dispute, he may as well lodge claim for employment. We therefore, sought an undertaking from the petitioners which is duly filed. We may extract the relevant portion of the said undertaking.
"2.It is submitted that the petitioners have already made prayer in the petition that the respondents 1 & 2 to accept the nomination form, affidavit and complete other formalities as per Rules for the purpose of employment to petitioners 4 to 7 subject to decision of this petition or subject to the final decision of aforementioned RCS no. 117/2015. The petitioners reserve their rights to avail/prefer statutory remedies as per law. The petitioners who are desirous of employment hereby reiterating and giving undertaking that their appointments can be made subject to final outcome of the aforesaid Regular Civil Suit. Other petitioners have no objection for the same. In the event if it is held that the petitioners are not eligible or they have no share in the suit property or any other person are entitled for the employment in place of the present petitioners, in view of acquisition of land in question, in that event the petitioners shall waive their right of employment and will discontinue the employment upon final decision of aforesaid RCSNo. 117/2015 that may be reached to its finality as per law. The petitioners shall not claim any equity or, any permanency or a like service benefits if the petitioners are appointed provisionally subject to final decision of aforesaid RCS No. 117/2015 that may be reached to its finality as per law."
They further undertake to follow the directions and conditions which may be imposed by this Hon'ble Court. The petitioners are ready to abide by any condition as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper, in the interest of justice.
8.In addition to the undertaking, we direct that if the civil court rejects the claim of the petitioners as the exclusive owners of the property or put it differently, acknowledges the title of the respondent 3 either as an absolute owner or as co-owner, the petitioners 5 to 7, who may be provided employment under the interim order, shall not claim any equity and shall leave the post on the day on which the verdict is pronounced."
15.In view of the above, we do not find any reason to not follow the similar course.
16.Mr. D.Y. Chatap, learned counsel for the petitioners, has filed an additional affidavit on behalf of the petitioners on 27.03.2026. In the said affidavit, the petitioners have stated on oath that a meeting of the Empowered Committee of the Functional Directors of respondent No.1 – WCL was held on 22.01.2026, wherein Item No.381/1 was considered and an important decision was taken.
It was resolved that, in cases where no stay or prohibitory order has been passed by any Civil Court or other competent Court, the claims for payment of compensation and grant of Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R&R) benefits, including employment, shall be processed upon obtaining an undertaking and an indemnity bond/declaration from the eligible landowners whose names appear in the 7/12 revenue record as on the date of publication of the notification under Section 9 of the Coal Bearing Areas (Acquisition and Development) Act, 1957.
The petitioners have also placed the aforesaid decision on record as Annexure-A1 at record page No.165, which reads thus:
“ITEM NO.381/1
SUB: Proposal for modification in the modalities of the SOP relating to disbursement of Land Compensation and R&R benefits to eligible landowners existing in 7/12 records as on date of publication of Section 9(1) of CBA (A&D) Act, 1957 in line with the orders of Hon’ble High court, Bombay and Hon'ble Supreme Court where Registered civil suit is pending in the court of law.
i)Shri Sachin Kumar Patil, General Manager (L&R) explained the proposal to the Committee.
ii) In consideration of the proposal and after deliberation, the Empowered Committee of Functional Directors headed by CMD, WCL agreed to the proposal and accorded approval for following modification at Point No. 5 in the modalities of the Standard Operating Procedure(SOP) for disbursement of Land Compensation and R&R benefits to eligible landowners approved at 694th meeting of FDs held on 02.12.2016 in line with the orders of Hon'ble High Court, Bombay and Hon'ble Supreme Court where Registered civil suit is pending in the court of law as brought out in the agenda note:
Point No. 5 of the SOP for disbursement of Land Compensation and R&R benefits be substituted as follows:
A. In the cases where subsequent objectors / claimants have not raised their claims timely earlier during course of acquisition as per settled procedure, or they have not objected under section 8(2) of CBA (A&D) Act 1957 with supporting appropriate requisite documents justifying their claims against the recorded owners at the time of section 9(1) and in the cases where no stay or prohibitory order is further issued by Civil court or any other Court and the payment of land compensation and/or R&R benefits is pending, only such cases will be taken into consideration.
Such cases shall be separately examined by Area committee on receipt of application submitted by recorded land owners at the time of Section 9(1) notification and if their name are included in R&R list, with a Legitimate bond and undertaking that if the civil court decides the claim of the objector against the recorded land owner (applicant) as the exclusive owners of the property or put it differently, acknowledges the title of the objector either as an absolute owner or as co-owner, the applicants provided provisional employment under the interim order, shall not claim any equity and shall leave the post on the day on which the verdict is pronounced, and also that all penalties, recovery imposed by company in that situation will be unconditionally binding to him/them.
Such claims and counter claims are to be examined by Area committee on merit in consultation with Legal department of Area.
And if it appears prima facie that the mischievous attempt had been made by subsequent objector that to ensure the rightful claimant whose land is acquired does not get succor of employment by filing ex facie frivolous suit or it appears to the Area committee that the claim of subsequent objector is not on merit or appears illegitimate or the claim of recorded land owners prima - facie appears on merit, then Area Committee will submit the proposal for providing provisional R&R benefits to the landowner recorded at the time of Section 9(1) and name depicted in R&R list with proper deliberations, observations and findings with the recommendations of AGM.
B. On receipt of such proposals, after its technical vetting, the same will be placed before standing committee for further deliberations and standing committee in consultation with HOD (Legal) will recommend the proposal for placing before competent authority for providing provisional employment subject to condition that if the civil court decides the claim of the objector as the exclusive owners of the property or put it differently, acknowledges the title either as an absolute owner or as co-owner, the landowner who has been provided provisional employment under the provisional order, shall not claim any equity and shall leave the post on the day on which the verdict is pronounced, and also that all conditions and penalties or recovery imposed by company in that situation will be unconditionally binding to him. In order to safeguard the interest of company the draft of such bond/ declaration deed as per appropriate legal proceeding may be get finalized by IR Dept and Legal department of Company.
C. If required by statute or advised by Legal Dept/Panel advocate, the concerned court shall be intimated suitably.
iii) General Manager (L&R) and General Manager (HR&IR) to take necessary action in the matter.”
In view of the aforesaid legal position and the modification of the Standard Operating Procedure adopted by respondent - WCL on 22.01.2026, the claim of the petitioners deserves to be considered in accordance with the aforesaid procedure, particularly when no stay or prohibitory order has been shown to have been passed by the competent Civil Court.
Accordingly and for the reasons set out hereinabove, we allow the petition in the following terms:-
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 are directed to process the proposal of the petitioners in accordance with the SOP for disbursement of land compensation and R & R benefits adopted in the meeting dated 22.01.2026, and to issue appointment orders in favour of petitioners, unless there is any other legal impediment. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of eight weeks from the date of this order.
It is clarified that the claim of the petitioners shall not be rejected solely on the ground of pendency of Regular Civil Suit No.25 of 2021.
The petitioners shall furnish an undertaking before respondent Nos.1 and 2 that the appointment, if granted, shall remain subject to the final outcome of the aforesaid civil suit. In the event, it is held that the petitioners are not entitled to the aforesaid land, or that any other person is entitled to the employment, the petitioners shall not claim any benefit on the principle of equity.
The undertaking shall specify that the employment, if granted, shall be provisional and contingent upon the outcome of the pending civil suit.
The parties shall extend necessary assistance to the learned Civil Court for expeditious disposal of the Civil Suit.
Rule is made absolute in the above terms. No order as to costs.
