S. Amrithanathan & Ors. Vs Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. & Ors.
Bombay High Court · 03 Nov 2026 · R.I. Chagla, J · Firdosh P. Pooniwalla, J
Judgment
(Per R.I. Chagla, J.)
By this Writ Petition, the Petitioners have sought a direction to the Respondents to extend the benefits of the ESSO KAVITA Pension Scheme, claiming their entitlement thereto pursuant to accrual slips issued to the Petitioners. They have sought implementation of the Judgment of this Court in the matter of Pensioners Social and Welfare Association Vs. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (WP No. 163 of 2018) and for a direction to the Respondents to utilize the appropriate formula for calculation of Pension benefits as affirmed by this Court in the said decision.
The Petitioners are retired employees of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited, Mumbai Refining and LUBE Refining. Respondent No. 1 is Hindustan Corporation Limited and Respondents 2 and 3 are the Managing Director and Director HR, respectively, of Respondent No. 1. Respondent No. 4 is the Union of India through the Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Gas.
The Petitioners had joined Respondent No. 1 on various dates from 15 July 1974 to 14 January 1978. It is pertinent to note that prior to the present Petitioners joining Respondent No. 1, the ESSO Refining Limited (“ESSO”) had been acquired by the Government of India under “The ESSO (Acquisition of Undertakings in India) Act, 1974” including LUBE India and ESSO Standard Refining Co. of India Ltd. on 12 March 1974 and 15th July, 1974 respectively. After nationalization and amalgamation, these companies were renamed as “Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited”, (Respondent No. 1).
The Petitioners, after joining the services of Respondent No. 1 on various dates and in various posts, had been paid wages and other benefits which the Petitioners claim were also paid to employees of ESSO Eastern Inc. The service conditions of the employees of ESSO were also continued and made applicable to them.
On 11 August 1980, a settlement was arrived at between Respondent No. 1 and the Employees Union. As per the settlement, which was signed under Section 2(p), read with Section 18(1), of the Industrial Disputes Act, the Gratuity Policy and Pension benefits of erstwhile ESSO were made applicable to the employees who had joined before 29 January 1976 in Fuels Refining and 14 January 1978 in LUBE Refining.
On 12 April 1983, another settlement was arrived at between Respondent No. 1 and the Employees Union, wherein it was specifically agreed that the clauses of the earlier settlement will be continued and not altered.
The Petitioners claim that accrual slips had been issued to them by the Respondents in respect of Pension balances of every year which confirm that the Pension Scheme of the erstwhile ESSO would be applicable to the Petitioners. The Petitioners are aggrieved by the denial of Pension to them as per ESSO Pension policy after their retirement. They claim that the Respondents had forced upon them Superannuation Pension Scheme signed in 1989 and implemented from 1988.
The Petitioners have relied upon the Judgment of this Court dated 3rd May 2019 in Writ Petition No. 163 of 2018, in which it was held that the Petitioners therein who were employed between 15 July 1974 to 1st May 1975, were entitled to Pension as per the ESSO Pension Scheme. Further, it was declared by this Court that all retired employees / Petitioners therein are entitled to computation of Pension at the rate of Pension accruals without any deductions. The present Petitioners claim to be discriminated from other employees who were Petitioners in the aforesaid Petition and who had been granted the relief by this Court. They have sought implementation of the Judgment in their favor.
The Petitioners have been making representations requesting for Pension as per the ESSO Pension Scheme, and one such representation had been made on 14 March 2017. There had been no response to the representation and accordingly the Petitioners were left with no other alternative than to approach this Court.
It is pertinent to note that subsequent to the filing of the present Petition, the Supreme Court vide its Order dated 19th November, 2024, in Special Leave Petition filed by Respondent No. 1, dismissed the Special Leave Petition on the ground that a part of the Pensionary benefit which had been extended to 269 employees of Respondent No. 1 under the ESSO Pension Scheme, had been withdrawn, admittedly, without following the principles of natural justice and without giving these employees an opportunity of being heard. Further, that it was too late in the day for the Petitioners to be given an opportunity of being heard. It was made clear by the Supreme Court that the view taken remains confined to the said 269 retired employees.
Mr. Anil Kumar, learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioners, has submitted that the present Petitioners would be covered by the Judgment of this Court dated 3 May 2019 which had been pressed in respect of similarly placed employees of Respondent No. 1 and who have upon their retirement been given the benefit of the ESSO Pension Scheme.
Mr. Anil Kumar has submitted that there is a clear case of discrimination between two sets of employees who have retired from the service of Respondent No. 1, and that the attempt on the part of the Respondents to deny Pensionary benefits to the Petitioners on the ground that they joined after 15 July 1974 is fallacious in light of the settlements arrived at between the Respondent No. 1 and the Employees Union on 11 August 1980 and thereafter on 12 April 1983.
Mr. Anil Kumar has submitted that the Petitioners have been discriminated against by the Respondents in not granting them the Pensionary benefits upon their retirement under the ESSO Pension Scheme and thereby violating their fundamental rights under Article 14 of the Constitution. He has submitted that Pension being part of Petitioners' livelihood, denial thereof amounts to violation of Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
Mr. Anil Kumar has also referred to Clause 7 of the appointment letters which had extended the benefit of the ESSO Pension Scheme to the Petitioners and other similarly situated employees of Respondent No. 1. He has also placed reliance upon the accrual slips which have been issued to the Petitioners and which extended the benefits of the ESSO Pension Plan to them.
Mr. Anil Kumar has submitted that the Respondent No. 1 has denied extending the benefits of the ESSO Pension Scheme to the Petitioners on the ground that they had joined as employees of Respondent No. 1 and not as legacy employees of ESSO and LUBE India Limited. Such ground for denial of the ESSO Pension Scheme would run contrary to the Judgment of this Court in Writ Petition No. 163 of 2018 which has been upheld by the Supreme Court by rejection of the Special Leave Petitions. He has accordingly sought for the Petition to be allowed and for the Respondents to be directed to extend the benefits of the ESSO Pension Scheme to the Petitioners.
Mr. D'Souza, learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents, has submitted that the Petitioners who were superannuated after the introduction of the contributory superannuation benefit fund scheme with effect from 1st January 2007, were receiving Pensionary benefits under the original Superannuation Benefits Fund Scheme from 1988 to 2006 as well as the revised scheme from 1st January 2007. The Petitioners, in addition, are in receipt of Pension under the Employees Pension Scheme 1995.
Mr. D'Souza has submitted that from the settlement dated 11 August 1980 between Respondent No. 1 and the Employees Union, it is apparent that the ESSO Pension Scheme was not applicable to the Petitioners as they were demanding a Pension Scheme as no Pension Scheme had been introduced for the employees after Respondent No. 1 was formed in the public sector. He has submitted that from the subsequent Settlements i.e. Settlements dated 11th January 1989 and 12th July 1989, which had introduced the Respondent No.1 Employees Superannuation Benefits Funds Scheme with effect from 30th May 1988, it is evident that it was an accepted position that the ESSO Pension Plan does not apply to the Petitioners.
Mr. D'Souza has submitted that the ESSO Pension Plan is a legacy Pension Plan which applies only to the employees of erstwhile ESSO who became employees of ESSO Standard Refining Company of India Limited, pursuant to the acquisition and takeover in the year 1974. Such employees joined the new company on the same terms and conditions of service as applicable to them in ESSO.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that the Petitioners had been recruited after formation of Respondent No. 1 and were not legacy employees of ESSO or LUBE India Limited. He has submitted that the appointment letters of the Petitioners, which were issued by Respondent No. 1, had no reference to the benefit of any Pension Plan, much less to ESSO Pension Plan.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that the Petitioners in Paragraph 8A of the Petition have stated that the employees who retired after 1974 from Respondent No. 1 and had initially joined ESSO were getting Pensionary benefits as per the ESSO Pension Plan. He has submitted that in Paragraph 17 of the Petition, the Petitioners have stated that they derived their right for Pension in accordance with the settlements drawn between the Employees' Union and Respondent No. 1. None of these settlements apply the ESSO Pension Plan to the Petitioners.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that considering that the Petitioners have claimed their entitlement for the ESSO Pension Plan under Clauses 16(1) and (2) of the settlement dated 11th December 1980, they ought to raise an industrial dispute under Section 2 (k) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, and cannot pursue a demand of non-implementation of settlement by invoking the writ jurisdiction of this Court.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that non-implementation of the settlement involves disputed questions of fact which can be adjudicated by the Industrial Tribunal. The Petitioners' claim of non-implementation of settlement dated 11th August 1980 is a ground for dismissal of the Petition due to delay and laches of 37 years.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that the Judgment of this Court in Writ Petition No. 163 of 2018 is distinguishable on facts and is confined to the Petitioners therein. Special Leave Petitions preferred by Respondent No.1 from the said Judgment have been rejected by the Supreme Court by its Order dated 19th November 2024. The Supreme Court made its view clear viz. that Pensionary benefits which had been extended erroneously to the employees who had been recruited by Respondent No. 1 after 15th July 1974 had been admittedly withdrawn without following the principles of natural justice and without affording the concerned employees an opportunity of being heard. Further, that at this stage it was too late in the day to direct the answering Respondent to afford such an opportunity of hearing. This was confined to the 269 retired employees who were before the Court.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that the aforesaid decision has no application to the case of the present Petitioners. The factual and legal foundation of the said proceedings are materially different, in as much as the Pensionary benefits in question had, in fact, been extended erroneously to the concerned employees and were subsequently withdrawn. He has submitted that in the case of the present Petitioners, no such Pensionary benefits under the ESSO Pension Plan were ever extended to the Petitioners in the first place. He has accordingly submitted that the observations made by the Supreme Court in the said decision cannot be mechanically applied or extended to the present case.
Mr. D’souza has submitted that the Petitioners who have at no point of time been extended the ESSO Pension Plan, cannot now seek to extend the same and accordingly the present Petition deserves dismissal.
Having considered the submissions, we are of the view that the present Petitioners cannot be said to be similarly placed as the Petitioners who had filed Writ Petition No. 163 of 2018 before this Court. Those Petitioners had been erroneously extended the Pensionary benefits under the ESSO Pension Plan, which had thereafter been admittedly withdrawn, and which withdrawal has been held by the Supreme Court in the Special Leave Petition (SLP) Nos. 5228-5229 of 2020 preferred from the Judgment of this Court dated 3rd May 2019 to be without following the principles of natural justice and without affording the concerned employees an opportunity of being heard.
It has been made clear by the Supreme Court in the Special Leave Petitions that the view taken is confined only to the 269 retired employees in the matter. We find much merit in the submission on behalf of Respondent No. 1 that the said decision has no application in the present case, as the factual and legal foundation of those proceedings are materially different, in as much as the Pensionary benefits in question had, in fact, been extended erroneously to those employees and were subsequently withdrawn, whereas in the present case, no Pensionary benefits under the ESSO Pension Plan have ever been extended to the Petitioners. Thus, the observations made by the Supreme Court in the said proceedings cannot be mechanically applied or extended to the present case.
It is pertinent to note that the present Petitioners have been conferred Pensionary benefits under the original Self-Contributory Superannuation Scheme titled "Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited Employees Superannuation Benefit Fund Scheme," (SBFS) from 1988 to 2006 as well as been conferred benefits under the Contributory Superannuation Benefit Fund Scheme from 1st January 2007. The Petitioners are also in receipt of Pension under the Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995.
From a perusal of the Settlement dated 11th August 1980 entered into between Respondent No.1 and the Employees' Union, it is apparent that there is an admission of the fact that the ESSO Pension Scheme was not applicable to the Petitioners, as there was no Pension Scheme introduced for employees such as the Petitioners after Respondent No. 1 had been formed in the public sector. The Petitioners have joined Respondent No.1 on various dates from 15th July 1974 to 14th January 1978, whereas ESSO had been nationalized by that date and along with LUBE India Ltd. and ESSO Standard Refining Co. of India Ltd. renamed as Respondent No. 1.
We also find merit in the submission on behalf of Respondent No. 1 that the ESSO Pension Plan is a legacy Pension Plan which applies only to the employees of ESSO who became employees of ESSO Standard Refining Co. of India Ltd. after the takeover, as such employees joined the Company on the same terms and conditions of service as applicable to them in ESSO. Thus, the employees of ESSO were continued under the ESSO Pension Plan, and the employees of LUBE India Limited were continued under the Pension Plan of LUBE India Limited after the takeover of ESSO by the Central Government under the ESSO Acquisition of Undertakings Act, 1974, and they had been renamed as Respondent No. 1.
The Petitioners, being recruited after the formation of Respondent No. 1, are not legacy employees of ESSO and accordingly they are not entitled to be extended the benefit of the ESSO Pension Plan.
Further, it is apparent from the definition of ‘eligible employees’ in the ESSO Pension Plan that it is only those regular employees who were members of the permanent residence staff of ESSO and who were engaged in service on and after the effective date of the ESSO Pension Plan, are eligible to the benefits as provided in the plan upon retirement. This cannot apply to the present Petitioners who joined as employees of Respondent No.1 and who were never in the service of ESSO prior to its takeover by the Government of India under the ESSO (Acquisition of Undertakings in India) Act, 1974.
The Petitioners have placed reliance upon Clause 16(1) and (2) of settlement dated 11th December 1980, in contending that they are entitled for ESSO Pension Plan. Interpretation of these Clauses would be by raising of an industrial dispute under Section 2 (K) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and not by invoking writ jurisdiction of this Court.
Further, we find merit in the contention on behalf of Respondent No. 1 that the Petitioners are claiming non-implementation of Settlement dated 11th August 1980 after delay and laches of 37 years, and accordingly the Petition is required to be dismissed on this ground.
Accordingly, we find no merit in the present Petition which is dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
