Arun Kumar Singal Vs Ajay Kumar Singal & Ors.
Delhi High Court · New Delhi · 20 Nov 2026 · Subramonium Prasad, J
Judgment
I.A. 13352/2019
The present application has been filed by the Plaintiff under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC for disposal of the Suit in terms of the Memorandum of Understanding-Cum-Family Settlement dated 08.07.2019 (herein referred to as the “Second MoU”)
Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts leading to the filing of the present suit are as under:
a. The suit involves a long-standing intra-family dispute between three brothers, Arun Kumar Singal (Plaintiff), Ajay Kumar Singal (Defendant No. 1), and Ashok Kumar Singal (Defendant No. 2, since deceased, represented by his legal heirs (sons), Defendants no. 2A and 2B ). Their family members, Smt. Anuradha Singal (Defendant No. 4) and Akash Singal (Defendant No. 5), as well as 13 closely held family companies (Defendant Nos. 3 and 6 to 18), are arrayed as defendants.
b. It is stated that for more than 25 years, the family jointly promoted and managed numerous private corporate entities and acquired valuable real estate assets (including a commercial plot B-18, Sector-62, Noida, owned by Defendant No. 3, M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.). It is stated that conflicting claims over corporate control, directorships, shareholding patterns, real estate developments, and financial advances led to a complete breakdown of trust among the three brothers.
c. Owing to such disputes, with the assistance of relatives and family friends, the parties executed a Memorandum of Understanding / Family Settlement dated 24.09.2016 (hereinafter referred to as „the 2016 MoU‟), which sought to distribute family companies and assets among the three brothers, such as assigning the Defendant No. 3 (M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.) to the Plaintiff at an agreed valuation of ₹106 per share. Terms of the 2016 MoU are not relevant for the purpose of adjudicating the present application.
d. It is stated that the 2016 MoU was never fully implemented due to alleged non-compliance, lack of formal corporate authorizations/board resolutions from Defendant Nos. 3 and 6– 18, and mutual allegations of breach raised by the parties against each other.
e. On 26.09.2017, the Plaintiff filed the present suit before this Court seeking specific performance of the 2016 MoU, declarations, and permanent injunctions.
f. Following the institution of the present suit, the conflict escalated across multiple judicial forums, leading to cross-litigations, including numerous FIRs, proceedings under the NI Act, NCLT Petitions, etc.
g. Ultimately, during pending proceedings before this Court, the parties were referred to mediation, which resulted in a Second MoU which was executed by 41 signatories, encompassing all family members, shareholders, and authorised corporate representatives.
h. It is based on this Second MoU dated 08.07.2019, in terms of which the Plaintiff seeks a decree under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC.
Submissions by the Plaintiff
The Plaintiff submits that during the pending mediation before the Court, 41 signatories, including all three brothers, their family members, shareholders, and corporate representatives, executed a comprehensive, voluntary, and irrevocable Family Settlement/Second MoU. This agreement constitutes a lawful agreement or compromise under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC that fully adjusts and satisfies all claims in the suit. It is the case of the Plaintiff that the binding nature of the Second MoU is evident from certain clauses such as clauses 14, 23, 28 and 35.
Learned Counsel for the Plaintiff states that after filing of the application under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, the Defendants started changing the shareholding pattern, which was brought to the notice of this Court, and this Court vide Order dated 03.12.2019 had directed that the shareholding patterns of Defendant No.3 and Defendant Nos.6 to 8 not be changed till the disposal of the application filed under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC.
Learned Counsel for the Plaintiff also states that on 25.05.2019, it was brought to the notice of this Court that steps have been initiated by both sides for quashing of the FIRs, meaning thereby, the Parties were interested in honouring the settlement. Attention of this Court has been drawn to Orders dated 07.12.2022 and 31.01.2023 wherein it was indicated that the Parties to the Suit were interested in implementing the settlement. Learned Counsel for the Plaintiff also states that even if in the Second MoU there are certain persons who are not party to the Suit, the same will be binding on all of them as they are all members of the same family, and this settlement was a one-stop settlement for all Parties since the dispute was between the family members, i.e., brothers, their representatives and the companies held by the brothers and their family members. He states that the Second MoU has been signed by all the interested Parties, and therefore, a decree can be passed in terms of the said MoU.
It is the case of the Plaintiff that the decree can be passed even if the Second MoU is disputed by the parties. It is stated that under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, the Court shall order such an agreement, compromise or satisfaction to be recorded and shall pass a decree in accordance therewith. Hence, once a valid compromise/settlement has been entered into between the parties, this Court can pass a decree even if one party is disputing the said compromise/settlement. Reliance is placed on the Judgment passed by the Apex Court in Pushpa Devi Bhagat v. Rajinder Singh, (2006) 5 SCC 566; judgment passed by the Co-ordinate Bench of the Orissa High Court in Bhaja Govinda Maikap v. Janaki Devi, 1980 SCC OnLine Ori 91, Judgment of the Apex Court in K. Venkata Seshiah v. Kanduru Ramasubbamma, (1991) 3 SCC 338 and the Judgment passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Kohli Housing & Development (P) Ltd. v. Convenience Enterprises (P) Ltd., 2009 SCC OnLine Del 1136.
In response to the contentions raised by Defendants Nos. D2A and D2B, it is submitted that the contention of the Defendants D2A and D2B that Order XXIII Rule 3 of CPC is limited to cases where settlement has been acted upon in praesenti, and not settlements that have obligations to be acted upon in the future, is baseless. It is submitted that in the present case, the settlement or adjustment does not depend upon certain events to happen but rather on enforceable promises to which the parties in the suit will be bound in execution proceedings. The Second MoU itself provides that the parties are entitled to pursue execution proceedings in case obligations under the Second MoU are not complied with.
In further response to the contention of Defendants No. 2A and 2B that the decree cannot be passed as all parties to the Second MoU are not parties to the Suit, it is the case of the Plaintiff that the same is misplaced, as Order XXIII Rule 3 expressly provides that the Court shall pass a decree 'so far as it relates to the parties to the suit, whether or not the subject-matter of the agreement, compromise or satisfaction is the same as the subject-matter of the suit. It is stated that all parties to the Suit are also parties to the Second MoU and a decree can accordingly be passed binding them and this position is reinforced by the fact that the additional parties to the settlement are merely pro forma parties being relatives, associates, shareholders, or related companies of the parties herein.
With respect to the contentions raised by the Defendant no. 1, it is the case of the Plaintiff that the contention of Defendant No.1 that the Application ought to have been filed under Order XXIII Rule 1, CPC for simpliciter withdrawal of the Suit, and not for compromise under Order XXIII Rule 3, CPC is misplaced as Clause 2 of the Second MoU as relied upon by the Defendants, itself refers to recording of statements of the Parties and clause 28 of Second MoU provides that parties shall be entitled to file contempt proceedings/execution proceedings and the same presumes an enforceable decree being passed. In fact, it is stated that it was Defendant No.1 who kept delaying the financial transactions, stating that there is a stay order by the High Court dated 03.12.2019 for any change in shareholding.
It is submitted by the Plaintiff that the submission of Defendants No. D1, 2A and 2B that the delay in performance of the MOU has rendered the conditions unworkable is entirely self-serving. It is stated that, in fact, the record reveals that it was Defendant No.1 who was dragging his feet in the matter of discharging his obligations under the Second MoU \ and at the same time, is conveniently seeking to use the said delay caused by him to defeat the implementation of the settlement.
Submissions of the Defendants No. 1 & Corporate Defendants (M/s IIBS Infonet & Defendant Nos. 6–18)
It is submitted that Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC requires that a suit be genuinely "adjusted" wholly or in part by a lawful agreement. Even assuming the Second MoU constituted a lawful agreement, substantive and deeply contested disputes persist regarding enforceability, reciprocal performance, monetary transfers, property valuations, flat transfers (Sanchar Vihar Flat No. 2503), transfer of NBFC licenses, defective titles, share pricing, and unpaid statutory government dues, passing a compromise decree would not lay the suit to rest or adjust the disputes between the parties, making Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC inapplicable.
It is submitted that a decree in terms of the Second MOU would unlawfully bind non-parties to the suit. It is submitted that Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC empowers the Court to pass a decree so far as it relates to the parties to the suit. The present civil suit comprises only 19 parties, whereas the Second MoU involves 41 individual/HUF signatories and 23 corporate entities (Annexure F & Annexure I). The Court cannot, via a summary compromise decree under Rule 3, create, extinguish, or regulate the legal rights and obligations of 22 non-parties and corporate entities who are not represented before this Court in the suit.
It is submitted that Clause 2 and Clause 5 of the Second MoU specifically provided that upon the quashing/compounding of FIRs, the Plaintiff and parties would withdraw the suit. On 26.08.2019, counsels for the parties specifically submitted before the Court that settlement has been arrived at between the parties and necessary application under Order XXIII Rule 1 of CPC in this regard will be filed within two weeks. Despite this, the Plaintiff violated the specific understanding and directions of the Court by surreptitiously filing an application for a decree under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC, instead of withdrawing the suit under Order XXIII Rule 1 CPC.
An additional submission of Defendant no.1 is that consent to the Second MoU was impacted by duress, including false criminal allegations and misrepresentations regarding title ownership of properties such as Flat No. 2503, Sanchar Vihar, Sector-4 Dwarka (Clause 7(n)). The Plaintiff defaulted on clearing Noida Authority dues of over INR 1.42 crores under Clause 7(i) of the Second MoU and failed to deliver M/s Pinkku Chits Pvt. Ltd. along with its valid NBFC license.
In conclusion, it is stated that the share valuation and net consideration figures were based on immediate execution of the Second MoU. It is stated that over 5 years of delay, asset valuations have multiplied, tax laws were amended removing indexation benefits, and heavy capital gains tax liabilities have arisen. Third-party shareholders who signed the Second MoU in 2019 on the promise of immediate payment are no longer willing to sell their equity at 2019 rates, and their consent can no longer be compelled via a decree in a suit where they are strangers.
Submission of Defendants Nos.2(A) AND 2(B)
It is submitted that Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC requires a concluded adjustment of the suit in praesenti. The Second MoU is an executory, multi-party agreement involving reciprocal, future obligations that remain deeply contested. Under Clauses 7(p) and 7(q) of the Second MoU, the Plaintiff and Defendant No. 1 were obligated to pay INR 5,00,00,000/- or transfer 10% equity shares of Defendant No. 3 ( M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd. ) to Defendant No. 2’s branch. Till date, the Plaintiff and Defendant No. 1 have failed to transfer a single rupee or a single share to Defendant Nos. 2(A) and 2(B). An executory settlement under which one branch has received zero financial consideration or assets cannot be declared a lawful compromise to force a decree against that branch.
It is submitted that Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC explicitly restricts the court’s decree so far as it relates to the parties to the suit. The civil suit comprises only 19 parties, whereas the Second MoU involves 41 individual/HUF signatories/corporate entities (as set out in Schedule-I / Annexure-F), meaning thereby that at least 22 signatories are not parties to the suit.
It is further submitted that the Second MoU required actions by external judicial and statutory authorities (such as quashing criminal FIRs by the High Court or regularising property titles via DDA / Registrar of Cooperative Societies). For example, FIR Nos. 374/2018 and 375/2018 (listed at Serial Nos. XL and XLI of Annexure-G, involving serious offences under the Indian Penal Code, 1860) were not quashed by the High Court despite the Second MoU, and proceeded to full trial, resulting in acquittal only in April 2022. Private parties cannot by compromise, pre-determine or bind the exercise of statutory or judicial powers.
It is submitted that following the untimely demise of Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal) and his wife in 2021, the Plaintiff used the Second MoU to secure benefits for himself (such as case quashings and property clearances) while abandoning the financial commitments owed to Defendant No. 2’s young surviving sons. Binding Defendant Nos. 2(A) and 2(B) to the Second MoU under which they received zero financial assets or property handovers would cause severe financial hardship and create acrimony between the brothers.
Heard the counsels for the parties and pursued the material on record.
In light of the submissions made before this Court, the sole question that arises for consideration before this Court is whether the Second MOU, by its very nature, is decreeable by this Court under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC.
It is without doubt that under the Second MoU, there were numerous obligations that were required to be fulfilled by the parties. A comprehensive chart detailing some of the important obligations of the parties towards each other is reproduced hereunder:
OBLIGATIONS OF THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
S.No OBLIGATION TOWARDS OBLIGATION REMARK 2 Obligations Towards Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal / Legal Heirs D-2A & D-2B) Direct Payment of INR 5 Crores or Transfer of 10% Equity Shares: On account of Defendant No. 1, the Plaintiff agreed to pay INR 5,00,00,000/- directly to Defendant No. 2 (or his legal heirs, Aman Singhal and Aayush Singhal). Alternatively, once all company transfer formalities are completed, the Plaintiff undertook to transfer 10% equity shares of Defendant No. 3 (M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.) to Defendant No. 2 in lieu of the INR 5 Crore sum (Clause 7(p), Clause 7(q)) Contingent on the Defendant No. 3 being transferred to the Plaintiff. Averred that the same has not been done. 3 Obligations Towards Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) & Defendant No. 5 (Akash Singal) Quashing & Withdrawal of Criminal Complaints/FIRs: The Plaintiff undertook to appear before concerned courts/authorities and record compounding/withdrawal statements for criminal cases and FIRs wherein Defendant No. 4 and Defendant No. 5 were arrayed as co-accused (including FIR No. 689/2017 and FIR No. 476/2018) (Clause 2, Clause 36, Annexure-G) FIR No. 689/2017 Compounded FIR No. 476/2018 Quashed 4 Obligations Towards Corporate Defendants (Defendant Nos. 3 and 6 to 18) Submission of Documents to Custodian Sh. Devender Gupta: Within 30 days of executing the 2nd MoU, the Plaintiff was required to complete all corporate formalities including resignation letters from directorships, share transfer forms, affidavits, minute books, share certificates, and board resolutions and deposit them with trustee/custodian Sh. Devender Gupta (CA) (Clause 6) The Plaintiff stated that the documents were duly handed over to Mr. Gupta (CA / friend of Defendant No. 1) in furtherance of his obligations under Clause 6. Execution of Share Transfers: The Plaintiff, as a shareholder across group entities, agreed to execute share transfer deeds for designated companies as specified in Annexure-I (Clause 30, Clause 31) Averred that the Plaintiff has also provided the necessary documentation to Mr. Davinder Gupta, who is otherwise the acquaintance of Defendant No.1. OBLIGATIONS OF THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
S.No OBLIGATION TOWARDS OBLIGATION REMARK Resignation from Directorships & Bank/ROC Notifications: The Plaintiff agreed to resign from directorships in companies being handed over to Defendant No. 1's group (such as Defendant No. 6, M/s Metro Infosolutions Pvt. Ltd.) and notify the Registrar of Companies (ROC), statutory authorities, and banks regarding changes in management (Clause 6, Clause 32) Only averred that all documents pertaining to transactions related to companies have been handed over to Mr. Davinder Gupta, who is otherwise the acquaintance of Defendant No.1 Prohibition Against Share Dilution: The Plaintiff agreed not to dilute shareholdings or alter board compositions in group entities until all settlement transactions were completed (Clause 37) 5 Other Obligations Withdrawal / Disposal of Civil Suit CS(OS) No. 555/2017: The Plaintiff explicitly undertook to make appropriate joint statements before the High Court of Delhi or the Mediation Centre for the withdrawal, termination, or disposal of CS(OS) No. 555/2017 in terms of the settlement (Clause 5) Pending before this Court Closure of NCLT & Section 138 NI Act Cases: Subsequent to FIR quashing, the Plaintiff agreed to withdraw all pending NCLT matters, civil complaints, and Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act cases detailed in Annexure-G within 15 days (Clause 3) Elaborated in the last chart Prohibition Against Backing Out & Future Litigations: The Plaintiff agreed that the 2nd MoU is irrevocable, binding, and cannot be backed out of on any ground whatsoever (Clause 23, Clause 35), and undertook not to initiate any fresh civil or criminal proceedings against the Defendants regarding settled family businesses (Clause 27) OBLIGATIONS OF DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
S.No OBLIGATION OF OBLIGATION REMARK (If any) 1 Defendant no. 1 Transfer of Equity Shares & Control of Defendant No. 3 (M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.): Defendant No. 1 is obligated to transfer the complete equity shareholding and management control of Defendant No. 3 (M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd.)—which owns 7,000 sq. meters of commercial land at Plot B-18, Sector-62, Noida, U.P. to the Plaintiff or his nominees (Clause 7(b) & Annexure-I (Clause 3)) Averred that the High Court passed an interim status quo order (at the Plaintiff's behest) restraining any change in the shareholding patterns of Defendant Nos. 3 and 6 to 18. Defendant No. 1 states that third parties consented in 2019 on the assurance of immediate payment and are no longer willing to sell their shares at the 2019 agreed rate after years of delay. Handing Over Corporate Records & Books of Accounts: Defendant No. 1 must hand over all original title deeds, corporate records, minute books, financial statements, and books of accounts of Defendant No. 3 Company to the Plaintiff. Clause 7(o) OBLIGATIONS OF DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
S.No OBLIGATION OF OBLIGATION REMARK (If any) Bearing Noida Authority Dues & Financial Liabilities: Annexure-I (IIBS Infonet Notes): Any outstanding dues payable to the Noida Authority for Plot B-18, Sector-62, Noida till 30.09.2016 and any liabilities payable to outsiders as per the Balance Sheet of IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd. (after adjusting bank balances) must be borne by Defendant No. 1 in his personal capacity. Following demand notices issued by the Noida Authority for INR 1,34,10,260/- (as of 31.03.2023) and INR 1,42,84,043/- (as of 30.09.2023), the Plaintiff filed I.A. No. 23227/2023 seeking a court direction to compel Defendant No. 1 to pay these dues. It is the case of the Defendant that post-30.09.2016, dues were to be paid by the Plaintiff as per the MOU Clearing & Closing Corporate Loans: Defendant No. 1 must pay off and close the corporate loan taken from SIDBI Bank Clause 7(i) Defendant No. 1 averred that he has fulfilled his part of the obligation under Clause 7(i) to pay off and close the loan taken from SIDBI Bank by M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd Not corroborated. Handing Over Original Registry Documents & Membership Records: Hand over original allotment letters, possession letters, registry documents, and No Dues Certificates for the 3 flats in M/s Satguru Welfare Organisation (in the names of Smt. Nitu Aggarwal, Sh. Roshan Lal, and Sh. Arun Kumar Singal), as well as original membership documents for M/s Saraswati Kunj Co-Operative Group Housing Society, Gurgaon. Clause 7(f) Handed over by the Defendant to Mr. Gupta. OBLIGATIONS OF DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
S.No OBLIGATION OF OBLIGATION REMARK (If any) Execution of Conveyance / Sale Deeds for Satguru Flats: As President of M/Satguru Welfare Organisation, Defendant No. 1 (along with Defendant No. 5 as Secretary) must execute conveyance/sale deeds for Flat No. 102 (Smt. Shweta Gupta), Flat No. 16 (Smt. Rajrani), and Flat No. 108 (Sh. Akash Mittal) Clause 7(a) Defendant Nos. 1 and 5 state that upon reconciling the bank accounts and records of Satguru Welfare Organisation, it was discovered that the concerned members (Smt. Shweta Gupta, Smt. Rajrani, and Sh. Akash Mittal) had made lesser/incomplete payments towards the total cost of their flats. once these members produce proof of complete installment payments or clear their balance dues, there would be no difficulty in executing and registering the conveyance deeds in their favor. OBLIGATIONS OF DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARK (If any) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quashing of FIRs & Withdrawal of Legal Cases: File petitions, appear before courts, and record statements for quashing/compounding all criminal FIRs filed against the Plaintiff and his family (including FIR No. 330/2018, FIR No. 664/2017, and FIR No. 476/2018). Clauses 1, 2, 36 & Annexure-G Withdraw all Section 138 NI Act cases (e.g., C.C. No. 1434/2017) and NCLT petitions (e.g., Case No. 185/241/ND/2018) instituted against the Plaintiff or his family members within 15 days of FIR quashing. Clauses 3 & Annexure-G | FIR NO. 330/2018 Quashed FIR NO. 664/2017 Quashed FIR NO. 476/2018 Quashed C.C. No. 1434/2017 Not corroborated Case No. 185/241/ND/2018 Dismissed for non prosecution | ||
| 2 | Obligations of Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal / Legal Heirs D-2A & D-2B) | Withdrawal of Cheque Bouncing Complaint: Withdraw Section 138 NI Act complaint C.T. No. 5403/2018 (regarding a bounced INR 5 Crore cheque) pending against Defendant No. 1. Clause 3 & Annexure-G | C.T. No. 5403/2018 Quashed |
| Cooperation in Corporate Transfers & Quashing: Execute share transfer deeds, board resolutions, and quashing affidavits/statements to facilitate the complete transfer of family entities and closure of inter-se litigations. Clauses 2, 6, 30, 31 & 36 |
OBLIGATIONS OF DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE PLAINTIFF UNDER THE 2019 MOU
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARK (If any) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | Obligations of Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) & Defendant No. 5 (Akash Singal) | Withdrawal & Quashing of Criminal Complaints: Defendant No. 5 (Akash Singal), as Secretary of Satguru Welfare Organisation, must withdraw criminal complaint C.T. No. 430/2018 (Satguru Welfare Organisation v. Arun Kumar Singal) before JMM Gurgaon and cooperate in quashing FIR No. 376/2018 (PS Sector-53 Gurugram) Clauses 2, 36 & Annexure-G Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) must withdraw/quash FIR No. 105/2019 (PS KN Katju Marg) filed against the Plaintiff and his family | FIR No. 376/2018 Completed as depicted in the chart filed by the Plaintiff. Not Corroborated FIR No. 105/2019 Quashed |
| Withdrawal of Section 138 NI Act & NCLT Cases: Defendant No. 4 must withdraw Section 138 NI Act complaint C.T. No. 1433/2017 against the Plaintiff, as well as NCLT petition ND/CP/376/2018 regarding M/s Kasauli Developers & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Clauses 3 & Annexure-G | C.T. No. 1433/2017 Not corroborated ND/CP/376/2018 Not corroborated |
MAJOR OBLIGATIONS OF THE DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE DEFENDANTS
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARKS (if any) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Obligations of Defendant No. 1 (Ajay Kumar Singal) towards Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal / LRs Aman & Aayush Singhal) | Regularization of Sanchar Vihar Flat (Clause 7(n)): Defendant No. 1 obligated himself to complete the regularization of Flat No. 2503, Sanchar Vihar C123o-op Group Housing Society Ltd., Sector 4, Dwarka, Delhi from DDA / Registrar of Cooperative Societies (RCS) at his own cost and expense. | - |
MAJOR OBLIGATIONS OF THE DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE DEFENDANTS
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARKS (if any) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Discharge of Mortgaged Properties: Defendant No. 1 was obligated to clear corporate bank loans (e.g. obtaining discharge/release of mortgaged properties) to unencumber assets associated with family members. | - | ||
| Settlement of the INR 5 Crore Debt via Tripartite Restructuring (Clause 7(p) & 7(q)): Under the 2016 arrangement, Defendant No. 1 owed INR 5 Crores to Defendant No. 2. Under Clauses 7(p) and 7(q) of the 2019 MoU, Defendant No. 1 arranged to discharge this liability by directing the Plaintiff to pay INR 5,00,00,000/- directly (or transfer 10% equity shares of Defendant No. 3) to Defendant No. 2 / his legal heirs on Defendant No. 1's account. | - | ||
| 2 | Obligations of Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal / LRs D-2A & D-2B) towards Defendant No. 1, D-4, & D-5 | Withdrawal of INR 5 Crore Cheque Bouncing Case (Clause 3 & Annexure-G): Defendant No. 2 undertook to withdraw Section 138 Negotiable Instruments Act complaint C.C. No. 5403/2018 (Ashok Kumar Singhal v. Ajay Kumar Singhal) pending in Rohini Courts regarding a bounced INR 5 Crore cheque. | C.T. No. 5403/2018 Quashed |
| Cooperation in Regularization Proceedings: Defendant No. 2's legal heirs (Aman & Aayush Singhal) agreed to extend full cooperation and file necessary claims before the RCS to facilitate Defendant No. 1 in regularizing the Dwarka flat. | - | ||
| 3 | Obligations of Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) & Defendant No. 5 (Akash Singal) towards Defendant No. 2 & Other Defendants | Withdrawal of NCLT Petition (Clause 3 & Annexure-G): Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) obligated herself to withdraw oppression and mismanagement petition ND/CP/376/2018 filed before the NCLT regarding Defendant No. 13 (M/s Kasauli Developers & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.) against Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal) and his sons (Aman Singhal and Aayush Singhal) | ND/CP/376/2018 Corroborated |
MAJOR OBLIGATIONS OF THE DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE DEFENDANTS
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARKS (if any) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quashing / Withdrawal of Criminal Proceedings: Defendant No. 5 (Akash Singal) agreed to cooperate in quashing FIR No. 376/2018 (PS Sector-53 Gurugram) filed by him as Secretary of M/s Satguru Welfare Organisation against Aman Singhal (D-2A) and others. Defendant No. 4 (Anuradha Singal) agreed to quash FIR No. 105/2019 (PS KN Katju Marg) registered against Defendant No. 2 (Ashok Kumar Singal) | FIR No. 376/2018 Not Corroborated FIR No. 105/2019 Quashed | ||
| Execution of Property Conveyance Deeds (Clause 7(a)): Defendant No. 1 as President and Defendant No. 5 as Secretary of M/s Satguru Welfare Organisation undertook to execute sale/conveyance deeds for Flat No. 102, Flat No. 16/502, and Flat No. 108 in Satguru Welfare Organisation in favor of designated members. | - | ||
| 4 | Obligations of Corporate Defendants (Defendant Nos. 3 and 6 to 18) towards Individual Defendants | Board Resolutions & Statutory Approvals (Clause 6 & Annexure-F): Through their respective Boards of Directors, the corporate entities were obligated to pass formal board resolutions authorizing the execution of the 2019 MoU, share transfers, and directorship changes. | - |
| Deposit of Records with Custodian Sh. Devender Gupta (Clause 6): The corporate Defendants and their controlling directors were required to deposit minute books, share certificates, transfer deeds, board resolutions, and resignation letters with custodian/trustee Sh. Devender Gupta (CA) within 30 days of signing |
| MAJOR OBLIGATIONS OF THE DEFENDANTS TOWARDS THE DEFENDANTS | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| S.No | OBLIGATION OF | OBLIGATION | REMARKS (if any) |
| Prohibition Against Share Dilution & Board Alteration (Clause 37): Companies (Defendant Nos. 6 to 18) were obligated not to alter shareholding patterns, issue private placement shares, or alter board compositions until the settlement execution was completed. | |||
NCLT Complaints
| Case No. 185/241/ND/2018 | Filed by Ajay Kumar Singal (Defendant No. 1 / Party No. 1) | Filed against: - Sh. Roshan Lal (Party No. 4 / Father of Plaintiff) - Smt. Nitu Aggarwal (Party No. 9 / Wife of Plaintiff) - M/s Pinkku Chits Pvt. Ltd. | Dismissed as Withdrawn Corroborated. |
| Case No. ND/CP/376/2018 | Filed by Smt. Anuradha Singal (Defendant No. 4 / Party No. 5) as Authorized Representative/ Director of M/s Kasauli Developers & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., acting alongside Smt. Shikha Singhal (Party No. 19 / Wife of Sushil Singhal) | Filed against: - Arun Kumar Singal (Plaintiff / Party No. 2) - Ashok Kumar Singal (Defendant No. 2 / Party No. 3) - Sh. Roshan Lal (Party No. 4) - Sh. Aman Singhal (Party No. 8) - Smt. Nitu Aggarwal (Party No. 9) - Sh. Shrey Singal (Party No. 10) - Sh. Aayush Singhal (Party No. 42) - The concerned corporate entities | Dismissed for default. Corroborated. |
The abovementioned charts have been drawn based on pleadings and documents filed by the parties, though not all of them have been corroborated by the documents.
A perusal of the above charts reveal that while certain obligations, mainly with respect to quashing of other legal proceedings have been acted upon by the parties, there are still numerous obligations that the parties have not complied with. Further, the Second MoU contemplates reciprocal obligations relating to, inter alia, the transfer of shares, financial consideration, allocation of assets and implementation of arrangements concerning various corporate entities.
At this juncture, it is pertinent to refer to Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, which is extracted below:
“3.Compromise of suit.—Where it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that a suit has been adjusted wholly or in part by any lawful agreement or compromise [in writing and signed by the parties], or where the defendant satisfied the plaintiff in respect to the whole or any part of the subject-matter of the suit, the Court shall order such agreement, compromise or satisfaction to be recorded, and shall pass a decree in accordance therewith [so far as it relates to the parties to the suit, whether or not the subject-matter of the agreement, compromise or satisfaction is the same as the subject-matter of the suit:]
[Provided that where it is alleged by one party and denied by the other that an adjustment or satisfaction has been arrived at, the Court shall decide the question; but not adjournment shall be granted for the purpose of deciding the question, unless the Court, for reasons to be recorded, thinks fit to grant such adjournment.]
[Explanation.— An agreement or compromise which is void or voidable under the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (9 of 1872), shall not he deemed to be lawful within the meaning of this rule.]
[3A. Bar to suit.—No suit shall lie to set aside a decree on the ground that the compromise on which the decree is based was not lawful.
3B. No agreement or compromise to be entered in a
representative suit without leave of Court.—(1) No
agreement or compromise in a representative suit shall be entered into without the leave of the Court expressly recorded in the proceedings; and any such agreement or compromise entered into without the leave of the Court so recorded shall be void.
(2)Below granting such leave, the Court shall give notice in such manner as it may think fit to such persons is as may appear to it to be interested in the suit.
Explanation.—In this rule, “representative suit” means,—
(a)a suit under Section 91 or Section 92,
(b)a suit under rule 8 of Order I,
(c)a suit in which the manager of an undivided Hindu family sues or is sued as representing the other members of the family,
(d)any other suit in which the decree passed may, by virtue of the provisions of this Code or of any other law for the time being in force, bind any person who is not named as party to the suit.]” (emphasis supplied)
A perusal of the provision above reveals that an important factor that this Court needs to consider while passing a decree in terms of the compromise/ agreement is that the decree can only be passed “so far as it relates to the parties to the suit”.
In the present case, the Second MoU dated 08.07.2019 is not confined to the Plaintiff and the Defendants arrayed in the present suit. On the contrary, the settlement has been executed by 41 signatories and contemplates the performance of various obligations involving family members, shareholders, HUFs and corporate entities, several of whom are not parties to the present proceedings. Thus, the scope of the settlement extends beyond the parties whose rights and obligations this Court is called upon to adjudicate in the present suit. In fact, if this Court were to pass a decree in terms of the Second MOU, it would have a direct bearing on the 22 non party signatories to the Suit, whose rights and obligations under the Second MoU would be directly affected.
A table differentiating between the parties to the Second MOU and the Suit is reproduced hereunder:
| S. No. | Party No. / Entity under 2019 MOU-Cum-Family Settlement | Name | Status in CS(OS) No. 555/2017 |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. INDIVIDUAL / HUF / OTHER SIGNATORIES IDENTIFIED AS PARTY NOS. 1–41 IN THE 2019 MOU | |||
| 1 | Party No. 1 | Sh. Ajay Kumar Singal | Defendant No. 1 |
| 2 | Party No. 2 | Sh. Arun Kumar Singal | Plaintiff |
| 3 | Party No. 3 | Sh. Ashok Kumar Singhal | Defendant No. 2 – since deceased; represented by his LRs |
| 4 | Party No. 4 | Sh. Roshan Lal | Not a party |
| 5 | Party No. 5 | Smt. Anuradha Singal | Defendant No. 4 |
| 6 | Party No. 6 | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 5 |
| 7 | Party No. 7 | Smt. Madhu Singal | Not a party |
| 8 | Party No. 8 | Sh. Aman Singal | Defendant No. 2(i) |
| 9 | Party No. 9 | Smt. Nitu Aggarwal | Not a party |
| 10 | Party No. 10 | Sh. Shrey Singal | Not a party |
| 11 | Party No. 11 | Sh. Shailesh Maurya | Not a party |
| 12 | Party No. 12 | Smt. Meena Sharma | Not a party |
| 13 | Party No. 13 | Sh. Vaibhav Singhal | Not a party |
| 14 | Party No. 14 | Sh. Balu Ram Gupta | Not a party |
| 15 | Party No. 15 | Smt. Shweta Gupta | Not a party |
| 16 | Party No. 16 | Smt. Rajrani Gupta | Not a party |
| 17 | Party No. 17 | Sh. Aakash Mittal | Not a party |
| 18 | Party No. 18 | Mrs. Nirmal Gupta | Not a party |
| 19 | Party No. 19 | Mrs. Shikha Singhal | Not a party |
| 20 | Party No. 20 | Ms. Payal Singhal | Not a party |
| 21 | Party No. 21 | Mrs. Sakshi Vohra Singal | Not a party |
| 22 | Party No. 22 | Mr. B.K. Garg | Not a party |
| 23 | Party No. 23 | Mr. Vijay Maurya | Not a party |
| 24 | Party No. 24 | Mr. Amit Magrya | Not a party |
| 25 | Party No. 25 | Mr. Ankur Goenka | Not a party |
| 26 | Party No. 26 | Ajay Kumar Singal HUF | Not a party |
| 27 | Party No. 27 | Arun Kumar Singal HUF | Not a party |
| 28 | Party No. 28 | Ashok Singhal HUF | Not a party |
| 29 | Party No. 29 | Shailesh Maurya HUF | Not a party |
| 30 | Party No. 30 | M/s Balaji Linkers Pvt. Ltd. | Not a party |
| 31 | Party No. 31 | Mrs. Alka Gupta | Not a party |
| 32 | Party No. 32 | Mr. Ranjeet Kumar | Not a party |
| 33 | Party No. 33 | Mr. Anshul Goyal | Not a party |
| 34 | Party No. 34 | Mr. Amit Goyal | Not a party |
| 35 | Party No. 35 | Mr. Mukesh Kumar | Not a party |
| S. No. | Party No. / Entity under 2019 MOU-Cum-Family Settlement | Name | Status in CS(OS) No. 555/2017 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 36 | Party No. 36 | Mrs. Murti Devi | Not a party |
| 37 | Party No. 37 | Mr. Arjun Sahu | Not a party |
| 38 | Party No. 38 | Mr. Abhishek Bansal | Not a party |
| 39 | Party No. 39 | Mrs. Sushma Rani | Not a party |
| 40 | Party No. 40 | Mr. Tushar Singhal | Not a party |
| 41 | Party No. 41 | Mr. Ayush Singhal | Defendant No. 2(ii) |
| B. COMPANIES FORMING PART OF THE 2019 MOU, AS IDENTIFIED IN ANNEXURE F OF THE MOU VIS-A-VIS THE CS (OS) No. 555/2017 | |||
| S. No. | Company forming part of the 2019 MOU-cum-Family Settlement as per Annexure F | Authorised Representative / Signatory as stated in Annexure F | Status in CS(OS) No. 555/2017 |
| 1 | M/s IIBS Infonet Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Ajay Kumar Singal | Defendant No. 3 |
| 2 | M/s Metro Infosolutions Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 6 |
| 3 | M/s Capital Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 9 |
| 4 | M/s Competent Exim & Infin Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 17 |
| 5 | M/s Dewan Finvest Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 10 |
| 6 | M/s Kasauli Developers & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 13 |
| 7 | M/s Metro Software Solutions Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 14 |
| 8 | M/s Metro Probuild Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 8 |
| 9 | M/s Puneet Mercantile & Credits Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 15 |
| 10 | M/s Pinkku Chits Pvt. Ltd. | Smt. Nitu Aggarwal | Not a party |
| 11 | M/s SPA Hotels Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 7 |
| 12 | M/s Total Properties Pvt. Ltd. | Smt. Nitu Aggarwal | Not a party |
| 13 | M/s Varshney Financial Services Pvt. Ltd. | Smt. Anuradha Singal | Defendant No. 18 |
| 14 | M/s Vikhyat Estates & Infin Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 12 |
| 15 | M/s M.A. Hotels Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Akash Singal | Defendant No. 11 |
| 16 | M/s Digitech IT Systems Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Ajay Kumar Singal | Defendant No. 16 |
| 17 | M/s Adishree Information Technology Pvt. Ltd. | Sh. Arun Kumar Singal | Not a party |
| 18 | M/s Bhuvesh Buildwell Pvt. Ltd. | Smt. Anuradha Singal | Not a party |
The submission of the Plaintiff that the additional signatories are merely pro forma parties does not by itself answer the aforesaid objection. The nature of a party to an agreement must be assessed in the context of the obligations undertaken by that party under the agreement. Where the settlement requires a signatory to transfer shares, receive consideration, convey property, or otherwise perform an obligation affecting their legal rights, such a signatory, in this Court's view, cannot be treated merely as a pro forma as they would have to be heard as to whether the Application under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC can be permitted and whether the reciprocal obligation is capable of being performed at this juncture or not. In fact, the Plaintiff’s reliance upon the language of Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC does not justify the passing of a decree extending to the entirety of the Second MoU without examining the rights and obligations of the non-party signatories.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered view that before proceeding to examine whether a decree can be passed in terms of the Second MoU dated 08.07.2019 under Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC, it is necessary to implead the several signatories to the Second MOU, who are not presently parties to this Suit.
Accordingly, the Plaintiff shall take appropriate steps, in accordance with law, for impleadment of those signatories to the Second MoU who are not presently parties to the suit and whose rights or obligations are directly affected by the settlement, particularly those upon whom obligations relating to the transfer of shares, payment of consideration, transfer of properties or implementation of corporate arrangements have been placed under the MoU. Upon the necessary applications being filed and the question of impleadment being considered in accordance with law, this Court shall proceed to examine whether the Second MoU constitutes a lawful compromise within the meaning of Order XXIII Rule 3 of the CPC and whether a decree can be passed in terms thereof.
The question of decreeability of the Second MoU is, therefore, left open for consideration at the appropriate stage.
Accordingly, the application is dismissed, with liberty to the Plaintiff to file a similar application after taking necessary steps, in accordance with law.
CS(OS) 555/2017 & I.A. 11506/2017, I.A. 12521/2017, I.A. 14873/2017, I.A. 13276/2018, I.A. 2913/2020 , I.A. 8097/2020, I.A. 1363/2021, I.A. 14878/2022, I.A. 23227/2023
List before the Roster Bench on 03.12.2026.
