Results
↑↓
High Courts(2026) 11 DEL CK 3531

Vivek Kumar Gautam Vs State Of NCT Of Delhi

Delhi High Court · 19 Nov 2026 · Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora, J

Open full page

Judgment

76 paragraphs · 3,763 words

MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J:

CRL.REV.P. 1011/2024

1.

The present revision petition has been filed under Section 102 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, [‘JJ Act 2015’] challenging the order dated 27.09.2022 [‘impugned order’] passed by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, North-West District, Rohini Courts, Delhi [‘Magistrate’].

2.

By the impugned order, the date of birth of the accused has been determined as 01.11.2003 by the learned Magistrate. Accordingly, the accused was declared a child in conflict with law [‘CCL’] in proceedings arising out of FIR No. 251/2020 under Sections 188, 323, 341, 379, 506 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 [‘IPC’], registered at Police Station (PS) North Rohini, [‘subject FIR’].

FACTUAL MATRIX

3.

Briefly stated, the facts of the present case are as follows:

3.1.

Petitioner is the complainant in the subject FIR, which was registered in relation to an incident dated 08.05.2020.

3.2.

It is alleged in the complaint that the accused, along with her relatives, obstructed the Petitioner’s way, assaulted him, and took away his gold chain and purse containing cash and documents. The subject FIR was registered on 09.05.2020 for the provisions referred to in paragraph 2 above. Section 506 of the IPC was subsequently added in relation to the alleged threats extended to the Petitioner.

3.3.

The Petitioner was previously engaged to the accused, which broke up.

3.4.

The principle issue challenged by the Petitioner in the present case concerns the conflicting claims regarding the date of birth of the accused, in the documents issued by police and third-parties on the basis of the statement of the accused and her family.

3.5.

It is stated that, in documents pertaining to the accused’s marriage to one Manvir Singh, the accused’s date of birth is recorded by Arya Samaj Mandir, Greater Noida1 as 01.11.1999. Similarly, in the custody warrant dated 17.10.2020 issued by the Duty MM (North-West), Rohini Court the age of the accused is recorded as 20 years, which information is attributed to the accused. Also, in the marriage deed2 dated 11.02.2021, signed between the Petitioner and the accused, the date of birth of the accused is recorded as 01.11.1999.

3.6.

It is stated that after the accused was arrested, she was sent to judicial custody and no plea of juvenility was raised before the Court on 19.10.2020.

3.7.

It is stated that thereafter, the accused approached the Petitioner herein for reconciliation and the parties executed a marriage deed dated 11.02.2021, which recorded her date of birth as 01.11.1999.

3.8.

It is stated that the accused married Sh. Manvir Singh on 08.03.2021; in the said certificate, the date of birth of the accused was recorded as 01.11.1999. The mother of the accused is a witness in this certificate.

3.9.

It is stated that, however, in September, 2021, the accused claimed juvenility before the learned Magistrate based on a school leaving certificate issued by the Government Co-Ed Sr. Sec. School, Dwarka, wherein her date of birth was recorded as 01.11.2003.

3.10.

It is stated that the accused was declared a CCL vide order dated 01.09.2021 passed by the learned Magistrate based on the report of an Investigating Officer [‘I.O.’]. As per the Petitioner, the learned Magistrate failed to hold proper and due enquiry before declaring the accused as a CCL.

3.11.

It is stated that, however, upon a challenge being preferred by the Petitioner, the learned Additional Sessions Judge (‘ASJ’), vide order dated 08.06.2022, set aside the aforesaid order dated 01.09.2021 and remanded the matter to the learned Magistrate, directing that a fresh inquiry be conducted to determine the age of the accused.

3.12.

It is stated that pursuant to the aforesaid remand, the learned Magistrate passed the impugned order dated 27.09.2022, again declaring the accused a CCL, based on the I.O.’s fresh report that accused’s date of birth had been verified from the records of her previous two [2] schools.

3.13.

Aggrieved by the impugned order, the present petition has been filed. The Petitioner contends that without examining the relevant witnesses or duly establishing the authenticity of the school leaving certificates relied upon by the I.O., the learned Magistrate has passed the impugned order.

SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES

4.

Learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the impugned order was passed without conducting a proper inquiry into the conflicting material concerning the age of the accused and without affording the Petitioner an opportunity to lead evidence in support of his contentions.

4.1.

He contended that the inquiry was not conducted in accordance with Section 94 of the JJ Act 2015, or the applicable provisions of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. He submitted that the particulars recorded in the certificate issued by the Govt. Co-Ed Sr. Sec. School, Dwarka, including the date of birth, were required to be verified by examining its author or a person having special knowledge of the relevant school records. In the absence of such evidence, the learned Magistrate erred in relying upon the said certificate as well as the inquiry conducted by the I.O. to determine the age of the accused. Reliance in this regard has been placed on the judgments in Updesh Kumar v. Prithvi Singh3 and State of Punjab v. Mohinder Singh4.

4.2.

It is contended that, in view of the conflicting material regarding the age of the accused and the disputed authenticity of the school records, a proper and fair age inquiry was necessary before declaring the accused a CCL.

4.3.

It is submitted that the learned Magistrate ought to have considered the jurisdiction of the Juvenile Justice Board [‘JJ Board’] in determining the claim of juvenility and the procedure prescribed under Sections 8 and 9 of the JJ Act 2015. It is submitted that in view of the fact that as per Section 8 of the JJ Act, 2015, it is only the JJ Board which has the exclusive jurisdiction to decide the juvenility, the learned Magistrate has erred in deciding so.

4.4.

In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for the Petitioner seeks setting aside of the impugned order dated 27.09.2022 and a fresh age inquiry in accordance with law to determine the actual date of birth of the accused.

5.

Learned counsel further submits that the Petitioner had initially challenged the impugned order before the learned Sessions Court by way of Criminal Revision No. 64/2023. However, the said revision petition was withdrawn on 24.04.2024, with liberty to approach the appropriate forum in view of the jurisdictional issue involved.

6.

In reply, Mr. Naresh Kumar Chahar, learned APP, submitted that Section 94 (2) of the JJ Act, 2015, sets out the order of preference of documents or methods which are required to be followed to determine the age of the accused in question. He stated that, as per Section 94 (2) of the JJ Act, 2015, first preference should be given to the school certificate or the matriculation or equivalent certificate from the concerned examination board for determination of age.

6.1.

He stated that the learned Magistrate conducted the requisite inquiry in accordance with Section 94 of the JJ Act, 2015, and rightly concluded that the accused was a CCL on the date of the alleged incident i.e., 08.05.2020 based on the school records relied upon during the inquiry, which recorded her date of birth as 01.11.2003.

6.2.

He stated that the school leaving certificate and the school records of two (2) schools where the accused was enrolled have also been duly verified by the police authorities, in accordance with the law.

6.3.

He further submitted that the law governing the conduct of criminal trials recognises the primacy of the Public Prosecutor in conducting the prosecution. He states that Section 225 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 [‘Cr.P.C.’] mandates that every trial before a Court of Session shall be conducted by a Public Prosecutor, while Section 301(2) Cr.P.C. stipulates that a pleader instructed by a private person shall act under the directions of the Public Prosecutor and may, with the permission of the Court, submit written arguments after the evidence is closed. Further, he submitted that the proviso to Section 24(8) Cr. P.C. permits the victim to engage an advocate to assist the prosecution with the permission of the Court; however, the expression ‘assist’ cannot be construed as conferring a right to conduct the prosecution independently.

ANALYSIS

7.

This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

8.

The learned Magistrate in its impugned order dated 27.09.2022 has referred to the report of the I.O. of even date. The said report of the I.O. records that, as per S.D.M.C. Primary Girls School, Dwarka, Sector-1, New Delhi and MCD Co. Ed. Pry. School, Manglapuri (Palam), New Delhi, the verified date of birth of the accused is 01.11.2003. The IO’s report was based on the certification issued by the Principal(s) of the said two (2) schools.

9.

The Trial Court record was called for and the IO’s status report dated 27.09.2022 has been perused which bears out the findings of the learned Magistrate in the impugned order.

10.

Learned Magistrate recorded that there was no other evidence filed on record to verify the claim of juvenility. It recorded that the notice served to the complainant i.e., the Petitioner on his last available address was returned back with the remark that the Petitioner does not reside at the given address. In these facts, the learned Magistrate observed that the date of the birth of the accused appears to be 01.11.2003 and since, the incident is dated 08.05.2020, her claim of juvenility was accepted.

11.

Notice in this petition was issued vide order dated 08.08.2024.

12.

During the course of the arguments on 29.09.2026, the learned APP has handed over further documents pertaining to the records of three (3) schools, i.e., MCD Co-ed Primary School, Manglapuri, Palam (also known as MCD Co-Ed Primary School), Nigam Pratibha Vidhalaya, Sector-1, Dwarka (also known as MCD Primary Girls School) and Govt. Co-ed Sr. Secondary School, Sector-6, Dwarka, which further confirm the date of birth of the accused as 01.11.2003.

The same are directed to be taken on record.

13.

This Court has perused the said fresh documents. It appears that during the pendency of this petition, the I.O. issued a fresh notice dated 12.09.2024 to the respective Principals of the said three (3) government schools where the accused was enrolled to produce documents relating to her age proof, etc. In response thereto, the respective Principals of each of the three (3) schools issued a response stating that, as per their record, the date of birth of the accused is 01.11.2003. The documents which formed the basis of the said statement were also enclosed.

14.

The Principal of MCD Co-ed Primary School, Manglapuri, Palam has issued a certificate dated 17.09.2024 which states that, as per their record, the date of birth of the accused is 01.11.2003. A copy of the admission and withdrawal register has also been enclosed, which shows that the accused was admitted on 06.04.2010 and she left the school on 03.05.2011 when she was in Class II. The certificate encloses an affidavit dated 06.04.2010 submitted by the mother of the accused to the effect that the birth date of the accused is 01.11.2003.

15.

The Principal, Nigam Pratibha Vidhalaya (also known as MCD Primary Girls School), Sector-1, Dwarka, has issued a certificate dated 13.09.2024. It states that, as per their record, the date of birth is 01.11.2003. A copy of the admission and withdrawal register has been enclosed, which states that, as per its record, the accused was admitted on 05.07.2011 to Class II-D and she left the school on 25.03.2015, when she was studying in Class V-A. It also encloses the school leaving certificate dated 06.05.2011, issued by M.C. Primary School (Girls), Manglapuri (Palam).

16.

Head of School, Govt. Co-ed Sr. Secondary School, Sector-6, Dwarka, has issued a letter dated 13.09.2024, enclosing the relevant documents pertaining to the accused in its records. It encloses an extract of the admission-withdrawal register, which shows that the accused was admitted on 08th/9th April, 2015 to Class VI-F and her date of birth as 01.11.2003. It encloses the school leaving certificate dated 25.03.2015 issued by Nigam Pratibha Vidhalaya, as available in its records, which records the date of birth as 01.11.2003. It further encloses the admission form, which at serial no. 4 records the date of birth of the accused as 01.11.2003.

17.

The matter was heard at length on 29.09.2026. The said documents collected in the year 2024 were also shown to the learned counsel for the Petitioner. Petitioner was unable to point out any deficiency in the said documents, which may raise any doubt with respect to their authenticity.

18.

The accused’s date of birth has been determined by the learned Magistrate as 01.11.2003 based on the certificate issued by the Principal of two (2) Government schools where the accused was enrolled in April, 2010. The documents furnished by the Principals form the basis of the record maintained by the schools, and the Petitioner has been unable to point out any deficiency in the said certificate.

19.

Section 94 of the JJ Act, 2015, stipulates the order of preference of the documents to be examined while determining the age of the accused, which reads as follows:

“94.

Presumption and determination of age: (1) Where, it is obvious to the Committee or the Board, based on the appearance of the person brought before it under any of the provisions of this Act (other than for the purpose of giving evidence) that the said person is a child, the Committee or the Board shall record such observation stating the age of the child as nearly as may be and proceed with the inquiry under section 14 or section 36, as the case may be, without waiting for further confirmation of the age.

(2)

In case, the Committee or the Board has reasonable grounds for doubt regarding whether the person brought before it is a child or not, the Committee or the Board, as the case may be, shall undertake the process of age determination by seeking evidence by obtaining —

(i)

the date of birth certificate from the school, or the matriculation or equivalent certificate from the concerned examination Board, if available; and in the absence thereof;

(ii)

the birth certificate given by a corporation or a municipal authority or a panchayat;

(iii)

and only in the absence of (i) and (ii) above, age shall be determined by an ossification test or any other latest medical age determination test conducted on the orders of the Committee or the Board:

Provided such age determination test conducted on the order of the Committee or the Board shall be completed within fifteen days from the date of such order.

(3)

The age recorded by the Committee or the Board to be the age of person so brought before it shall, for the purpose of this Act, be deemed to be the true age of that person.”

(Emphasis Supplied)

20.

Section 94(2)(i) of the JJ Act, 2015 accords precedence to the date of birth certificate issued by the school, or the matriculation or equivalent certificate issued by the concerned examination board, for the purpose of determining age. In the present case, the certificates issued by the two schools based on which the learned Magistrate determines the age of the accused, fall within the category of documentary evidence contemplated under the aforesaid provision. The certificates consistently record the accused’s date of birth as 01.11.2003, and there is no discrepancy between the records on this aspect. The corresponding entries in the certificates issued by the two (2) schools thus lend support to the recorded date of birth and are required to be assessed in accordance with the statutory priority accorded to such documents.

21.

The Petitioner has been unable to cast any doubt on the record maintained by the schools. The record which forms the basis is of the years 2010, 2011 and 2015 across different schools which consistently record the accused’s date of birth as 01.11.2003. This record pre-dates the disputes which arose between the Petitioner herein and the accused in the year 2020.

22.

A perusal of the documents submitted by the respective Principals of the three (3) schools show that the primary document, which forms the basis of recording the accused’s date of birth as 01.11.2003 are the (i) affidavit dated 06.04.2010 given by the mother of the accused; and (ii) the affidavit dated 05.04.2011 given by the father of the accused given to the first school i.e., MCD Co-ed Primary School, Manglapuri (Palam) declaring the date of birth as 01.11.2003.

23.

Learned counsel for the Petitioner submitted that the documents which form the basis of the respective Principals of the three (3) schools confirming the date of birth as 01.11.2003 are ante-dated and the record of these schools has been fabricated by the accused and her family members. This claim of the Petitioner is unsubstantiated from the record and is a mere allegation. The reliance placed by the Petitioner on the judgments of Updesh v. Prithvi (supra) and Mohinder Singh (supra) fails to substantiate the challenge. The accused’s date of birth is duly supported by the affidavits of the accused’s mother and father dated 06.04.2010 and 05.04.2011, respectively.

24.

The Petitioner has relied upon the statements made by the accused and her mother before different authorities, i.e., Arya Samaj Mandir, etc., which indicate that the date of birth declared before the said authorities was 01.11.1999.

25.

With respect to the said documents, which are all issued during the period 2020-2021, this Court can only observe that the Petitioner will be entitled to rely upon the said documents while defending himself in the criminal proceedings initiated against him in FIR No. 626/2021. If the contents of the said documents are proved by the Petitioner herein against the accused and her mother, the consequential relief to the Petitioner will be decided by the concerned Court deciding the said criminal proceedings.

26.

Furthermore, this Court is unable to accept the contention that the learned Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to determine the claim of juvenility. Section 9(2) of the JJ Act, 2015 expressly provides:

“2)

In case a person alleged to have committed an offence claims before a court other than a Board, that the person is a child or was a child on the date of commission of the offence, or if the court itself is of the opinion that the person was a child on the date of commission of the offence, the said court shall make an inquiry, take such evidence as may be necessary (but not an affidavit) to determine the age of such person, and shall record a finding on the matter, stating the age of the person as nearly as may be:

Provided that such a claim may be raised before any court and it shall be recognised at any stage, even after final disposal of the case, and such a claim shall be determined in accordance with the provisions contained in this Act and the rules made thereunder even if the person has ceased to be a child on or before the date of commencement of this Act.”

(Emphasis Supplied)

A plain reading of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that a Court other than the Juvenile Justice Board, including a learned Magistrate, is empowered to inquire into a claim of juvenility and record a finding regarding the age of the accused. The exclusive jurisdiction conferred upon the Board under Section 8(1) of the JJ Board Act, 2015 is expressly subject to the other provisions of the Act and does not exclude the inquiry contemplated under Section 9(2) of the JJ Board Act, 2015. Accordingly, the jurisdictional objection is untenable.

27.

The accused’s age has been determined based on the documentary evidence prescribed under Section 94 of the JJ Act, 2015, following the prescribed procedure. The objections raised by the Petitioner do not discredit the school record or disclose any illegality, perversity or material irregularity in the impugned order. Therefore, in view of this Court, no ground for interference in the exercise of revisional jurisdiction under Section 102 of the JJ Act, 2015 is made out.

28.

With respect to the submission of the learned counsel for the Petitioner that the complainant ought to have been granted an opportunity to cross-examine the respective Principal of the three (3) schools or its record keepers, this Court finds no merit in the said submission. As recorded above, the Petitioner has been unable to show a shred of evidence which casts any doubt on the record maintained by the school. In addition, this Court finds merit in the submission of the learned APP that the complainant herein has no vested right to cross-examine the respective Principals or the record keepers. In this case, the prosecution has expressed its satisfaction with the documents supplied by the respective Principals of the three (3) schools and does not seek to challenge the veracity of the documents supplied by them. (Re: Rekha Murarka v. State of West Bengal and Anr.5)

29.

Moreover, this Court finds that the Trial Court gave an opportunity to the Petitioner herein to participate in the proceedings; however, the complainant could not be served at the given address.

30.

This Court has considered the submissions of the Petitioner on merits and finds no ground to interfere in the impugned order.

31.

Accordingly, in view of the aforesaid observations, the present petition is dismissed.

CRL.REV.P. 1016/2024

32.

The present revision petition has been filed under Section 102 of the JJ Act, 2015, [‘JJ Act 2015’], seeking the following relief:

“…

(c)

set aside the impugned judgment dated 08.05.2024 passed by the Hon’ble Court of Ms. Susheel Bala Dagar, Ld. ASJ-01 (POCSO), North-West District, Rohini Court, New Delhi passed in Criminal Appeal bearing CA No. 22/2023 titled as “Vivek Kumar Gautam vs State of NCT of Delhi & Anr.” And set aside order dated 20.12.2022 passed by Ld. Principal Magistrate Mr. Mohit Sharma, JJB-I terminating the proceedings in case FIR No. 251/2020 u/s 188/323/341/379/506/34 IPC PS North Rohini; OR/AND”

33.

Learned counsel for the Petitioner states that in case CRL. REV. P. 1011/2025 is not allowed by this Court then the relief prayed for in this petition does not survive for consideration.

34.

In view of the aforesaid submission, this petition is dismissed.

Footnotes

  1. 1.Annexure P-8, Document at page 54
  2. 2.Annexure P-7, Document at page 51
  3. 3.(2001) 2 SCC 524
  4. 4.(2005) 3 SCC 702
  5. 5.(2020) 2 SCC 474 at paragraphs 11 and 12