Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), Central Railway Office, Pune Vs Dinanath Jadhav & Ors.
Bombay High Court · Aurangabad Bench · 05 Nov 2026 · Ajit B. Kadethankar, J
Judgment
. Heard.
These First Appeals arise out of common judgment and award dated 23.06.2009 passed by learned District Judge-2, Beed in the respective Land Acquisition Reference applications as mentioned below:
| Sr. No. | F.A. No. | L.A.R. No. | Date of Judgment | Court |
| 1 | 1452 of 2010 | 180 of 2003 | 23.06.2009 | District Judge-II, Beed |
| Sr. No. | F.A. No. | L.A.R. No. | Date of Judgment | Court |
| 2 | 1453 of 2010 + X-Obj.104/2022 | 179 of 2003 | 23.06.2009 | District Judge-II, Beed |
| 3 | 1454 of 2010 | 158 of 2006 | 23.06.2009 | District Judge-II, Beed |
| 4 | 1431 of 2010 | 178 of 2003 | 23.06.2009 | District Judge-II, Beed |
| 5 | 1432 of 2010 | 86 of 2006 | 23.06.2009 | District Judge-II, Beed |
All these Land Acquisition References were decided by the Reference Court by a common judgment and award. In all these Appeals, the respective lands were acquired for the purpose of construction of railway station at Beed for the Ahmednagar-Beed-Parali railway line. The details of the land acquisition process are as follows:
Section 4 notification: 02.08.1998
Possession: 07.06.1997
Section 6 notification: 05.12.1998
SLAO Award declaration: 02.08.2001
Receipt of the claim amount under protest: 10.07.2002
Rate granted by SLAO: Rs. 910/- per R.
The acquisition is as per following details:
L.A.R. No.180 of 2003 - 1 H 82 R from Survey No.18/2
L.A.R. No.179 of 2003 - 7 R from Survey No.18/5
L.A.R. No.158 of 2006 – 1 R from Survey No.104/3 and 40R from Survey No.18/4.
L.A.R. No.178 of 2003 - 5R from Survey No.18/3
L.A.R. No.86 of 2006 - 19 R from Survey No.18/7+103/3
After assessing the evidence on record, at paragraph number 24 of the common judgment and award, the Reference Court held that approximate market value of the subject matter lands at the rate of Rs.11,069/- per R. Further, deducting one-third portion towards development of lands of which area was larger than 41R, the Reference Court held that the compensation in the Land Acquisition Reference Nos.158 of 2006 and 180 of 2003 would be Rs.7379/- per R. To clarify, for other Land Acquisition References i.e. Land Acquisition Reference Nos.178 of 2003, 179 of 2003 and 86 of 2006, deduction was not applied, thereby holding the said land owners/ claimants entitled for compensation at the rate of rupees 11,069/- per R.
It is on this backdrop, present First Appeals are filed by the Acquiring Body on the premise that the Reference Court granted compensation to the claimants in Land Acquisition Reference Nos.158 of 2006 and 180 of 2003 at the rate of Rs.11,069/- per R, despite having held that deduction was to be applied.
It is further submitted that since the Reference Court granted excess award even at Rs.11,069/- per R, the same is under challenge on account of wrongful appreciation of evidence.
During the course of hearing, it is also argued by Mr. D. V. Soman, learned Advocate for the Acquiring Body that at least the judgment and award to the extent of Land Acquisition Reference Nos.158 of 2006 and 180 of 2003 be modified to compensation at the rate of Rs.7379/- per R.
In Cross Objection filed by the claimants in Land Acquisition Reference No.179 of 2003, it is contended that the Reference Court did not consider the sale instances produced on record and relied by the claimants. It is further contention that the map produced by the claimants which shows the close proximity with the acquired lands is also not considered by the Acquiring Body. Thus, it is contended that although the area under acquisition was a smaller one, still the Reference Court ought to have granted compensation at enhanced rate.
I have heard both the learned Advocates extensively. These First Appeals are placed before this Court for final hearing. Considering the short controversy, the matters are heard for final disposal. So far as the objection of Acquiring Body as regards to the valuation of subject matter properties at Rs.11,069/- is concerned, I have keenly gone through the findings recorded by the Reference Court, particularly from paragraph Nos.14 to 23 of the judgment. I find that the Reference Court has rightly discussed on the sale instances produced on record by both the sides.
Although the Reference Court has not quoted Exhibit numbers of the sale instances, with the able assistance of the learned Advocates for both the sides, I have gone through the Record and Proceedings. At the conclusion, I do not find any error in the findings recorded by the Reference Court for fixing the rate at Rs.11,069/- per R. Thus, the first objection raised by the Acquiring Body is not found to be convincing to modify the impugned judgment and award.
However, so far as the findings recorded by the Reference Court at paragraph number 24 is concerned, whereby the Reference Court deducted the compensation towards development costs and granted compensation at the rate of Rs.7,379/- per R, I find that the Reference Court erringly granted the compensation in Land Acquisition Reference Nos. 158 of 2006 and 180 of 2003 at Rs.11,069/-per R. This could be by way of typographical mistake or the Reference Court might have overlooked its own findings at paragraph no.24. To the extent of this, Land Acquisition Reference Nos. 158 of 2006 and 180 of 2003 needs to be modified.
So far as the other Appeals, arising out of Land Acquisition Reference Nos. 178 of 2003, 179 of 2003 and 86 of 2006 are concerned, the Reference Court granted compensation in the light of the discussion made at paragraph Nos.14 to 23. There is no error of any type in these cases.
So far as argument in Cross Objection is concerned, the Reference Court at paragraph No.17 has observed thus:
17] Area and location of acquired land from S.No.18/7, 18/3, 18/5 and 103 found very small comparing to the area and location of the land from S.No.18/2, 18/4. This Court is of the view that though acquisition was for the Railway Station at Beed for Parli-Beed-Ahmednagar Railway Track but land from S. No.18, 103 and 104 found in non agricultural site and it was not applicable for the land from survey numbers in sale instances. Even at the time of acquisition the land was under cultivation at it’s holder i.e. claimant however the lands from S. No.18, 103 and 104 had no cultivations even before it’s acquisition. This was happened because of surrounding localities and sites. All most all lands at and around S. No.18, 103 and 104 were not in agricultural cultivation but holders of the land were intending for it’s development. In the given circumstances one has to consider true aspects fro value of the land acquired from S. No.18, 103 and 104 if the lands are surrounded by non agricultural site the Court my consider such land’s potentiality different than the lands which were still in cultivation at the date of acquisition proceeding. I would differ the market value of these lands on this Principle.
The map on which the petitioner in the Cross Objection relies, cannot be considered from the viewpoint of its authenticity. Even otherwise as I have recorded above, relying on the only applicable sale instances and applying the principle of highest consideration, the Reference Court from paragraph numbers 14 to 23 has rightly granted compensation at the rate of Rs.11,069/- per R.
It is submitted that the land to which the claimant/petitioners in Cross Objection seek enhancement of compensation substantially are different from the quality/status of the acquired lands.
In view of above reasoning, I find that the First Appeal Nos.1452 of 2010 and 1454 of 2010 arising out of Land Acquisition Reference Nos.180 of 2003 and 158 of 2006 deserves to be partly allowed. The First Appeal Nos.1453 of 2010, 1431 of 2010 and 1432 of 2010 arising out of Land Acquisition Reference Nos.179 of 2003, 178 of 2003 and 86 of 2006 are liable to be dismissed. Cross Objection No.104 of 2022 is also liable to be rejected. However, the law laid down by the full bench judgment of this Court in the case of State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailash Shiva Rangari, 2016(3) Mh.L.J. 457 needs to be applied so far as interest part is concerned. Hence, I pass following order:
ORDER
a. First Appeal Nos.1452 of 2010 and 1454 of 2010 are partly allowed.
b. The claimants/respondents in First Appeal Nos.1452 of 2010 and 1454 of 2010 are held entitled for compensation at the rate of Rs.7,379/- per R. To that extent, the judgment and award be modified.
c. First Appeal Nos.1453 of 2010, 1431 of 2010 and 1432 of 2010 stand dismissed.
d. Cross Objection No.104 of 2022 stands rejected.
e. The respondents in all the First Appeals are permitted to withdraw the amount together with accrued interest deposited by the Acquiring Body in this Court/Reference Court without making any separate Civil Application.
f. The registry of this Court/Reference Court shall disburse the amount to the claimants by calculating the interest in the light of Full Bench judgment in Kailash Shiva Rangari (supra).
g. If any amount is found excess deposited by the Acquiring Body, is permitted to be withdrawn by it.
h. Award be drawn up accordingly.
Pending Civil Application if any, stands disposed of.
