AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Nevaskar, J.—Accused Yusuf was prosecuted for an offence u/s 307 Indian Penal Code in respect of three different acts of causing injury to Abdul Qayum, Abdul Gani and Shabir and was sentenced to 4, 3 and 2 years rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs, 10/- in each of the offences respectively by Additional District Magistrate Ujjain. The sentences of imprisonment were ordered to run consecutively. On appeal the learned Sessions Judge confirmed the findings of the Trial Court but ordered the sentences of rigorous imprisonment to run concurrently, This is a revision-petition filed on behalf of the accused.
The only point seriously pressed on behalf of the applicant is that the treat of the accused for causing injury to three different accused at different times and places is illegal and the conviction based as a result thereof are illegal.
Facts alleged by the prosecution are as follows. On 28-1-1955 the accused caused injury to Shabir with a "Rapa" while he was passing along the street in the town of Baranagar. He caused injury with the same weapon to Abdul Gani earlier when the latter was sitting at his shop and prior to that he caused injury to Abdul Qayum while the latter was engaged in felling water on a tap by the same weapon from behind. All these acts were said to have been performed between 10 and 12 and the injuries caused we such that they could be said to have been caused with the intention of causing death of each of these person. The learned Magistrate held a joint trial in this case on the ground that these three acts took place in a chain and practically at short interval. Presumably the learned Magistrate had Section 235 Criminal Procedure Code in mind.
The question to be considered is whether the three acts of the accused are so connected as to indicate continuity of action and purpose and may for that purpose be said to form part of the same transaction.
It is alleged by the prosecution that the accused had a quarrel with Anavar brother of the complainant Abdul Gani and Shabir and a distant cousin of complainant, Abdul Qayum. The reason for this quarrel was that the accused invited Anavar to wrestle with him. The latter refused saying that his bands and feet were "not without utility". Thereupon the accused abused Anavar and he abused in exchange. Since then the accused nursed a grievance. On the date of the incident he attacked the three complainants one after the other causing them injuries with a "Rapa". The accused was jointly tried for these three acts at one trial. The Court below held the trial good.
Mr. Harbansingh who appeared for the accused again pressed the illegality of the trial. According to the learned counsel the assaults upon Abdul Qayum, Abdul Gani and Shabir were three distinct acts each constituting a separate offence and there should have been a separate trial.
On the other hand it was contended by the learned Government Advocate that these acts are part of one transaction and for that reason they should be deemed to have been committed in the course of the same transaction,
The prosecution evidence consisting of the statements of the three complainants P.W. 5 Abdul Shakur and P.W. 6 Abdul Gaffar and others indicated that there had been quarrel between the accused and Anavar brother of Shabir and Abdul Gani and he struck the complainants because of this Ill-will.
The accused himself in his statement admits the existence of ill-will. He gives the cause to be that these people prevent him from wrestling on the wrestling ground (Akhada).
It also appears from the statement of Abdul Gaffar that the accused attacked these three complainants one after the other. He injured one and proceeded further to injure the second and then the third. In view of the common motive, unity of purpose and continuity of action it will have to be said that the three acts were committed in the course of same transaction. Identity or proximity of time and place is not necessary where there is continuity of action and unity of purpose as held in AIR 1935 Nag 149, R.S. Ruikar Vs. Emperor.
In this view of the matter the trial cannot be held to be illegal particularly where no prejudice is shown to have been caused. No argument was addressed upon merits.
The petition therefore has no force. It is therefore dismissed.
