High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 5208

Western Coalfields Ltd. vs Shri Anil Kumar

Bombay High Court, Nagpur Bench · Decided on 21 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
Pravin S. Patil, J
RESULT
Allowed
CASE NUMBER
WRIT PETITION NO.4821 OF 2011

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

55 paragraphs · 4,355 words
1.

Heard learned counsels for the respective parties.

2.

The petitioner herein assailed the award dated 11.05.2011 passed by learned Presiding Officer CGIT-cum-Labour Court, Nagpur in Case No.CGIT/NGP/61/2002, whereby, directions were issued to provide employment to the respondent on compassionate ground within a period of one month from the date of publication of award in Official Gazette.

3.

It is pointed out by the petitioner that this Court, on 13.03.2012 issued Rule in the present matter and further granted stay to the impugned award during the pendency of the present petition. In the light of this fact, I have perused the record as well as the submissions of both the parties and the case laws which are relied upon by both the parties in the present matter.

4.

In the present case, it is undisputed fact that the father of the respondent was an employee of petitioner-Western Coalfields Limited and was working as a General Mazdoor. He was expired on 12.12.1982. Prior to his death, respondent’s mother was already expired on 04.03.1980. The respondent was a minor at the time of his fathers’s death and attained the age of majority on 20.07.1993.

5.

It is the submission of the respondent that deceased employee-Ramadhar, was governed by the rules and regulations implemented and enforced from time to time. The National Coal Wage Agreement (for short “NCWA”), is a settlement arrived by and between the Management and its representatives of various registered and affiliated trade unions.

6.

After attaining the age of majority, the respondent, approached to the learned Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central), near about after 7 years i.e. in the year 2000, thereby, raising a dispute for failure of petitioner in not providing employment to him on compassionate ground. The said conciliation proceeding being failed, the matter was referred to the learned Central Government Industrial Tribunal (for short “CGIT”) by the Central Government Reference dated 07.05.2002 by referring the issue as under :

“Whether the action of Sub Area Manager, Ballarpur Colliery 3 & 4 Pits Ballarpur, Distt. Chandrapur, in not providing employment to Shri. Anil Kumar, dependent of late Shri. Ramadhar as per Section 10.4.2 of NCWA- 2 is legal and justified? If not, to what relief Shri. Anil Kumar is entitled to?”

7.

The respondent in pursuance of the said reference has filed his Statement of Claim before the learned CGIT and stated that as per the relevant provision i.e. 10.4.2 of NCWA-II, defines the word “dependent”. According to him, his father died during the course of his employment. Therefore, there being no other member in his family, after attaining the age of majority, he has applied for appointment on compassionate ground. Hence, he is entitled for the appointment as per the said agreement.

8.

He also stated that he had repeatedly approached to the petitioner to grant him appointment as per the provisions of 10.4.2 of NCWA-(II), (III), (IV) and (V). However, the same was never considered seriously by the petitioner and thereby, the petitioner prolonged the issue for one or other reason. On 10.06.1996, the petitioner had informed the respondent that he cannot be given employment. Thereafter, he has taken up the matter in the petitioner’s Head Office at Nagpur. At the Head Office, the issue was again came up for discussion before the General Manager (IR) and it was agreed to send the proposal of respondent’s appointment on compassionate ground for reconsideration. However, the Director (Personal) in the discussions held on 10.12.1999 and 18.12.1999, agreed to re-examine the case. But, all his efforts were failed. Thereafter, through the Union, he made further attempt to get the appointment. As those all efforts were failed, therefore, he approached to the learned Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central) and raised a dispute of not providing the employment to him on compassionate ground.

9.

The present petitioner before the CGIT has raised preliminary issue that dispute raised by respondent through Union is not tenable because the Union has no locus-standi to raise such a dispute. It is further alleged that the dispute was raised for the first time before the learned Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central), Chandrapur, on 03.03.2000, i.e. after a lapse of 18 years. Hence, the reference is extremely belated and, therefore, the same cannot be entertained in the light of the law laid down by this Court as well as the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.

10.

The submission of the petitioners before the learned Tribunal was that compassionate appointment cannot be claimed as a matter of right as per the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. According to them, such an appointment can be given only on humanitarian grounds, with the sole object of providing an immediate relief to the family of deceased employee to tide over the sudden financial crisis and cannot be claimed as a matter of right. It is further stated that while appointing such person, it is required to examine the financial condition of the family of the deceased employee and only if it is satisfied that family is not able to meet the crisis, then employment can be offered to the eligible member of the family. In the present case, the respondent has claimed the appointment on compassionate ground after more than 18 years and hence, the same cannot be granted.

11.

It is further a specific submission of the petitioner before the learned Tribunal that at the relevant time i.e. at the time of death of the respondent’s father, the provisions of NCWA, does not provide the live roster for a minor. The said provisions were brought into effect after the death of the deceased employee. Therefore, at the relevant time as this provision was not available, the respondent cannot claim any right over the post on the basis of the NCWA, more particularly, under the Clause 10.4.2 thereof.

12.

In the light of the submissions of both the parties, the learned CGIT, by the impugned judgment and award has decided complaint and thereby, directed the petitioner to provide employment to the respondent on compassionate ground as per Clause 10.4.2 of NCWA-II.

13.

In the light of the submissions of the parties, it would be relevant to first consider the settled legal position of law of compassionate appointment. It would be relevant to refer the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh and Others Vs. Ashish Awasthi reported in (2022) 2 Supreme Court cases 157. In the said case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has specifically observed that any policy or the appointment on compassionate ground cannot be made applicable retrospectively. It is held that policy prevalent at the time of death of the deceased employee only is required to be considered and not a subsequent policy. It would be relevant to refer paragraph No.5 of the said judgment, which reads as under:

“5.

As per the settled proposition of law laid down by this Court for appointment on compassionate ground, the policy prevalent at the time of death of the deceased employee only is required to be considered and not the subsequent policy.”

14.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held in the case of Sanjay Kumar Vs. State of Bihar and Others reported in (2000) 7 Supreme Court Cases 192, wherein, it is held that compassionate appointment is intended to enable the family of the deceased employee to tide over sudden crisis resulting due to death of the breadearner, who had left the family in penury and without any means of livelihood. It has also held that there cannot be a reservation of a vacancy if the petitioner was a minor until he attains the age of majority after a number of years. In this regard, the specific observation made in para 3 is relevant in the present matter, which reads as under :-

“3.

We are unable to agree with the submissions of the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner. This Court has held in a number of cases that compassionate appointment is intended to enable the family of the deceased employee to tide over sudden crisis resulting due to death of the breadearner who had left the family in penury and without any means of livelihood. In fact such a view has been expressed in the very decision cited by the petitioner in Director of Education v. Pushpendra Kumar. It is also significant to notice that on the date when the first application was made by the petitioner on 2-6-1988, the petitioner was a minor and was not eligible for appointment. This is conceded by the petitioner. There cannot be reservation of a vacancy till such time as the petitioner becomes a major after a number of years, unless there are some specific provisions. The very basis of compassionate appointment is to see that the family gets immediate relief.”

15.

Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of J&K and Others Vs. Sajid Ahmed Mir reported in (2006) 5 Supreme Court Cases 766, has held that once it is proved that in spite of the death of the breadwinner, the family survived and a substantial period is over, there is no need to make appointment on compassionate ground at the cost of interests of several other eligible persons, thereby, ignoring the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The relevant observations made by Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 11 are as under:-

“11.

We may also observe that when the Division Bench of the High Court was considering the case of the applicant holding that he had sought "compassion", the Bench ought to have considered the larger issue as well and it is that such an appointment is an exception to the general rule. Normally, an employment in the Government or other public sectors should be open to all eligible candidates who can come forward to apply and compete with each other. It is in consonance with Article 14 of the Constitution. On the basis of competitive merits, an appointment should be made to public office. This general rule should not be departed from except where compelling circumstances demand, such as, death of the sole breadwinner and likelihood of the family suffering because of the setback. Once it is proved that in spite of the death of the breadwinner, the family survived and substantial period is over, there is no necessity to say “goodbye” to the normal rule of appointment and to show favour to one at the cost of the interests of several others ignoring the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution”

16.

It is further pertinent to note that recently the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of State of West Bengal Vs. Debabrata Tiwari and Others reported in (2025) 5 Supreme Court Cases 712 has held that compassionate appointment not being a vested right but relative to financial condition and hardship faced by family of deceased. A claim for compassionate appointment may not be entertained after considerable period of time. Accordingly, the Hon'ble Supreme Court observed in para 32 to 32.5 as under:-

“32.

On consideration of the aforesaid decisions of this Court, the following principles emerge:

32.1.

That a provision for compassionate appointment makes a departure from the general provisions providing for appointment to a post by following a particular procedure of recruitment. Since such a provision enables appointment being made without following the said procedure, it is in the nature of an exception to the general provisions and must be resorted to only in order to achieve the stated objectives i.e. to enable the family of the deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.

32.2.

Appointment on compassionate grounds is not a source of recruitment. The reason for making such a benevolent scheme by the State or the public sector undertaking is to see that the dependants of the deceased are not deprived of the means of livelihood. It only enables the family of the deceased to get over the sudden financial crisis.

32.3.

Compassionate appointment is not a vested right which can be exercised at any time in future. Compassionate employment cannot be claimed or offered after a lapse of time and after the crisis is over.

32.4.

That compassionate appointment should be provided immediately to redeem the family in distress. It is improper to keep such a case pending for years.

32.5.

In determining as to whether the family is in financial crisis, all relevant aspects must be borne in mind including the income of the family, its liabilities, the terminal benefits if any, received by the family, the age, dependency and marital status of its members, together with the income from any other source.”

17.

In the light of this legal position, the submission of the petitioner before this Court that in the peculiar facts of the present case, wherein, admittedly, the father of the respondent was expired on 12.12.1982, at the relevant time, respondent was minor and he has attained the age of majority in the year 1993 and applied for the post in the year 2000 i.e. nearly about 18 years after the death of the father. Such application is contrary to the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India and therefore, the petitioner has rightly rejected his application.

18.

The learned counsel for the respondent however, stated that there was a policy in terms of 10.4.1 of NCWA-II, wherein, it was agreed that employment to one of the dependent of the worker who dies while in service will be granted. Therefore, according to this settlement, the respondent was entitled for the employment. In support of this submission, respondent has heavily relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Mohan Mahto Vs. M/s. Central Coal Fields Ltd. and Others reported in 2007 (115) FLR 427 wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held that in terms of the settlement, if a person applied for appointment on compassionate ground, an application of such employee cannot be turned down on the ground that he was a minor. It was held that the application moved after attaining the majority, should be considered and the limitation mentioned in the circular therein was not statutory and was not a part of original settlement. Hence, directed to issue the appointment order. The relevant observation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in para 10 of the judgment are as under:-

“10.

A settlement within the meaning of Sub-section (3) of Section 18 of the Industrial Disputes Act is binding on both the parties and continues to remain in force unless the same is altered, modified or substituted by another settlement. No period of limitation was provided in the settlement. We would assume that the respondent had jurisdiction to issue such circular prescribing a period of limitation for filing application for grant of appointment on compassionate ground. But, such circular was not only required to be strictly complied with but also was required to be read keeping in view the settlement entered into by and between the parties. The expanding definition of workman as contained in Section 2(s) of the Industrial Disputes Act would confer a right upon the appellant to obtain appointment on compassionate ground, subject, of course, to compliance of the conditions precedent contained therein.”

19.

The respondent has further relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Subhadra Vs. Ministry of Coal and Another reported in (2018) 11 Supreme Court Cases 201 wherein, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that though the grant of compassionate appointment is not a matter of right and discretion is available to the employer, if such discretion is not properly exercised then, in such cases, the applicant may be entitled for compensation. The respondent then relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Raspelli Bhagya Kishaiya and Others Vs. General Manager, Western Coalfields Limited and Others in Civil Appeal arising out of SLP (C) No.7244 of 2026 decided on 12.08.2026, to submit that once the authorities have considered his entitlement and after doing the police verification and other exercise, rejection of the claim is illegal. Relying upon the clause 9.3.4 of NCWA, it is held that the employee was entitled for employment. The respondent has placed reliance upon para 17 of the said judgment, which reads as under :-

“17.

In the present case, it is important to note that certain facts are undisputed. Clause 9.3.4 of the NCWA provides that a dependent seeking compassionate appointment should not be more than 35 years of age. The deceased employee died on 17.12.2020. On that date, appellant No. 2 was below 35 years of age. On 03.01.2021, appellant No. 1 (widow) approached the authorities regarding the post-death service benefits and on 04.01.2021, the respondent-authorities themselves directed appellant No. 2 to undergo police verification. Appellant No. 2 completed 35 years of age on 05.02.2021 and police verification and document verification were completed on 11.02.2021 and 25.02.2021 respectively. Thereafter, appellant No. 2 submitted the prescribed pro forma application on 28.05.2021 and the respondent-authorities acknowledged the receipt of the formal application on 14.06.2021 as the relevant date. However, the claim was rejected only on 03.02.2023 on the ground that appellant No. 2 had crossed the age of 35 years.”

20.

The respondent has also relied upon further case laws of this Court as well as the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in support of the submission that an employee like petitioner in terms of the agreement is entitled for the appointment on compassionate ground.

21.

After considering the legal position, I am of the opinion that the judgment delivered by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Ashish Awasti (supra) is more important and is relevant in the present matter. In the said judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court has made it clear that the policy prevalent at the time of death of the deceased employee, is only required to be considered and not a subsequent policy. Therefore, it would be relevant to consider what was the policy at the relevant time in the present matter.

22.

Admittedly, at the time of death of respondents’ father, the National Coal Wage Agreement-II was in existence. Clause 10.4.2 of the said Agreement, reads as under:-

“10.4.2

Employment of one dependant of the worker who dies while in service:

i)

The dependant for this purpose means the wife/husband as the case may be, unmarried daughter, son and legally adopted son. If no such direct dependant is available for employment, younger/widowed daughter/widowed daughter-in-law or son-in-law residing with the deceased and almost wholly dependant on the earnings of the deceased may be considered to be the dependant of the deceased.

ii) The dependant to be considered for employment should be physically fit and suitable for employment and aged not more than 35 years provided that the age limit shall not apply in the case of spouse.”

23.

A perusal of the aforesaid provision states that employment of one dependent of a worker should be granted and dependent has been defined as “wife, husband, unmarried daughter, son and legally adopted son”. As such, persons who are dependent on the earning of the deceased can be considered for employment, subject to the condition that such person should be physically fit and suitable for employment and not having age more than 35 years.

24.

In the said clause, no provision has been made that if the defendant is minor, as like in the present case, then, after attaining the age of majority, he can move an application or same can be considered by the respondent. So also, no policy at the relevant time was framed by the petitioner to maintain the live roaster to consider the claim of minor dependent, at the relevant time.

25.

The petitioner has pointed out that the policy was subsequently amended and Clause 9.5.0 in NCWA-V was introduced and was in effect from the period 1991 to 1996, whereby, it was made clear, if the dependent of a deceased is aged about 15 years or above, then his claim will be kept on live roaster and would be provided employment commensurate with his skills and qualifications when he attains the age of 18 years.

26.

The said policy was further amended by Clause 9.5.0 of NCWA-VI, wherein, the age of dependent of deceased was considered as 12 years and declared that he will be kept on live roaster, till, he attains the age of 18 years. Both these clause are reproduced in the writ petition are relevant and same are reproduced as under :-

“Clause No.9.5.0 (NCWA V)

iii) In case of death either in mine accident or for other reasons or medical unfitness under clause 9.4.0, if no employment has been offered and the male dependant of the concerned worker is 15 vears and above in age, he will be kept on live roaster and would be provided employment commensurate with his skill and quatifications when he attains the age of 18 years. During the period the male dependant is on live roaster, the female dependant will be paid monetary compensation as per rates at paras (i) & (ii) above.

Clause No.9.5.0.: (NCWA VI) iii) In case of death either in mine accident or for other reasons or medical unfitness under clause 9.4.0, if no employment has been offered and the male dependant of the concerned worker is 12 years and above in age, he will be kept on live roaster and would be provided employment commensurate with his skill and qualifications when he attains the age of 18 years. During the period the male dependant is on live roaster, the female dependant will be paid, monetary compensation as per rates at paras (i) & (ii) above. This will be effective from 1.1.2000. A bare perusal of the aforesaid clauses show that there is no agreement to provide employment to a minor who was 7 years of age at the time of death of the employee after attaining majority.”

27.

Taking into consideration the aforesaid agreement, it is clear that at the time of death of the respondent’s father, this amended agreement were not in existence. Therefore, respondent cannot be said to be eligible as per the policy which was prevailing at the death of his father. The policy of maintaining the live roaster was came into operation from year 1991 onwards. Therefore, prima-facie on this ground in the light of the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the respondent’s claim cannot be considered in the present matter.

28.

In the present matter, the whole claim of the respondent employee depends upon the clause 10.4.2 of NCWA-II, whereby, it is stated that the employment of one dependent of a worker who dies while in service, shall be provided. However, this phrase which is used in this clause needs consideration in the light of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India.

29.

The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, time and again has consistently held that compassionate appointment is not an alternative to the normal course of appointment and there is no inherent right to seek compassionate appointment. The object under this scheme is only to provide solace and succour, to the family of deceased employee in difficult times and thus, this principle is required to be followed while dealing with the issue of compassionate appointment. Therefore, it would be appropriate that as no direct dependent was available, the other person as contemplated under Clause 10.4.2 would have get appointment, subject to satisfaction of criteria. But, no one came forward at the relevant time. Now almost period of 45 years has been lapsed, therefore, appointment on compassionate ground cannot be granted in the matter.

30.

It would be further pertinent to note that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sanjay Kumar (supra) has specifically held that there cannot be reservation of a vacancy, till such time, as the petitioner becomes a major after number of years, unless there are some specific provisions to that effect.

31.

In the present case, admittedly, the date of birth of respondent-employee is 20.07.1975. Considering, the date of birth at present, the respondent has crossed the age of 50 years. During these outgoing years, it is not pointed out that the respondent could not survive or was helpless due to the untimely death of his father. Rather, it came on the record before the learned CGIT that the respondent was in private employment and having his own earning for his livelihood. Therefore, considering this material fact in the present matter, the period is of almost 25 years, after moving the application for compassionate appointment, needs consideration in the matter. In my considered opinion, applying the principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, the respondent cannot be held entitled for his appointment on compassionate ground.

32.

The respondent has relied upon the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Subadra (supra) wherein, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has awarded the compensation to the respondent-employee. In the facts of the said case, the agreement on the basis of which the employment was claimed, there was specific clause of the assurance to the dependents of the family of the deceased for appointment on compassionate grounds. However, in the present case, as already held that there was no such specification in the clause 10.4.2 of NCWA-II. In my opinion, the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, will not be applicable in the present matter.

33.

In the light of the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the present case, the impugned award dated 11.05.2011 passed by the learned Presiding Officer CGIT-cum-Labour Court, Nagpur, is not sustainable and the same needs to be quashed and set aside. Accordingly, the following order is passed:-

O R D E R

(i)

The Writ Petition No.4821 of 2011 is allowed.

(ii)

The impugned award dated 11.05.2011 passed by learned Presiding Officer CGIT-cum-Labour Court, Nagpur in Case No.CGIT/NGP/61/2002, is hereby quashed and set-aside.

34.

The writ petition stands disposed of. No order as to costs.