AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
(Hybrid Mode)
[Per: Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan (Oral)]
Heard Shri Manu Agarwal, Learned Counsel for the Appellant, and perused the record.
The proceedings of this appeal are running ex-parte against the Respondent.
The instant appeal has been filed by the Appellant – Welnit Tradelink Pvt. Ltd., being aggrieved by the impugned order dated 17.09.2025 passed by the Learned NCLT, Ahmedabad Bench, Court No. 2 (Adjudicating Authority) in CP(IB)/274(AHM)/2025, whereby the petition moved by the Appellant under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (Code) has been dismissed.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant while drawing our attention to the impugned judgment submits that the Learned Adjudicating Authority has not considered the facts of the instant case in correct perspective and has dismissed the petition on the score that the amount of Rs. 10 Crore lended by the Appellant was an investment in lieu of allotment of 50% equity share in the CD and also that the petition is also barred by limitation, as the date of default has been shown in the petition as 31.03.2022, and the petition has been filed on 08.04.2025.
It is further submitted that, on various dates, an amount of Rs. 09,72,60,000/- was lended to the Respondent, however, the same was not returned, despite issuance of a notice dated 23.12.2024, the amount was not paid, and therefore, the petition under Section 7 was filed.
It is next submitted that the amount lended to the Respondent was a financial debt, and therefore, it was obligatory on the part of the Learned Adjudicating Authority to have at least issued a notice to the Corporate Debtor so that the correct factual position have emerged.
It is further submitted that, even if the finding of the Learned Adjudicating Authority, with regard to the fact that the amount lended appears to be an investment, is correct for the sake of argument but even then on the principle of acknowledgment the said investment on account of non-payment has transformed into a Financial debt, as the money has neither been paid to the Appellant nor any shares have been allotted by the Respondent.
It is further submitted that the petition filed by the Appellant was otherwise within limitation, and a wrong finding on this score has also been recorded by the Learned Adjudicating Authority. Therefore, the impugned judgment be set aside and the matter be remanded back to the Learned Adjudicating Authority for decision afresh.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant, has also drawn our attention towards the financial statements of the CD as well as of the Appellant in order to show that, in the financial records, the money lended has been shown as debt, and the TDS is also shown in the financials of the CD which was a living proof of the fact that the money has been advanced as financial debt and interest has also been paid by the CD to the Appellant.
We have heard Learned Counsel for the Parties and perused the record. Having considered all the facts and circumstance of the case, and having seen the balance sheet of the year 2021-2022 & 2022-2023, we have certain reservations with regard to the claim of the Appellant that the amount allegedly lended by the Appellant to the Respondent is reflected as the financial debt in the balance sheets of the Appellant and Cd of relevant years.
During the course of deliberation, we noticed that on 25.02.2024, the Director of the Appellant namely Mr. Dilipbhai Jethalal Raval, has filed a complaint before the Judicial Magistrate First Class, Ahemdabad, under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act against the Respondent and its Directors, namely – Mr. Shubhash P, Alex and Mr. Mittalkumar Jagdishbhai Patel.
Perusal of this complaint would reflect that it has been specifically stated therein by the Director of the Appellant that an investment of Rs. 10 Crores was made in the CD in lieu of allotment of 50% equity shares and, since no such shares were allotted, the cheques were issued in favour of the Appellant to the tune of Rs. 09,90,00,000/- and which were subsequently dishonoured and it is on this score the complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instrument Act has been filed by the Appellant.
During the course of deliberation, it has been admitted by Learned Counsel for the Appellant that the said complaint filed under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is still pending before the Court concerned. The relevant part of the complaint, particularly paragraphs 3 to 5 thereof, are relevant and are being reproduced hereunder;
The complaint company was introduces to the Directors, Promoters and Shareholders of the accused company namely Ghanshaym Keshavlal Patel, Jyoshna Keshavlal patel, Shartiben Keshavlal Patel, Subhash P. Alex, Harijivan Chaturdas patel, Kanubhai Kantilal Patel and Mittalkumar Jagdishbhai Patel. Pursuant to such introduction, the aforementioned Directors, Promoters and Shareholders claimed that the accused no. 1 company was recently acquired by them, that they were in the process of recommencing and expanding operation and for such purpose needed investors who ready and willing to provide financial assistance in exchange of equity. Accordingly, after various discussions and deliberations, by and between the Directors of the complainant and the Directors, Promoters and Shareholders of accused no. 1 company it was agreed that against an investment of Rs. 10,00,00,000 (Rupees Ten Crore), the complaint will be entitled to receive 50% equity shares of accused no. 1 company. Accordingly, from June, 2021 till July 2023, the complainant has invested a large sum of money in various tranches as provided herein below;
| Date | Amount | Bank |
| 19.06.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 19.06.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 21.06.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 23.06.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 23.06.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 25.06.2021 | 35,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 25.06.2021 | 40,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 28.06.2021 | 45,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 28.06.2021 | 30,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 29.06.2021 | 40,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 09.07.2021 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 03.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 05.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 07.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 07.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 09.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 13.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 15.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 20.06.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 01.07.2023 | 50,00,000 | ICICI Bank |
| 06.07.2023 | 32,60,000 | ICICI Bank |
Despite such amounts having been invested, the Directors, Promoters and Shareholders of accused no. 1 refused to part with any details in connection with the present equity of the company, the mode and manner in which the allotment of shares was to be undertaken, the price that was supposed to notionally fixed for such allotment, the purpose and utilization of the money as received from the complainant and hence, refused to share any details or data in connection with either the shares or the money as invested by the complainant. Additionally, the Directors, Promoters and Shareholders of accused no. 1 after receiving the aforementioned investment refused to either allot the equity shares or return the aforementioned invested amount. A copy of the ledger as maintained by the complaint is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure D.
Finally, after much persuasion, accused no. 1 to 3 with a view to make part payment towards its entirely financial obligation issued a cheque of Rs. 9,90,00,000 (Rupees Nine Crore Ninety Lac) bearing no. 000590 dated 20.12.2023 drawn upon the Mehsana Urban Co. Op. Bank Ltd. to the complainant. Original of such cheque is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure E.
The aforesaid paragraphs of the complaint would evidently show that the Appellant has admitted that the amount of Rs. 10 Crore was given to the Respondent as an investment in the CD, in lieu of allotment of 50% equity shares in Respondent company (CD).
There is no loan agreement executed between the parties. Keeping in view the admission of the Appellant in its complaint moved under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, it is an admitted fact to the Appellant Rs. 10 Crore were invested by the Appellant in the CD and it was not a financial debt under Section 5(8) of the IBC.
We are in full agreement with the conclusions drawn by the Learned Adjudicating Authority and, in our considered opinion as well, the amount of Rs. 10 Crores was invested by the Appellant in the CD in lieu of allotment of 50% equity shares of the Respondent company and on a dispute arisen some cheques were given to the Appellant by the Respondent and on the dishonour of the same a complaint under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act has been filed by the Appellant. Thus, the amount given by the Appellant as share application money cannot be treated to be as financial debt so as to enable the Appellant to initiate insolvency process under Section 7 of the Code.
Since we are of the considered opinion that the amount of Rs. 10 Crores has not been lended by the Appellant by giving any financial debt and that was an investment in the CD the other issues with regard to limitation do not appear to be relevant for our consideration, as on this ground alone the appeal filed by the Appellant is liable to be dismissed.
Keeping in view all the facts and circumstances of the case, and for the reasons recorded hereinabove, we do not find any merit in the appeal and the same is hereby dismissed.
Pending I.A.’s, if any, are also disposed. There is no order as to costs.
