AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
PER S. RIFAUR RAHMAN, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER :
This appeal is filed by the assessee against the order of ld. Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals)/National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi (NFAC), Delhi [“Ld. CIT (A)”, for short] dated 08.04.2026 for the AY 2018-19 raising following grounds of appeal :-
“1.The reassessment is invalid and without jurisdiction as the appellant has declared returned income exceeding Rs.20,00,000/- and therefore, jurisdiction over appellant lies with Circle not with ITO as per CBDT Instruction No.1/2011 F.No.187/12/2010-IT(A-I) dt: 03.01.2011 and hence, the reassessment initiated vide notices u/s 148/148A by the AO i.e. ITO is invalid, illegal and without jurisdiction.
2.On facts and circumstances of the case, the authorities below have erred in upholding the reassessment proceedings ignoring the fact that the same has been initiated after taking approval from incorrect authority u/s 151 of IT Act and therefore, the reassessment proceedings need to be deleted.
3.On facts and circumstances of the case, the authorities below have erred in upholding the reassessment proceedings ignoring the fact that impugned assessment is invalid and without jurisdiction as the said assessment is completed without complying with legal requirements of the provisions of section 147/l48/151/148A/149 of the Income Tax Act therefore such assessment is void ab initio and liable to Be quashed.
4.The Ld, CIT(A) has erred both in law and circumstances of the cases in upholding the addition of Rs.30,00,000/- u/s 68 rws 115BBBE or the IT Act holding the unsecured loan as unexplained cash credit ignoring the fact that the assessee has discharged its initial onus u/s 6ll of the IT Act explaining nature and source of the credits by filing requisite documents proving identity and creditworthiness of the lenders and also to establish genuineness of the transaction during assessment proceedings.
5.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred both in law and circumstances of the cases in upholding the addition of Rs.30,00,000/- u/s 68 rws 115BBE of the IT Act holding the unsecured loan as 5 I unexplained cash credit ignoring the fact that the above loans I were repaid and therefore, the same cannot be held to be in- genuine and bogus.
6.The Ld. CIT(A) has erred both in law and circumstances of the cases in upholding the disallowance of interest paid on unsecured loan amounting to Rs.2,17,479/- of IT Act 1961 ignoring the submission of appellant and the fact that the above disallowance without specifying the section under which the above disallowance is made.”
At the time of hearing, Ld. AR contested only the legal issues raised in the Grounds No.1 to 3. The submissions of the assessee are reproduced below:-
“Ground No.1 Initiation of proceedings u/s 148 without jurisdiction and completion of assessment by the authority having
no jurisdiction.
In the present case, the proceedings u/s 148 dated 02.04.2022(PB 29) were initiated by ITO, Ward 35(1), New Delhi, i.e. AO, who did not have jurisdiction over the appellant. As per the ITR available for AY 2018-19 filed on 26.09.2018 (PB 1), the returned income of the appellant is Rs.20,77,420/- and this fact is mentioned in para 2 of the order u/s 148A(d) dated 02.04.2022 (PB 26-28) and also in the assessment order in para 1 (PB 190). Therefore, the jurisdiction over the appellant was with the Circle and not with the above Ward officer. The above limit of income for non-corporate charge is fixed as per CBDT Instruction No.1/2011 F.No.187/12/2010-IT(A-I) dt: 03.01.2011 wherein it was specified that if the returned income of the non-corporate assessee exceeds Rs.20 lakh then the jurisdiction over that case will be with the Circle only and not with ITO. Hence, the reassessment proceedings in the present case are to be treated as being initiated by a non-jurisdictional assessing officer and consequently, the reassessment proceedings and reassessment order both need to be quashed. The co-ordinate Bench of Hon’ble ITAT in the case of YKM Holdings P Ltd vs ACIT ITA No.1020/Del/2019 dated 29.04.2024, Sh Vipul Mittal vs DCIT ITA No.2850/Del/2019 dated 15.01.2025, Vertex Consultants P Ltd vs DCIT ITA No.2617/Del/2026, Om Parkash Bansal HUF vs ACIT ITA No.2984/Del/2024, Balraj Sharma vs ITO ITA No.4370/Del/2025 dated 03.03.2026, New Star System Solution P Ltd vs DCIT ITA No.3585/Del/2025 dated 21.01.2026, Ketan Tokershi Shah vs DCIT ITA No.1107/Mum/2023, ITO vs M/s Watermark Systems (I) P Ltd 2023 (2) TMI 1348-ITAT Mum and Monarch & Qureshi Builders vs ACIT 110 ITR (Trib) 76 (ITAT Mum) has quashed the assessment proceedings on identical grounds relying on decision of Bombay High Court in the case of Ashok Devichand Jain vs UOI 452 ITR 43 (Bom) & Hon’ble Calcutta High Court in the PCIT vs M/s Shree Stoppers ltd 468 ITR 18 (Cal) and has also rejected the revenue objection of applicability of sec 124(3)/292BB of IT Act.
It is a settled law that the assessment proceedings should be initiated by the authority having jurisdiction over an assessee. The Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of CIT vs. Lalitkumar Bardia (2017) 84 taxmann.com 213 (Bombay)) has held that mere participation in proceedings or acquiescence would not confer jurisdiction upon the Assessing Officer who otherwise was not the Assessing Officer of the assessee. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Kanwar Singh Saini vs Delhi High Court (2012) 4 SCC 307 (SC) in Para 13 has held that there can be no dispute regarding the settled legal proposition that conferment of jurisdiction is a legislative function and it can neither be conferred with the consent of the party nor by a superior court.
Ground Nos.2 and 3: Assumption of reassessment proceedings in violation of provisions of sec 147/148/148A/151/149 of IT Act.
A. Non-Application of mind
The foundational reason for initiation of proceedings u/s 148A was that the appellant had been a beneficiary of a so-called accommodation entry of Rs.30,00,000/- from M/s Kasera Agency P Ltd (“Kasera”) which was highlighted as a high-risk transaction in the CRIU/VRU category in the line of the high-risk management strategy formulated by CBDT. The above entry has been identified as related to the bank account of the above-named Kasera maintained with Union Bank of India vide Account No.552401010050232. These details are mentioned in the notice u/s 148A(b) (PB 19-21)and also in the order u/s 148A(d) dt: 02.04.2022(PB 26-28).The above information based on the presumption that the transaction of Rs.30,00,000/- has taken place during the assessment year 2018-19 which is factually incorrect. The appellant, vide e-submission dated 24.03.2022(PB 24-25) had explained that during the year under consideration only Rs.20,00,000/- has been received and the balance Rs.10,00,000/- represents opening balance due as on the opening date of the financial year. The Ld AO takes the above explanation in para 4 of the order u/s 148A(d) on record along with the information that the loan has been repaid during FY 2019-20 along with interest. Despite the above explanation brought on record, the Ld AO, without contradicting the above factual submission, opted to reopen the case based on the transaction of Rs.30,00,000/- as if it pertains to the AY under consideration, without bringing any material on record to dispute the factual position highlighted in the submission made by the appellant. The above factual error in quantifying the income escaping assessment does not provide valid ground for initiation for reassessment proceedings in view of the decisions cited below:
Shamshad Khan vs ACIT 395 ITR 265 (Del); Pr CIT vs M/S SNG Developers Ltd 404 ITR 312 (Del) revenue’s SLP dismissed in SLP © 42379/2017 Dt: 09.02.2018; M/s Synfonia Tradelinks P Ltd vs ITO435 ITR 642 (Del); CIT vs Suren International Pvt Ltd 357 ITR 24 (Del); Pr. CIT vs. RMG Polyvinyl (I) Ltd (2017) 396 ITR 5 (Del), CIT vs. Atlas Cycle industries (1989) 180 ITR 319 (P&H);
B. Non-compliance of provision of sec 149(1)(b)
The Sec 148A/148 proceedings in the present case have been conducted by the department in the manner shown in the table below:
| S.No. | Nature of proceedings | Relevant Date & reference |
| 1. | AY under consideration 2018-19 | AY ending on 31.03.2019 |
| 2. | Notice u/s 148A(b) | 23.03.2022 (PB 19-21) |
| 3. | Reply to notice u/s 148A(b) | 24.03.2022 (PB 22-25) |
| 4. | Approval u/s 151 taken for passing order u/s 148A(d)/148 | 30.03.2022 (PB 26 & 29) |
| 5. | Passing of order u/s 148A(d) and 148 | 02.04.2022 (PB 26 & 29) |
| 6. | Time available to AO u/s 149(1)(a) of IT Act within 3 years from the end of the relevant AY | 31.03.2022 |
From the order u/s 148A(d), it is evident that reopening of the present assessment is made to bring the income of Rs.30,00,000/- to tax u/s 147/148 of the IT Act. Since the income chargeable to tax that has escaped assessment is less than Rs.50,00,000/-, the notice u/s 148 was required to be issued in a period of 3 years from the end of the relevant AY, i.e. on or before 31.03.2022. But the notice u/s 148 in the present case was issued on 02.04.2022, after the above time limit laid down u/s 149(1)(a) of IT Act. It is therefore a case where the Ld AO ceased to have jurisdiction to initiate action after 31.03.2022 in accordance with provision of sec 149(1)(a) of IT Act since the income escaping assessment is less than Rs.50 lakh.”
On the other hand, ld. DR of the Revenue relied on the orders of the authorities below.
Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that assessee has filed its return of income declaring income of Rs.20,77,420/-. As per the CBDT Instruction No.01/2011, the jurisdiction over the assessee’s case lies only with Assistant/Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax as the income declared by the assessee is above Rs.20 lakhs falls under the category of non-corporate returns. For the sake of brevity, CBDT Instruction No.01/2011 is reproduced below :-
“Order-Instruction - Income Tax
References have been received by the Board from the large number of taxpayers especially from the mofussil areas, that the existing monetary limits for assigning cases to Deputy Commissioners / Assistant Commissioners and ITOs is causing hardship to the taxpayers.
INSTRUCTION NO. 1/2011 [F. NO. 187/12/2010-IT(A-I)] DATED 31-1-2011
References have been received by the Board from a large number of taxpayers, especially from mofussil areas, that the existing monetary limits for assigning cases to ITOs and DCs/ACs is causing hardship to the taxpayers, as it results in transfer of their cases to a DC/AC who is located in a different station, which increases their cost of compliance. The Board had considered the matter and is of the opinion that the existing limits need to be revised to remove the abovementioned hardship. An increase in the monetary limits is also considered desirable in view of the increase in the scale of trade and industry since 2001, when the present income limits were introduced. It has therefore been decided to increase the monetary limits as under:
Income Declared (Mofussil Income Declared areas) (Metro cities) ITOs ACs/DCs ITOs DCs/ACs Corporate returns Upto Rs. 20 lacs Above Rs. 20 lacs Upto Rs. 30 lacs Above Rs. 30 lacs Non-corporate returns Upto Rs. 15 lacs Above Rs. 15 lacs Upto Rs. 20 lacs Above Rs. 20 lacs Metro charges for the purpose of above instructions shall be Ahmedabad, Bangalore, Chennai, Delhi, Kolkata, Hyderabad, Mumbai and Pune.
The above instructions are issued in supersession of the earlier instructions and shall be applicable with effect from1-4-2011.”
It is brought to our notice that proceedings u/s 148 dated 02.04.2022 were initiated by ITO, Ward 35 (1), New Delhi, who did not have jurisdiction over the assessee in the case considering the fact that the return of income declared by the assessee is over and above Rs.20 lakhs. Therefore, the jurisdiction over the assessee was with the Circle and not with the above Ward officer. We observed that the above limit of income for non-corporate charge is fixed as per CBDT Instruction No.1/2011 F.No.187/12/2010-IT(A-I) dt: 03.01.2011 wherein it was specified that if the returned income of the non-corporate assessee exceeds Rs.20 lakh then the jurisdiction over that case will be with the Circle only and not with ITO. Hence, we observed that the reassessment proceedings in the present case are to be treated as being initiated by a non-jurisdictional assessing officer and consequently, the reassessment proceedings and reassessment order are to be quashed.
Further, we observed that ld. AR relied on the decision on various decisions and also relied on the decision of coordinate Bench in the case of Om Prakash Bansal (HUF vs. ACIT 2025 (10) TMI 1062 – ITAT, Delhi (in which the Accountant Member is the Author). The findings of the aforesaid decision are reproduced below :-
“12.Considered the rival submissions and material placed on record. We observed that assessee has filed its return of income declaring income of Rs.30,71,730/-. As per the CBDT Instruction No.01/2011, the jurisdiction over the assessee’s case lies only with Assistant/Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax as the income declared by the assessee is above Rs.20 lakhs falls under the category of non-corporate returns. It is brought to our notice that notice u/s 143(2) was issued by the ITO, Ward 47 (1) on 21.09.2018, who do not have jurisdiction over the assessee in the case considering the fact that the return of income declared by the assessee is over and above Rs.20 lakhs. The assessment was completed by the ACIT, Circle – 46(1), Delhi u/s 143(3) of the Act. However, we observe that the jurisdiction lies only with DCIT, however the statutory notice u/s 143(2) was issued by the ITO instead of the present Assessing Officer i.e. DCIT. Ld. DR objected to the submissions of the assessee for the reason that the present jurisdictional issue raised now instead of raising the same during assessment itself within one month from the date of receipt of the notice u/s 124 (3) of the Act. After considering the factual matrix in this case, we observe that similar issue under consideration is considered by the coordinate Bench in the case of YKM Holdings Pvt. Ltd. vs. ACIT (supra) wherein it was held as under :-
“4.We have heard the rival submissions and perused the material available on record. At the outset, we find that the additional grounds raised by the assessee go to the root of the matter challenging the jurisdictional per se. All the facts relevant for its adjudication are placed on record. Hence, in the light of decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of NTPC Ltd. reported in 229 ITR 383, we are inclined to admit the additional grounds and take up the same for its adjudication.
5.We find that assessee’s returned income for the A.Y. 2015- 16 was Rs. 37,78,510/- hence, the jurisdiction of the assessee should lie with ACIT/DCIT since the returned income had exceeded Rs. 30,00,000/-, in view of the CBDT Instruction No.1/2011 dated 31.01.2011. For the sake of convenience, the said Instruction No.1/2011 [F. No.187/12/2010-IT(A-I)] dated 31.01.2011 is hereby reproduced:-…………….
6.In the instant case, the notice under section 143(2) of the Act stood issued to the assessee on 12.04.2016 by ITO Ward 27(4), Delhi. In July, 2016, the ITO transferred the jurisdiction of the assessee from him to DCIT since the returned income for A.Y. 2015-16 is more than 30,00,000/-. Copy of the said transfer memo is enclosed in page 5 of the paper book. After the transfer of jurisdiction from ITO to DCIT, no fresh notice under section 143(2) of the Act was issued by ACIT, Circle 4(1), Gurgaon. The assessment was ultimately framed under section 143(3) of the Act for A.Y. 2015-16 on 14.12.2017 by ACIT, Circle – 4(1), Gurgaon. It is pertinent to note that assessment for the A.Y. 2014-15 of the assessee was completed under section 143(3) of the Act on 30.11.2016 by DCIT, Circle – 27(2), New Delhi. Hence, it was argued that the notice under section 143(2) of the Act dated 12.04.2016 issued by the ITO selecting the return of assessee for A.Y. 2015-16 for scrutiny is without jurisdiction and consequently, the assessment framed under section 143(3) of the Act dated 14.12.2017 required to be quashed as void ab initio. When this was confronted to learned DR, he pointed out to the provisions of section 124(3) of the Act wherein it was mentioned that assessee should challenge within one month about the jurisdiction of the AO on receipt of the notice. In the instant case, nowhere up to learned CIT(A), the assessee has challenged the jurisdiction of the learned AO. In our considered opinion, this argument of the learned DR is wrong in as much as section 124(3) of the Act talks only about territorial jurisdiction, whereas the issue involved here is pecuniary jurisdiction. Further, the provisions of section 124(3) of the Act could be taken shelter by the Revenue only when legal valid notice under section 143(2) of the Act has been issued by the Revenue. In the instant case, notice issued under section 143(2) of the Act on 12.04.2016 by ITO is not legal as he did not possess jurisdiction over the assessee for A.Y. 2015-16 in as much as the returned income for A.Y. 2015-16 had exceeded Rs. 30,00,000/-. We find that the issue in dispute is no longer res integra by the decision of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the case of Ashok Devichand Jain vs. UOI reported in 452 ITR 43 (Bom). In this case, very same issue was addressed in the light of CBDT Instruction No.1/2011[F. No.187/12/2010-IT(A-I)] Dated 31.01.2011. For the sake of convenience, the entire order is reproduced hereunder:
“1.Petitioner is impugning a notice dated 30th March, 2019 issued under section 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act) for A.Y. 2012-13 and order passed on 18th November, 2019 rejecting Petitioner’s objection to reopening on various grounds.
2.The primary ground that has been raised is that the Income Tax Officer who issued the notice under section 148 of the Act, had no jurisdiction to issue such notice. According to Petitioner as per instruction No. 1/2011 dated 31st January, 2011 issued by the Central Board of Direct Taxes, where income declared/returned by any Non-Corporate assessee is up to Rs. 20 lakhs, then the jurisdiction will be of ITO and where the income declared returned by a Non Corporate assessee is above Rs. 20 lakhs, the jurisdiction will be of DC/AC.
3.Petitioner has filed return of income of about Rs.64,34,663/- and therefore, the jurisdiction will be that of DC/AC and not ITO. Mr. Jain submitted that since notice under section 148 of the Act has been issued by ITO, and not by DC/AC that is by a person who did not have any jurisdiction over Petitioner, such notice was bad on the count of having been issued by an officer who had no authority in law to issue such notice.
4.We have considered the affidavit in reply of one Mr. Suresh G. Kamble, ITO who had issued the notice under section 148 of the Act. Said Mr. Kamble, ITO, Ward 12(3)(1), Mumbai admits that such a defective notice has been issued but according to him, PAN of Petitioner was lying with ITO Ward (12)(3)(1), Mumbai and it was not feasible to migrate the PAN having returned of income exceeding Rs. 30 lakhs to the charge of DCIT, Circle 12(3)(1), Mumbai, as the time available with the ITO 12(3)(1) was too short to migrate the PAN after obtaining administrative approval from the higher authorities by 31st March, 2019.
5.The notice under section 148 of the Act is jurisdictional notice and any inherent defect therein is not curable. In the facts of the case, notice having been issued by an officer who had no jurisdiction over the Petitioner, such notice in our view, has not been issued validly and is issued without authority in law.
6.In the circumstances, we have no hesitation in setting aside the notice dated 30th March, 2019.
7.Consequently the order dated 18th November, 2019 rejecting Petitioner’s objection is also quashed and set aside.
8.Petition disposed.”
In view of the aforesaid observations and respectfully following the judicial precedent relied upon hereinabove, we have no hesitation to hold that the assessment framed under section 143(3) of the Act deserves to be quashed in the instant case as the initial scrutiny notice issued under section 143(3) of the Act dated 12.04.2016 by ITO was without jurisdiction as he did not possess jurisdiction over the assessee for the A.Y. 2015-16. Consequently, assessment framed under section 143(3) of the Act is hereby quashed as void ab initio. The additional ground no.2 is hereby allowed.”
Similar view was expressed by the ITAT, Mumbai in the case of Monarch & Quershi Builders v. ACIT Circle – 33(2) ITA No. 2026/MUM/2023 and by the coordinate Bench in the case of Sapna Rastogi vs. ITO – ITA No. 617/DEL/2024.
Further the Revenue has not brought on record an order u/s 127 of the Act passed in order to transfer the case to DCIT, Circle …………, New Delhi except making the submissions that assessee should file the objection within one month u/s 124(3) of the Act. Since the issue of notice u/s 143(2) is the basis of initiation of the assessment u/s 143(3) and the jurisdictional officer should have issued the notice and also completed the assessment. The present Assessing Officer has completed the assessment without following the due process of law and we, respectfully following the decisions of the coordinate Bench and ITAT Mumbai, are inclined to hold that the jurisdictional notice u/s 143(2) was not issued by the DCIT before completing the assessment u/s 143(3) of the Act and that there is an unwarranted defect in this case which is not curable. Accordingly, the assessment passed in the given case is quashed and accordingly, the additional grounds raised by the assessee are allowed.”
In view of our above findings and respectfully following the aforesaid decision, we hold that the present Assessing Officer has completed the assessment without following the due process of law and there is an unwarranted defect in this case which is not curable. Accordingly, the assessment passed in the given case is quashed and accordingly, the legal grounds raised by the assessee are allowed.
The assessee has raised several grounds on merits as well. Since we have already decided the legal grounds in favour of the assessee, we are inclined to keep the other grounds of appeal open at this stage.
In the result, the appeal filed by the assessee is allowed as above.
