High CourtsSingle Bench(2026) 10 BOM CK 6409

Viraj Profiles Pvt. Ltd. vs Eastern Metec Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.

Bombay High Court · Decided on 28 October 2026

HON’BLE JUDGES
S.M. Modak, J
RESULT
Dismissed
CASE NUMBER
Arbitration Petition No. 125 of 2026

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

25 paragraphs · 1,584 words
1.

I have heard learned Advocate for the Petitioner and learned Advocate for the Respondent.

2.

This is a petition filed under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act for appointment of sole Arbitrator. The Petitioner has relied upon arbitration clause No.35 from the purchase agreement dated 27th September 2022 (Page-60). As per the said agreement the Petitioner has agreed to purchase certain goods from the Respondents. It is in respect of 7.5 MVA Submerged Arc Furnace (Para-9)(Page-3). Even though the furnace is installed, there are certain dispute amongst the parties about its functioning. That is why after issuing notice under Section 21 of the said Act, the Petitioner has filed this petition.

2.

There is a preliminary objection taken about maintainability of the petition in view of the fact that the Respondent has already availed the statutory remedy under Section 18 of Micro and Small Enterprises Act before the Facilitation Council. The Respondent has also duly informed the Petitioner about the said proceedings vide email dated 23rd March 2026. On this background it is submitted on behalf of the Respondent that the present petition is not maintainable.

3.

Whereas according to learned Advocate for the Petitioner there is no dispute about the arbitration clause and once there is arbitration clause and once there is a notice, the Reference Court is required to appoint an Arbitrator without conducting a detail enquiry. She relied upon certain judgments by way of compilation whereas learned Advocate for the Respondent also relied upon certain judgments by way of compilation.

4.

One of such judgments is delivered in case of Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. v/s. Mahakali Foods Pvt.Ltd. (Unit-2) and anr.1 wherein Supreme Court has dealt with various appeals filed arising out of the Award passed by the Facilitation Council and it was challenged before the High Court, however, failed. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has considered the provisions of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act 2006 on one hand and provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act on the other hand. Considering the Non-obstant clause in the Act of 2006, Supreme Court held that it will override the provisions of Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Few of the observations are relevant. Learned Advocate for the Respondents relied upon few other judgments given by various High Courts.

4.

I have gone through the observations in the judgment relied upon by the Petitioner. It is true in case of National Textile Corporation Ltd. v/s. Elixir Engineering Pvt.Ltd.2 this Court has dealt with the petition filed under Section 34 of 1996 Act thereby challenging the award given by the Facilitation Council. This Court has set aside the awards for the reason set out in Para No.35. It was observed if there is a works contract, then Facilitation Council is not having jurisdiction. The observations in case of M/s.P.L. Adke v. Wardha Municipal Corporation3 is relied upon.

5.

She also relied upon the observations of Orissa High Court in case of Indian Oil Corporation v/s. Adarsh Nobel Corporation Ltd.4 . There was an issue about the meaning of the word supplier as per Section 18. It was held that expression ‘Supplier’ is not confined to micro or small enterprises. On facts it was held as a contract involving goods and service and hence it is a works contract. The award by Facilitation Council was set aside. The observations of the Supreme Court are also noted in Para No.29. The Supreme Court interpreted the legal character of ‘works contract’. The award by the Facilitation Council was set aside.

5.

She also relied upon the observations of Delhi High Court in case of Tata Power Company Ltd. v/s. Genesis Engineering Company5. There was a petition filed under Section 11(6) of 1996 Act (Page No.9). In para-20 it is observed works orders executed by the parties in that case fall within the category – A (as it comprises of 2 contracts which include supply of goods and labour for its installation). There is a factual finding that both supply of goods and element of labour and service was involved in the works order. It is further observed it is also a settled principle of law that dispute arising from works contract are not amenable to the jurisdiction of Facilitation Council and hence Arbitrator under Section 11(6) was appointed.

6.

Both the learned Advocates have invited my attention to certain documents, invoices. They are as follows:

a)

offer given by the Petitioner (Page-23)

b)

Purchase orders given by the Petitioner (Page 25, 34)

c)

Purchase agreement dated 27th September 2022 (Page-44)

d)

Notice under Section 21 of 1996 Act (Page-81)

e)

Reply of Respondent dated 6th April 2026 (Page-94)

f)

Udyam registration certificate in the name of Respondent (Page-102). Except for the year 2024-25 Respondent is classified as a small enterprises. For the year 2024-25 they are classified as medium enterprises.

g)

Tax invoice issued by Respondent (Page-102, 104 and 106)

7.

On the basis of these invoices the submission on behalf of the Petitioner is the contract in between the Petitioner and Respondent is a works contract. Whereas learned Advocate for the Respondent submitted that it is not a works contract. Learned Advocate for the Respondent also relied upon a Circular issued by Dy. Director (Policy) dated 4th January 2023 wherein it is clarified that an enterprise who is having Udayam registration can avail of the benefits of the scheme of Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises. He also relied upon the observations by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh on Page-120 in case of Vijaylaxmi Enterprises v/s. M/s. K.V. Projects Ltd. The said Circular dated 4th January 2023 is referred in Para No.36. Court has taken a note that there is inclusion of works contract as per micro, small and medium enterprises and hence Council has got jurisdiction. This submission is made by the learned Advocate for the Respondent by way of alternate submission. If this Court comes to conclusion that the agreement between the parties is a works contract, even then the Faciliation Council can adjudicate the dispute. Whereas there is a challenge to this Circular on behalf of the Petitioner for the reason it cannot take place of the provisions of the law.

8.

Now the issue is what is true nature of transaction in between the Petitioner and Respondent, whether it is plain contract for the sale of goods or whether it involves the sale of goods alongwith execution so as to treat it as a works contract. There are two aspects. There are judgments given by the various High Courts holding that Facilitation Council is not having a jurisdiction to deal with the dispute arising out of the works contract. At the same time Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. (cited supra) has elaborately dealt with the provisions of both the Acts and concluded that the provisions of 2006 Act overrides the provisions of 1996 Act. It is undisputed fact that the Respondent has firstly approached the Facilitation Council at Calcutta.

9.

Now the issue is whether the issue about the true nature of the contract whether it can be decided by this reference Court or whether it should be relegated to other forums that is to say the arbitral Tribunal appointed as per the Arbitration and Conciliation Act or to Facilitation Council as per 2006 Act. The observations made by the Supreme Court in case of Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation are relevant. Para No.48 reads thus:

“48.

When the Facilitation Council or the institution or the centre acts as an Arbitrator, it shall have all powers to decide the dispute referred to it as if such arbitration was in pursuance of the arbitration agreement referred to in sub- section (1) of Section 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1996 and then all the trappings of the Arbitration Act, 1996 would apply to such arbitration. It is needless to say that such Facilitation Council/institution/centre acting as an Arbitral Tribunal would also be competent to rule on its own jurisdiction like any other Arbitral Tribunal appointed under the Arbitration Act, 1996 would have, as contemplated in Section 16 thereof.”

11.

In view of these observations this Court feels that while deciding a petition under Section 11(6) of the Act, this Court cannot go into the issue about the true nature of the contract. Even though there are certain judgments relied upon by the Petitioner wherein the reference Court has dealt with the issue about true nature of the contract and appointed an Arbitrator, but I do not find that in that judgment the observations by Supreme Court in case of Gujarat State Civil Supplies Corporation (cited supra) are referred.

12.

Hence, I am not inclined to allow this petition. In fact the invoices filed by the Respondents are sufficient enough to make observation that the Facilitation Council can deal with the objection by the Petitioner that “it is not a works contract”.

13.

In view of that no case for appointment of an Arbitrator is made out. The Facilitation Council at Calcutta is at liberty to deal with the issue about the true nature of contract whether it is works contract or otherwise. The Petitioner is at liberty to put forth their case before the Council once they will appear there.

14.

With these observations, petition is dismissed.

Footnotes

  1. 1.(2023) 6 Supreme Court Cases 401
  2. 2.Commercial Arbitration Petition (L) No.326/2018
  3. 3.Arbitration Appeal (st) No.30508 of 2019
  4. 4.Writ Petition (Civil) No.20210/2025
  5. 5.Arbitration Petition No.1415/2022 decided on 12 April 2023