AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
(Per Dr. Neela Gokhale, J.)
By this Appeal, the Appellant assails the Judgment and Order dated 20.04.2022 passed by the City Civil Court at Mumbai in Commercial Summary Suit No. 1340 of 2021, whereby the suit filed by the Respondent stands decreed ex-parte, whereas the learned Trial Judge has directed the Appellant to pay ₹40,18,890/- to the Appellant / Defendant, along with interest at 12% per annum on the principal outstanding amount of ₹25,00,000 to the Respondent from the date of filing the suit until the said amount is realized.
The facts of the case in brief are as under: 2026:BHC-AS:45149-D
The Appellant and the Respondent were traders. The Respondent advanced a loan of ₹25,00,000 to the Appellant herein by issuing 3 cheques dated 11.01.2010, 15.01.2010, and 15.01.2010, respectively. The Respondent contends that the Appellant executed receipts dated 11.01.2010, 15.01.2010 and 15.01.2010 acknowledging receipt of the said cheques. It was also agreed that the Appellant would repay the loan amount with interest at 12% per annum. The Respondent claims that the Appellant paid interest at 12% per annum on the aforesaid amount advanced to him till September 2016, and that he also issued a confirmation of account on 01.04.2018. However, thereafter, the Appellant stopped paying the interest. The Respondent thus issued a notice through his advocate dated 04.03.2021 calling upon the Appellant to make the outstanding payment. However, the Appellant failed to do so and, therefore, the Respondent claims that an amount of ₹40,18,890/- is outstanding against the Appellant. Hence, the Respondent instituted Commercial Suit No. 240 of 2021 before the City Civil Court, Mumbai.
According to the Appellant, the Writ of Summons along with the copy of the plaint was purportedly served upon him at Parini- I, 7 A, Shah Industrial Estate, Andheri West, Mumbai 400 053. The Appellant contended that he never received the summons, as the address to which it was sent was of a building under construction and uninhabitable. Since the building was under construction and not in use at the relevant time, the Appellant was not available at the said address. After2026:BHC-AS:45149-D serving a copy of the summons and the plaint at the said address and not receiving an acknowledgement, the Respondent filed an affidavit of service affirming that the writ of summons and the plaint were served on the Appellant. Based on the affidavit of service, the learned Judge passed an order that the suit proceed ex-parte against the Appellant. Thereafter, based on the Respondent's affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief, the learned Judge proceeded to decree the suit ex-parte. The Appellant assails this ex-parte Judgment, order, and decree in the present Commercial Appeal.
We have heard Mr Aseem Naphade, learned counsel representing the Appellant and Mr Jagdish Nagar, learned counsel for the Respondent. We have also gone through the case records with their assistance.
Mr Naphade submitted that the Respondent provided 3 addresses in the cause title of the plaint. However, for reasons best known to the Respondent, the Respondent deliberately served the summons and the plaint only at the address where the building was under construction. According to Mr Naphade, the said address was only a site and sales office where only some construction workers and security personnel may have been present. The Appellant is not aware whether the summons was served on any employee of the developer, security personnel, or construction worker at the site, as construction work was ongoing. Mr Naphade contended that, the service is bad in law, as the Appellant is an individual without any independent/employee security guard representing him. Thus, the service of the suit according to Mr Naphade is not in accordance with Order 5 Rule 15 of the2026:BHC-AS:45149-D Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC). Mr Naphade also submitted that the Respondent was well aware of the addresses at which the Appellant was available, as the statement of sub-confirmation of accounts for the year 2015-16 was addressed by the Appellant to the Respondent at the address of Deepak Building, 401 SV Road, Ville Parle (W), Mumbai – 56 (Deepak Building address). In these circumstances, the Respondent had provided the Deepak Building address in the cause-title of the plaint. Similarly, the sub-confirmation of accounts and the statements for the years 2016-17 and 2017-18 were also addressed to the Deepak Building address, which is the Appellant's address. In these circumstances, the Respondent was well aware of the Appellant's correct address and deliberately issued the writ of summons to the under-construction site address.
Mr Naphade contended that the impugned order is based on an ex-parte account narrated by the Respondent and the Appellant had no opportunity to defend himself on the merits of the case. He submitted that the plaint was filed in or around September 2021 and the matter was listed for the first time on 24.01.2022, on which day the learned Judge concluded that the writ of summons was duly served only on the basis of the Respondent's affidavit of service. Finally, Mr Naphade contended that the order was passed during the COVID-19 pandemic, when an SOP was in place stating that no adverse orders were to be passed during the pandemic. Thus, he submitted that the learned Judge ought to have directed the Respondents to attempt service at one more address mentioned by him in the array of parties in the cause-title of the suit. Mr Naphade thus stated that the Appellant has a good case on merits and, since the Respondent deliberately2026:BHC-AS:45149-D served the summons only at one address, which was an under-construction site, the impugned judgment and order be set aside.
Mr Nagar, learned Counsel for the Respondent, attempted to defend, contending that despite three addresses provided by him in the cause title of the suit, the Appellant, as per his instructions, was very much available at the under-construction site. According to Mr Nagar, a plaintiff need not serve the Defendant at all addresses mentioned in the cause-title; service at any one address is sufficient and good service. He also pointed to the service affidavit filed by him before the Trial Court, stating that service effected by him on the under-construction site was good service. Mr Nagar further submitted that the impugned judgment and order is passed by the learned Trial Court is a considered judgment on the basis of evidence laid by him before the Court and the same does not require any intervention by this Court. He also relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in Indu Bhushan v. Munna Lal and Anr.1, to suggest that notice through a process server is not mandatory and notice at any one address of the defendant is sufficient. He thus prays that the Appeal be dismissed.
We have heard both the counsel and have examined the record with their assistance.
A bare perusal of the impugned judgment and order indicates that the Trial Court has in one line accepted the service affidavit of the Respondent to hold that the Appellant was duly served with the writ of summons, referring to its order2026:BHC-AS:45149-D dated 25.02.2022, directing the suit to proceed ex-parte. We have also examined the reasons recorded by the Trial Court to decree the suit. The Trial Court does not appear to have recorded any finding on the facts of the case as averred by the Respondent, save for blanket reliance on the Respondent's affidavit filed in lieu of the examination-in-chief. The confirmation of accounts for the financial years alleged to have been signed by the Appellant has been accepted only on the basis of the averments of the said affidavit. It is a settled position of law that even if the suit is to be proceeded ex-parte against the defendant, the plaintiff must discharge the burden of prima facie proof qua the existence of relevant facts and circumstances out of which the cause of action has arisen. The Court must pass a decree only after ascertaining the factual and legal veracity of the plaintiff’s claim. The plaintiff's case must stand on its own legs, and the plaintiff must move its case before the Court can pass a decree in its favour.
Insofar as the contention of the Appellant regarding absence of service is concerned, we have examined the record. The plaint indicates three addresses furnished by the Respondent in the cause-title of the suit. There is no explanation given by the Respondent and recorded by the learned Trial Court as to why the writ of summons was not issued on the other addresses, especially when the record itself indicates that the confirmation of account statements for the financial years 2015-16, 2016-17 and 2017-18, placed on record and purportedly proved by the Respondent, clearly mentioned the address of the Appellant to be the Deepak Building address. Further, the Advocate notice issued on behalf of the Respondent was addressed to the Appellant at Smag House, Sarojini Road Extension, Ville2026:BHC-AS:45149-D Parle (W), Mumbai – 56. Furthermore, the non-starter report for the pre-institution mediation clearly indicated that the notice issued to the Appellant was returned with a postal endorsement as ‘incomplete address’. The cheques for the amount advanced to the Appellant were received on the Appellant's letterhead. The address of Smag House appears on the said letterhead. The Respondent relied on these receipts to prove his case before the Trial Court. These documents thus indicate that the Respondent knew the Appellant's correct address, and it appears that the Respondent deliberately chose the under-construction site address to serve the writ of summons and the plaint on the Appellant.
We also note the relevant provisions of the CPC on service of suit summons namely Order V Rule 1, 9, 9A and 10.
A conjoint reading of Rules 1, 9, 9A and 10 indicates that the compliance mandated by these provisions is mandatory. The question of fact is whether the affidavit of service tendered on behalf of the Respondent satisfies compliance with these provisions. In our opinion, the Respondent's affidavit of service does not satisfy the elementary requirements of the CPC Rules. The addresses of the Appellant are clearly mentioned in the cause-title, but there is no clarity in the affidavit of service, nor any official report of the Registry of the Civil Court that the summons was duly served or effected on the registered address of the Appellant so as to accept such service to be in compliance with Order V Rule 1, 9, 9A and 10 of the CPC.
We find that the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, also does not in any manner2026:BHC-AS:45149-D dispense with the requirements of Order V Rule 1, 9, 9A and 10 of the CPC insofar as the manner in which private service of suit summons must be effected and certified by the Court. In the present case, the Trial Court’s reliance solely on the affidavit of service filed by the Respondent does not, in any manner, satisfy the CPC's mandate for valid service. By denying the Appellant an opportunity to be heard, the Trial Court has caused serious prejudice, as the Appellant suffered an ex-parte decree. We have also perused this Court's decision in Best Industries Corporation thr its Mr.Jowender Singh Sethi v. the Standard Products Manufcaturing Co.2. The legal aspect discussed therein is directly applicable to the facts of the present case.
We have also perused the decision relied upon by Mr Nagar. The facts in Indu Bhushan (supra) are completely distinct from the facts of the present case. Moreover, the legal proposition in Indu Bhushan (supra) supports the Appellant's contention. The Supreme Court has clearly held that service through the Court's process is mandatory. Moreover, in Indu Bhushan (supra), service was effected by several process servers who gave notice of service, and their endorsements were on record. Moreover, in Indu Bhushan (supra), the Court also examined the postman who effected service by registered post.
In the light of the above discussion, we are of the clear opinion that the Appellant has made out a case for setting aside the ex-parte decree. In view of the same, we dispose of this Appeal in terms of the following Order:
ORDER 2026:BHC-AS:45149-D
The Impugned Judgment, Order and decree dated 20th April 2022, passed by the City Civil Court, Mumbai, in Commercial Suit No.1343/2021, is quashed and set aside. The said suit is directed to be restored and decided on merits.
The Appellant shall file his Written Statement / counter-claim, if any, within a period of four weeks from the date on which the suit is restored to its original file without any further extension.
All contentions of all the parties are expressly kept open.
Thus, the appeal stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
Interim Applications, if any, do not survive and are disposed of accordingly.
