High CourtsSingle Bench(2012) 11 P&H CK 0148

Vinod Kumar vs UT Chandigarh

Punjab And Haryana At Chandigarh · Decided on 23 November 2012

HON’BLE JUDGES
M.M.S. Bedi, J
CASE NUMBER
CRM M-31549 of 2012 (O and M)

CourtKutchehry membership

More clarity. Every judgment.

Download court copies, explore connected cases and make more of every research session.

Loading membership options…

Ask AI about this case

AI Structured Summary

Not yet generated for this judgment

Judgment

5 paragraphs · 747 words

M.M.S. Bedi, J.—Petitioner seeks the concession of pre-arrest bail in a case of breach of trust registered at the instance of Poonam Chauhan alleging that the petitioner after having received cash, gold articles etc. has broken the marriage with her after distribution of cards as demand of Car raised by the petitioner was not met by the complainant. Counsel for the petitioner has vehemently contended that it is not the petitioner who has committed the breach of trust or misappropriation of the articles but it is the complainant who had refused to marry the petitioner on account of affair with one Rohit. The petitioner has filed a suit against Poonam Chauhan and her family members for recovery, annexure P-4, on account of damages in the Court at Una. Counsel for the petitioner has referred to the telephonic conversation recorded by him to submit that there has not been any demand.

2.

Counsel for the complainant has put in appearance to oppose the petition for pre-arrest bail contending that the petitioner has been taking steps from the very beginning to create a defence and to falsely implicate the complainant and her family members. In support of his contention, he has referred to a complaint filed by the petitioner in Police Station, Amb District Una indicating that the petitioner had filed a complaint u/s 156 (3) Cr.P.C. under Sections 420, 406, 403, 120B IPC. The matter was inquired into and the allegations of the petitioner were found to be false by the police of Una. It has also been informed that the petitioner had also approached this Court earlier by filing a petition for a direction that he should be heard by the police in a complaint filed by the complainant. Said petition was disposed of by a Coordinate Bench of this Court with a direction to SSP to decide the representation of the petitioner and his family members.

3.

After considering the allegations in the FIR against the petitioner, without expression of any opinion on as to who was responsible for the breaking of the marriage proposal, it is sufficient to observe that there are allegations against the petitioner of having received cash alongwith gold articles and gifts. If for any reason a proposal of marriage has not finalized, the petitioner and his family members are liable to return the articles and money received by them as said articles, as claimed by the complainant was property handed over to the petitioner as trust. In case of marriage having not been solemnized, the petitioner was required to return the articles entrusted to him. No doubt, 22 items after registration of FIR have been got recovered from the petitioner.

4.

When questioned as to whether the petitioner is ready to return the cash amount received by him, counsel submits that he has been informed by the petitioner that small shaguns of Rs. 500/- or Rs. 100/- were paid.

5.

After carefully going through the facts and circumstances of this case, it is apparent that the petitioner has adopted all the defensive devices to pressurize the complainant and her family members either by filing a complaint at Una u/s 156 (3) Cr.P.C.; lodging an FIR at Una; filing a suit for recovery as abundant caution as a defence measure; recorded the entire conversation to be used as defence mechanism and filing a petition for a direction in the High Court. It will not be appropriate at this stage to enter into the niceties of the trial regarding receipt of shagun amounts on account of the proposed marriage. The petitioner was directed to join investigation but it has been informed by the investigating officer that he did not cooperate with the investigation. From the conduct of the petitioner, it is believed that he must not have cooperated with the investigation. It is not out of place to observe here that in order to test the bonafide of the petitioner he was asked to handover a bank draft of Rs. 1 lac in the name of the complainant vide order dated November 1, 2012. In view of the abovesaid circumstances, no extraordinary exceptional circumstances exist for grant of concession of pre-arrest bail to the petitioner. The relief u/s 438 Cr.P.C. is deserved by a person who apprehends arrest being an innocent person but a person who is alert and active enough to create defence in advance and avail and create the defences, he is not entitled to the extraordinary relief u/s 438 Cr.P.C.