AI Structured Summary
Not yet generated for this judgment
Judgment
Heard. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard finally with the consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties.
By this Writ Petition, the petitioners are challenging the order dated 22.06.2026, passed by the learned Principal District Judge, Amravati in Civil Misc. Application No.118/2026 filled under Section 24 of Civil Procedure Code, 1908, thereby withdrawing and transferring case bearing R.M.J.C. No.878/2024 pending in the court of 5th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amravati and Regular Civil Suit No.393/2025 pending in the Court of the 8th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amravati to the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Amravati to try with the Special Civil Suit No. 318/2024.
The facts in brief are that the petitioners and respondent No.1 are the real brothers and sisters of deceased Hansraj V. Bhasin and deceased Krishnarani H. Bhasin leaving present petitioners and respondent No.1 has legal heirs leaving behind various immovable and movable properties. Thereafter, petitioners moved an application under the Bombay Regulation VIII of 1827 for obtaining legal heirship certificate in favour of present petitioners and respondent No.1 having application bearing R.M.J.C. No. 878/2024.
However Respondent No.1 has contested said application on the ground that father of petitioners and respondent No.1 had executed registered gift deed dated 11.08.2017, thereby bequeathing respondent No.1 immoveable property in respect of Saw Mill along with machinery and the license. Respondent No.1 contended that another Will-Deed was also executed on 23.11.2017 in which certain immoveable properties and cash was bequeathed in favor of Respondent No.1. Therefore, the respondent No.1 preferred a Special Civil Suit No.318/2024 before the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Amravati for declaration and mandatory injunction against the Respondents state authorities.
The respondent No.1 filed another suit for declaration and permanent injunction bearing Regular Civil Suit No. 393/2025 against the petitioners, seeking ownership based on the alleged Will-Deed and Gift-Deed and claiming that the family settlement deed dated 07.07.2018 is a forged document, respondent No. 1 further filed an application under Order 14 Rule 5 of the Civil Procedure Code for framing additional issues regarding his rights under the Will-Deedand Gift-Deed. The learned 5th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amravati rejected this application on 24.12.2025. This rejection was upheld by this Court in Writ Petition No.150/2026 vide judgment dated 25.02.2026 and further upheld by the Hon'ble Apex Court which dismissed Special Leave Appeal (C) No. 15621/2026 on 06.05.2026.
Subsequently, the respondent No.1 filed Misc. Civil Application No.118/2026 before the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Amravati under Section 24 of the Civil Procedure Code, seeking withdrawal and transfer of the heirship proceedings (R.M.J.C No. 878/2024) and R.C.S. No. 393/2025 to the Court of Civil Judge, Senior Division, Amravati to be tried along with Special Civil Suit No.318/2024. The learned Principal District Judge, Amravati, vide the impugned order dated 22.06.2026 allowed the application on the ground of common subject matter and to avoid conflicting decisions. Being aggrieved by the impugned order dated 22.06.2026, the Petitioners have approached this Court.
I have heard Mr. R.N. Ghuge, learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. S.D. Chopde, learned counsel for respondent No.1 and Mr. A.S. Fulzele, learned Additional Public Prosecutor for respondent Nos.2 to 5.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that impugned order is absolutely cryptic and fails to record satisfaction regarding the mandatory parameters required for a transfer under Section 24 of the Civil Procedure Code. The learned Court completely failed to appreciate the distinct nature and scope of the proceedings that were clubbed with the suit pending before the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Amravati. He further submits that the learned Principal District Judge failed to appreciate that proceedings under the Bombay Regulation VIII of 1827 are summary in nature, meant solely for the formal recognition of legal heirs, executors, and administrators. Such formal recognition does not confer title to the property. Therefore, clubbing these proceedings with substantive civil suits involving complex title disputes based on alleged Will and Gift deeds is unwarranted and legally unsustainable.
Learned counsel contends that the learned Court failed to consider the dilatory tactics adopted by the respondent No.1. The sequence of litigation clearly demonstrates that Respondent No.1 is not interested in concluding the heirship proceedings and filed the transfer application solely with a mala fide intention to stall the issuance of the certificate.
Lastly, it is submitted that the learned Principal District Judge failed to appreciate that there are no common issues required to be decided across all three proceedings. Notably, in the heirship certificate proceedings, respondent No.1 has already admitted that the petitioners are the legal heirs of the deceased parents. Thus, no extensive evidence is required for the issuance of the heirship certificate, making the consolidation an injudicious exercise of discretion.
Per Contra, learned counsels for the respondents have opposed the present writ petition submitting that the impugned order dated 22.06.2026 is well-reasoned, legally sound, and warrants no interference.
In the light of above facts, rival contentions fall for my consideration. I have gone through the record of the matter and also gone through the various judgments of the Hon'ble Apex Court. The learned counsel for the petitioners, by taking me through the Bombay Regulation VIII of 1827, would submit that grant of heirship certificate would not establish any right of such party in the property of deceased by itself, but it is only a formal recognition of the right. For this proposition, he relies on a judgment of this Court Aloysius Manuel D’souza & ors Vs. Mary Kamala William Manuel D’souza and ors. reported in 2006 (6) Bom.C.R. 56. In the said matter, the Division Bench of this Court has analyzed the entire scheme of the Bombay Regulation and in para 5,6,7,8,9 and 10. which are read as under :
“5.We are concerned with Chapter 1. Clauses 1 to 8 thereof read thus:-
1.Whenever a person dies leaving property, whether moveable or immovable, the heir or executor, or legal administrator, may assume the management, or sue for the recovery, of the property, in conformity with the law or usage applicable to the disposal of the said property, without making any previous application to the Court to be formally recognized.
2.First.-But if an heir, executor or administrator is desirous of having his right formally recognized by the Court, for the purpose of rendering it more safe for persons in possession of, or indebted to, the estate to acknowledge and deal with him, the Judge, on application, shall issue a proclamation, in the form contained in Appendix A, inviting all persons who dispute the right of the applicant to appear in the Court within one month from the date of the proclamation and enter their objections, and declaring that, if no sufficient objection is offered, the Judge will proceed to receive proof of the right of the applicant, and, if satisfied, grant him a certificate of heirship, executorship or administratorship.
Second.-[Publication of proclamation] Rep. Act. XII of 1873.
3.If, at the expiration of the time mentioned in the proclamation, no sufficient objection has been made, the Court shall forthwith receive such proof as may be offered of the right of the person making the claim, and, if satisfied, shall grant a certificate in the form contained in Appendix B, declaring him the recognized heir, executor or administrator of the deceased.
4.First.-If, before the expiration of the time, any objection is made to the right of the person claiming as heir, executor or administrator, the Judge, on a day to be fixed (of which at least eight days previous notice shall be given to the parties), shall summarily investigate the grounds of the objections on the one hand, and of the right claimed on the other, examining such witnesses or other evidence as may be adduced by the parties, and either grant or refuse a certificate, as the circumstances of the case may require.
Second.-But if from the evidence adduced, it appears that the question at issue between the parties is of a complicated or difficult nature, the Judge may suspend proceedings in the application for a certificate until the question has been tried by a regular suit instituted by one of the parties.
5.Whenever an executor is formally recognised, under the rule contained in section 4, the authenticity of the will, if any, by which he is appointed, shall be proved, and the certificate of executorship shall be endorsed thereon.
6. [Wills and recognitions to be registered.] Rep. Act XII of 1873.
7.First.-An heir, executor or administrator, holding the proper certificate, may do all acts and grant all deeds competent to a legal heir, executor or administrator, and may sue and obtain judgment in any Court in that capacity.
Second. But, as the certificate confers no right to the property, but only indicates the person who, for the time being, is in the legal management thereof, the granting of such certificate shall not finally determine nor injure the rights of any person; and the certificate shall be annulled by the Zilla Court, upon proof that another person has a preferable right.
Third.-An heir, executor or administrator, holding a certificate, shall be accountable for his acts done in that capacity to all persons having an interest in the property, in the same manner as if no certificate had been granted.
8.The refusal of a certificate by the Judge shall not finally determine the rights of the person whose application is refused, but it shall still be competent to him to institute a suit for the purpose of establishing his claim.
6.The first part of Clause 7 provides that an heir holding the proper certificate, may do all acts and grant all deeds competent to a legal heir and obtain judgement in any Court in that capacity. The second part of Clause 7 clarifies that the heirship certificate confers no right to the property. It only indicates the person who is in the legal management of the property of the deceased. It further provides that grant of such certificate does not finally determine nor injure the rights of any person and the certificate may be annulled by the Zila Court upon proof that another person has a preferable right. The third part of Clause 7 provides, inter alia, that a heir holding a certificate shall be accountable for his acts in that capacity to all persons having an interest in the property, in the same manner as if no certificate had been granted.
7.Clause 8 provides that refusal of a certificate by the Judge shall not finally determine the rights of the person whose application is refused, but shall still be competent to him to institute a suit for the purpose of establishing his claim. Conversely, therefore, it can be said that if the certificate is granted, then it does not finally determine the rights of the person in whose favour the certificate has been granted and does not take away the rights of other person to establish his claim in the competent Court nor does, as provided in the second part of Clause 7, the certificate confer any right to the property.
8.The appellants seek to submit that Mary Kamala never married the said deceased and she is not his widow and, therefore, not entitled to the estate of the deceased.
9.The grant of heirship certificate does not establish the right of such party in the property of the deceased by itself. In this view of the matter, the rights of the appellants, if any, in the property of the deceased are not taken away by grant of heirship certificate to the respondent No. 1. On the other hand, Clause 7 further makes it clear that such heirship certificate holder is accountable to all persons having an interest in the property for the acts so done by him or her.
10.In the backdrop of the aforesaid legal position, it needs no emphasis that based on the heirship certificate simplicitor, the respondent No. 1 cannot be said to have acquired any right or title in the estate of the deceased.
It is thus clear that the Division Bench of this Court has taken into consideration the scheme of the Regulation and has emphasized that only on the basis of the legal heirship certificate, the party concerned cannot be said to have acquired any right or title in the estate of the deceased. The said judgment has been followed consistently by this Court in Group Grampanchayat Vs. Sunanda Shamrao Bandishti and ors. Reported in 2011 (5) Bom.C.R. 162 and also in Ganpati Vinayak Achwal, reported in 2014 (6) Mh.L.J. 683 and also various judgments Baban Ramchandra Shukla and others Vs. Parag Arvind Shukla and another, 2018 (3) ALL MR 46.
In the backdrop of this settled legal position, if the impugned order is perused, I am afraid the said order cannot be sustained as far as it seeks withdrawal and transfer of the R.M.J.C. No.878 of 2024.
From the perusal of the impugned order, it is clear that the Principal District Judge has not even cared to consider the settled law regarding the scope of inquiry of an application under Bombay Regulation No. VIII of 1827. The only reasoning can be seen is in para 7 of the impugned order. In the said para, the Principal District Judge has recorded an erroneous finding that only because the respondent herein has raised certain objections, the legal heirship application becomes a contesting application. In my considered opinion, the said finding is clearly erroneous, as can be seen from the prayer clause in the application. The petitioner herein has not only prayed for declaring him as a legal heir, but also prayed for declaring the non-applicant as a legal heir. Even though the respondent herein may choose to raise certain objections, the fact remains that a declaration of being legal heirs is claimed with respect to the applicants as also the non-applicant.
In my considered opinion, therefore, the application would not become a contested application, as has been observed by the Principal District Judge. Apart from the fact that whether it is a contesting or non-contesting, the scope of inquiry would not be as wide as is in the civil suit.
The other reason which has weighed with the District Judge is regarding avoiding of any conflicting decisions and to resolve the controversy, all the three matters are clubbed. This reasoning, in my considered opinion, also is incorrect, inasmuch as, as stated supra, the scope of inquiry in the legal heirship certificate would be entirely different as is in a full-fledged trial in the civil suit. Even if the legal heirship certificate is granted or not granted, under the scheme of the Act, it would operate in a very limited spectrum and would not clothe the person in whose favour the certificate is granted with any rights outside the scope and purview of the said certificate. Therefore, in my considered opinion, the order impugned is partly unsustainable. In that view of the matter, following order is passed :
O R D E R
The Writ Petition is partly allowed.
The order dated 22.06.2026, below Exhibit-1, passed by the Principal District Judge in Civil Miscellaneous Application No. 118 of 2026 is quashed and set aside to the extent it transfers R.M.J.C. No.878 of 2024, pending in the Court of 5th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amravati.
However, as far as transferring of R.C.S. No.393 of 2025 pending in the Court of 8th Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division, Amravati, withdrawing and transferring it to the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Amravati and to be tried with Special Civil Suit No.318 of 2024 is maintained.
It is made clear that the Court dealing with R.M.J.C. No.878 of 2024 will deal and adjudicate the same in accordance with law.
The petition is disposed of.
Rule is made absolute in above terms. No costs.
